Back again after 11 months and it's still good! My meal hasn't arrived yet but just had my salad w house dressing. Cottage cheese and dinner rolls- a good start! read more

Mick & Mary's - Back of the menu - American Near Me - Thayer, Illinois

See all

Good food, great service, literally the WORST lighting of anywhere I've ever been. Not just the worst restaurant lighting, I mean, the worst lighting of any place I've ever been in my entire life. It's simultaneously way too dark and yet insanely harsh white light... that's barely on. It's like a torture chamber. It's so bad, it's funny. read more

Great food and great service. Casual dining. Hidden gem. Owner greets patrons and is hands on with the business. I have never had a meal there I didnt like. Boom Shrimp app is great. Pork chop dinner is my go to. Portions are more than enough. The two pork chop dinner will give me two lunches. I did order the chicken gizzard (I know some think they're gross) horseshoe. Tastes so good but I ate too much of it and over did it. I also recommend the Four Roses Old Fashioned. read more

Huge portions and delicious food. Both my husband and I ordered the whole catfish. It was wonderful. We always take the side of spaghetti home and have it the next day, so 2 meals for the price of one. read more

Food, service, value - always 5 out of 5. This hidden gem is always worth the drive and we continue to go back.

Everything was awesome! Had a hiccup, but was resolved quickly and happily. We had never been there but were happy and will be back!

The worst service ever! It took 20minutes to ask what we wanted to drink and another hour and 30 for dinner to come. The manager actually sent our first dinner to his friends that just arrived and sat right next to us. They looked like they just swallowed crow when they got it. Manager looked at us and laughed. We're not the townie's so he didn't care! Wouldn't recommend this place to anyone with class! Very clicky place and definitely not for the norm! read more

Great local restaurant! Delicious food and nice staff! Get the fried chicken! You won't be disappointed.

Food terrible Ambiance ordinary-diner like Horribly overprice. our two waitresses excellent, particularly under the circumstance. Check out this review of Mick & Mary's Restaurant on Tripadvisor: https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g36772-d17412872-r925676537-Mick_Mary_s_Restaurant-Thayer_Illinois.html read more

Had an outstanding meal last night. The service was prompt & courteous. The rolls were a great place to start ... pulled from the oven at the right time, they were awesome (I've made my own rolls for a number of years, these were spot on). The Ribeye I had was outstanding (they source a lot of their meat from Magro's out of Springfield). It was huge, yet surprisingly tender for the size. One of our dinner companions opted for the pork chop. It also was huge, but grilled to a "T" -- from my side of the table it looked like a great option to the monster sitting on my plate. Owner Josh was on hand to make sure things were running smoothly. If you're looking to get out of Springfield (and the chain restaurants) or are just in the surrounding area of Thayer, you owe it yourself to take a short trip and check out Mick & Mary's. I believe it will be one of the best meals you've had in a while. Take cash to get a discount; the credit card machine is down temporarily. They throw in a tasty side of spaghetti on the house which is a Mick & Mary tradition. Try the homemade house dressing! read more

We went without a reservation & they were able to accommodate us! Our table had the whole catfish, catfish nuggets, 2 pony shoes & the black & blue filet! The food was delicious & served quickly! It was my first time there, but I will definitely go back! read more

call the day before for reservatio, arrived early for reservation, waited nearly an hour to be seated Would not recommend regardless of the food! read more

We went to Mick & Mary's for the first time and it was worth the drive from Godfrey area. The catfish fritters were the best I have ever had, chicken livers were amazing. They give you so much food that we had to take it home and had lunch the next day. The rolls and homemade butter were delicious and they make their own salad dressing. The spaghetti doesn't have enough sauce for my taste, but it felt like a free extra meal anyway! The service is not super quick but it was worth the wait. Staff was very friendly. read more

By far, the best steak in the area. The fillet with blue cheese was delicious. The service is always top notch.

One of our favorite places for great food and excellent service. Always friendly and accommodating.

The food is delicious! Had the bacon wrapped filet and it melts in your mouth. So much food! The service is always friendly. Great date night with friends! read more

Side dishes that are more like a second meal. Specialty is fried chicken. You will want to call ahead on weekends.

