German Village location felt open, airy, organized & clean…read more Barber was friendly, timely, listened, & check in with me to ensure he was giving me the haircut I wanted. Truly a custom haircut & enjoyable experience. Top 5 BEST haircuts I've ever receive. Well worth the cost. Service received on 07/11/26

This was my first experience here, and unfortunately, I was very disappointed with the haircut I…read morereceived from Matt. I paid $103 total, and for that price, I expected a much cleaner and more professionally finished haircut. I gave Matt clear instructions about exactly what I wanted and showed him reference photos before the cut. However, the final result did not reflect the level of detail or precision I asked for. The sides and areas around my ears were left uneven, and the blending and overall finishing lacked the attention to detail I expected. The photos show the final result. For a $103 visit, especially after clearly communicating what I wanted, I expected significantly better quality. I'll be returning to my original barber.

I have spent the years since Covid struggling to find a place to get my haircut that does a good…read morejob, has a nice environment, and treats their customers well -but it seems that I have finally found it! Modern Male does a good job of capturing the 'male spa' experience without feeling forced or pretentious and they offer a wider array of services than their peers. While I haven't yet sampled any of the their other offerings, I have been returning to the same stylist (Courtney) for a haircut/ scalp treatment for the better part of a year so far and couldn't be happier. Truth be told, I'm not sure what the value of the scalp treatments is - or if I need it, but it's a really relaxing massage at the very least! Everyone in the salon is extremely pleasant and engaging, and the space is cozy, clean, and has a good energy about it. They don't have their own parking, but there is a large lot nearby and I've never really had any issue finding a spot. I intend to avail myself of their other services in the future, so I may edit at some point, but this place is aces in my book!

Husband had a horrible experience. Clippers kept pulling hair out. He was looking for a razor shave…read morefor his head as he goes with the bald look, they don't offer straight blade. He wanted a beard trim they messed up his beard and took it down a lot. It's expensive and he could have just buzzed his head at home. He said it actually hurt to have his beard trimmed. The place is clean but clearly don't know what they are doing. Save the money do it yourself or go to a barber shop.

Today was our first time at Goodfellow's and we'll definitely be back!…read more I spent time looking up different barber shops, trying to find a place where my son would have a good experience since his last couple cuts were really terrible. Booking was simple and you can easily see everyone's availability online. Since this was our first time, I wasn't sure who to pick, but I noticed that Cory had over 500 five star reviews so we went with him. I'm not sure how difficult parking is on a normal basis but we were able to park on the side street with no trouble. Once we stepped on to High Street, I wasn't quite sure which building it was because the lettering on the window is slightly hidden (and I didn't pay attention to what the address was when I started my navigation) but once you walk up closer you can see the barber pole. When you walk in you feel like you're walking back in time a little. The whole vibe was pretty great! When you walk in the counter is directly in front of you and there are some stairs that go up to what I believe is the massage area. There is seating there by the door and also off to the right, including a sofa. We were greeted right away and only had to wait for a little bit to get started. The barbers are in two different sections and there is enough space so you don't feel super crowded. My son told Cory exactly what he wanted and that's what Cory did. Cory talked with my son and made him feel comfortable which I absolutely loved because normally my son doesn't talk to the barber other than answering with head nods or simple words. I think Cory did a great job treating my son like a young man instead of a kid. My son had a little complaint and Cory fixed the issue immediately. I'm pretty sure my son just found his permanent barber! Even if you have to drive a little further, I think this place is definitely worth checking out. The prices were really reasonable, payment was easy, and the service was wonderful.

After living in Columbus for a few years, I'm happy to say I finally found a barbershop that I will…read morecontinue using. Goodfellow's Tonsorial Parlor was recommended by a friend after I griped about having a difficult time finding a reliable barber in Columbus. Welp, this little gem in German Village is just what I was looking for! It's an old house converted into a barbershop with 1-2 chairs per room. The decor is awesome and it feels very cozy. Booking online is a breeze, and no credit card is required to make an appointment for a regular haircut ($35). There is free street parking on High St or some of the side streets. I've been to two different barbers, and both did a great job on the cut. Personalities were surely different though -- one was very chatty, the other not so much. Thus, whether you like to chat it up, or just relax and zone out, you'll be able to find someone at Goodfellow's.

Had my haircut by Travis. He's very good at what he does and I'm highly satisfied. Great atmosphere…read moreand he makes you feel at home. Highly recommend.

