We had a group of 14 people that chose Doherty's on a recommendation. We arrived at the restaurant and were shocked to find out they had arranged a table for all of us in a back room. Our server was Austin. Austin was incredible. He handled all of us with great knowledge and enthusiasm. He had answers about every menu item that we asked about. He took group photos of us and had coozies for all of us. He could not have been more entertaining and a great ambassador for the restaurant. All of our group would highly recommend Doherty's! Make sure you ask for Austin 3:16 as your waiter! read more

Doherty's is a Decatur landmark at this point. The Irish fare and theme is great. Shepherds pie is my go to and my mother and husband always order the bookmaker. If you're feeling adventurous they do have escargot which surprisingly isn't terrible. Service is always good and it's usually busy. read more

I came at lunch (after trying to call for over 90 mins) to place a to-go order for 6 people. No one ever answered the phone so I thought maybe their service wasn't working, and I'd just have to place an order in person. I went to the bar and said I'd like to place a to-go order and that I'd tried calling previously. The lady snapped at me. She was very busy, but I think she could have handled that better. The man at the bar was also not very friendly. I've waited tables and bartended...stay calm and friendly! People understand that it's very busy but being rude and abrupt is not the answer. read more

Checked out this Irish pub in Decatur that's more typical of the local bars. It certainly isn't fancy but it's not all bad though. Doherty's is known for its cheap drinks, food, and games. For sure it's even cheap for around here. There's a few locals always at the bar it seems. After many of the other places around here have closed, it was a later night option for us to get drinks and a bite. It was pretty quiet inside. This place isn't a wild hangout most times. It has a pretty simple menu. There's the most basic stuff. It's about $5 for the cheapest Irish whiskey, not bad. The food can be even cheaper if you can believe it. Fries are $3, and these are about the healthiest food here you can get. The rest of the food mostly is meats. Good place to get something cheap. It may not always be good food, in fact it usually isn't, but most people just come for the drinks so they don't really care too much about any of the food. They also have games including arcades and slots for those looking for entertainment and things. read more

Doherty's Pub & Pins - Jameson And Fries - Irish Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

Our waitress was very attentive & checked on us throughout. The shrimp cocktail & escargot were good, as was the shepherd's pie, BUT the corned beef & cabbage left much to be desired. It tasted like it had been sitting for a long time & the edges of the corned beef were dried out. It didn't have any flavor, nor did the cabbage & red potatoes. It wasn't even salty like corned beef should be. read more

Great staff awesome food and The best Saint Patrick Day Celebrations! Diverse crowd and book awesome Entertainment! read more

We sat at the bar .. had to wait a bit then she took our order .. it was Friday night and fish sounded so good.. I ordered cod and fries .. $13.50 and you had to order the slaw separate and it was $3.50.. When it came it was one piece of fish so I thought It was all burnt breading and no fish inside!!!! I was going to tell the lady that waited on us but she was no where in sight. A man came by gave us a bill and took my plate before I could say anything .. I was so sad and disappointed .. I just ate my slaw and a few cold fries ...my husband paid our bill it was 80$ with tip I won't be ordering that again! read more

My Ruben was eh. wasnt doing backflips over it. Red Pepper soup very good. At the end the waitress automatically added 20% because we were a party of 7 but divided bills into 2 and 5.. a little frivolous assuming youre a great server with 20% And she was a good server but 18% wouldve been fair if u were a tight ass w the money. Atleast they only did the 20% on the food tho not the tax. We Wouldve gave her 20%+ anyways but dont think that was her call to make. kinda left a bad taste in my mouth. she thought 'Ima go ahead and tag these people' assuming we wont tip or not that good. Wouldve prefered the Cabbage more cooked, it was raw and hard. Almost a crunch. like a coleslaw without the mayo. Pepsi bubly and good. and on time. A little too much ice. Mozzarella stick p good. Think some plates were gettin cold while waitin on others to be done. Corned beef id give it a 3. I like mine a little lighter incolor but it was ok. Quality not too thick Asparagus cooked well. Nice real bar read more

Doherty's Pub & Pins - Irish Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

Food took 1 1/2 hours and was overcooked and bar service sucked!! Don't waste your money or time's

Their Reuben sandwich is fantastic. My Caesar salad and red pepper with Gouda soup...delicious to the last warm spoonful of tasty goodness! The people there were welcoming and very friendly so we felt right at home. Many more items on the menu for us to explore in future trips on our date nights. Been married since 77 but Friday night will always be date night. Now this lovely establishment will become part of our rotation. Thank you Decatur for so many wonderful restaurants! read more

Doherty's has an amazing red pepper Gouda soup. It's a must when dining there. It's a great local establishment.

