We stayed in Gallatin for 4 nights. We were with two other families. When booking this house I was…read morea bit skeptical that it would not be sufficient for 8 people but we were pleasantly surprised it was good for 10 people. We had one outside bed in lower living room and needed an extra bed for my son. The staff was extremely friendly and helped us with a small foldable foam bed. House was well maintained and we had no complaints. One small suggestion would be if they could put out a garbage disposable outside or behind the house that can be easily identifiable. We initially struggled a bit to spot the garbage disposal box.

We rented the Buffalo Creek cabin (#420) for a week. We were having a family reunion, and there…read morewere 18 of us. The cabin was perfect for us, it has 5 bedrooms downstairs, and 3 upstairs. We had plenty of room for everyone. Of the 8 bedrooms, 6 have king size beds, and two of them have private full baths. There are 3 additional full baths for the others. The cabin itself is pretty new, so everything was clean and in working order. The location is very close to the west entrance to the park, and is convenient to downtown shops and restaurants. The kitchen had plenty of plates, silverware, pots and pans, etc. I was especially impressed with the quality of the pots and pans, very nice for a rental. The cabin also has a full sized washer and dryer, which was very convenient. The WIFI was available, but I have to say it is not very fast. Considering the location, this was not too surprising. There were no problems with billing, or unexpected charges. Overall a great choice for a large party, I highly recommend this location!

This motel is privately owned and offers spotless, comfortable, rooms, with amenities and parking…read more It is conveniently located, within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and close to Yellowstone National Park west entrance. The owners, Brian and his wife, are friendly, accommodating, and helpful with local recommendations, complimentary snacks including hot beverages and suggestions to make our travel and sightseeing experience better. We give them a 10/10!!

The people running this motel, went out of their way to make sure we had a good visit. The bed was…read morecomfortable, the room was quiet, everything was super clean. I will definitely stay here again.

We stayed two nights here while visiting Yellowstone and it was exactly what we wanted…read more We actually switched to this place mid-trip. We'd been booked at an older property inside the park with no air conditioning, cancelled it, and found the 1872. Best decision we made. The AC worked exactly as it should, and after long days in the park it made a real difference. It's an adults-only boutique property at the edge of town -- close enough to walk downtown, far enough to escape the crowds and noise. Quiet is the word that keeps coming to mind, and that's rare in a gateway town in August. Check-in was easy, and the gentleman at the front desk walked us to the room himself and showed us how everything worked -- the gas fireplace, the towel warmer for the bath towels. Small touches, but you notice when someone takes the time. The room was spotless and a good size. We had four pieces of luggage open at once and never felt crowded. Beds were very comfortable. Anything we asked for, we got. We loved it and would stay here again without hesitation. The switching story is the strongest thing in the review now. Anyone weighing in-park lodging against staying in West Yellowstone is going to read that paragraph and make a decision.

Clean, beautiful rooms, good breakfast and amazing proximity to the park and dining optionsread more

We spent three fairly pleasant nights here in early August, and were overall happy with our…read moreexperience. We booked the 2-room unit in the motel (a king bed in one room and two queens in the other). When we got to our room we were initially concerned about noise because it was along a high-traffic corridor for guests heading to the restaurant and main lobby. As it turned out, this wasn't an issue at all. The positives: - very convenient to the west entrance of Yellowstone - just drive down the street and you're there - short walk to all the restaurants and shops, though probably every other hotel in town is also a short distance away - super friendly front desk staff, easy to reach with questions - free cookies in the lobby (and they are delicious!) - very good breakfast buffet with hot items that changes a bit every day The less positive: - the rooms and furnishings are very dated, but clean - not enough seating for everyone - just a couple small arm chairs and a desk chair - the toilet/bathtub room is a little cramped, and the shower head is low so taller people will have to stoop - air conditioning was temperamental. We figured it out eventually but the first night was a little uncomfortable - bath amenities were a little spartan. A fresh bar of soap for the shower wasn't provided for our stay. It would be nice to have a separate conditioner because the shampoo/conditioner option wasn't all that great The cost of our three-night stay, with breakfast included, was about $1000. Given that we were there in the summer season just before the end of the school break, it wasn't entirely unexpected, plus we had two rooms and three large beds total. It was worth it.

This place was great! Easy check in, reasonable pricing and free cookies/tea. The vouchers for…read morebreakfast were so amazing and food was tasty. The rooms were clean and had us in a perfect location. All staff were very kind as well. Water pressure was not great but that was my only complaint the entire stay! Highly recommend

"Kelly and I meet secretly We stay out of sight…read more When we're in each others arms We know it isn't right" (Del Shannon) Great location about 2 minutes from the West Yellowstone business district, so you have super easy access to the plethora of souvenir stores and places to eat. Our room was great-- big and comfortable with a nice desk/work stations. fridge, coffee machine, flat-screen, plenty of plugs, except wifi, good sized bath (with a separate sink), and comfy beds. The included breakfast was very good, with plenty of healthy options like cut fruit, whole fruit, cereal, and yogurt to complement the eggs, French toast potatoes, sausage, biscuits and gravy, toast, bagels and pastries. The staff was great and put out a pre-Halloween basket of candy. We could not have been happier with our two nights at Kelly. Pro Tip Free coffee in the lobby at night

Great location. Very close to Yellowstone and town. Staff is very friendly. They have a free…read morebreakfast in the morning that has a variety of items each day. Free hot chocolate in the lobby as well as a list of area restaurants. Staff will happily tell you their picks as well. Great area for walking around outside. I found a trail not far from the hotel to walk. Rooms are large and clean and the beds are comfortable. Would definately stay here again.

