Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza, located inside Plant Street Market, downtown Winter Garden is a…read moregreat place if you are looking for pizza. Their menu is pretty large and they cook their items in the coal fire pizza oven. I like that since it gives it that crispy crunchy pizza. Their location is inside Plant Street which has a ton of food places. The best thing about Plant Street is that everyone can get what they want. There are tables throughout Plant Street and Michael's Ali Coal Fire has a few bar seats at their location as well. They specialize in pizza but do have additional options such as stromboli's, wings, and sandwiches. There are some specialty pizzas on their menu but you can also create your own, which is what we did. Next time we will probably go with a specialty pizza just to try it out, but we went with pepperoni and bacon. It was also topped with a little basil. The bacon was pretty much nonexistent but it did have a slight saltiness to it, so I'm sure it was there. My wife loves bacon on her pizza so she definitely wished there was more of it. Overall it was a great pizza. We actually ordered it to take home since we had already had some food at Plant Street. However, it was good and hot and fresh, we ate the entire thing. The pizza is not overall large, I think about 6-7 slices. We shared since we were trying a lot of things. The crust was also really crispy, and not overly charred as sometimes coal fire pizzas can get. Another item we wanted to try but were too full, was the Cheesy Bread which has Roasted Garlic Oil fired with Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Provolone & Gorgonzola. We saw someone else get it and it really looked delicious, very cheesy and really good. The team who works here is also really nice. They were friendly, let us take our time, offered to answer any questions and were just nice. They had a little game going and would ask a question as you paid. They were keeping track of answers. Overall, this is a great spot. I would come back anytime we felt like a pizza. Very great food! ACES!

Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza is located inside Plant Street Market in downtown Winter Garden. It…read moreis a local pizza spot serving really great food. They actually have a really large menu for a small spot. They are closer to Crooked Can. There are some seats at their spot (similar to bar seats), but most people get their food to go and eat around Plant Street. Plant Street is a market that has tons of permanent vendors, most of which are food. This spot is truly Italian specializing in pizza but there are other options as well. Some of those options include stromboli's, wings, and sandwiches. They have a few different specialty pizza selections but then you can also create your own. We like to create our own but all their specialty pizzas sounded absolutely delicious. Next time, I think we will pick one of the specialty ones. We went with just pepperoni and bacon. The bacon was hardly present but did give a nice saltiness to the pizza. The pizza was on the thinner side which I love, it was crispy on the edges and just a really great pizza. We actually ordered it with the intention of taking it home for the next day, but it was so good, we ended up eating it all that night. Something we wanted but we were so full from other food options at Plant Street was the CHEESY BREAD which has Roasted Garlic Oil fired with Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Provolone & Gorgonzola. This is something we will for sure be getting next time. It sounded so great! For pizza we will be getting the BUFFALO CHICKEN which is Hot Wing Sauce Base, Roasted Chicken, Gorgonzola, Provolone, Mozzarella...Finished with Celery. Their options are just really great. The servers were super friendly as well. They will take your phone number and text you when its ready. This way you can go walk around, grab a table, grab a beer from Crooked Can and wait for your food. This is definitely a spot you need to try out when you are at Plant Street! Great food, great employees and a fun atmosphere.

Best pizza I've had in central Florida and it's less than a mile from our house! Not sure why it…read moretook us so long to try it, but it's phenomenal! We've been four times in the last month and have turned it into a weekly meal! Veteran owned and offers a discount for veterans and military! That's amazing because you don't see that a lot around here and means so much as the spouse of an active duty Air Force member! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. I love the casual atmosphere! The crust is chefs kiss and the sauce is the best I've had. You can tell they put a lot of love into their pizza and have a real craft!

To go review; No…read morenotes on the service or the ambience. I love greasy New York style pizza with a good crispy crust. I'm also slightly weird that I really enjoy pepperoni and pineapple pizza. So as you can see from the pictures, we got a half and half. The pizza was absolutely fantastic, however, it was ice cold when it arrived. It's hard to know if it was a long delivery time, it's been super cold outside, or if it sat for a while before being picked up. I don't blame the restaurant that, and the pizza was very delicious! I'm looking forward to going in person and trying them out. Garlic knots were delicious pizza sauce was fantastic, and the chocolate chip cannoli was devoured and enjoyed by all. It was a little pricey, but then again everything nowadays feels more expensive. I did really appreciate on the to go box that they had a flyer to purchase online noting that they deliver and you can save money versus Ubereats or GrubHub. Will update the review after I go in person.

I had a great experience at Cariera's Fresh Italian. The atmosphere is warm, friendly, and very…read morewelcoming. The food is absolutely delicious--especially the lasagna and the lemon chicken, which were both amazing. Highly recommend!

Cariera's Fresh Italian is a pretty solid option for Italian if you are in Winter Garden, Florida…read moreand seeking that wonderful cuisine. Cariera's Fresh Italian is located in the Tri City Center on West Colonial Drive (State Road 50). The service here was friendly and the place has a pleasant enough ambiance and vibe. If you are in the area, I would definitely recommend Cariera's Fresh Italian.

Wonderful time couldn't believe it meet and greet very nice staff very friendly staff and amazingly…read moreaccommodating and helpful unbelievable beautiful people

I place an online order for a stromboli through their website. I waited for about five minutes and…read morethe status of the order never moved from "sending order." I called to verify and they confirmed the order was received, while the website was still sending the order. I was disappointed to see the size of the stromboli for the price I paid. The price wasn't unreasonable but you can get more for your money at other places. I thought the bread was a little thick. The stromboli had great flavor. The cheese and other ingredients also went pretty close to the edges.

