Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mathers Realty

    2.0 (3 reviews)

    Services - Mathers Realty

    Apartments

    Property management

    Mathers Realty Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mathers Realty

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    14 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Apartments 228 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Stull Real Estate

    Stull Real Estate

    (11 reviews)

    I rented a 1 bedroom apartment at Stull Apartments on Locust in in 2023. My move in date kept…read moregetting moved back. I finally got in. The reason for the delays was they were "cleaning". Unfortunately, the cleaners were not professional cleaners. It took me 2 months to actually get it clean myself. I had no walk through with them, so I did it myself in writing complaining about all that needed repair. I dated it and had Karen sign it. The refrigerator was so noisy it kept me awake at night. She finally replaced it after a month with another old refrigerators that defrosted into the unit. I had to use a large pot inside to catch the water. No replacement for that. The apartment came with a washer and dryer that smelled bad and the dryer sounded like it was full of sand. No replacement for that. Any time she sent a handyman, except for one, they looked and acted like they lived on the street. I refused to let them in my apartment. The one that was a professional refused to do any more work for Karen because she wouldn't pay him! Because I complained constantly about the apartment and appliances she said she would let me out of my lease. I was gone in 6 months. I still have friends that live there and all have the same issues. I wish that a complaint would be made with the realtors association that they would actually check out. Karen Stull is a negligent landlord.

    When you have an appointment to meet with a potential client, usually the idea is to SHOW UP to the…read moreappt! No call, no anything. Bush league business. Look at all the other 1 star reviews. They're there for a reason.

    Dona Ana Properties

    Dona Ana Properties

    (21 reviews)

    Illegal scam business. Literaly with extort money illegally…read more Literaly tried to scam me of 1750 with a fake "move in fee" with a cat "cleanup" charge issued before a cat even existed here. There is NO mention of this on the lease Also they will make up FAKE damages, and absolutely without a shadow of a doubt charge you to exploit you. They tried to charge me $150. To replace UNDAMAGED $15 blinds. The amount of manipulation they used to falsely and blatantly tell me that 25% of $1200 was $388 and charge me for it Scam and fraud.

    People PLEASE read all reviews, the few 5 star reviews have been paid for by Dominic. I personally…read moreknow a man who was being paid by Dominic to post fictitious 5 star reviews under various names. He was told exactly what Dominic wanted them to say. I read an email from Dominic stating exactly what to say how to word it, with a note at the bottom of the email stating if he exposed this Dominic would evict him and black ball him so he wouldn't be able to rent in Las Cruces. You will notice many more 1 star reviews, read them fully. Do not trust the 5 star reviews the are most definitely fake. You will notice most of the 1 star reviews have a common theme. Unfortunately my sister still lives in one of his properties, almost 8 years now, and still the broken windows have not been replaced, my sister has taped over them in hopes to keep the pieces in place so the pieces don't continue to fall out and the whole become larger. For $2500 a month you would think he would make repairs such as that. I let everyone I know who is looking for a rental company to manage their homes, DO NOT CALL DONA ANA PROPERTIES, HE WILL NOT RESPECT YOUR PROPERTY. There are much nicer, friendlier, respectful rental companies to go with. THIS IS NOT ONE OF THEM. MY OPINION THIS IS THE ABSOLUTE WORST COMPANY TO TRY TO DO BUSINESS WITH.

    Steinborn David M Realtor

    Steinborn David M Realtor

    (1 review)

    I have used Steinborn since moving away from LC several years ago…read more * They have been and continue to be surprisingly unresponsive ignoring emails and phone calls more often than not. -- when they do respond, they provide incomplete or unclear answers * They have made modifications to the wiring of my home at the request of the tenants and *without* seeking approval from me. -- mind you these were *changes* not repairs -- they billed me for the work * They neglected to tell me the tenants did not exercise their option for a 3rd year on the lease *after* telling me the tenants wanted to and I gave approval -- 6 months later I get the surprise that the tenants are leaving when I believed they still had another 6 months on the lease * I requested an appraisal on the house several times and was completely ignored * When I called management (several times) to complain, I never got a return phone call -- they did switch me to a different property manager who is, frankly, no better * I have had billing errors, being charged the management fee twice in a month -- I have to catch these errors and go after them to get them fixed * For all this, they charge a fee of 10% These outfit is breathtakingly unprofessional and disinterested in any kind of customer service. It's as if they flipped on the auto-biller and went to sleep. I could probably do better offshoring the property management to a 3rd world country in Asia. Do not make the mistake I did. Steer clear of this firm.

    Mathers Realty - apartments - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...