We checked in to room 221 in West Yellowstone, right outside of the park for one night. The hotel…read morewas in a great location, an easy quick walk to the shops & restaurants in West Yellowstone. The hotel was very hot the man across the whole compared to Auschwitz. The Club House Inn is rustic and has charm. Our room had two queen beds, a dated coffee maker, microwave and refrigerator. We had a view of the parking lot. The walls were paper thin we could hear people walking above us and conversations next-door until 10:00. Our room was dark and it was tight with all of our belongings for 3 weeks. We didn't have much counter space in the bathroom and the water pressure was weak. Hot coffee was available in the lobby. There is a pool, hot tub, and a laundry room with two washers and two dryers. We had issues with the Wi-Fi. A buffet breakfast was included from 630 until 930. The usual toast, muffins, fruit, scrambled eggs, potatoes , sausages, biscuits, yogurt, juices.... There was not enough seating for all the guest, and it was extremely hot in the dining room. When we were done with breakfast, we went up to our room to brush our teeth and we were already checked out. It required two trips down to get back into our room.

We chose this hotel based on it's proximity to the west entrance to Yellowstone - only 5 minutes…read moreaway from the entrance - this was the best part of the hotel for sure. The service at the front desk was also spot-on, very polite and friendly staff even when we had issues. That being said, for the cost of the hotel I would've expected more in regards to the quality of the building and linens. The bathroom/shower was not as pictured and was far more dated than we expected. At least one of our towels had frayed edges. At some point we had issues with the TV and had to reset the entire tv/box to get it to work again. The light bulb in the bathroom went out and we had to ask the front desk to send someone to replace it AND THEN the lights in the vanity area outside of the bathroom became faulty as well. It seems that room needed some new wiring and general updates to the bathroom overall. At least the ac/heater worked well! The breakfast was standard complimentary breakfast and we appreciated the variety over our 4 night stay. Overall, even though it was in a great location, we likely would choose another, more modern, hotel.

The sites are indeed close together but we have stayed in even cozier. Did not use the laundry or…read morerestrooms so cannot comment. The place was quiet and exactly what we needed for exploring Yellowstone. No problems whatsoever.

I'll start with the positives: - Extremely close to west…read moreentrance of Yellowstone - WiFi worked 90% of the time Now for the negatives: - Old, outdated everything within the bathroom - bathroom stall doors that won't close - shower stall doors that won't close - Cold restroom with a non-functioning wall heater - Cold water showers (brrr....) - please bring your slippers with you to shower in (dirty, gross floors. Don't get caught standing barefoot in there) - Non-existent water pressure coming from shower head (think a steady trickle or violent mist is all you get) - Remember to bring your own toilet paper with you (I'm serious folks!) - tight spaces (you are right up on your neighbors) I really tried to not let this place ruin our wonderfully, amazing experience in Yellowstone National Park. After a long day wandering and exploring, I hope you don't have to call this place home. I would only stay here again if nothing else was available and even then, I probably wouldn't...

If only for the location this gets five stars since it's only a few hundred yards from the West…read moreEntrance to Yellowstone. It's also very close to downtown and tons of restaurants and shops and there's a McDonald's on the corner. But beyond that the rooms are very nice, they have a pool and hot tub and a good breakfast. They also have a firepit in front which on it's own is nice, but they also offer free s'more kits every night which is totally fun and a great way to meet other travellers. It's also pet friendly and reasonably priced. My only complaint is that the front desk staff are a little aloof and not overtly friendly, but I think that may be more due to their lack of experience; they all seemed pretty young.

MOLD!!! This is a very dated hotel. While walking on the carpet barefoot, I noticed that it was wet…read morenear the fridge. The fridge must be leaking bc the cabinet surrounding it also clearly has water damage. I did report this to management but they did nothing other than say they'd look into it. The room smelled very moldy. Unfortunately we didn't discover this until we were getting into bed and I couldn't change rooms by myself with a young child... not that another room would've maybe been any different. We liked that there was a little bit of garage parking underground. The breakfast was great. Room was quiet.

The absolute worst hotel I've ever stayed in. $400 for a 10x10 room. Water pressure for the sink…read moreand shower was almost non existent. Oh and forget hot water. The worst part of it all is the rooms are right above the open lobby. We heard every single noise, conversation, sneeze, you name it, that came from the lobby. You'd think if you pay $400 for a room you'd at least have it quiet. We might as well have just slept in the lobby. We unfortunately got stuck in a pinch due to our other hotel canceling on us so this was our only choice. I would've much rather have slept in my truck instead. How this place is still in business is beyond me. They are a total scam.

Just a bad place to stay In definite need of upgrades and…read moreimprovement Rooms are small and dirty No view Staff super unfriendly and not welcoming Way overpriced for what is offered Breakfast lacks big time in protein offerings

Worst Air BNB booking ever!!! We ran the hot water in the shower and it never got even warm, for an…read morehour and a half while attempting to contact the host via the Air BNB app, text message and phone calls with no answer. While running the shower we found the tub doesn't even drain. We had to leave the room and move to a local hotel in the middle of the night. While on the phone with Air BNB we pulled the sheets back and found someone else's hair all in the sheets and terrible pilling on the sheets. So disgusting and appalling none the less during a global pandemic. Google address is wrong for the physical location also. DO NOT STAY AT THIS PLACE.

The outside appearance does not do the place any justice. 1st impression as we are driving up…read more ... looks a little like trailer trash. But once inside our room, it was quite nice and cozy. Has everything u need.