Great experience as a first time customer. Had a flat tire and they had the best price out of 5…read moreshops I called in the area. I brought in my car and made a purchase for the tire and they said it will arrive the following day. Instead of leaving the car there until the next day and going to work without a car, they gave me a loaner tire. Next day they replaced my tire in half an hour and was on my way. Top top experience. I mainly dealt with vinny but everyone is great. Highly recommended.

Had a car accident in front of there - cop said they had a video of it - when I called They said…read morethe person who has the vid wasn't there - called again the person who had the vid said they sent it to the cop - could not get the video - showed up to this racist business and the guy says he send the vid and deleted it - which was a lie - kid who hit us worked there and of course they produced the vid for him as if my insurance and lawyers weren't going to get it lol so yea I got the vid but you can tell it was because I was Spanish and the kid who hit and almost killed us was white! they are nasty and rude as well all assholes dont give them your business - also kid was found liable for the accident so idk hat they thought they was doing

I had to share my wonderful experience with Great Kills service station on Nelson Avenue in Staten…read moreIsland. I've been told twice from Kia that they can't see anything wrong with my car. I had this intermittent issue with the acceleration on my car. The problem kept happening, but never when I would bring it into service. Today it happened again on my way from work. I wanted to drive straight to a mechanic to see what the problem was. I saw these men standing outside, and I flagged them down. Their service station was already closed but they took time to help and explain to me what could be happening. It's sometimes hard to find a mechanic you can trust. But I can say wholeheartedly I would trust all of my car repairs with Great Kills service station. The young gentleman there Geo and Roman were not only patient and kind they took the time to look at my car when the service station was not even open and gave me great advice. I am so appreciative of them. They are truly honest, good gentlemen. I recommend this service station to everyone.

Very fair pricing and excellent customer service. I would recommend! I had an EVAP leak. They give…read moreyou the price before doing the work and they explain every detail of the work

Needed repair for broken pipe under car near the catalytic converter. Elson explained what Needed…read moreto be done. It was late Friday afternoon and we agreed to fix it the next Monday morning. I sat in the waiting room area and Elson worked on the issue. After a few hours my car was repaired and back to normal. I recommend them to anyone needing repairs. This is now my Go To place for any repair or regular maintenance issue I need. Steve and Elson are really nice gentlemen that explain the repair or issue and how it will be fixed. Trustworthy and prices are fair for the work they do. Linda

I called these guys 20 minutes before closing time, on a Saturday afternoon, the night after a huge…read moresnowstorm. This is after calling and visiting 3 other places that were supposedly open according to google, but actually decided to stay shut - likely because it had snowed fairly heavily. Anyway, I was lucky enough to get Elton on the phone who told me to come on in for my oil change and I got there 6 minutes later. First, he cleaned the snow off my car. Offered me a seat in the waiting room in the back of the shop. After fiddling on my phone for a bit, I decided to go and check on the status and just as I stood up off the chair Elton was walking in to let me know it was done. 15 minutes, maybe, for the oil change. Synthetic for a 2024 car - was $90. Reasonable. Not do it yourself cheap, but not outrageous either. Honestly, no appointment, weekend, bad weather, arrive and receive service immediately, friendly. I'm literally writing this immediately after leaving because they deserve the praise. Also, there was a beautiful.. I mean absolutely beautiful Chevrolet inside the garage, I'd guess from the 80's, but it could have been late 70. Heck, it could even have been early 90's, I have no idea. All I know is 20 years ago I'd call it a piece of junk but today I couldn't take my eyes off it. Funny how that happens. Anyway, I digress a second time. Hylan Auto Repair, Elton, thank you for taking care of this chore that I've had on my todo list for 2 months longer than it should have been on there. Next time I know where to go to get it done in time. Happy new year, too!

So I have to update my review for this establishment because the last time I was there, they…read moreactually yelled at me for having replaced my own car battery. I haven't been back since. Any business who thinks that I owe it to them to spend 3x more money to give them my business for a job that I can do myself, does not get my business anymore. I was seriously taken aback by the attitude of the owner to act like I did something wrong by doing my own car repairs. Replacing a battery is not a difficult repair. And I don't care if you think that the quality of the battery that I got somewhere else is crap. I brought the car there to try to find out why the battery kept dying. Even if the new battery I put in was crap, the previous battery was the one that he had put in a few years before and I had the same problem with that one for years and he knew that. There's something going on with my car that causes it to drain the battery if you don't drive it at least every few days. Anyway, I really don't appreciate being yelled at by any business for any reason. Maybe I could understand that if I was rude to you but not because I didn't hire you for another job that you think I should have. That's just totally out of line. I had mostly good experiences before. But they weren't so good that I could forgive this.

Amazing experience with Island Car Care! Danny and his techs are so friendly and really know their…read morestuff!! I had an electrical problem that could not be fixed (and thats after going to 3 different shops). Finally someone recommended Danny and said they had a great experience. I can see why! I too am so happy with how they were able to find my problem and fix it! They are well priced and honest! Danny sent me photos along the way to show me the issues and even things that the previous shop had damaged. From now on Island Car Care is my go to shop! They do everything from regular service to difficult issues!

If you're looking for an honest mechanic who gets the job done right and quick this is your place…read more I've been going to them for years and they are a godsend. Vinny and Phil are both amazing and always make sure to go above and beyond for their customers.

Very dismissive. I felt I was rushed and treated like I don't know anything. The owner is so…read moreunhelpful and I had to take my car somewhere else for fixing a small part. I was having such a rough day, especially as a healthcare worker, not knowing if my car is safe to drive. Anything I asked him about the car, he responded "I don't know". He was very short tempered and I felt like he just wanted to take my money and get rid of me. People may forget what you said, may forget what you did, but will never forget how you made them feel. Will never be coming here and I do not recommend this place.

I have been going here for years, always reasonable, friendly service and honest... I highly…read morerecommend this business

The best place to get your car fixed, there reasonably, honest and knowledgeable..... can't loose…read morehere

Radiator Busted after work, I arrived at 5:30, they close at 6. They did not hesitate to diagnose…read morethe leak and quickly gave a price for labor and parts. Turnaround time was 2 days. Very good staff and easy communication

Such empathetic thoughtful service in no appointment mode in the Saturday for a screw in the tire…read more I am so thankful for their great service in all senses. Happy to have found the local guys!

Honest, and as knowledgeable as can be. All issues explained clearly. Car problems fixed no…read moredrama. A real asset that is only appreciated when their help is needed. Big time recommended.

George and his guys do a great job! Only recently has my car needed certain repairs/replacements…read moreas it hits the 11 yr mark, and I only trust these guys. I don't even bother going to the dealership any longer. And they won't gouge you like many other garages.