We had an AMAZING stay! Very safe, quiet, clean and well…read morekept bed & breakfast. Host was attentive, available and friendly. Breakfasts are homemade and delicious! This will be our go-to when we visit again!

Excellent place and value. Excellent location and wonderful people. Loyal customers.read more

If you stay here its like the1800's. There is no bathroom or TV, BUT the bath areas across the hall…read moreare all brand new and super nice. Its right downtown so perfect for putinbay fun. it was $214 for TWO rooms for the night. my biggest complaint? The room wreaked of cigar smoke. The should have never offered this room until it was free if this smell. we stayed here last year and it really is fun to be right downtown.

I think most of the reviews here nailed it so this won't be long. Victorian charm, beautifully…read moremaintained, comfortable beds, friendly staff, pastries and coffee for breakfast. Our cab driver told us this is the only place his family stays when they come to visit the island. We were there on a weekday so the place was very quiet and I never saw any other guests on our floor. The toilet stalls are very small, and there's one and sink and two shower stalls to share (for men, at least). Not a problem midweek but I'm not sure how that would play out on a crowded weekend. I couldn't get the Wifi to work in our room, the signal was too weak. But it is available in the lobby and maybe it's better in other rooms.

this place was run down dirty and you could hear the people next door like they were sitting in…read moreyour room....the staff was non existent ....just horrible ...stay away

This phenomenal place needs more reviews. It is impressively clean and cozy. A little small but I…read moreenjoyed the cleanliness and updated feel of it all and didn't need extra room for anything so it was all good. Also, I really liked the balcony and chairs for people watching. The staff are friendly and try their best to accommodate you and your requests. I will be staying here for each visit to Put in Bay. Thank you!

When looking for a place to stay while we visited Cedar Point, there were a lot of expensive places…read morethat didn't fit our budget. Thankfully we found the Maples! It's only slightly further out from the theme park than other hotels and infinitely worth the price reduction. The fancy old school neon sign out front is a helpful waypoint when you're coming back after dark (no missing your turn!). This isn't a chain location; it's independently owned and operated by a swell fella named Steve. Steve was very friendly and happy to have us for three nights. Each morning we were able to go over to the "office" (the back of his home) and snag free coffee, donuts, fruit, and granola bars (no COVID excuses!). He said hi to us or waved whenever he saw us enter or leave the property. And what a gorgeous piece of property it is! We both really enjoyed the more "homey" feel to this over the traditional parking lot + multifloor hotel. The rooms are small and honestly reminded me of my grandma's old house, which is probably accurate because this place was probably built around the 1950's. You can see it in the tile bathrooms and fixtures. That said, it is on the older side so there are some imperfections here and there if you look close. Some rusty grout, some warped wood, that kind of thing. Sure, it'd be nice if some renovations were done. But again, we spent the majority of our time riding roller coasters, not relaxing in our room so we really weren't seeking a "resort" experience. It all depends on what you're looking for in a stay. There is a pool which we unfortunately never got the time to utilize, but it looked really nice and the hours are generous. The ice machine worked really well so we were never without cold water to drink. The only thing that was missing that would've been really nice to have was a mini fridge/microwave so we could have some meals without going out. Each room also comes with a fold-out little bed so you can sleep an additional person or child. I actually ended up using it because it was softer than the full-sized bed. Steve was generous in supplying additional soap bars/shampoo during our multi day stay. The TV worked well and had all the standard channels. The wi-fi worked great for all my needs! A/C was functional and not too loud. Do note that this place is right next to the railroad tracks and trains will go by throughout the day/evening. We noticed the busiest time seemed to be 7am. The trains always blow their whistle while going by and it is quite loud.

This place is a VIBE and has a family business for 100 years! Not going to lie, the photos almost…read morethrew me off and we almost didn't stay here. However, when a business is open for 100 years, you have to give it a shot! First, I highly recommend that the owners hire a social media manager and post pictures that do this place justice. The grounds are super cute and the sign offers a great photo op! Walking into the room brought an enormous rush of nostalgia. It was cool to be able to stay in a place that my grandparents would have stopped at in their younger years. Most importantly, the rooms and bathrooms were super clean!! The room comes with a modern television and a small refrigerator. The property owners are very personable and, as part of your room fee, they provide freshly made local donuts each morning. The donuts are worth the stay alone. In this day and age, we were surprised to be able to find such a cool Experience for such little cost. Easy parking, beautiful pool (we didn't use it but it looked nice), amazing customer service. Without hesitation, we will stay here whenever we are back in town. Maples Motel is a historic treasure and I highly recommend staying here.