Food was GREAT and the service was very friendly, I have a great meal and the place is warm and inviting. I will be back! read more

See all

Have been wanting to try this place out for a long time and finally made it through the door. Late dinner after a local event so we arrived around 8/830p. Not a lot of patrons at that time so we had the place to ourselves for the most part. Sat at the bar and enjoyed our bartender/server. Super nice gal who was very courteous, efficient and made you feel at home. She was on top of our drink refills, made good menu suggestions and kept herself busy in the meantime stocking, wiping stuff down etc. Now that might sound like a funny thing to comment on but I'm so over people on their cell phones when they should be working. Especially in the service industry. Anyway! We ordered the waffle fry nachos and the hot beef sandwich- cannot recall Irish name for it - and both were very good. I wish the nachos had more nachos on it for $9.99 but it was tasty and did the trick so my only complaint. We will return soon to try something new! I bet this would be a great place to watch a football game on the weekend. Just had that vibe going to me...neighborhood old school bar, excellent staff, cold beer and a good nosh. read more

Really good food and atmosphere. Not too pricey and staff is super friendly. They have daily specials also

Nice semi-authentic Irish pub serving Guinness on tap and over cooked French fries. Good location in center of Decatur. Bartender with detached attitude. No matter. Beer is beer. read more

Great service, beer is cold large menu and has specials. We will go again to this Irish pub the soup was so good roasted pepper

This place is one of my favorites to come here when I visit Illinois. I always love the food and am never disappointed. The reason I am giving this 4 stars is because our service sucked. It took them until our food came out to get one person a Pepsi. Either way, I would still come here any day just to eat the food. The Ruben Ponyshoe is by far my favorite thing on the menu. The cheese sauce is delicious and so was the corned beef. Despite the poor service I highly recommended you check this place out if you have a chance. Order anything covered in cheese sauce!! read more

Doherty's Pub & Pins - Irish Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

Always great service and food here. Friendly staff and a call out to the house salad. Yummm. Delish burgers too and fries.

Had a last minute event here. The coordinator was FANTASTIC, she made it so easy suggesting the perfect amount and type of foods. The meatballs and egg rolls were delicious. I also have had lunch here before with my mom. The red pepper soup and a Reuben. Very delicious as well read more

Yeah sometimes service is slow but for me the food is the most consistent in Decatur. Their app options are really good - fried pickles, mushrooms, cordon blue bites. I love the red pepper soup. My go to order is the bookmaker. I don't know why it doesn't stand out so much but it is one of the better places to eat in Decatur. read more

I attended a wake here for a passed grandfather. They charged the widow over a thousand dollars in fraudulent charges after she hosted an open bar celebration of life. After discussing this incident, they apparently do this frequently. They are a shameful establishment. read more

My husband had been familiar with this establishment back in the 70's. Since we were looking for something new, we decided to give it a try. I wanted to try local beers-the first three I asked for, they are 'all out' of this or that when I tried to order. The list was fairly extensive, although not much available from that list...hmmm. At this point, I ordered a Corona Extra-our waiter brought me a light and my husband an extra. I told him I wanted an extra, and he copped an attitude saying 'you ordered a light'. My response 'why would I order a light when I don't drink light?' On to the food. it was not memorable. I guess after the waiter did not even bother to come by and ask how things were going. We would of at least ordered another beer. I would NOT return to this place and tolerate that waiter. It does not surprise me that there were few patrons in there. So if you are strolling downtown Decatur and looking for a place, just keep walking....you are bound to find better service. read more

Doherty's has the best food in Decatur and Emma is the best server in town as well. The Gouda red pepper soup is delicious. I recommend that you have a fantastic cheese toasty with that and a nice cold Harp. read more

