DAMN! This was a good one on a chilly November Friday night. Had a really, really tasty piece of salmon. Excellent char, the right amount of crunch. "Burnt without being burnt," if that makes sense. Cornbread fire too. Owner came by to check on each table personally - love that. We'll have to come back for the stew chicken and the soup. and FYI - good Caribbean food *takes time*. IT IS WHAT IT IS... and it's worth the wait at MIG. read more

Morgan's Island Grill - JERK $ALMON - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

The food was a good effort with good portion size . The jerk chicken was very dry. The oxtail was okay; too salty and mid way through I couldn't eat anymore. The plantain was ripe and cooked well. Unfortunately there is a blue lives matter flag on the door of this Jamaican restaurant, so we will obviously never return. read more

We went on a Saturday for dinner. We walked in and the place was empty. This place does lots of take out orders. The young lady behind the counter was very nice and helped us out. At first there was no feeling we were in a Jamaican restaurant until they turned on the music. We ordered the reggae platter. It came with 4 choices of meat. Ribs, golden wings, jerk shrimp and jerk chicken. I'm not going to describe each one because they were all amazing. It also came with cornbread, rice, cabbage and plantains. My wife and I have been to Jamaica several times and this food brought us right back to the island. As they say on the island "respect". That's what I say to Morgan's. read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Golden wings, bbq ribs, jerk chicken, jerk shrimp - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Another meal, and Morgan's is still worthy of the high star Yelp acclaim and serves up some very delicious Caribbean Island cuisine. We have been here several times now and have ordered the oxtail platter, jerk chicken platter, curry chicken platter as well as a side of mac and cheese. This time we had the Red Snapper Platter. It was great, just wish there was nice snapper for the price. It's a whole snapper bones and all! The portion sizes are very generous and we easily split a large platter between two adults. The platters are served with rice and beans, cabbage, plantains and a piece of corn bread. The chicken is succulent, flavorful, and spicy. The corn bread is among the best I've had and the mac and cheese amazing. The rice and beans was as Caribbean as you're going to get. The only thing I didn't care for is their cabbage or mixed vegetables, because it's bland in comparison to the other food on my plate. The main reason, my reviews forgo a star is the salt content as well as it takes a while to get your order. We usually do take-out, but there is casual dining seating inside as well as outdoor tables. read more

See all

Very good food and reasonable prices. Food has a Jamaican touch and there sure is plenty of it. We enjoyed our visit and the food.

Listen!!! Do I have your attention hands down the best, let me start again. THE BEST Authentic JAMAICAN FOOD IN NEW JERSEY. The owner Morgan is great makes you feel at home and is very gracious with all patrons. let's get into the food the portions there not stingy you will be fed like you made your own plate at home . the flavors the extensive menu and the hospitality you must try this hidden Jersey gem take ride run don't walk get there asap read more

See all

Food was great and had a hint of spice. We ordered the oxtail, bbq ribs, and jerk chicken sweet. Their patties get sold out pretty fast we only were anle to try the beef patty. Medium is for one person and Large is a shareable size. They have a one bathroom and its unisex but honestly looks scary. read more

See all

let me start by saying morgan's you guys did yall thing!!! from the time i walked in the door i felt good. i came here from highland park to try out this restaurant and i am leaving here feeling stuffed, happy and talking about the food!!! if i could give you guys ten stars i would!!!great restaurant to eat in and dine out!!! read more

See all

Well, this is the place if you want no questions asked flavor, value and a freshness. The cabbage is cooked but flavorful and crisp, and jerk is very jerky and thoroughly cooked and the start of the show, the Ox Tails are all that. Small bone, more meat. I did take out for a pre-birthday dinner. It was completely satisfying. I highly recommend it as take out. Maybe one day, I will stop in to sit in the restaurant. Loved it. read more

Outstanding food! Happy and pleasant staff. Wonderful flavors. substantive portions. A great experience all around. read more

Rasta pasta waa very tasty and delicious except for the overcooked chicken pieces. Curry chicken was too salty and curry masala needed to cooked more it tasted that turmeric taste. The roti wrap was disappointing. Very stale. Seems like the standards dropped. Hoping this review will help them improve the quality/taste of the foods read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Rasta Pasta with shrimp and chicken. - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

What a gem! I ordered the medium BBQ Jerk Chicken and it was FANTASTIC!!! Even the cabbage was superbly flavored. And who even compliments cabbage, right?!? It was THAT good! The chicken was juicy, the cornbread had a lovely distinct taste unlike your run-of-the-mill cornbread, and the rice was good, too! I wished there were more plantains but that's just me being greedy. Their medium portion was more than enough for 2 meals so I had the rest for lunch the next day. My server was kind and helpful. The place could use a little sprucing up, especially the bathroom (...it's ok...I wasn't eating in there), but despite all that, it just felt comfortable. Looking forward to returning when the weather is warmer so I can dine outside. It's got an ideal corner location to people watch. read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

