We visited Kitchen 251 for the first time, and it definitely won't be our last! Everything was absolutely delicious. I had the grilled shrimp, and my husband ordered the bison burger--both were cooked perfectly and full of flavor. The restaurant was clean, had plenty of seating, and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. From the atmosphere to the food, it was a wonderful experience. If you're looking for a great local spot, we highly recommend Kitchen 251. We can't wait to come back! read more

Kitchen 251 was one of the best places we've eaten in a long time. LOVED the ambiance. The food was absolutely amazing, and every dish that came out was full of flavor and beautifully prepared. We were dining with our young kids, and our server was incredibly patient and kind with them, which we really appreciated. That level of service made the experience even better. The chef came out and talked with us, and you can tell he truly cares about his food and his guests. Everything we ate was outstanding. If you're looking for great food and great people, Kitchen 251 is a must-try. We'll definitely be back and highly recommend it! read more

See all

Service was spectacular food was top notch hot and fresh! Loved the atmosphere and the friendliness of the staff. Can't wait to come back and enjoy another delicious meal! read more

Kitchen 251 - Bread Pudding - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Finally a neighborhood spot with great service and menu options. Collard greens, Mac and cheese nice wine list read more

Kitchen 251 - New digs in Fernandina Beach. Now at the corner of Beech & 8th. - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Beautifully prepared, presented and tasty! The service was quick and attentive. The NE Clam Chowder was very good too. read more

Kitchen 251 - 1/2 Blackened Salmon Salads - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Not only was this the best crab I've had in downtown amelia island, but the scenery was even better. Really nice ambience, Chef Michael McCarroll clearly outdid herself! My wife's boyfriend and I will be coming back next time we're up in amelia island! read more

This spot is unassuming but dang was it so good! Most of what we ordered was from specials menu but everything was amazing. To start with got blackened scallops, hush puppies and a cup of corn and crab chowder. The chowder was dynamite, probably the best I've ever had. The scallops were cooked perfectly with the right amount of spice. The hush puppies were fluffy and crunchy. Meals wise I got the crawfish boil and my husband got the bison burger with coleslaw. My husband loved his burger and said the onion jam was really nice. The crawfish boil is no joke and has a little bit of a kick but it was so good! I don't know what the sauce is it came with but I really enjoyed it. And because we didn't already eat enough we finished by getting the pina colada cheesecake that was delectable. They run a really efficient operation for how small they are and it's really impressive. We will definitely make a trip back here. read more

See all

Everything continues to be great even away from the water. I noticed a hamburger on the menu and decided to try one. Absolutely delicious! read more

Had lunch at Kitchen 251 on Amelia Island, and it was fantastic! Our server, Kayla, was absolutely exceptional--engaged, friendly, enthusiastic, and incredibly sweet. She made the experience even better! I've been on a personal quest to find the best chicken tenders on the island (my ultimate comfort food), and Kayla completely sold me on theirs--and trust me, I don't like to be sold, but I love to buy! Ha! The tenders were perfectly crispy, juicy, and full of flavor. I was on the fence about the fries, but they arrived hot, crispy, and seasoned just right. No regrets! Highly recommend Kitchen 251, and I'll definitely be back--next time, I won't forget to snap a photo! read more

Kitchen 251 - Lovely Views! - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

The best meal of our trip to St Augustine. And I mean the best! We came during the lunch hour and the service and food were amazing! I had the scallop special and soup and my husband had a fish special. Prices are normal for seafood in the area, but the view cannot be best! It's the best! We will return! read more

See all

It's obvious that Kitchen 251 sources its fresh seafood locally. It's delicious, well-seasoned not overly salty. Crab cakes are as close to perfect as a human can get. Plenty of crab! Shrimp tacos were spectacular. Service was great. Ambient setting to enjoy a sunset on the deck. read more

I love it when they have soft-shell blue crab sandwiches! All seafood is excellent, but a tad bit pricey.

