I haven't been to an emergency room is many years. Urgent care sent me to the ER and I'm glad I…read morewent to this one. They were quick, pleasant and professional. I observed that even their interactions with one another were pleasant and professional. It was also very clean. Best emergency room experience ever. Thank you MNRH!

One good experience. Then a dreadful experience 3 months later on same ward. Sadistic nurses…read morewouldn't call a MD or PA help me while I was writhing in pain and crying loudly. They said that there was no one on duty because it was Sunday and closed my door. Left me there in agony. I threw ice packs at the door yelling. Four hours later I was practically out of my mind from pain and a PA happened to walk by and heard me, came in and saved me. New meds intravenously. My doctor never acknowledged this whole experience nor did the pain MD I had seen before the operation to quell my fears. Great. And the whole throwing ice packs at the door to get the nurses attention is now in my medical record. Really.

I had an asthma attack and couldn't breathe. So, I went to this hospital emergency room. From the…read moretime I entered the emergency room I was given the best care from the best nurses, doctor on duty and nurses aids. Everyone was professional, friendly and experienced in their field. You could feel their concern for you. I was admitted on the 22nd of September and spent the night I had a male nurse (Theo) who made a big impression on me. He explained everything he was going to do. Always smiling and when I was admitted later he came up to my room to make sure I was doing well. This man went to school, studied and worked no time for a life. Thank you the dedicated workers in the E.R. and on the 5th floor . Also, Ms. Coombs patient care director who talked to each patient asking how their stay is and how they can improve the quality of care. She even got a repair worker in to fix my tv fast. Thank you Dr. Miyazaki for discharging me. I had one person to pick me up with a time limit. He went out of his way to discharge me right away. The hospital was clean and well staffed. Their care makes an unwanted visit a little more pleasant.

I've always had strong experiences with NewYork-Presbyterian, so I came in expecting that same…read morelevel of professionalism and care. This location did not meet that standard. The doctors themselves were solid. The OB/GYN who cared for my wife stood out. Professional, attentive, and genuinely caring. Dr. Kevin Molyneux also made a strong impression. He was focused, clear, and took good care of my wife. Where things fell short was with the overall staff experience. Bedside manner across much of the team was lacking. Interactions felt dismissive at times, especially in the emergency department. Basic coordination also needs work. Housekeeping was requested multiple times and never showed up. Communication between shifts was inconsistent. There were gaps in handoffs and documentation, which made it harder to understand what had already been done and what came next. The facility itself feels dated and doesn't reflect the standard I associate with NYP. I'm giving 3 stars because the doctors delivered where it mattered most. But based on this experience, we would choose a Manhattan NYP location next time.

I've been in their outpatient detox clinic. They really do care & are very attentive and hear you…read moreif you're serious about detox , they'll truly help. I also had went to their emergency room everything went so quickly I was bought in right away ( but at time had heart problem & I catch seizures so they had to bring me in right away and do a EKG ) but even after the doctors had me out of there after a panic attack or 2 in like 1 hour maybe few more minutes over. My doctor also really understood me.

My Sister has been admitted to this hospital for complications with her CLL. The healthcare…read moreprofessionals in the facility go beyond expectations and really make her feel that she is heard and she seen during every interaction. These HCPs provide amazing medical care.

Horrible service; ER bathroom has water coming up from the floor when you flush the toilet; i…read moreinformed the staff at the desk 1 nurse completely ignored me the other sitting next to her acknowledged me simply because she realized that the nurse wasn't answering me. The bathroom is unsanitary. the patient that was next to my Mom; we were able to hear every question and answer because they were using an interpreter on a portable stand who was loud enough for anyone in the immediate area to hear. Do better NCB!!

I realized they delete negative Google reviews so I will post my experience here. I came here…read morebecause my normal hospital is in the city and I am going through some post-op complications. This hospital has a high rating so I took a chance. What a waste of my time. If I had known the incompetence of some of the staff here, I would have rather let myself bleed out than come here. First time I have said this, but I actually like the doctors more than the nurses and other supporting staff. Triage was a nightmare. I only said a total of two sentences, which wasn't enough to explain the reason I was there, because she cut me off so she could type it down. I have never met someone who typed like a kindergartener. It took nearly 20 minutes for her to type a literal 3 sentences. The ER nurses, physicians, and surgical team were lovely. I was medicated, sent to a CT, and admitted in under 5 hours. However, the regular hospital team on the inpatient floor? Wow. No words to describe my horror and disappointment. Again, the surgical team was lovely and transparent. The nurses all need to be fired or restrained. God forbid a nurse at this hospital does their job. My IV line kept causing the machine to beep and I had to keep silencing it because the nurses were too busy doing absolutely nothing to come turn it off. Also, I complained TWICE about the lady I was sharing a room with. She would not shut up, talking in her sleep, groaning, moaning, and making all sorts of inappropriate noises all night. Both times I complained? The nurse peeked around the curtain to ask if the woman was okay, ignored me, and walked out. No reprimand, no attempt to explain to this lady that she waa being disruptive. I did not get an hour of sleep the entire evening. I had an Asian woman come in to do my blood just now and I had to tell her off. Why? Because she was attempting to draw blood without actually looking for a vein. She was going based off what she could see. She poked around in my opposite arm before giving up and going into my hand. No warning, no communication, no prodding with her finger to find the best vein. She just went into whatever she saw. It was painful because she kept moving it in and out since the blood wasn't flowing well (hm, wonder why) and I moved because it was painful. She had the audacity to tell me she wasn't done and I told her to please get me a nurse who knew what they were doing because clearly she didn't and was being reckless. Aside from the crappy staff, the building is a health hazard. The floor of the CT was disgusting, clearly hasn't been swept or mopped in God knows how long. The entire hospital is disgusting. The bathroom in my inpatient room was dirty, not cleaned or wiped down. The surgeons and doctors are who saved it for me. But considering nurses and other supporting staff are the main faces, please get rid of all of them. Terrible workers. Thus why people would rather travel to Manhattan for their medical care.