I stumbled upon Morgan's Island Grill when I visited New Jersey. It's located in a cute little neighborhood called Highstown. The restaurant itself is a cute like hole in the wall with both indoor and outdoor seating. I was greeted and my order was taken by the owner, himself. He was such a friendly and helpful person. I love my spicy food so immediately ordered the Jerk Shrimp meal and boy...IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT! Spicy, flavorful, good portion and they sure were not stingy with their shrimp. I was told not to leave NJ without having Jamaican food and now I know why-it's non like it anywhere else. read more

See all

The food was amazing! The oxtails we A1 and the jerk chicken with rice and beans were delicious!! Oh my gosh I cannot say enough good things about the food!! read more

While passing through the area today at lunchtime, we stopped at Morgan's Island Grill, and found it to be a great place for lunch. I had goat, curry and oxtail, and it was some of the best oxtail I've ever eaten! The restaurant was clean and the service friendly. I highly recommend you try this gem. read more

We vacationed in Jamaica, and unfortunately stayed at a resort without much Jamaican food. As soon as we returned to NJ, we knew we had to visit Morgan's again. It's been a minute, and I'm happy to say it's as good as ever. We grabbed some Red Stripes from the bar down the block, and arrived just in time to grab a table outside where a Jamaican band was playing. Service was quick. We ordered the roti skin appetizer. I had dry rubbed chicken wings with a side of plantains, cabbage & rice. My meal was delicious - super fresh and enjoyable. My husband had some sort of chicken too (I forget how it was prepared) but he liked it with the spicy bbq sauce on the side. (The roti never arrived and we had to ask for it to be removed from our bill.) Do yourself a favor and try Morgan's - you'll love it! read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

I planned a 4th July backyard bbq and did not want the usual bbq food...hot dogs, hamburgers, corn...so I went to Morgan's Island Grill. Kenny, the owner said he could cater for 50 and will deliver. He worked with my budget and I repeatedly stressed the importance of non-spicy food. Kenny did not disappoint. EVERYONE...yes...ALL 52 guests complimented the food. Everyone left with 2 or 3 take home containers. I definitely will use Kenny again. read more

The food was delicious, service is accommodating and the owner was very gracious. Please support this black owned business. You won't be disappointed. read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Curry chicken and shrimp with cabbage, rice and peas and cornbread. Can I say delicious? Oh and I also had a spinach patty, spicy but good. - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

absolutely love this restaurant. The food is authentic and delicious. Morgan takes his cooking seriously and makes sure his patrons are happy! The food and experience is always consistent. read more

Excellent food. I loved everything on my plate except the cabbage. My man loved everything on his too besides the cabbage as well lol. His curry goat was very tender. The mac and cheese was yummy and so was their cornbread. I just wish they offered normal sized bottles of water; we received mini bottles. We'll be back to try something new. I thought they had lunch specials (saw online), but I did not see that on the menu. read more

See all

I needed to have some good food for my daughter's baby shower and I called Morgan's Island Grill and we talked about what I wanted. Morgan was so friendly and patient with me he made me feel like a member of his family so I knew the food would be good. On the day of the event he walked in very happy to be there and brighten up the room. Well not only was the food delicious he brought food I did not order. Every dish was chef's kiss. People were lined up and ready to eat every last bite on their plates. People went back for seconds and were still able to take food home with them. Morgan went above and beyond serving food, joking, cleaning just a genuine nice man with a big heart that knows how to cook. I highly recommend this restaurant and catering service. You will not be disappointed! Thank you Morgan!i read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Every dish was delicious - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

This is where you go! To a hardworking and warm staff who care and serve the most authentic food possible. Seriously one of the best meals i'll have all year hands down. Flavor, freshness, and quality is all 10/10. The entree comes with loaded plate of rice and beans, plantains, cabbage and the sweet jerk BBQ chicken had perfect char and the sauce was unreal! read more

My husband visited here and got me me a diamond salad to go. It was absolutely fantastic! It was so fresh and just bursting with flavor. I definitely recommend stopping here to try for yourself. read more

Morgan's Island Grill - The Diamond Salad - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

The food is so well seasoned! The curried goat is top notch!! Definitely treat yourself to this local jewel!

