Over the years the McNallys menu has evolved but has remained consistently great. The food quality has also remained consistently great and the service is still solid. I love the introduction of their smoked traditional wings! As a person that loves a cold dark stout, McNallys is a great place to enjoy a Guinness pour. We have tried the: Fish and Chips Fish Po Boy (personal favorite) Rueben Traditional Wings with Asian Zing Traditional Nachos Irish Nachos ...and more They also have a great outdoor seating with outdoor heating to extend the outdoor availability into Fall. On some occasions you will be treated with live music either inside or outside. They also recently added a juke box which was a great addition. If you are visiting Sioux Falls sometime, definitely check out this great Irish bar nestled in the south central area of Sioux Falls, about 16 miles from the Sioux Falls airport. read more

See all

Hire some help. 20 people outside bar area. One wait staff for the whole establishment.

Atmosphere was great, lots of menu choices, friendly service and fantastic food. My husband had corned beef, I had bangers and mash.

All things were great! Food was good drinks were refreshing. Even had live music. They were ok read more

McNally's Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

I liked the good happy hour drink prices, the cheerful service and the nice interior at this Irish pub. The $2 happy hour discount took wells and draughts down to about $3.50 - nice. I noticed seven TVs, contemporary background music (not too loud), a wood toned interior with a fireplace, a nice patio, two small, private rooms and a patio. read more

See all

Great Service Reasonable prices Ambiance Great Kitchen prep time slow. Order food when you sit down! read more

This is a warm, comfortable place. It's really nice, but casual. I ordered the salmon and it was fabulous! The potatoes were good, and so were my veggies. This is probably the only time I have ever gotten squash that had a great buttery taste. It was seasoned perfectly. My husband and I are not from Sioux Falls, but we will definitely stop by again. Yum! (Also, we ordered cocktails that were great, too!) Sorry. My food smelled so good that I ate some before I took a picture. read more

McNally's Irish Pub - Salmon, potatoes, and mixed veggies - Irish Pub Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

Food was mid, but ambiance is terrible. Irish but with loud thash rock. I get it maybe for the after 8pm crowd but at dinner? Cool Irish pub playing loud American 90's rock? why? so weird. Won't be back. read more

We stopped hoping to grab some dinner. There's a nice outside area. Sitting out there we were asked if we were just drinkin' or eatin'. Originally we were going to split an app., but I was hungry so we decided on meals. I got the salmon and it was GREAT! The mashed potatoes were delicious. I even enjoyed the cooked veggies that came w/it, am I am NOT a huge cooked veggie fan. Hubby got some steak tips that came with bread and a dipping sauce. The steak was yummy. A little pricy for what we got, I think, but the food was good. Service was a little slow/off. My husband did receive a 'free' Guiness because the waitress made a mistake and ordered an extra. Can't complain about that! The inside is cool. A little too loud for my taste, but it's cool. They had a girl singing and playing a piano. Bathrooms were nice and clean. There was also a game room but I didn't check that space out. Menu is quite small, but that isn't always a bad thing. Typically that means they do their food well. The area this place is in is NICE! A 80,000 dollar car parked next to us! read more

McNally's Irish Pub - Salmon and mashed potatoe. - Irish Pub Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

We love McNally's. St. Patrick's Day it's a must but any day it s just a really nice comfortable place to eat and have drinks.

We had not been here in over ten years so we thought we would try it again. We should have waited another ten years. The food was worse than what I had remembered. I would not recommend going there for the food. The service was good and it is a nice place but they need to rethink the food they serve. read more

Came here for a late bite to eat and a drink. Fun interior with lively atmosphere - a live musician playing, and college football on tv. Service was prompt and kind. Went with the Philly Cheese - the hoagie was soft and warm and it had a healthy serving of steak. I did add hot sauce which was a nice touch in my opinion. Chips were solid but would rather have fries - not the MO here as I understand. Drink was solid, wish I remembered it's name. Also had the seasonal hot apple cider drink and it went down easy. read more

McNally's Irish Pub - Dublin Philly Cheese - Irish Pub Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

See all

Great wait staff. We tried 3 appetizers and 2 dishes. All was 'good enough' but not something to write home about. Prices were reasonable. We like the small rooms where. If you have a small child, you can shut the door and then when the child wants to walk about, it's walking within 'your space'. read more

Great spot to find. We were able to sit outside with our dog,eat a great meal and enjoy a cold beer. They brought our dog a dish of water. Everyone was super friendly. read more

Great service! Wonderful people! Beautiful patio! Amazing food! Couldn't have been a better experience!

