This is our second time dining at Mavericks as a big group for Memorial Day weekend and we had another lovely experience. The service was impeccable and the waiter super approachable. The seafood towers were fresh and the quality outstanding! Everyone got either the tuna steak or the ribeye and we have no notes! Would definitely recommend! read more

Mavericks's prices are astronomical, but our experience was decidedly down to earth. Reserved a few weeks ahead requesting a sunset view table for a birthday celebration, but was given a small table with no view instead, just a few inches from our neighbors. Our server Shiljo acknowledged the birthday with a glass of bubbly, and he was friendly and helpful throughout the meal. My "Verdant Vesper" cocktail was fresh, a pretty green and tasty. Grilled oysters with kimchee were delicious but a paltry portion. Unfortunately our entrees fell flat. Why oh why would anyone obscure the sweet natural taste of fresh lobster with a very spicy thick red sauce, as the Chef did in his version of lobster radiatori? I'm fine with some judiciously used spice, but not when the star of the show is obscured. Partner's strip steak was a thick slab of bland beef, fairly tender but utterly lacking in taste/texture/marbling as prime meat should have. Creamed spinach side arrived with a large round marrow bone stuck in the middle of the bowl, a black spoon weirdly protruding from its center. The white gooey marrow wasn't cooked enough, so overall an unappetizing presentation. Cheesecake with a small dab of preserves was tasty and light. An interesting $$$$ experience, not one I'd necessarily care to repeat. Maybe I'm just not the intended audience for this particular culinary performance, and that's OK. read more

See all

Charlotte was absolutely amazing!! She was so fun and made the dinner for us so special. 10/10 experience! Can't wait to come back. Amazing ambiance! read more

We had a test run at this steakhouse in July with drinks and apps at the bar. I'll be back for a full dinner in August. Pro's: incredible views. New & beautiful restaurant. Upscale crowd. Cons: overly Expensive ($26 martinis). Indifferent service at the bar. read more

Wow, this place is terrible. So many reviews say the food is awful... I told my friends... they still wanted to go... all regretted it. I think it's built for people who get bedazzled by fancy surroundings, have unlimited money, and zero palate for food. I say this without exaggeration - I'm not a fancy person and not a pro chef, and I wouldn't have served a single dish we got here at my home to a guest, or myself, for a random weekday meal. The thought would've gone through my mind... "wow, this is really bad, I can't eat/serve this, let me try it again". How this food gets the okay from the chef, manager, and owner, is mind blowing. Roasted mushrooms - swimming in oil and tasteless Potato gratin - this is one of the worst dishes I've ever had... from top to bottom, every aspect couldn't have been worse Lobster cavatelli - a few small pieces of lobster in a sauce that tastes like one you can buy at the IGA Short rib - overcooked and tough... nobody wanted more than a couple of bites so we took it to go and fed it to our friend's dog... not joking. Price - yeah, it's absurd. But it's absurd for a summer in Montauk, which is saying something. You can get food that's actually edible at other restaurants in Montauk. Take your fancy pants off, get a sandwich somewhere in town (trust me it will be better than this), and go for drinks somewhere else. read more

My new favorite spot in the Hamptons. The service is phenomenal, the food is fantastic, the atmosphere is elegant and the view is beautiful. The steak is cooked to perfection, and the food comes out fast. I will be back!! read more

See all

Came for my birthday and had a great dining experience. All the food was fresh and flavorful. Cannot wait to come back again read more

Mavericks Montauk - Steak and lobster pasta with scalloped potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

My best friend and I had a 7:30 reservation on August 19th, 2025. The restaurant itself is beautiful, with stunning views, but unfortunately the service and food did not live up to expectations. Upon arrival, we waited at the reservation desk while the staff tried to resolve a computer system failure. Before even being seated, we were asked whether we'd be paying by cash or credit--which was asked again after we'd already been at the table for 10 minutes. It felt uncomfortable and set the wrong tone for the evening. Our waiter was pleasant but lacked knowledge about the menu, wines, and cocktails. At a restaurant of this caliber, I expect staff to be well-trained. For example, when ordering an Old Fashioned, the waiter didn't know how it was made; my friend assumed it would be with bourbon, but it was made with rye. I ordered a margarita specifically with Herradura Reposado, but it was made with blanco instead--and I was still charged for reposado. I let it go to avoid making the night more awkward for my friend, but it was disappointing. The food also missed the mark. Our Caesar salad was overdressed and far too salty. My gnocchi with chanterelles was gritty from not being cleaned properly, and though the menu mentioned black truffles, I was told they used truffle oil instead--yet there was no truffle flavor at all. For $42, I would expect shaved truffles, not an oily substitute. My friend's steak was cooked well but lacked even basic seasoning of salt and pepper. At these prices, I expect precision, care, and consistency in both service and the kitchen. Sadly, we received none of that. Beautiful setting, but the overall experience was not worth returning for. --Pierrette & Laura read more