I've been coming here for about a year, and I have no complaints. Easy online scheduling, which…read moremeans no more wasting time hanging around the barber shop waiting for an open barber, and I love that their scheduling system sends me an Outlook calendar invite and text reminder. Unfortunately I've become someone that goes where my phone tells me to go, so I like that the scheduling system makes appointments easy to manage and it puts it right on my calendar. Everyone does a great job with cuts and beard trims. Pricing is reasonable, right in line with other barber shops, and I really appreciate that the owner doesn't mind sharing a little taste of his bourbon. This is a really great spot for anyone looking for a professional barber.

I scheduled a long hair cut with Andy on a weekday during lunch and the entire experience was…read morefantastic. Due to Covid-19 I was quite concerned about going to a salon, but I felt very comfortable the entire time I was there. They have a lot of precautions put into place including taking temperatures when you enter. Additionally everyone in the salon wore their masks correctly which is not something that occurs in many places. Andy was very easy to work with and I was confident with the length (removing 12+ inches) and style that he suggested. I was very happy with my cut and look forward to visiting again. I would recommend going to him if you need a haircut!

I recently relocated from Chicago and was having a terrible time finding someone who could cut…read morecurly hair and actually had availability. Reddit directed me to Jekyll and Hyde and I made an appointment with Beth. Beth is now my forever hair stylist until she moves on or I drop dead! I never thought I'd find someone on par with my stylist in Chicago, and somehow Beth is even better while saving me some money too. It is obvious that she not only loves but also prides herself in her work. She is meticulous and kind. And I'm always showered with compliments after I've been in for a cut!

Jude did a great job. The shop was clean, bright and well maintained. Check-in was easy and my…read moreappointment started right on schedule.

Was traveling for work and needed a haircut. Popped in and Gwen took care of me. First thing, she…read moreasked me questions, and then she listened to my answers. Then she talked about what she thought would work, which was a brief departure from my normal, boring old-man haircut. Fast forward thirty minutes and it was the best haircut I've had in years. Finally, she showed me how to style it. My wife loves my "new" look! I may have to plan trips back to Ohio, just so I can get my haircut! Awesome job!

Scheduled an appointment, barber didn't know whether or not I had an appointment & had to wait 15…read moreminute past my appointment time. The shop was eclectic with random pictures & animal heads on the wall. The barber stations were antique pieces. It felt disorganized & randomly put together. Barber was friendly but didn't seem to fully understand what I wanted. When I questioned him, he assured me he understood & said, "trust me". I didn't get what I asked for. It wasn't worth the price charge. I would've been more satisfied with a Great Clips haircut at a less expensive price.

I have been going here for 6 years and this is the best barber shop in town. The vibe is amazing…read moreand they got a drink if you need one. I've never had a bad haircut and it's just a overall great place to go to.

Terrah was amazing and enjoyed a kings treatment. Highly recommend for a haircut. She was also fun…read moreto chat with and had perfect tips for my hair care routine

looks they keep newbies for haircut as mine was messed up big time. Around ear and neck they cut…read moreway higher looking funny .

Kaley is great! Staff is always courteous and wait time is minimal. I highly recommend this team!read more

Aubrey did me right W Aubrey and all the other staff were very nice and overall gave high quality…read morehaircut

Hammer & Nails in Westerville is a grooming lounge designed specifically for men's hair and nail…read morecare, and it's been a great option for my husband over the years. I originally bought him a membership as a way to pamper him, but he never quite embraced it the way I hoped. Thankfully, the shop lets you use those service credits for friends and family, which has been a huge perk. I've even enjoyed a few pedicures there myself. I must admit, on my first visit I was convinced I had seen Michael Phelps or his doppelgänger. It definitely caught me off guard., but overtime I realized Hammer & Nails attracts all kinds of clients, and the atmosphere is relaxed, friendly, and easy-going. The technicians are skilled, attentive, and consistently deliver a great experience. You are offered your choice of beverage, including alcohol, and each station has a large TV playing sports, which fits the laid-back masculine vibe perfectly. It's a comfortable, well-run spot with reliable service and flexible membership options. A solid choice for men's grooming in Westerville, and a nice treat for anyone who appreciates a little pampering.

It's a decent spot for what it is, the stylists & cosmetologists are more interested in rushing…read morepeople through then they are with quality work. I've been to this location twice and both times I felt rushed both in my haircut and pedicure. The pedicure for example started 20 minutes late and she rushed to get it done so the next client (husband and wife) could be started on time. For the haircut I offered both stylists VIP for a concert and both said they would come, but neither showed. So don't waste your money here on these ladies. They don't actually care about the clients just money and getting as many through as possible. If you want quality go to Dublin or Upper Arlington where they TAKE THEIR TIME with the clients and give them the actual CARE they're paying for