This place is permanently closed! We made a special trip to go to this place because it still showed as open on Yelp only to find out it's been closed for over a year. read more

The positives: our waitress was nice, attentive, and checked on us several times. Excellent service! The food tasted great also. I liked the decor and it was a fun environment. The negatives: this is one of the dirtiest restaurants I've ever seen. Right away I noticed the bottoms of the doors looked like they have never been cleaned. There were splatter marks all over them and the glass was dirty as well. When I entered the bathroom, gross build up of splatters all the way around the room on the tile. The worst I saved for last. My drink was served full to the rim upon arrival. Once I drank some of it I noticed lipstick marks on the rim. 1. I don't wear lipstick and 2. I used a straw. It's a really cool place, has excellent service, good food and local beer. However, I don't know how this place is passing any kind of health code inspections. read more

We came here driving back home from vacation. We are stopping in Casey, IL and this town was the closest place with a hotel so I googled restaurants and this had a pretty good rating. Lots of parking (in an old plaza) and staff were friendly. We stopped on a Sunday evening around 6pm. We were seated quickly and drinks, orders and food came out quickly. Food was hot and a we expected. It wasn't the absolute best we've had to say we would drive back just for this restaurant but it was pretty good and we left with full bellies. read more

Ordered wings steak bites and onion pedals. Steak and onions were great. Chicken wing was undercooked when I brought to their attention the offered me a 2 dollar discount. read more

Was stuck there for two weekend events, tried to go to the bar for drinks , waitresses hung out with kitchen staff. This place is so understaffed. I watched a guy have to interrupt his dinner, to clean tables. The bar maids are just bad, one presented to not understand a "well" drink. The waitresses are friendly but I would not trust this place to cook food correctly. I had to walk across the car park to get the beer the barmaid, avoided getting me. read more

Great food! Great service! Great tap list! After 6 hours in the car we were searching for a good meal. We arrived 15/20 minutes from closing in hopes of placing a to go order and were delighted that they not only were able to accommodate, but encouraged us to eat in. Brussel sprouts were so great! Crispy, sweet, spicy, delicious. Buffalo chicken wrap and fish sandwich were great as well. We will definitely stop in again if we are back in the area. read more

My husband had the A1 steak sandwich and was surprised that an entire steak was in the sandwich; he said it was cooked to order and he'd recommend it. We both had the sweet potato fries which were tasty and crispy but the portions are small. I had the sweet chili boneless wings and appreciated the lack of breading (all too often that's the majority of a boneless wing) but the flavor was lacking. The first two beers both of us ordered from the menu were no longer available -- if you're not going to keep the plastic-coated/printed beer menu up-to-date, why not just print a new list weekly, or write what's on tap on a chalkboard? Service was good and prices were reasonable. read more

Terrible food, it was cold and portions small. Our server was horrendous. will never go back.

Service was OK, although I received my salad after the steak was delivered. Steak was a New York strip, and possibly the worst cut of meat I've ever attempted to eat in a restaurant. Everything else was done very well the steak was cooked to the correct temperature the fries were great the flavor was there it was just a terrible cut of meat... lots of gristle and extremely chewy/fatty. Out of 12 ounces maybe 4 ounces was edible. I explained this to the manager and she graciously gave me 20% off. Needless to say I gave the waitress a nice tip but I wouldn't recommend getting the New York strip at this place... read more

Great place to eat! All I can say is all good things from Chelsea behind the bar. Great service and even better food recommendations. Check it out! read more

We have been here twice this week. First time, food was great and service was also. They were practicing social distancing and following health department guidelines. Tonight...different story altogether. We waited for quite a while for a table as they are packed. It is a Saturday eve, so that is somewhat to be expected. However, every single table is in use and no social distancing whatsoever. We never saw the same server twice. The one who took our order was not the same who brought it. Also not the same to check on us, even though that only happened once. We waited quite a while for our drink order, and when it arrived (finally) our appetizers had already been finished. The food, this time, was mediocre at best. My husbands fries were so salty they were inedible. We would have sent them back, but had a heck of a time finding someone. My husband had one beer, they never came back to ask for refills. He gives one chance to convince him you will get a second visit. This time he went because we wanted to go...his first visit was not positive. So second visit did not impress. We waited for over 25 minutes from the time we were brought a take home box until we got our check. Our server waited at the table for payment, and that was the longest anyone attended to us. Needless to say...it will be quite a while before we go back. If ever. And if wearing a mask is important to you...they don't. Not. A. Single. One. read more

We were in Mattoon for an unrelated event. We stopped in and had lunch. The waitress was excellent as was the food and drink.