Just....WOW. This was my first experience at Mavericks and it was absolutely incredible. First, let me say how great it was to have so many N/A drink options! The mocktails were killer! The food was out of this world. The apps were amazing, with my favorite being the tuna tartare. As for the entrees, I have never been a fan of swordfish, but my friend convinced me to try it and OH MY GOODNESS. It was delicious. The NY Strip was cooked PERFECTLY and the Amagansett Potato Gratin was my favorite! As for deserts....don't sleep on the key lime pie or the cheesecake. The view was stunning and the service was even better. I will 100% be returning!!! read more

See all

Too pretentious overpriced won't return any time soon .................cool for the younger crowd though

start with the food... one step above burger king - 240+ bucks for a porterhouse for 2... ohh u would like some sauce ... another 10bucks.. the service is sub-par , drinks are ok.... as they say...one and done.. read more

We recently tried Mavericks in Montauk and it was phenomenal! This is their sophomore season and they specialize in steaks We begin our meals with the Parker House Rolls, which are made in-house by their pastry chef! You MUST get, they're delicious! We also loved the Caesar salad It had a nice lemon flavored to it Their secret menu item is a gourmet burger made with ribeye fillet and New York strip meat and it is TO DIE FOR!! Seriously it is so good! It comes with Gruyère cheese and caramelized onions on a homemade Parker House roll. This is not on the menu, so be sure to ask your server about it. Come first serve to get in order to have one because it is the best burger we've ever had!! The lobster pasta was amazing. It is served with a spicy tomato basil sauce and the cavatelli is cooked to perfection! We all loved this dish. It's definitely one of the better pasta dishes we've ever had. If you are a lobster fan, this is for you! All the desserts made in house as well! You MUST GET the pecan pie, it was out of this world!! The crunchy pecans mixed with the warm pie and vanilla ice cream on top with a great combo and our favorite dessert! We also love ice cream sandwich with homemade chocolate chip cookies, you can never go wrong with a cookie The Staff is very knowledgeable of their menu and gave many great recommendations! Our waitress was so kind and thanks to her we had the best meal ever!! Additionally, the views of Fort Pond are amazing. You can dine either inside or outside. Both are beautiful in their own way! They also have a great bar. This is definitely a great place for dinner and drinks with friends If you were coming to Montauk this summer, you must come here #longisland #longislandeats #longislandfoodie #lifoodie #lifood #eeeeeats #foodandwine #foodies #tryitordiet #devourpower #eatfamous #brunch #lunch #dinner #dailyfoodfeed #eattheworld #cheatdayeats #cheatday #cheatmeal #delicious #foodieztm #foodiesinternationalchat #eatwithfoodiez#foodieexplorertribe #foodandbeverageonly read more

See all

Recently ate at Mavericks in Montauk. The food was exqusitie and the service was very fast. The restaurant has outdoor and indoor seating which is very nice with a gorgeous view of the ocean. Definitely recommend coming here when in Montauk. read more

Mavericks Montauk - Carrot soup - Steakhouses Near Me - Montauk, New York

Not baby friendly, does not allow strollers in the dining area and here is the topper they do not provide high chairs for babies " because of ADA regulations/restrictions. I did the research, not accurate. read more

The ambience is great, this is clearly the place to see and be seen for Hamptons out of towners. Come well dressed and mingle at the bar! The service was kind and attentive, we waited 45 mins for our table due to unexpected rain but made our first round of drinks complementary which was nice. The food was very solid but be wary, the main portions are very generous and we definitely felt we over ordered (a good problem to have). Overall enjoyed the experience and would go back again if in Montauk read more

