My wife had a Philly steak n cheese sandwich and I tried a pizza. We enjoyed both meals very much and had leftovers we took home. The price was quite reasonable and the wait staff was friendly and helpful. read more

- A cheesesteak aficionado speaks! - - And I am not a purist! - I screwed up! This is one of the finest Italian/Pizza/Sub shops in the area and I've never talked about their awesome cheesesteak! This review rectifies this. Customer Service- So I blew into order my cheesesteak to-go. The young lady at the counter was a little chatty as I am and just fine. It took me maybe two minutes and my sammich was out in about five more. No choice but five stars! Food- So they bake their own rolls here which is a big plus. The gold standard for cheesesteak is an Amoroso roll from the Philadelphia area. These are not that but very good. There was plenty of tender meat with no fatty pieces. Good stuff! Here they add peppers onions & mushrooms, and I have no problem with that, and they were tasty. They use White American cheese, and it was tasty and there was plenty of it. Now for something weird and wonderful. A couple of years ago a good friend asked me to try adding pepperoni to my cheesesteak. I did and it was awesome! I've been doing it ever since and this time it costs me an extra buck. The basic sandwich is $11.99. I brought this bad boy home, and you can see my picture. It was an excellent filling cheesesteak, and I love supporting a local business. Five stars! read more

Little Italy - I added pepperoni for a custom, awesome cheesesteak! - Italian Near Me - Avon Park, Florida

See all

Stopped in for lunch and for the first time tried the Lasagna. It is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. The best Lasagna I have had in the area. I have previously posted about Little Italy and must say I have never had a bad experience there. Food, service, everything. Always great. A gem of a restaurant, right on Main Street in the heart of Avon Park. read more

Little Italy - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Avon Park, Florida

The pizza is spectacular. Best in town for sure. Garlic knots! So delicious. Our two favorite things here. read more

Little Italy - Garlic knots that are fabulous. The best I have had at any restaurant. - Italian Near Me - Avon Park, Florida

See all

Family owned and operated, very friendly, excellent lasagna! I go every week for a slice...served all day and night.

Very good subs ! I had a pepers n sausage sube they gave you a lot and it was delicious. I had the meatball sub and it was delicious also would recommend those two sandwiches. People at the desk were very nice and a guy came from the back to bring my sandwich and he was very nice. Pricing was good for the big sandwich. read more

Too generic. Not real Italion taste.Pizza ok. Nice owners, friendly. Clean building, ex bank. read more

Snowbirds from Indiana, wanted a good pizza and we finally found it! 5 topping large pizza, garlic knots and cannoli! I'm not much on sweets but tried it everyone enjoyed the entire meal! Inside was super nice, bright, open and clean! Keep up the good work! The food was done and ready when I arrived from 12 miles away! read more

Without a doubt the best pizza I have ever had... Perfect crust... Just the right amount of sauce... Generous toppings... And don't get me started on the garlic knots! read more

Yesterday we ordered a Stromboli and Philly cheesesteak for lunch and they were quite good. The Stromboli was with meat and we would have been better to get it regular but we did learn. The Philly was very good and meaty. We also got cannoli for desert and they were delicious. Definitely will be going back in the near future. read more

Still the best pizza in the county Service is A1 Everyone is always pleasant Place is spotless and easy parking read more

First of all, the cook was coughing in the back...I could hear him several times. The cashier/food preparer had a cold...she looked miserable. Here's an idea...stay home! No one wants to get sick; especially when you are handling food...that is plain common sense; which is neither common or makes senses to most people these days. I uploaded a picture of these sick employees. Food was good! read more

See all

Being from Connecticut we were happy to find a place that knows how to make a good pizza. We had the veggie pizza and it was delicious, they didn't skimp on the real tomatoes or black olives like most places. Great pizza read more

We went to Little Italy looking for a true New York style pizza that we haven't found since we've moved here from Pennsylvania and it didn't disappoint us. It's a true hand tossed thin crust pizza and their sauce is right on point. Choose your favorite toppings and you'll be in heaven with the taste of your favorite pizza. read more

I'm originally from New York, and picky with pizza. But this restaurant has 'the' best pizza and calzones in Florida! Their chicken bacon calzones are 10/10! read more

I drive an hour and 20 to get this pizza! The crust is crispy on the bottom just the way I like it!! We got a meatball with ricotta and cheese extra sauce and it was delish!! read more

Fantastic pizza, we usually get take out once a week from this place. The crust is amazing. Worth every penny! Staff is friendly and fast. read more

Great Italian food eat in take out and delivery. Love there pizza by the slice you can go with cheese or add any toppings that are on premisses add some soda and a salad and you have a nice little lunch. They have a good selection of pasta and different types of add on like meatballs or sausages mushrooms more cheese. They have lasagna baked ziti spaghetti with whatever meat you want or mushrooms or some garlic knots delicious. Sub sandwiches hot or cold ones meatballs with or without cheese ham and cheese hot or cold chicken Parmesan. So many different types of pizza that they have a lot of specialty ones you want to look at the menu to see what kind of pizza. They have some great salads all different types with add ins and different dressing so much food it's really hard to get something that you don't like I have never come across anything in the past 7 years that I didn't like from this place. They also offer some wine and beer with your dinner if you like to have it. They have some great chicken wings really huge. Definitely a great place to eat. Enjoy read more