We met up with some friends here around Christmas. Food was decent, nothing to write home about, service was sufficient and efficient. Definitely one of the better options in town, just nothing I'd go out of my way for. read more

I have eaten here half a dozen times. Food has been good, service okay. BEWARE, I had previously paid cash, last night used credit card. The waitress handed me the card reader and said "just sign the box". She had preloaded 25% tip. Wonder how many other people she had pulled that on? Update: contacted the restaurant and the owner responded that it was a software glitch they had been unaware of, the default setting was 25% and had been fixed. That's an acceptable answer but still betting the waitress knew what it was doing. read more

I've been going to this pup since it opened under tht McQuarter's name. It's never been 5 star but it was reasonable for what you got.. I've owned and worked in the Food and Beverage Industry for 40 years.. Tonite was the worst i've ever been trreated in a resturant. As bad as the manager was the cook was as rude as you can possibly imagaine.. my friend and I were speechless. I'd encourage Justin Mc Quarter to consider a major shake up. Mattoon/Charleston is a small market and the last thing a resturant needs is a bad image. read more

We're on vacation from MN. Stopped at several restaurants in several states during our 10 day trip. Our stop at Mcquarters was the BEST, by far. Our server, Sara, was beyond incredible. Ive never had service like this in my entire life. Food was great, atmosphere was fun. If I lived closer, I'd be a regular!! read more

This place is absolutely fantastic. To know the backstory makes it even better. The steak is as good as it could possible get. Service was fast and efficient and the drinks were just as good! If we could give it a higher rating, we would! read more

We ate Dinner here tonight! It was delicious food and excellent service! Our food was brought out very fast! Highly recommend their sampler appetizer tray. read more

I had the Shrimp and Chicken on penne noodles and She had a Reuben Sandwich. I was quite full and the food was great!! I have nothing bad to say about this meal or service, I just wish I had taken pictures first, but I was hungry! read more

I have been here twice now. Both visits were wonderful. Delicious food and beer! Wide variety of liquors, wine and beer. Plenty of food choices! I have tried the Reuben and backyard BBQ burger with sweet potato fries...all are outstanding! The dipping sauce for the sweet potatoe fries is delicious too! Manager, bartender and other staff are friendly, accommodating, efficient and just great! I highly recommend stopping by! read more

One of your families faves. Service is usually pretty good but sometimes a little slow. I've eaten a variety of things on the menu all have been good. My fiancé says the wings are the best in town. read more

dirty dishes but good food the waiters are also good at their job just think need new dish washers

Our server was new last night and he was nice but the service was very slow. All the tables getting sat waited at least 3-5 minutes before being asked for drinks and then there was another 3-5 minute wait to get the drinks. I got a ponyshoe and the melted cheese on top was hard and cold from it sitting so long under the warmer. They forgot the shrimp on one of the meals and brought it out later. The food had potential but they either need more help or to train their servers better before releasing them. read more

First time here. Came in for late lunch with hubby. Got the fried mushrooms as an appetizer and they were excellent. Will definitely get again. Fresh sliced, dry breading. Light crispy and very tasty. I ordered horseshoe with crispy chicken. French fries were frozen but good. Chicken was good. Had yellow cheese sauce, it was ok but nothing special. Hubby had steak sandwich and said the steak was good and tender. He didn't care for the sauce ,A1 which the menu stated. Dinner not served till 4 pm. Service was excellent!!! Would come back just for the mushrooms! read more

Not saying it's a badd place to eat but my food was not all that great the 2nd time I went there