See all

Mavericks was a big hit. Such a pleasure to enjoy a delicious dinner looking at a beautiful sunset and be attended to by an experienced and gracious waitstaff. Highly recommend! read more

Mavericks Montauk - Outdoor patio view...dreamy - Steakhouses Near Me - Montauk, New York

It was worth the wait! Mavericks opened last year and, bc my summer home is in Bridgehampton, i never got organized to arrange for the drive haha. FINALLY made it happen while on a staycation in Montauk with my partner Will for our one year anniversary. We had an 8PM reservation and were shown to an amazing corner banquette table with a spectacular lake view! We were greeted promptly and ordered a pair of martinis with blue cheese stuffed olives. We opted to splurge for our anniversary and went for broke with the caviar service ($170 for an oz so pricey) and the special boneless T bone for dinner with a side of cream corn. The knives presentation was a highlight haha! The caviar was luscious, the Bellini's hot, the steak perfectly cooked. We only had the two courses and it was enough for 2. We paired our main with a lovely Chablis by the glass. The room is BEAUTIFUL, live music, a great vibe and walls of windows so the view takes center stage. We enjoyed a nightcap on the terrace after dinner to make our night perfect. The staff - EVERY MEMBER: from hostess, to bus staff, to server and food runner to my dear friend Nick, the GM- was sheer PERFECTION! Attentive and professional without being too much or over selling. We joked as we were leaving that we needed to get a place in Montauk just to make Mavericks our neighborhood place! We loved it and will return soon!! read more

See all

Great food, drinks, location, and all around vibes. The staff was kind and caring. I had the strip steak and it really exceeded my expectations. I would love to return. Such a nice place in the beautiful hamlet of Montauk! read more

See all

really just ok.. Came here with High expectations. The food was good enough, but not spectacular. You are paying for the setting. Very nicely appointed restaurant on the water in a tourist town. We had a variety of steaks, fish and salads. One member of our party wanted a ceasars salad the only way to execute this was by ordering a full roast chicken dinner along with the salad. They couldnt do a chicken breast and upcharge us for that. Our waitstaff while pleasant and conversational was a bit low rent for what I would expect from a restaurant that ended up costing $155 per person for dinner. Keep in mind we only had mains, a few sides, no apps and only 3 drinks among us. Lastly, they had the nerve to put their bread on the menu as some special buns that they would charge $10 for. Really? $2.50 per roll when we are ordering entrees that range from $55-$129 plus sides.. Good thing we are only here for a week and don't have to really think about coming back. read more

Lovely setting, friendly staff, food mostly great. Just a few words about attention to detail: The sommelier should present the bottle of wine to the person who ordered it. My husband and I had dinner last night. I ordered a bottle of Bandol rosé from the server. The sommelier presented the bottle to my husband instead of me. My husband just nodded. I didn't see it. The sommelier opened the wine away from the table, brought it to pour and it was red wine not rosé. If he had presented the bottle to me I would have caught the mistake. I was offered a glass of rosé on the house. Which then appeared on the bill. We ordered shrimp cocktail and crab claws arrived. The server brought the shrimp later and said the crab claws were on the house. Which was good because they were tasteless. We ordered chocolate cake and vanilla ice cream from the dessert menu - it arrived without the ice cream. Your restaurant is very beautiful and the prices are very steep. $452 for 2. I was surprised at these missteps. read more

We had a great dinner at Mavericks in Montauk on Friday night. The restaurant is located in a beautiful new building with huge windows that offer stunning views of the pond. We made a reservation in advance, which I would recommend as the restaurant is quite popular. The food was interesting and creative. We started with the bread appetizer. For our mains, we had the lobster pasta, the tuna, and the steak. The lobster pasta was creamy and flavorful, the tuna was cooked perfectly, and the steak was juicy and tender. We shared one bottle of wine, which was a good choice for us. The staff was very attentive and made sure that we had everything we needed. They even cut the tuna and steak for us so it was easy to share. Overall, we had a great dining experience at Mavericks. The food was delicious, the views were stunning, and the service was excellent. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a special night out in Montauk. Pros: Interesting food Beautiful views Excellent service Dress to impress atmosphere Great for groups Cons: Can be pricey Bathroom labeling is confusing Additional details: We sat indoors We made a reservation in advance We shared everything for a group of 4 Outside seating is first come first serve as is one long table inside read more