The service at McNallys was exceptional. The ambiance was very pleasant and the food was very good. The only subtraction from the day was the drinks are poured very weak. A couple people in our party ordered shots and they were not even a full shot but a mini version. Drinks are over-priced for what you get. read more

Nice portions, the service was really nice. I loved the fish and chips, the fish was crispy and the fries were really good. The salads are nice portions. My hubby had the Reuben, was quite good, if not a bit too much meat for him. read more

Food was ok, but I recommend you Go to Blarney Stone on Phillips Ave. much better ambiance and vibe. More robust drink and food menu as well. read more

It had been one year since I'd been to McNally's because of COVID. Some nice improvements. The menu has been scaled down. My past few visits, the food was disappointing. Not this time! I ordered the Jameson Whiskey Steak. It was perfectly medium rare, very tender. The mashed potatoes were excellent. Great service! My only complaints - the chairs are too small for tall people! Also, the cutlery is cheap - difficult to cut even a good steak with a bad knife. read more

A place with a atmosphere that will give one the feeling of being in Ireland. Great food.

The wait staff was sooo thin (1 guy) that we got up to leave after waiting 15+ minutes after getting a drink. The waiter came over because I went to the bar to pay and leave. They had outdoor and indoor seating but the one waiter was having to handle both. The owner should be ashamed for putting him through that ordeal. The food? Either overpriced or too small a portion. Either way, highly forgettable. read more

A beautiful classy Irish establishment.... The eats are not mind blowing but the staff has always been pleasant. The Irish coffee is yummy. read more

McNallys is special to us. We had our 1st date there and also my fiancé proposed there. Last week we went for an early dinner about 4pm. The waitress was friendly and helpful. The Leek Soup looked more like a thick gravy, but it didn't taste as bad as it looked. A cheeseburger I ordered medium rare was overdone and very dry. We didn't order Bread Pudding this time because the last several times it was dry and hard. What used to be a fun place with delicious food has changed. We paid & tipped and left--but we will not be coming back. Days later we ended up downtown at the Blarney Stone. The food was great as it consistently always is and their Bread Pudding is to die for. We will be going there for our Irish fare. read more

Cool place, great staff, incredible bartender! Josh is killing it here. Hardest working bartending he area!

Update on the post. First time I had the pretzels they were awesome this time very disappointed. They not only were hard but they seem to have shrunk and the cost for three tiny pretzels $10. Won't be coming back anytime soon. Drinks we had the Jameson jewel which was very good. First post see below. Pretzels are awesome as is the Dublin tea, although a little strong on the sour. Stay away from the grape cough syrup also known as peach berry press as we were not fans same with the diet cherry Coke similar to robitusin . On a previous trip and Irish nachos were great, after work special! read more

McNally's Irish Pub - Pretzels at mcnallys - Irish Pub Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

Nice cozy spot for lunch with a fireplace! Excellent food as well as service!!!All of their soup is excellent!

Davis was the waiter when we went in on a Saturday at about 1 PM. He was very nice and helpful. I ordered a Shamrock Club Sandwich and it was pretty good (although I wish I would've ordered something else, I eat sandwiches too much). The place looked pretty clean, which is always good to see. The food came out fast as well. Additionally, this pub be playing the latest tracks and it had the pub popping so hard. And they had some college football games. Good vibe overall and this is somewhere I would definitely recommend for my friends and family to attend. The bathrooms were clean too. I don't have anything else to say. read more

See all

It's like St Patty's day 365 days a year. ALWAYS hard not to go with corned beef but the bangers here are my treat! read more

This place gives everything it promises. Irish beer, bangers and mash, a cozy atmosphere and the Irish nachos that don't totally make sense but are still good none the less. I'll be back. That walleye sandwich was much better than it needed to be. read more

Not a big fan! Good assortment of beers but food from kitchen was tasteless. Male manager didn't seem to care.