We went to M and M for New Years Eve dinner. I got the Ribeye. Might have been the best steak I've ever eaten. Grilled to perfection.... My Girl had the chicken dinner - one of her favorites .... But that steak, with all the fixins that are standard with yr meal: salad, potato, fresh bread, spaghetti , a vegetable medley and a choice of cottage cheese or apple sauce .... I choose both .... This is 5 out of 5 stars .... We have been here many times and will go back many more.... Less pricy but just as good as the steak... their pork chop dinner Try this place. It does not disappoint Would have taken a pic of steak - but dug in too fast read more

Come hungry! My first time here. They just reopened after a lengthy closure due to a fire. Well, the place sparkles, tables are spacious and spaced nicely. The bar is separated from the dining room. Both rooms have plenty of TVs playing sports. I had the Chicken (half) Dinner and he had the whole catfish. Each dinner came with a salad, choice of potatoe, choice of apple sauce or cottage cheese and a side of spaghetti with meat sauce and a vegetable side of corn. Big time food ensemble! Best fried dinner I have been to. Coating was thin, like flour not a batter. Bolongese was seriously meaty and good, not sweet. There are also soups and salads on the menu - so needed these days. Service was prompt, attentive, smart, helpful, just right. They have a full bar. If you want to bring your own wine corkage is $10 . Great for couples families or groups. read more

Mick & Mary's - Whole catfish dinner $17.50 - American Near Me - Thayer, Illinois

See all

This place is a hidden gem. I highly recommend it. I'm my opinion the best chicken and ribeye steaks in Central Illinois. There fillet ( black and blue) is awesome as well. Chief specials on the weekend always deliver a tasty surprise.It's a local landmark for a reason . read more

I have been eating there for many years at least once a week. Always good service and delicious food and plenty of food.

What a hidden gem! Service AND food was AMAZING! If you leave hungry, it's your own darn fault! Huge portions, many standard items come with dinners and all very tasty! read more

We were looking for a restaurant off the beaten path and outside of our normal and WOW, did we find a great one. Our waitress Sarah was that great kind of friendly and helpful. I had the pork chops and my wife had the chicken breast for our main entree. But the hit of the evening was our appetizer the fried mushrooms. The portions were extraordinarily huge and very tasty. We have lunch all set for tomorrow. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

It is dated and understaffed but the food is excellent. It may seem overpriced at first but the quantity and quality is more than worth it. Make a reservation if you go on the weekend read more

You won't find any place In the Springfield Illinois area that serves a better meal. It is not just one item one the menu that is amazing, everything is.. it is worth you're time to take a drive to Thayer and experience Mick & Mary's. read more

What's in Thayer, you ask? Come to this place and find out! After my first visit I vow to come back and try every steak they serve. I had the bacon wrapped filet, which was absolutely without fault. We were a huge party of 20 or so people and our waitress was spectacular. She (and the owner, I believe) were mindful not to put the beers down where the baby could grab them (she's at that age). The cocktails were on point; the sides were flavorful. My friend had the catfish and it looked very good, as well. Just a jewel in far south Sangamon county. read more

Mick & Mary's is a local treasure, hidden away in a small town (Thayer). The food is wonderful, and the service is great and the beer is ice cold. If you're looking for Midwestern home town cooking that's delicious, not to mention the huge portions, visit Mick & Mary's. you won't be disappointed. read more

We tried to have dinner there tonight. When we arrived it took at least 10 minutes at the front desk before anybody would acknowledge us. They lost our reservation. Then they said it would be a long wait. There were empty tables. We gave up and left. read more

Really good fried chicken! Salad, breadsticks, applesauce, potato and a side of spaghetti came with our meal. Definitely plenty to eat! Our waitress was really nice and it's very clean. read more

Great improvment from a visit years ago. Plenty to eat, clean good waitress. Could do without a radio speaker near our table

Fried chicken here is very good. Be aware if you order Cajun chicken. I was thinking it was a dry rub when it was really drenched in buffalo wing sauce. Not what I was expecting, but, I should have asked. You get tons of sides and won't leave there hungry. read more