See all

Great setting. Beautiful. Very overpriced (comically). Food is bland (steak, gnocchi and creamed spinach) and they added random glasses of wine to bill. Seemed intentional but who knows. read more

The ambiance was wonderful, I mean sunset views. The service was good, not great. And I say this only because it was my daughters birthday and they brought her cake out when everyone had gone to the bathroom and so she got her cake with nobody at the table but me and her when there was seven of us... that sucked since it was her dinner. The food was good but overpriced. I mean $215 for a t-bone for two is expensive but I felt in this case not worth it. Not melt off the bone $215. The other dishes when I asked were just ok I was told, nothing stood out flavor wise... and it seemed like kitchen was rushed as my other daughter asked her steak to be taken back to be actually cooked to medium rare not raw for my other daughter for example. So really 3.5 but no halves so the stars fall on the four side. And honestly, the cost and being overall service makes me not want to go back. read more

Order the swordfish! Outdoor dining is beautiful ! Nice sunset. I enjoyed the soft jazz and contemporary decor. The tuna tartare was spectacular! The sides of mushrooms and beet greens were so so. read more

This was a last minute change because our original plans did not work out at Surf lodge even with reservations and we were disgusted so left. But we are so happy that it happened because Mavericks was the place to be. They took us last minute reservations and were super polite. The entire staff is professional and personable while friendly especially our host Christian (I believe was his name - I had many amazing drinks that night). They had live music and the atmosphere was lively without being noisy. read more

Asked for the steak to be sliced and it came out not sliced. Waiter tried arguing with us saying it was sliced when it clearly wasn't. 1st cocktail had a fly in it, waiter never apologized even after bringing out a 2nd one with half the liquid in it which he blamed to a bigger ice cube in the 1st one. Cocktail without the fly I rate a 8/10 and the steak was fatty and overcooked so it gets a 6.5/10. Come here with low expectations and you'll leave happier than I left. Try to sit by the window, they stuck us as far from the window as possible even though we were the 1st table here. read more

Mavericks Montauk - Brown Butter Old Fashioned (1st one had a fly in it) - Steakhouses Near Me - Montauk, New York

Let me start with the decor - beautiful, warm, sexy, spacious, and fancy. It's not the usual beachy type place you get in Montauk a lot; this is more Manhattan style. The service was good, prompt, polite. There was a weird thing where we sent back the beef kebab because it was done more than described, and it was dry. The waiter took to back to the kitchen and brought it back again to show us it was pink. It really wasn't but why bring it back to show us?! It wasn't up to par and the prices are steep; so we expect great not blah. The better things we had: - tomato salad was insanely good! - beef kebabs were good, but could be better. Medium is pink in the middle (not red as waiter described). May have affected the quality. - lobster pasta was excellent in taste and tons of lobster pieces in the dish. - summer squash: blah is flavor; would skip it - bone marrow: what you would expect and I liked it! - creamed corn: delicious read more

See all

Went here to celebrate my 5th year wedding anniversary and it really disappointed us. One dish I was excited to try because it was marked gluten free, come to find out it wasn't. So I decided to get their very pricy wagyu steak and it was extremely tough and gamy I could not eat it. The food was very dissatisfying for the price. read more

Incredible food delivered from Chef Jeremy Blutstein and Chef Remy Ertaud. All the produce used in their dishes are fresh and local. Beautiful restaurant with amazing views all around, whether you're inside or outside. The entire staff is very warm, welcoming and knowledgeable. A visit that is an absolute must in Montauk! Always a pleasure. read more

Not happy at all. Beautiful place and ambience. Food was not great super expensive. I've had better steaks in many other restaurants

Nice ambiance. Food is good but service is mediocre. Management is unapologetic about service. Took a while to get service.

overpriced food, And mediocre at best. we were rushed through out the entire meal. Asked to leave table after 2 hours. Owner said we only had 2 hours at the table. Will never go back. Way better places in MTK. read more

Mavericks newly opened this summer and is a welcome addition to the restaurant scene in the area. The location is beautiful, right on the water, sunset views and with outdoor seating available when the weather is nice. The menu has a nice selection of options, from steaks to fish to raw bar. Highly recommend! read more

