I am giving a 5 star review solely for the brilliant individual Cassie who handled my issue in the most professionally executed manner-- When I called the agency regarding an issue, I was just about ready to take my business elsewhere, but thanks to Cassie I hung up from that same call with plans to bring all of my other insurance policies to her. This is the type of employee I have seen very few of in my many years as a business owner and sales professional. Outstanding work, Cassie! Ron read more

I had a tree fall on my summer house in Yarmouth during the tornado last year. Luckily we were all safe but there was a huge hole in my roof. McShea's staff made me feel so much better & that everything was under control. They truly delivered. My claim was paid within a few weeks for the full amount of the damage done. You hear so many negative things about insurance companies unwilling to pay--this was a major relief. McShea has found a lifelong client in me! read more

I bought my first house on the vineyard a few years back. I was pretty overwhelmed with the entire process of buying a home. My realtor recommended McShea. Their quotes were around the same price as the other agencies, but the professionalism, timeliness and friendliness of their staff is what made the choice easy. Since then, I've bought more homes on the island and continue to go through McShea. I don't trust anyone else. read more

Whenever I have to call, it doesn't matter who I'm talking to, not once have I had a bad experience. These people are competent, patient, and good at explaining things. Home insurance through McShea has great coverage and highly affordable rates. Overall pleasant experience. read more

I had a great experience with McShea insurance! My agent Megan was incredible! She saved me over $500 on my new homeowners policy! She was very responsive, consistent, and provided me with clear guidance for my coverage needs. I would highly recommend this agency! read more

McShea Insurance saved me so much on my homeowners and auto insurance. They take the time to shop around for the best policies

Amazing company! They work hard to find the best coverage for the best premium. McShea Insurance doesn't disappoint

Super nice staff and very professional! Answered all of my questions and followed up with me in a timely manner.

What a great team of people at McShea Insurance. Someone always answers the phone and the service is impeccable