First time here and it was very good. If you like wedge salads you'll love this one!! Fish sandwich was good but could use some kind of a sauce. Bean and ham soup was very good as well. All complimented by some Guinness Blond, sooo smooth! Overall a great meal out, Thank you! read more

We arrived at about 5pm. Not too busy, but there were a few people already seated. Our waiter came over shortly after we sat down and soon brought us our "ice tea". It was wet and cold, lots of ice, pale brown, and tasted like water. He said he would be back in a couple of minutes to take our order. After he spent lots of time chatting with a pretty blonde waitress and serving other tables, he finally came to take our order. He couldn't answer a question about a menu item and finally asked a passing waiter. We ordered and waited for quite some time for our food to be served. The burger was over done and dry, but hot. The Dublin Dog arrived with cold toppings which apparently cooled the meat, and it also had a cold bun. When we told the waiter about it being cold, he sent a manager over. He offered to make another one, which we refused. Instead, they took half off the total bill. We thanked the manager. Will not get the Dublin Dog again, and will ask for the burger to be done medium well and not well done IF we get a burger at all. read more

Excellent Irish food and, of course, very good beer! Dish & Chips excellent, Shepard's Pie was outstanding, potato leek soup very good and a very festive (and LOUD) atmosphere.... just like an authentic Irish pub should have! Always pretty crowded but that's generally the sign of a good place to eat at! read more

I recently darkened the doors of McNally's Pub. It surpassed my expectations. The pub has a great sense of style with classic decor. My service was excellent. My waitress Annie was energetic, stunning, and helpful all at once. The owner/hostess Nickie was a delight to meet. Nickie's wit & charming smile make this an inviting place. A full bar & Irish kitchen makes this a perfect place to dine & drink. The Irish meatballs are a classic! read more

I have always been a fan of McNally's. I've been there many times and have never been disappointed. My two go to's are the bangers and mashed and the patty melt. I really enjoy that it is a 21 and up place to be with amazing food and plenty of drinks. It's nice to be in a place without a screaming baby or an annoying child! The staff are friendly and I always receive my food quick. Even during busy times. Tonight I went with the patty melt and the Apple and celery soup! I liked both and took half the patty melt home for a nice lunch tomorrow. I highly recommend visiting this charming restaurant. Sit on the patio during the nice weather for an enhanced experience. You won't go wrong with the quality offered here! read more

On a busy Friday night the service was outstanding. For that and a nice variety of whisky, they get three stars. Unfortunately, it was so loud we couldn't have a conversation, and this wasn't due to a live band, as there was none. I didn't know they were actually playing Irish music until I went the restroom and could hear it in there. The food left a lot to be desired; the meat loaf gravy was extremely salty, the green beans were cold, and the bread pudding was not sweet, neither was the Shamrock cake (even the cream cheese frosting was not sweet at all). My husband's top sirloin was mediocre, however, the Jamison sauce was tasty. Maybe if you were going with a group of friends and can out-yell the other patrons, and not order food, but just drinks, this would be the place. I do like that their Over 21 rule. read more

Great atmosphere in this pub located on the Southern end of Sioux Falls. It can be loud at times but I guess you get that with a busy overflowing pub. The food is typical pub food but tastes great. My biggest complaint is that I went in there once with my 2 yr old to have dinner on a quiet night and was told to leave. I guess the rules are different in South Dakota than other states and countries. Where I grew up there was always a family area in pubs where families could enjoy the atmosphere. They should have a sign that says 21+ only. Crazy when they act like a restaurant/pub but only allow adults.So they just get an A-OK from me. read more

I love this place! Live music on weekends. Great specialty drink menu (try the hard cider and Jameson or the Dirty Girl Scout). The decor is neat. And nice looking outdoor patio I'm excited to try once all the snow melts. Oh and the walleye sandwich is delicious, so good I actually had it for dinner two nights in a row. And if you like Guiness, they do a good pour. Not as good as what I had in Ireland (what is?) but better than every other one I've had in the U.S. and they will put a shamrock in the foam! read more

McNally's Irish Pub - Shamrock in the foam! - Irish Pub Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

I only ever take the time to leave a review if it's 5 stars and try to give disappointing places the benefit of the doubt and leave them be, but this will be an exception. Our waitress immediately came to our table to greet us and give us our drinks while we looked at the menu, then never returned. We patiently waited for over half an hour as we watched her repeatedly pass us giggling as she talked to her friend on the phone, never stopping once or even glancing at us. The place was far from busy--almost all the other tables were empty and waited on by other servers. We finally ended up walking out and leaving some cash on the table for my iced tea. Very unfortunate because we'd talked about going here for months and drove an hour and a half just to dine here. Nice ambiance and probably would have been a much better experience if we'd had any other server, but she spoiled it for us. Ended up going to the Blarney Stone Pub instead and had much better service and great (and larger) food and beer selection. read more

Great place. Beer selection is typical Irish but the whiskey selection is exceptional, including Green Spot and Red Breast pot still whiskeys. Turkey club hit the spot and service at the bar was good- just don't sit too close to the kitchen: sounded like kindergartners with tattoos in there. Great Irish atmosphere and decor. read more