Better than you'd think…read more Family owned motel, but it's clean and well-kept. Service was great, like they really care it goes well for you. Breakfast is not great, but again, better than you'd expect. Love the pancake atm machine! Value was stupendous, $202 for a two-room suite with three double beds. Only two real drawbacks: beds are not comfortable, and coffee is watery.

Schitt's Creek vibe. Definitely some of the reviews have nostalgia to them. South Shore Inn has a…read moreprime location, and during Cedar Point's busy season you'll definitely pay for that convenience. We booked last minute because of a basketball tournament and there weren't many options available. The hotel had great reviews, so we decided to give it a try. To be fair, the rooms were relatively clean, and you can tell they've tried to update an older motel. The front desk staff was very friendly and accommodating throughout our stay. The complimentary breakfast was simple but well done, and the older ladies running it were hardworking, welcoming, and kept everything stocked. The pool & hot tub were great. Almost no one uses it during the day. That said, for a room that cost nearly 300 a night, I expected more. The rooms are very small, the air conditioner was extremely loud, and there was a noticeable gap under the door that could easily let bugs or other critters inside. The biggest issue was that some of the posted rules didn't seem to be enforced. The pool was supposed to close at 11 p.m., but there was still quite a bit of activity afterward. There is also a picnic area where another sports team gathered with a large Bluetooth speaker playing music late into the night, making it difficult to relax and sleep. Overall, it's a decent place if you need a convenient location near Cedar Point, but be prepared to pay premium prices during peak times for accommodations that are fairly basic. Pro tip: Book directly with the hotel instead of using Hotels.com or similar sites. The direct rates were significantly lower than what the third-party booking sites were charging.

We loved the suites. They let us have a room to store our bags when we first arrived on the island…read moreuntil check-in. They had some snacks we could grab and the girls were so nice. The suite was great and we had a lot of fun. Really close to the bar strip and food so we didn't need a golf cart (just a taxi to get from the ferry to the suite)

We checked out Island House Hotel as part of the Walleye Drop to ring in 2026…read more I scoured reviews to see what I could find out about it, and it turns out the hotel is now individual vacation rentals. It seems that a large majority are managed by a few vacation rental management companies, so could explain why some had different experiences than others. As some other reviewers stated, yes the rooms are small.. but it's a historic hotel. If you've ever stayed anywhere historic, this is pretty common. Nothing unusual. The room was clean and pleasant. Due to it being a holiday, I'm sure the rate was a bit higher because this hotel is centrally located. This is the upside, you can walk to everything from the hotel. Parking was included and plentiful, and the self-check in/out was smooth. As some have noted, the instructions come by email so make sure you watch for that. Overall I have nothing bad to say about it- worked out great for us for what we wanted.

It's a good place to spend a night if all you need is a bed. We stayed in room 2210 which was…read morecalled the Babe Ruth room (the rooms all have individual names). We had a king bed (not very comfortable) a mini-fridge, microwave, and a TV. Sink was backed up and was slow to drain, but the shower was hot and fine. It's really a no-frills place, so don't expect any more than that. The hotel opens up to a street that is blocked off and has live entertainment which is another plus. I'd probably come back but it wouldn't be my first choice.

The Maxwell House is a gem in Lakeside! The location couldn't be better, being just up a bit from…read morethe several small businesses that line walking only street. The porch is a perfect place to sit with a cup of coffee and watch the day go by or talk to the always engaging owner, Jeanne. Maxwell's is right across the street from the Lakeside auditorium so, when shows are occurring you can enjoy the sound from the porch. Just a great family run, period bed and breakfast!

You will be greeted by the oh so lovely Jeanne and you will thoroughly enjoy your stay at this…read morelovely bed and breakfast. 4 minute walk to the shore and the cutest shooed surrounding. " Guest House. Open Memorial Day through Labor Day at Lakeside Chautauqua. Victorian Home with terrific front porch. Home available off season for groups. Retreats, Reunions, Study. Come relax with us for a weekend or a week or longer!"