Irish nachos on par Beer selections great Friendly staff Right there with all needs Would recommend over and over read more

Doherty's Pub & Pins - the bar area - Irish Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

Had the bookmaker tonight. It needed a bit more Beef, the au jus was perfect, not to salty. Fries were way over cooked. Or server was hard to find and never filled any drinks. I had To ask another server for more tea. I might give It another try, for the shepherds pie. And hopefully a waitress that could be on her game a bit more , instead of acting like She doesn't want to be there read more

Traditional Irish pub, and that's a good thing! It closes fairly early for a city bar, so check the hours before you head here. Other than that, Doherty's has a solid menu and a good selection of draft craft beer! If I'm in Decatur and I'm not feeling too adventurous (JOM), I'll swing by Doherty's for something familiar yet substantial. read more

Can't believe this place hasn't been reviewed. I've eaten here many times over the past year. Can't go wrong with the red pepper soup or escargot for apps. For lunch I've been chomping down on fish and chips or the reuben. The reuben rocks. They char up a pretty good steak for dinner as well. It's a converted bowling alley, has a full bar, and all the locals know the place. But for those of you that may be passing through, you need to give this place a shot. The food is good, the service is good, and the people are really nice. Yep, I'm biased because I grew up in Decatur, but those of you that have seen my reviews know, I wouldn't jock the place just for that reason. read more

Can't go wrong with a bookmaker. Gotta add some onions and peppers too it with some pepper jack cheese. Now that's a 5 star. Wish the bowling could be upgraded since it's called pub and pins. Nice drink selection beer, liquor. Depends what time you go and how many people you have to get great service it is Decatur. But great everything here will come back. read more

This is an ok bar bar to visit in Decatur. They usually have a decent beer selection. Their menu is pretty solid as well. When I usually go I like to order their Rueben sandwich. The atmosphere is nice as well. It's a good place to meet if you are wanting a place to sit and chat with others. read more

Damn good food...but DEF 5 stars for the view the entire meal Seriously though, the Irish nachos and they were quite good, money wise prolly go with the half order but delicious in my opinion. read more

I went to Doherty's with a group of 8 people for a trivia night. We were treated like crap. I spent $125 for dinner and couldn't get a waitress to come to my table. We were told that because we were with the group we had to walk up to the bar to order. I ordered a prime rib sandwich and a salad and was again told by the wait staff that if I wanted silverware that I had to go up to the bar and get it myself. When I went to the bar, they would only give me a plastic forks and knife. I will never go back read more

Stopped in here about 2 months ago. Friendly staff. Great beer selections and menu is great! Worth seeing for yourself!

Went here for lunch on a Friday with some coworkers. It wasn't very busy and we were served drinks right away but it took a very long time for them to take our food orders. It then took a while to get our food. When the three of us got our food, I was given the incorrect side and one of my coworkers was given the wrong bread. When we told the waitress, she was fairly rude but did bring us the correct food quickly. I had the cup of soup and half sandwich option, I got a half a chicken wrap and it basically had 3 bites of chicken in it and immediately fell apart. The wait staff was overall very friendly and that why I gave 2 stars. Will most likely not return. read more

Very good...things are opening back up...a bit. Outside seating for now. We had a BLT and fries. It was great and the server was super. Will be back. read more

Excellent place. I have not been for awhile but I used to go all the time. Try the Irish Rueben! Only complaint is the parking. It can be a pain some times. read more

Very good. Great location downtown. Plenty of parking. The Shepherd pie was one of the best I have had. Spices in the ground beef were excellent. Others had Rueben sandwich which they said were excellent. We had coupon which made it very reasonable. Would go again. read more

Never had a bad experience here! Love all of the food. Especially the Shepherds pie! Can even order with DoorDash now for delivery! Will always recommend here! read more

Food was decent, service was fast. Went here for late lunch when I traveling for business. Staff was friendly.

Always the best craft beers on tap. Open-faced ribeye sandwich and chicken wings are two of my favorites from Doherty's. Highly recommend for a low-key relaxed meal in an Irish restaurant atmosphere. read more

My favorite bar in town. Not my favorite restaurant, but nice options. And a great place to host events.