Hopefully you dont have to be here, but if you have to you are in good hands…read moreEveryone from Valet to security , nurses and doctors was amazing. I received amazing care and give this hospital my highest review

My experience at St. Barnabas Hospital was extremely concerning and unacceptable…read more My mom came into the ER experiencing chest pain, and her blood pressure was 240. She was given a bed, but we waited approximately an hour before anyone came to properly assess her. While we were waiting, my mom became extremely dizzy and appeared to be fainting. A nurse named Eva was walking by with doctors, so I immediately told her that my mom was getting worse and that she was losing consciousness. Instead of coming over to assess my mom or getting someone to help, she yelled at me, "But she's breathing, right?!" and continued walking. I was shocked by the response. The people who were with her were also visibly shocked, and even the woman in the bed next to my mom was upset enough to ask for the nurse's name. Another interaction was equally concerning. A staff member came to take my mom for imaging and asked whether she could walk. I explained that she could not walk independently and that, although she is not paralyzed, she is extremely weak and would need assistance getting into a wheelchair. She responded, "I didn't ask you for that." I told her, "Why are you talking to me like that? Please speak to me with respect." She then walked away and said, "She'll remain there," and never came back. I also personally witnessed four other people leave the ER while we were there, clearly frustrated with their experience. Seeing multiple people leaving while patients were still waiting only added to my concerns about how things were being handled. Breathing is not the only indication that someone is okay. My mother had extremely high blood pressure, chest pain, and was becoming faint right in front of us. As a family member, I was asking for help because I was genuinely concerned about her condition. Patients come to an emergency room because they need to be taken seriously and assessed when something changes. Being spoken to that way while trying to get help for my mother was unacceptable and deeply upsetting. This was only the beginning of our experience, and unfortunately, there were additional concerns during her stay. I will be documenting those experiences as well. I sincerely hope the hospital looks into how patients and their families are being treated in this ER. With that said, the one bright spot in our care was Dr. Cohen. In stark contrast to the rest of our experience, Dr. Cohen was exceptional. He was extremely compassionate, thoroughly attentive, and treated both my mother, me and other patients with genuine kindness and respect. He took the time to listen to our concerns, explain everything clearly, and provide the high level of professional, thoughtful care that every patient in an emergency room deserves. Dr.Cohen represents the absolute best in medicine, and we are deeply grateful for his help during such a stressful time.

Don't Waste your time. The front desk staff is nice , compassionate, caring , but they have no…read morecontrol over what happens in terms of care provided. I sat there for 5 hours and still wasn't seen for possible appendicitis. Even I was called , eventually , it would have meant another two or three hours waiting for care once you get a bed. I left. I'll just wait at home for my appendix to burst , then I can get see faster ... I hope. If not , I guess I'll just drop dead. Part of the problem is people coming there for things that should be handled by urgent care. We now live in a third world country.

I was admitted Saturday morning I had the best care when I got into my room from the ER staff to…read morethe nurses on the 5th floor very kind made me comfortable while I was sick I recommend going there for good quality care and compassionate people I was extremely sick when I got there they treated me right kudos to them at Lawrence Hospital in Brownsville,NY

We was hoping for some answers with my husband. He was schedule to take a MRI to find out what is…read moregoing on with his back and shoulders locking up. His neck be tightening up also. Now, that no MRI was done no need for him to stay in the hospital. The quality of care was ok for me but I wasn't the one laying in the bed. He said the quality was horrible. They only gave him 2 Tylenol since he been in here and the medicine for him to take and relax was a half of pill which didnt work at all. Now, that no MRI was done he's being discharged today. No information was given about the CT SCAN. CT SCAN update brain is ok didnt see nothing

I took several hyperbaric oxygen therapies in this hospital. All the staff of that department is…read moreexcellent. Good treatment, care, kindness and very trained.

This is the first time in my life ever saying this. " The Best hospital stay in my life ". To the…read morehospital staff on the i.c.u. and my nurse Ada , and the many more beautiful people who had a hand in taking excellent care of me. Thank you is not a strong enough word . The sea of humanity i felted will live with me forever. To all who shared their stories of their lives. Thank you all. To Dr . GOLDSTEIN and his beautiful staff ,God BLESS YOU ALL. TO ALL OF YOU AT MONTEFIORE KEEP ON BEING A BEACON OF HUMANITY. YOURS Truly , Richie the "Pug" PUGLIA

Avoid bringing elderly loved ones to the Moses Montefiore Division ER. My parent has dementia and…read moreis unable to speak or advocate for herself. Complete labs and diagnostic tests were performed in August 2026, which revealed a severe infection. Tragically, no one from the ER staff or the Montefiore team ever reached out or followed up, leaving an elderly patient with dementia completely untreated for a painful infection. It is heartbreaking to see vulnerable patients who cannot speak or defend themselves subjected to this level of neglect.