Outstanding! Food, service, vibe. Went back 2 times in one week. Besides the food and service, was really happy to see a genuine wine list that's both well crafted and thoughtful. read more

See all

I was super excited about going for dinner here, but was unfortunately extremely disappointed by how our party was treated by the hosts and managers. Upon sitting down, we noticed that there were a fair amount of guests being seated wearing flip-flops, hoodies, and graphic T-shirts when we had understood the restaurant as a place to dress up for dinner. When our party was seated we were immediately greeted by how cold it was in the restaurant for a particularly cool night outside and asked our server whether it would be possible to turn down the air conditioning. She was responsive and told us that she had made the request, but since the temperature hadn't felt like it changed, one of the members of our party told her that she was going to get a hat for the cold. Our party ordered drinks (which we found that the cocktails were the same price when ordered with or without the alcohol) and a couple of courses for the meal. For the first course, one of our appetizers was a soup, which unfortunately came out of the kitchen cold (it was not intended as a cold soup). The rest of our appetizers and dishes were good, but felt priced highly. At the end of our meal, after ordering coffee and dessert, a hostess came over to our table and told the person in our party wearing a hat to take it off. We explained that our meal was almost over and that it was incredibly cold so the hat was a way to enjoy the meal without feeling too marred by the cold. She persisted in telling us that the hat needed to be taken off and that it wasn't permitted in the restaurant. The person in my party left the table and went outside to wear the hat and upon leaving was accosted by the manager who was exceedingly rude about the situation, yet wouldn't explain why people wearing flip flops (made for the beach, in a worn in the sun, sand, and dirt way) and T-shirts weren't escorted from the restaurant as we were. After leaving, I looked at their website, and found that their dress code states that flip-flops and athletic attire - as we saw so clearly at the restaurant - are not permitted. I am not sure why we were targeted and other guests were not. The unfortunate fact that stuck with me was that we were seated at the table closest to the door and were thus visible to the hosts and management the whole meal - why did the management wait until we had ordered every course and spent as much money as possible to force us to leave? read more

Really impressed! The ambiance is amazing and we were really impressed with the steak variety and shrimp. Already have our next reservation booked. David the manager is the best! read more

Mavericks Montauk - Steakhouses Near Me - Montauk, New York

When I tell you this place is overpriced: holy hell it's overpriced. Just to give you an idea, they have a broccoli side dish, and it's $24! $24 for broccoli! The "hand cut fries" which were terrible, were also like $20 and just not good. I will say I really expected the sides to be tiny portions but they were decent sized. The gratin potatoes was enough for 4. Steak was really well cooked and the seafood was fresh: pretty standard bougie Montauk crowd. Beautiful views and restaurant but I didn't think it was worth the price. There is much better food and service for less in Montauk read more

Came here after what appeared to be their reopening over Memorial Day weekend and my gosh - the ambience & their service! We tried our luck and arrived about an hour before our reservation and they were able to seat us. Our server was extremely attentive & thoughtful. Must order - these dishes blew us out of the water!!! Grilled Oysters Wood Grilled Bone in Swordfish Texas Waygu Steak Definitely will be revisiting :) read more

We had a reservation at 9:00 P.M. for 7 to celebrate a birthday here last night. They called us to confirm around 2 P.M. and all was well. We then received a text message at 8:30 P.M. to remind us of our reservation. We arrived at 8:55 P.M. to a sign on the door (pictured below) stating that the restaurant was closed. Clearly, they had the necessary contact information to inform their customers of the emergency closing. Most restaurants in town are closed at this time and we were left stranded, hungry, and dressed for a celebration, driving from restaurant to restaurant looking for a restaurant to accommodate our large party. Needless to say, this is extremely unprofessional and the complete opposite of the service we expect at a "fine dining" establishment. We will never attempt to dine here again. Not a courtesy call, text, or even follow up apology. Disgusting! Thankfully, Talya accommodated our party. read more

Mavericks Montauk - Steakhouses Near Me - Montauk, New York

Waited 1 hour and 15 mins for one drink. Begged 4 people to serve us and no one would. When I got my martini it was warm. We said to the manager we've been waiting for over an hour and his response was that sucks. Then we paid full price. The food is not even good... save your money and skip this place Good ambiance though read more