Delicious pizza! Service was good--quick to deliver our order minutes after we arrived. Environment…read moreis a typical pizza joint--nothing special.

Food usually always a wonderful experience this time we had it delivered through their delivery…read moreservice 40 minutes later we get cold pizza soggy mozzarella sticks cold spaghetti... is what it is this time :/

This is one of the most unique places to get a pizza on the west side. This is my second time…read morecoming to Pinottis and it does not disappoint. Interior feels high-end and the dining experience there is very elevated, but the service and vibes are down to earth. It's just like your classic mom and pop shop only a little fancier feeling. This is a great place for both a date night and a family gathering. I got the large pizza and pal, vegetarian zucchini and half chicken. The staff is really nice to let me know that that's an option and who doesn't love a little variety. Be prepared their prices for a large are a bit up there and this ended up being close to $40. It's definitely delicious and was checking out. Dig In!

Pinotti's Pizza isn't just a local favorite in Winter Garden; it's a culinary experience waiting to…read morebe discovered. This independent pizzeria consistently tops the charts as one of the most popular spots in the city, and a single bite reveals exactly why locals are so loyal. Forget the chains and immerse yourself in the authentic taste of Winter Garden by trying their acclaimed dishes. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, a visit to Pinotti's promises new favorite flavors and a true taste of local pizza perfection. Pinotti's Pizza no es solo un favorito local en Winter Garden; es una experiencia culinaria por descubrir. Esta pizzería independiente encabeza constantemente las listas como uno de los lugares más populares de la ciudad, y un solo bocado revela exactamente por qué los lugareños son tan fieles. Olvídate de las cadenas y sumérgete en el auténtico sabor de Winter Garden probando sus aclamados platos. Ya seas residente de toda la vida o solo estés de paso, una visita a Pinotti's te promete nuevos sabores favoritos y una auténtica experiencia de pizza local.

Refreshing peach pizza was delicious with great service by Katie. Will definitely returnread more

Food is always great at MangoniKatie was a great server with great recommendations!! We love the…read morespecialty pizzas and fun drinks!

OBSESSED with this spot! My husband who is a PA native says this is the best pizza he's had in…read moreFlorida. We had done takeout previously and it was just as good. The ambiance inside is fantastic. The flooring inside is filled with iconic pictures with pizza photoshopped in. We will absolutely be back again and again and again!

Every once in a while, you find a pizza place that doesn't just meet expectations -- it resets…read morethem. AJ's Pizza is exactly that kind of discovery. What immediately separates AJ's from the crowded pizza scene is their ability to execute multiple styles at a high level. Whether you're craving a crispy-edged Detroit, a hearty Sicilian, or a classic New York thin pie, this kitchen clearly understands the craft behind each one. Start with the garlic knots -- exceptional. Golden, flavorful, and perfectly textured with just the right balance of garlic and well seasoned red sauce. The meatballs follow suit: tender, rich, and tasting unmistakably homemade. Add a thoughtfully selected wine list, and it's clear this isn't just a pizza stop -- it's a complete dining experience. Then came the recommendation that made the night memorable. The hostess suggested the Maui Maui Detroit-style, and take this advice without hesitation -- order it. The caramelized cheese crust delivers that signature Detroit crunch, while the chili-infused pineapples create a surprisingly sophisticated sweet heat that elevates every bite. It's bold, addictive, and executed with confidence. Equally impressive is the staff. Friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely engaged, they guide you through the menu with the kind of enthusiasm that signals pride in what they serve -- always a strong indicator of a well-run restaurant. AJ's isn't just another pizza spot; it's a place for people who take their pizza seriously. Rare to find, difficult to forget, and absolutely worthy of becoming a regular destination.

Rating: 5/5 Fantastic first visit to Mister O1 in Dr…read more Phillips. Our server was incredibly welcoming and guided us through the menu with excellent recommendations. She even brought out a spicy olive oil that added a perfect kick to the pizza. We started with the Burrata Caprese--the cheese was delicious, and the rich balsamic glaze even made the arugula enjoyable. The Star pizzas are the highlight; the crust is light and crispy, and the ricotta-filled points are a brilliant touch. The Beckham (bacon and ranch) and the Luca/Alessandro (pepperoni and zucchini) were both hits. We finished with the decadent banana Nutella calzone. A must-visit!

I've been enjoying coming here for the last two years now and I'm extremely picky with gluten-free…read morepizza gluten-free vegan pizza is very hard to make. It's very hard to make it taste good. It's very hard to just in general just make gluten-free pizza because sometimes the crust is horrible.. As for service, I guess it's OK. I only get it to go. I don't ever eat inside the restaurant.. The only downside I have is that they're gluten-free dessert pizza is horrible. It's only horrible because they use the same crust that has herbs in it..... so an herb pie crust surrounded by Nutella. It's absolutely disgusting. Best pizza other than Disney in the area

Very good Italian style restaurant, NY style pizza and menu…read more Service is excellent and it's easily accessible

Solid pizza / Italian spot in a trip mall. But don't let looks deceive you. When you walk in, it…read morefeels very cozy and intimate and the place was filled with families etc, it felt nice. We loved it , our waitress was very helpful. She brought us garlic bread and apparently it is for free, which was a nice touch with the entrées. Everything tasted pretty standard, but great. We will be back since we live in the area. We will try the stone fired pizza next time. Cheers