Our family had a very positive experience with Mr. Piper's Jeeps during our visit to St. John's in March 2015. Given the horror stories of deceptive practices by some car rental companies in Cruz Bay, it was definitely worthwhile to do some research before reserving a car.
Mr. Piper's Jeeps is a relatively new company that opened in late 2014 after the owner purchased the business from Paris Rental Cars (which no longer exists). As a result, the owner is eager to build a good reputation! The office is located about a block away from the roundabout up the hill from the Cruz Bay ferry terminal. If you drive toward the Starfish Marketplace from the roundabout, and make a right on the first one-way street, it's located just before the St. John Inn.
I spoke by phone with Chrystal, who had a 1-day rental available (2015 Ford Escape) for the last day of our stay. Since it was peak season, I was grateful any car was available. I was delighted to see the car was brand new with only 1,000 miles on the odometer. Chrystal took my credit card information and briefly inspected the vehicle before we were on our way to Coral Bay.
Mr. Piper's Jeeps provided outstanding service the next morning when we had to catch a 9am ferry back to St. Thomas. Chrystal agreed to have somebody meet us at the ferry terminal when I called from the gas station. After refueling the car at 8:45am, we ran into local traffic and reached the ferry dock area by 8:50am. Unfortunately, it started to rain so we scrambled to park in a nearby lot (Smith's Limos) and paid $5.
At 8:55am, after moving our luggage to the dock, I met Mr. Piper at the courtyard one block up away from the dock. He saw the look of panic in my face about missing the ferry to St. Thomas, and calmly asked where the keys to the Ford Escape were. When I explained that it was with the Smith Limo parking lot attendant and that I had already paid $5 to park there, he said that I should run to the ferry and that he and Chrystal would take care of the paperwork and payment for the 1-day rental. Our family cannot thank him enough for saving us valuable time and avoiding a 1-hour wait for the next ferry. We boarded with 3 minutes to spare and made it to the airport on time.
I would strongly recommend Mr. Piper's Jeeps. The fleet of 2015 cars is new and Chrystal was professional and responsive by phone. Be sure to confirm when and where you plan to return the rental car or jeep! We plan to reserve a car again with Mr. Piper's Jeeps on our next trip to St. Johns. read more