I had a pleasant experience as a walk-in. Needed my tire checked out in a pinch and they went out…read moreof their way to take a look and resolve it on the spot. I made small talk with some friendly employees. Nice and attentive people work here, I recommend this Mavis on 110.

I've been a long-time customer of this Farmingdale location of Mavis, but over the past few years…read moremy experience has changed significantly and not for the better. I keep detailed service records, and a clear pattern has emerged of recommendations that don't align with normal wear and tear: **Wiper blades flagged at every inspection: ** I was told my wiper blades needed to be replaced to pass NYS inspection in 2024, 2025, and 2026... three years in a row. While wipers do wear out, failing inspection for the same item every single year is questionable. **Tires labeled "dry rotted" far too early: ** -On my Honda Civic, tires purchased in 2022 with only ~11,000 miles were deemed "dry rotted" and replaced in 2026. -On a second vehicle (Honda CR-V), tires were again described as "dry rotted" at replacement time, despite being regularly driven. While those had higher mileage and may have been due for replacement, the repeated use of "dry rot" as the explanation is concerning. **Major suspension work recommended but contradicted by another shop: ** During my most recent visit, I was advised that my vehicle needed struts and additional suspension work. I declined and took the car to a separate, reputable repair shop for a second opinion. After a full inspection, they found no issues requiring replacement and confirmed everything was in normal condition with no safety concerns. **Repeated or questionable services: ** I've also had rear shocks replaced twice (2020 and 2025) with relatively low mileage between, along with multiple flush services and add-ons that seem to be recommended frequently. Before around 2022, my visits here were straightforward and I trusted the guidance I received. Since then, nearly every inspection has come with multiple recommended repairs that feel inconsistent with the vehicle's condition and usage. To be clear, I understand that maintenance is necessary and I'm willing to pay for legitimate repairs. The concern is the consistency and accuracy of what's being recommended. When multiple items--from wipers to tires to suspension are repeatedly flagged in ways that don't align with typical wear, it becomes difficult to trust the advice being given. I would strongly encourage anyone visiting this location to seek a second opinion before approving repairs, especially for higher-cost items. Unfortunately, what was once a reliable shop now feels focused more on maximizing sales than providing trustworthy, needs-based service.

The best Mechanic's around honest fair prices very nice people great reputation over the years…read more Mitch

Richie is the best around HONEST knows what he is doing no trial and error leading to extra charges…read moreI have been a customer for over 30 years better then any dealer service around even if the dealer does it for free they always come up for some bull to charge for also Richie is a really nice guy

I had to bring my 2023 Hyundai Santa Fe to 1042 Collision after it was damaged in a collision, and…read moreI couldn't have asked for a better experience. Marie, who runs the shop, was incredibly professional and kind. She kept me informed every step of the way and acted as the intermediary with the insurance company, which made everything so much easier for me and my family. What truly sets Marie apart is her determination and advocacy; she won't let insurance companies bully the customer. She made it clear that insurance companies are there to serve the customer, not the other way around. Her expertise in navigating the complexities of New York and New Jersey insurance was invaluable. I truly can't recommend them enough; they're the best I've ever worked with!

There is no substitute for quality work, done swiftly, efficiently, and at a fair price. I've used…read more1042 many times in the past and will continue going back as they are simply the best. I've always been treated fairly, honestly, courteously almost as if I were part of the family. It's always top notch, first class, professional work. I always feel taken care of, and the experience is always worry free. They take pride in what they do, and rightly so. It's flawless. I can't recommend them highly enough.

These guys are incredibly professional and accommodating. We brought our work truck into them for…read moreservice and they went above and beyond, fixing things that I didnt even know was wrong. They charged an acceptable fee for their quality work. I would definitely recommend them. Quality Stair Builders

Check point Have a Maserati 2025 Nick took care of me…read moreMore then half the price of the dealer and used Maserati parts Great guy great service

I have been to Plainview Tire and Auto a few times over the years. This is a no nonsense honest…read moreshop run by experts. They know what they're doing and as their mission statement says they never over promise and under deliver. Conscientious Honest Highly Skilled Priced Fairly What more could you want?

Had a nail in my tire so I pulled up around 8:30am and waited in the waiting room. Nobody came out…read moreso I stuck my head in the service station and this grumpy old man asked what I needed. I said I have a nail in a tire and I was told to park it and come back in 3-4 hours because he's the only one here. I drove down the road to Plainview Auto Care and it was fixed in 5 minutes. Avoid this establishment at all costs!!!

This place always takes care of me & even more important they take great care of my car!! Nick…read morealways provides awesome fast service to get you back on the road!!

Armando and his team were extremely helpful, professional and very pleasant to work with. Highly…read morerecommend!

Ignore the naysayers - this is the place to take your car in the Farmingdale area. Fast top notch…read moreservice at a fair price. Needed a flat replaced asap, other shops wouldn't have the tire I wanted for a day or more. One phone call and they had it on order for that same afternoon, car back in my posession good as new before sundown and at a lower cost than most other places I called. Most definitely found my new spot for auto service. Big thanks to Gary, Eric & the crew for getting the job done right!

Driving along Southern State Parkway and low tire pressure warning comes on the console. Pull over,…read moregrateful for a portable Compressor. Huge Screw in my tire- can hear the air hissing out- as fast as I'm filling up - pressure continues to drop. Made it safely to this shop where I was initially told by Paul- it could be a couple hours before they get to me. Expressing that I needed to be at a luncheon for an account by noon and a lil emotional breakdown.... Paul took mercy on me and worked me in. Louis did the labor and worked diligently to help get me on the road.... I made it to my luncheon after all and kept this giant screw for posterity. Very professional, very kind, affordable and clean establishment. I would recommend in a heartbeat.

Have been coming here for a couple of years since my previous mechanic retired. Always a good…read moreexperience, reliable, trustworthy, reasonable cost. Stands behind their work. Would recommend highly.

CENTER ISLAND AUTO - FARMINGDALE. Chris, Liz and Shawn, a…read morefamily business owned the best in Long Island!! I have been going to them for every need of my car and my son's car as well and they have proven themselves to be the best of the best! They are courteous, efficient and most importantly honest with all of their customers. They are always willing to make time to fix my car and always in a timely manner. If you want to be treated honestly and promptly, please go and visit CENTER ISLAND AUTO, FARMINGDALE!! Ana Juarez