I work with people who seek my assistance to procure toys and other unique items for their collections. I joke that I'm a Toy Hunter for fun. Not my full time job but I do love going into odd and ends stores to find a specific item. It's the thrill of the find that I chase for. So every time my husband and I are vacationing across the country, we spend a little bit of that time to find vintage shops like this one to find what is needed for his collection or others. I've been in search for a 2017 Mighty Morphin Red Ranger, made by Bandai, and is part of their "Build a Zord" collection, for about 5 years now. For whatever reason, my husband missed the opportunity to purchase this item when it came out. Time passed and when we finally located that item, the scalpers were selling them for an arm, a leg, and your first born child. I found the exact item on eBay from Make Cents and purchased it as an early Christmas gift for my husband. At a very fair price. I wanted him to go there, stumble across it, then surprise him that I had already purchased it. Plans did not work as the day before we were going on a journey to the establishment, he was whining that I was working on procuring items for everyone but not for his most sought-out item. So I broke the news to him. Make Cents is such a fun store. It's what I would imagine when I think of the best place where all my childhood toys are. Video games, TMNT, Barbie, Rainbow Brite, to wrestling figures, loved and displayed perfectly. The shop is small but so clean. There's also a glass display of all pastel pink items and I can tell you, I wanted each and every item. So nostalgic! The people there take pride in their products and they are aware of the magic this place has. The person who sold the item to us was so kind. He allowed us take our time to look at everything in the shop and was available to answer any questions, even if the shop was closing in 15 minutes. This establishment is such a gem and a must-see for all walks of life. read more

What a find! I didn't quite know what I was getting into but I knew what I was looking for. Makes Cents is a collection of everything vintage from toys to video games and collectibles. The small store in a nondescript strip mall is a must see for collectors. Almost all of the items are in a case or behind the counter and are clearly marked with a price. This is the kind of place to get a gift for yourself or that person who appreciates the effort of finding that unique item you won't be able to find elsewhere. There's a lot to see in this small but well organized space. I look forward to returning and making sure that I didn't miss a thing. read more

Makes Cents Variety Store - Video Game Stores Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This was a pimpadocious experience! Came from Miami Florida w/ a homie/coworker on a CDL trucker mission and yoOo hell yeahhh the maaaddd raw collectibles, got a rare Michael Jackson on thriller mode holding an A R & a sword plus rockin' the shell top adidas LOL going straight into my collection!!!!!! This is what I have in mind when I think collectibles, Make Cents is my type of vibe keep it up y'all read more

See all

Visiting from California I had to visit this shop. Macho man on the tv screen. Games and old toys galore (mostly 80's action figures). The mood was positive and I recommend this store. It's a hidden gem! read more

Makes Cents Variety Store - Video Game Stores Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Awesome environment and wide arrangement of games systems, toys, cards and so much more. It's a must stop if ur in the area! read more

Makes Cents Variety Store - Games! - Video Game Stores Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Cool vintage toy and video game shop with lots of finds. Wrestling buddies, games, and more. More than a Disc Replay would have in rare finds, cool place read more

Came in just to look around, ended up getting a playstation 1 for a very decent price. Shop is clearly kept very clean and well. It shows that they care about the products and appearance. Tons of games, systems, comics, etc. The worker was extremely helpful and nice. read more

Drove from Chicago and Cant wait to come back again!! Unbelievable store, selection and service!! I was born in 1973 and this store is a Heaven of memories from my youth. Tons of Video Games, Hand helds, electrons, action figures, etc... You can spends days in here and just get started! I actually purchased a full size refurbished arcade cabinet with joysticks and track ball!! Came installed with EVERY ARCADE GAME (8000+) AND EVERY HOME SYSTEM WITH EVERY GAME for a fraction of the cost of the online guys! *Ask for the owner Chuck! One of the coolest Guys you will meet and happy to share the memories and is very fair! read more

Awesome blast from the past and also the future. Lots of video games available as well as classic games. The have showcases full of pop culture toys both new and old. Lots of Funko pops, and video related items. A fun place. read more

We bought NES with wifey! all boxed with instructions with few good games on top. Felt like throw back to late 80s, First time visit. Store inside is pretty clean and well organized. Prices are great compared to Illinois. few arcade machines where you can play for free. Great atmosphere. Will shop again! Recommended ! read more

Very solid collection of classic console games, action figures, arcade games, and gaming memorabilia. The autographed "Mike Tyson's Punch-Out" poster is a great centerpiece behind the counter. Highly recommended for anyone looking to start a collection, add to a collection, or just bask in the 80s and 90s :) read more

One of the best shops i have ever visited. The owner Chuck is an incredibly cool, down to earth, and awesome guy to deal with. I try to visit at least once a week, because his inventory is always changing. Constantly new retro and 80's things to look at and reminisce about. If its retro, you can find it here. And his pricing is the best I've seen. So the break down is, good people, good stuff, good prices and good times to be had. read more