This is a restaurant close to where I work. I like to come here on my lunch break because the atmosphere is relaxing and because the food is amazing. You can choose what level of spice you want that day, they have Jamaican sodas and coconut cake. The employees are friendly and it's easy to get a parking spot nearby. read more

Absolutely amazing food. Fresh and delicious!!! The staff there are incredibly friendly and attentive! Was my first visit and won't be my last!!! read more

Love the diversity of restaurants in town. This is one of them, bringing a fun Caribbean vibe. Service was friendly. We had the oxtail - which I was excited to try. I found the flavors a bit too sour / sweet; I've had this dish at a couple other Jamaican places where I preferred the sauce much more. It came with cornbread, cabbage and beans. However I definitely want to come back and try some other dishes. read more

See all

We really enjoyed our meal on Juneteenth Day! Oxtail , plantains and BBQ Jerk chicken wings was great. Definitely will revisit. read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Fried shrimp & BBQ Jerk Chicken wings - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

This was my first time having Caribbean food and omg its flavor blasting to say the least! The staff was super sweet and helpful with helping to pick what to eat. We had the bbq jerk chicken and ribs which was amazing. The plantains were so tasty and the cornbread was absolutely delicious and my husband really liked the rice! I gotta go back and try their oxtail which is apparently their best seller! read more

This is an update, as I haven't posted in some time. I've had the pleasure of frequenting Morgan's Island Grill for just about seven years, and from my previous reviews, what furthermore is there to say? Morgan's Island Grill's food has always been fresh (most every dish is prepared fresh), bold with flavors, generously portioned, and simply stated.....delicious! Customer service is always friendly, especially Chef Morgan himself, who is so amiable to all customers. When he has rare free time, no doubt he will be greeting customers and being an amicable host. In my seven years, I've seen him garner a large and loyal repeat customer base (mark me and my sister as part of that group); a testament to the quality of the food, the staff, and Chef Morgan as a restaurateur. Bottom line, if you're reading this review, and have not tried Morgan's.....I suggest you plan a visit as soon as possible!! read more

Morgan's Island Grill - My favorite order: Large combination of BBQ Jerk Chicken (spicy) & Sweet Bosa - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

This food takes us to heaven! We've had homemade Jamaican food from neighbor's, and this is just as good if not better!

Best authentic Jamaican food around. Highly recommend to try. The people are friendly and the place is low key.

Great find while on business in NJ. Had a curry dish and slow cooked goat. Wow, so tasty. Friendly staff, enjoy!

Food, atmosphere, and staff were all great. This is such a good change from all the local pizza and typical food. Can't wait to go back

Morgan's Island Grill truly takes me back to My Mama's Home Style, Authentic Southern Cooking with an Island twist Long term patron and supporter Menu never gets old, boring or outdated Spices, Flavors & Presentation ~ 1st Class Staff is always courteous and kind AAA Cleanliness Inside & Out ILoveClosingForYou.com read more

A New Jersey gem! Mr. Morgan is a good man that makes great food! The best oxtails, with rice and cabbage. The curry goat and jerk wings are awesome! I really like the redemption salad too! I'm always in a better mood after lunch at Morgan's island grill! one love! read more

See all

Straight up great Caribbean food. Fresh, delicious and wholesome. Got the bbq Jett chicken medium platter and loved it. This is a no frills simple byob joint. The owner is super friendly and the service is quick. Wonderful all around. read more

amazing!!! Amazing service , and nice vibe. Food was amazing as well !! Everything thing was on point. met Morgan himself and he was very nice. read more

Popped in here on the way home from DC - so glad we did! Very welcoming little restaurant that was doing a steady business for late on a Sunday afternoon. Service was excellent & gave great recommendations. There's medium sized or large sized portions - large will give you enough to take a decent sized portion home (which we did). I love oxtail & theirs lived up to my expectations! Savory & a little heat - perfect. Hubs went for the jerk chicken plate - he said it's the golden standard for mild jerk chicken (you can get it hotter). Plates come with plantains, rice & beans, cabbage & cornbread. Our Little Miss a thumbs up to the homemade Mac & Cheese. Kids plate comes with a side too - she liked the cornbread. Top it all off with Jamaican sodas & you've got a tasty diversion. If you're in Hightstown, you've got to try this place! read more

Morgan's Island Grill - Large Oxtail Plate & Pineapple Jamaican soda - Caribbean Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Just fabulous. Some of the best food from the islands that I have had anywhere. The jerk wings appetizer was outstanding and spicy enough to feel but not so spicy as to rip your insides apart. I had an oxtail roti as a main course which was both huge and delicious. Our server was super-friendly and this contributed to an all-around terrific experience. read more