We have been there at least 8 times in this year, everything was great, service was excellent, everything we ask for was done right and very fair prices to boot also. read more

The Philly Cheese Steak is fabulous! Always busy for a reason! Benny (the owner) is the best!!! read more

Today was my first time at Little Italy, and it has already won me over for my favorite pizza place in Florida. They have the most delicious garlic knots! It's so buttery & garlicy & the dough is perfect. Their marinara was really good too. Their pizza is perfectly crispy & the perfect thickness. I'll have to try their Sicilian pizza next time. Garlic bread came with the lasagna. Lasagna was pretty good, but the garlic bread was surprisingly not good. Garlic knots are the way to go! All of the employees were nice. We used to always take our visitors to Market 27, but now we're going to start taking them here. Only downfall is that their beer selection is not good. I had the Sweetwater 420, which was the only craft beer on tap. It's pretty good. Their other beers on tap & bottles are just typical American lagers & Corona. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

We stopped here on our way home. It was late and kids were hungry. Pizza is VERY good. We got a large xtra cheese with meatballs. Not spicy. Very cheesy! We probably didn't even need the extra cheese. Service was very friendly and helpful. And wait was appropriately timed for a fresh pizza. Atmosphere was cozy small town. Several TVs for us to sit and chill. Restaurant was clean. read more

See all

The food is mediocre, sorry, but most of it is kinda bland. The saving grace for this place is that it is pet friendly. Bring your pup, just keep them on the floor next to you and you're golden! read more

Location was good . Pizza and garlic rolls were great! Staff were friendly . 2nd time here and we will continue to keep this restaurant as an option on our road trips from Miami to Lake wales. read more

Great place! Great pizza and friendly atmosphere. New to the area and was very happy with my pizza.

Quality of ingredients below average. Service is minimal. Should get better sauce and cheese.

Great place to stop and have a good pizza. We had a large ham and pineapple Hot and tasty. Also ordered pasta with meatball. We all enjoyed. My favorite was the special bottle of wine for the price of two glasses. Perfect touch for a Sunday. Friendly staff. read more

Pizza is not consistent. The Help turns over almost every few days. They value their help over customers who have been going there and paying Crazy high prices for pizza for years!! They Obviously don't care if I never go back. My $200 - $300 a month is Obviously not needed. read more

Now that I have had lunch here for the sixth time I have to say the consistency in which they have kept the level of food quality is outstanding . In my opinion I've had the best Italian sub in highlands county and probably beyond. Everything they make seems to have special attention. Highly recommend. Also very friendly staff . read more

We had pizza here, and the pizza was very good . It had nice thin crust, not doughy at all , and it was not to oily. A nice casual atmosphere pizza place/sports bar type. I recommend Little Italy. read more

Fast service and DAMN good food. We got a hot Italian sub, a stromboli and a whole bottle of wine for 30 bucks!

I enjoyed their tossed salad which comes with a delicious vinaigrette dressing. Their hours of operation are better than most.

Best little pizza place in town. The owner will take good care of you. Must try if you're passing through town.

I've gotten pizza delivered 4 times. I think, this is the best pizza in the county. I grew up in NY and I have struggled to find good Pizza in highlands and surrounding counties. I know what I'm talking about this is some good pizza! read more

Good food hot and always a great place to have a great pizza or a calzone or Stromboli the cannolis are always good to always made fresh never made up ahead of time. read more

I was in Zolfo Springs FL. for many months. Not very many good Restaurants. But this little place is a gem. Good food much more than just pizza. Meat Balls are really good. All Italian dishes are good. Hubby liked meat balls and sausage with a loaf of there fresh bread. It's a great little place. The owner is terrific. Friendly and caring staff. Recommend highly. read more

Wow..the first time I was there. We had take out, large Supreme and it was the best pizza my wife and have had in long time. Very good lots of flavor!..we will be back i am sure, don't go a chain support your local restaurants. read more

Been eating there as often as possible since they opened. I've never had a bad experience in anyway shape or form with the food or the service. I usually order over the phone, pick it up when I get there and enjoy it on the front patio that's filled with tables and chairs with an ice cold beer. Being from Illinois but yet living in Florida most of my life I do truly enjoy the NY style pizza at Little Italy. read more

Little Italy - Italian Near Me - Avon Park, Florida

Remember that Avon Park doesn't have a plethora of restaurants but this Little Italy definitely has pizza and subs and delicious garlic knots. I apologize for so little pics but we ate so fast. We enjoyed being able to eat outside. When in avon park, check them out. Plenty of room for large groups too. read more

Little Italy - Italian Near Me - Avon Park, Florida

Only game in town so you are stuck getting theirs waited for 15 mins for pizza while it sat on top of oven cool pizza yum!!!