We were insured with rogers and gray for years and finally had it with their lousy communication…read moreand slow service etc....My friends recommended we go across the street to Almeida and the difference is day and night... Seriously kind, knowledgeable, prompt and open wonderful agents at Almeida and Carlson. Bob is awesome and took great and also compassionate care of us with 2 nasty accidents we had ( not our fault .) This week we bought an rv and needed out of state registration and paperwork for the transaction etc... Sort of complicated. Kathleen Swanson took care of me on the spot as a walk in and got it all lined up just right. She knows what she is doing too. This office represents what we need and should expect from an insurance company...Helpful is an understatement... They know what they are doing and who they are working for...their customers. The BEST!

From the owner: Personal Lines; Home; Condo; Rental; Auto; Antique Auto; Motorcycle; RV; Jewelry; Umbrella; Flood;…read moreMarine; Business; Commercial Lines; Bonds; Workers Compensation. **If you would like a no obligation insurance quote, please include your name, phone number and email address in your request**

I moved from California to Cape Cod at the height of the Covid pandemic. Not only did Rebecca find…read moreme great insurance she also made me feel safe and welcome, providing me with other recommendations and helping me get my car registered as well. Rebecca is amazing and I highly recommend her for all your insurance needs!

From the owner: Auto, Homeowners, Life & Health. Contractors, Landscapers, Plumbers & Electricians.read more

AFTER the merge with Baldwin Group, service is AWFUL Cannot…read moreget a return call or any help with a small claim

Writing as a business owner that has been a customer for 4 + years who paid our premiums on time in…read morefull and had 0 claims, they cancelled my insurance do to an audit that was completed, confusion on my part and miss-communication on many levels. This is the worse customer service I have ever experienced! In addition, I found out after the fact that they were overcharging me and taking advantage of me as well! Please do you homework and get several quotes before signing up with any insurance company. I ended up with another company and their policy came back $4000.00 less and I actually spoke to a kind, professional human on the phone who tried her best to save me money, understanding that I am a small business owner that has enough challenges operating a business.

Living on Martha's Vineyard since 2002 I experienced huge home insurance increases the last few…read moreyears, including the offer for the current renewal, starting in March, 2025. I read a recommendation for Eric Miranda on a thread in Islanders Talk, a Facebook group. I called him at RogersGray. The next day (yesterday) he presented to me policies for my home that saved $3,500 for my home, auto, and liability insurance renewals. I signed on and paperwork flowed to me within hours. He is great, and the insurance offers excellent coverage. Adele Dreyer, February 27, 2025

Terrible. Slow. Didn't compare rates. I went down the street hours later and got the same coverage…read morefor $600 less. (Rogersgray quote was $1200!!!) the woman who "helped" me didn't actually finish filing the paperwork so I accidentally drove my car uninsured, she didn't know how to use the computer and she kept trying to add coverage I didn't want. Use McCalfee down on Gifford. They took 15 minutes and it was super easy. This was two hours and it didn't even go through. Ridiculous waste of time. Totally incompetent agent.

Terrible agency. Was given no advise or input, gave me a boiler plate policy. When I realized how…read moreover charged I was I shopped around for the same policy for my 4 cars and one house and was able to save 3k a year. Totally taking advantage of busy people. Found out that 2 other friends were using them, and now we are all leaving. They gave me a terrible time trying to cancel, I couldn't believe how nasty they were. I'm not new at this over 60 and have owned many homes.

I have been a client of Calfee Insurance since 2005, anytime I have needed anything insurance…read morerelated there is always an amazing and friendly voice on the other line. I was in a major car accident a few years back and I never once had to worry about anything except healing. Davidson has always made himself personally available when needed and if not him one of his amazing staff members. I can not say enough about this agency and the people who work there! Thanks Calfee

McShea is an amazing agency with rockstar insurance agents. They work as a team and get things…read moredone. They did everything they could and made sure everything was taken care of and paid when i had a claim last year. (First time in 30 years of homeownership!!!)I've heard nightmares about it taking months and months of insurance companies dragging their feet. I'm lucky to have found genuine people who actually care. 10/10 recommend!!

I contacted McShea Insurance after receiving mail for my properties and after great service in the…read morepast year, decided to roll all my auto policies to them and they consulted me on the savings I would receive after bundling. Great service and nice local family business.

Extremely helpful and efficient. Rick directly addresses needs for your individual circumstances…read more Doesn't horse around talking about things that don't align with your needs.

Rick was extremely helpful with my needs. He worked around my schedule and was transparent and…read morehonest with my coverage. I highly recommend him.