I've been bouncing into this place a few times per year for about 25 years. I've seen it go…read morethrough a few owners, countless chefs, servers and menu changes. I can tell you with complete honesty that the overwhelming majority of those 25 years the food was consistently good. However around 22/23 the menu and food quality went to a new level. Seriously it is mind blowing especially when you factor in the price. Very reasonable prices. The service is great , the atmosphere is definitely on par or slightly above average but the food quality to value ratio is off the charts. Their BLT is legit! And if you're lucky enough to catch their salmon topped summer salad, I'd be shocked if it doesn't roll your eyes back! Try a few things here and I promise you will find something you enjoy.

This is our first visit here. When we arrived the hostess asked us if we had reservations as all…read morethe tables were reserved. We had no idea that was even an option here, let alone a requirement for this evening. She invited us to sit at the bar since we were there to see the band playing later this evening. Service is very friendly and helpful!!! Our server was helpful in suggesting meals and was available to refill our drinks as needed. Other servers were just as friendly to us, even though they were not serving us. We played a dice game while waiting for the band to start. A gentleman asked us about the game, so we showed him how to play. We did not know this at the time, but this gentleman turned out to be the owner, Travis. His friendliness and kindness is very likely why the rest of the staff is kind and friendly!! The food is good! I ordered the chicken pesto. My companion ordered chicken bowl (a chicken sandwich without the bread). We also enjoyed the buffalo cauliflower bites appetizer. The other patrons were around middle-aged, which we liked, as we are in the same age group. It was not a bunch of rowdy "kids", We originally came here to see the band, which was very good! But we'll be back for the food (and another band?) one day soon.

Outstanding service,good as well! I'd love to get breakfast here ever morning. You know it's good…read morewhen you walk in for a carry out and the dine in is packed.

Nice experience! Local's diner. Friendly service. Good food. Bring cash (plenty of signs telling us…read moreso). What's not to like? We'll definitely be back!

What a wonderful gem! Wonderful fresh made food, lovely service, and small intimate ambiance. If…read moreyou can score a reservation do it! My family had such a memorable evening! We loved everything.

Taking this from 5 to 4 stars for one reason, allowing the rental of the entire restaurant on a…read moreSaturday night. This ruined our plans for the evening. The only reason I don't take them to 3 stars is the time of year, the end of March, which is not high season. If they accepted reservations this would make more sense but they do not so we didn't call ahead. I never dreamed a restaurant would do this on a prime night. In the future, Westmain, please confine your large groups to a weeknight.

Came from out of town for a weekend- Called- was told you…read morecould just walk in. We did but they were very busy.... I would suggest making a reservation. Wait was not long at all. They have a great menu! Something for everyone. From sandwiches to surf and turf and pasta to salads. Was told their pizza was a must try. It was very good.... Would love to go back and try an actual dinner. Salmon/ prime rib-etc Good food- A little pricey but you get what you pay for. Really good portions. More "upscale" for a small town but you will see everyone from shorts and flip flops to nicely dressed people out on a date. Will definitely be back!

Only a short drive from our house but we have only been there twice in the last five years. It's…read morewell worth the time and the money.

Our family sat down and waited 15 minutes while the wait staff didn't acknowledge us…read more A waitress walked to every other table in our area multiple times and did not even say a single word to us. The food looked delicious, but we can't speak to that and won't be visiting again. Even as we walked out, not a single person attempted to speak to us. There was only 1 other table seated in our area when we arrived, and there were 6 including ours when we left.

The last time we ate at the frog. The services on the patio was slow. There attitude of some of…read morethe waiters suck. We use to go there a lot in the summer with our boat.

Down under is down right delicious! And who doesn't love a restaurant with a fun entrance (in the…read moregazebo, down the stairs). I had the fried tenderloin sandwich - larger than the bun as is necessary per Hoosier custom. It came with all the fixins for you to dress as you please. The house salad is fresh and the house dressing (a sweet Italian) takes it to the next level. I snuck a few fries from others at my table and they were fantastic too - hot and crispy. Service was quick and helpful! If I had one complaint it's that I don't know what's in most of the cocktails on the list. Hoping to see ingredients added to a future version of the cocktail menu so I can try more options during future visits this summer!

This place Love and the food very tasty! I would recommend this to all the steak/prime rib lovers!…read moreThe service was fast and on it. The cool underground location created a private cozy atmosphere. We will definitely come again.

We had a wonderful experience with Shelia tonight! You would be lucky if she is your server. We got…read morethe steak and lobster special & the chicken Alfredo. Both were wonderful! We also got the oysters Rockefeller, crab crakes bites (those were absolutely phenomenal with the chipotle sauce) and the fried mushrooms. Great time! We will be back!

The menu selection and pricing is totally out of line of what you get. A Cobb salad was very basic…read morefor $18. We have ordered this salad at other restaurants that were much better and priced way less. The handheld sandwiches are also outrageously priced. How can a hamburger and fries cost $20. Other than a nice view of Lake Wawasee, this restaurant is not worth it. You will have buyer's remorse!

First Time trying the Channel Marker. Melisa ordered the Steak Salad. She said she wishes they…read morehad a more variety of Types of lettuce in it. I order the Michigan White fish that was laid out on a Cedar Plank. Fish was wonderful. The house salad was good. I also ordered a small bowl of Clam Chowder and it was ok.

Service was slow, but I kind of expected that on a busy Sunday evening. Food took about an hour…read moreafter ordering. Not sure if that is standard but the waitress kept apologizing so it must have not been. Perch was good but the Baja shrimp tacos and chicken quesadilla were not edible. And the added avocado wasn't there but didn't have time to reverse the charges. That said the bang bang shrimp were great.

Great drinks! Good selection of food and drinks. Nice place for families. Beautiful new dining…read morearea. Nice bar area also. Outside area for corn hole/bean bags and other games.

Went to this restaurant for the first time yesterday evening. My wife had a large salad and onion…read morerings. The salad was average and the onion rings were ok. I had a 4 piece fish dinner with coleslaw and fries. The fried fish was a little over cooked and dry, the coleslaw was good and tasty, the fries were just ok. The waitress was an older lady and we noticed she kept spilling things, she spilled a drink on a friend, spilled salad dressing on the food tray, and did the same to the next table over. She almost spilled the drinks on most of us. The prices are very reasonable, the service was below average. Because the prices were very reasonable, we will give this place another chance hoping the next time the food won't be over cooked and the waitress will not be as clumsy.

Been sitting in line for 25 min and still don't have the food. No refund offered. It's ridiculous…read more I wouldn't even give this location one star if I didn't have to.

I actually think the workers are playing with there butts took them 20 mins to bring me out 2…read moresandwiches