Since my first review I have been back several times and can honestly say the 5 star rating stands…read more Eric & company run a great shop in the heart of Delaware. I've done everything from buying items to selling items to trading items and they are always fair on the prices/offers. While small it's easy to look around and see everything without feeling overwhelmed. We are able to take our time and they're knowledgeable if you have questions about items. Every we visit we leave with at least 1 item. This is definitely a spot to check out.

Was excited to check this place out on a strong recommendation. Drove an hour only to find a closed…read moresign hanging with a piece of paper taped to the window stating the store was closed for 16th and 23rd. Business hours were not updated on any media platform.

This was a fun learning/toy store to take my grand daughter to. Lots of different toys that you…read moredon't see in a regular toy store. I like that they have the featured toys out for the kids to play with.

Came looking for kid craft projects, and they have a few. Loads of educational stuff, a big sale…read moreright now for back to school, decent prices, great service. Handy off Polaris.

Stopped in while doing the Dublin Fairy Door Trail. Impressive place, bigger than it looks,…read moreseveral rooms winding around. Loads of interesting toys, large and small. Really hard to walk out without any. But "mama won't be happy with either of us if we bring another toy home" works most of the time. Educational stuff, costumes, dolls, goofy little trinkets, big playsets, just so much. Well worth a visit, though maybe come alone and shop for birthdays or Xmas, because if you bring your kid, they are going to give you the business.

Some pros and cons about this shop. I love a good small business and this a cute store in a great…read morelocation. I love that they have craft classes for kids. Cons, they are selling fake Needohs which is for one illegal, and the person working first tried to tell me they were real, and then tried to tell me it was fine that they are doing it. It's not. When you sell something using another company's branding that isn't from the company it's copyright infringement which makes it a counterfeit product and illegal. It's confusing for customers that don't know any better. Not to mention they are double the price of actual Needohs. This bothers me especially because my mother in law came home super excited because she finally found one for my son. I didn't have the heart to tell her it was fake. I'm sure plenty of others are being duped as well. It's disappointing coming from a reputable toy store. Please stop.

Awesome shop! Service is excellent- always super patient and willing to answer any of my questions…read more I have bought a Nintendo switch, Pokemon cards, and countless PS5 games from them. They always come off as super honest and willing to actually help you. I even bought a PS5 extra storage chip, and they offered to install it for me free of charge. So happy to support a place like this versus some corporate GameStop. Highly recommend!!

I'm not normally one to write reviews about shops, but this treasure of a place is absolutely worth…read moreit! The employees are so friendly and knowledgeable! There's an unbelievable selection of video games -- from Nintendo to PlayStation and XBOX. We stopped to see if would be lucky enough to find XBOX 360 games for our son for Christmas, and they had an entire ceiling to floor section of them to choose from! But what really was impressive is that they didn't price them out at an outrageous cost! We were able to snag 3 games for less than the price of ONE! If you ever come through the Delaware area, give this shop a chance! There's something in there for EVERYONE!

Ever changing stock of popular anime characters, models, plushies, and figures. Large selection of…read moremech models too!

I go here every time I go to Polaris and I love it! I always buy the hololive mystery box when they…read morehave it! I just wish you could keep the art

First time going into this toy store, amazing service! The lady behind the counter was super…read morefriendly, greeted us when we walked in and made an effort to get to know us and what ours needs were. She was very warm and welcoming, showed us in the right direction of what we were shopping for. Highly recommend and will definitely be back! Thank you for such a great experience! She also has the best selection of toys!

Such a gem! After being in town a few days and driving past Blue Turtle Toys multiple times, we had…read moreto pop in! They carry the best selection of unique toys for all ages and interests! High quality brands at fair prices - you can't leave without buying a few goodies! We will be back next time we're in town!

Adorable local toy shop with a great selection! I was also plseantly surprised that their prices…read morewere reasonable as well!