Kitchen 251 is located near the water with great views. It is cozy on the inside; there is also seating outside, but it was too windy during our visit to sit outdoors! Service was great! The food, Yum! We enjoyed our meal and thought everything was DELICIOUS! Not pictured are the corn & crab soup and gumbo which were quickly devoured. The seafood seemed fresh and were cooked very well. I wish we stayed longer; I would have visited a second time! read more

See all

Food is quite good. However, beware of miniscule portions and high prices. I had the pick-two fish basket -- literally a tiny piece of flounder that was at most 2 inches by two inches and 5 oysters for $30. We had a pleasant server. Desserts were good, but again, very pricey. The rent must be driving the prices, and restaurant is off the beaten path of "true" downtown. read more

Food and service is excellent! Outdoor eating area is relaxing and shaded. Great wine list. Nice place to have a special meal. I'm

A favorite little restaurant to eat outside near the water on Amelia Island near the marina. Good seafood and southern cooking with a touch of Cajun/Creole. Tonight I got the catfish with crayfish etouffe which was delicious and filling. My wife got a cup of corn and crab soup to start and a bison burger which she enjoyed. Staff are pleasant and attentive. Indoor seating area is small with some bar seating as well. Just over the bridge as you come on the island. read more

See all

First time eating at the new location. This was our go to place before they moved. Strike 1, the tiny table we had was not big enough and very cramped to nearby tables. Strike 2, my wife's order, spinach salad with salmon which she had numerous times before, was served with a substitute ingredient which she is allergic to. We were not told about the substition. My steak was underdone. Almost strike 3, the prices have gone up, to be expected with the new location but still higher than expected. The place was very busy and a little chaotic, which hopefully improves in time. We will give it a try again but it will be a while. read more

Wasn't impressed with the menu or the vibe. What a waste of a lovely space. Only beer and wine. Maybe would have hung around a bit but no body really cared if we were there or not. Much better options in the area for visitors. read more

Great views of the harbor and tasty, flavorful food with excellent service. Stopped for lunch on a Friday and they were busy, but there were a few open seats. We got in our orders and the food came out quickly. I got the Bison Burger- one of the daily specials. It was very good, with seeded jalapeños on the side and a tasty bacon jam. The potato salad was a mustard-style and good. My wife got the soup of the day-White Bean Chili. It had a good, lasting kick, and was very good as well. We saw a number of people getting the Salmon Salad, a large mix of greens and veggies, with a huge piece of fish and a red velvet looking muffin. It apparently comes in full and half-size portions. Drink prices were reasonable and the food was on the higher side of average. Great overall, and recommended! read more

Kitchen 251 - Sandwich of the day-Bison Burger - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Beautiful location, superior service, exceptional food options! The red beans and rice are the best we've ever had! read more

Kitchen 251 - Fish Tacos - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

New location is gorgeous and service is excellent. Menu is fairly routine and predictable. Advise to NOT order the fried zucchini starter. Soggy strips of zucchini left a lot to be desired. They needed to be salted, drained and dried before breading and frying. Crab cakes were uninspiring and presentation was bland. Our table loved the fries and I have to admit they were pretty yummy. read more

Excellent! My husband and I went to dinner last night, and both the service and the food were delicious. We sat at the bar.

Great food Great service Great atmosphere Ample parking Reasonably priced Waterfront view read more

Small bar and restaurant with wonderful food and great views of the marsh and marina. It does get busy so it's pretty wise to come early. It is ran by a friendly group of people that do a great job if you like Cajun inspired seafood - you will find something to enjoy. If the white chili with chicken is on the menu try a cup! It's some of the best that I have had. read more

Kitchen 251 - Black and seafood and shrimp creole over linguine - great buttered toast in the side. Wonderful! - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Service was really good, food is a bit high price for what we got. Ambiance was also comfortable.

This review is based on food, service, cleanliness, atmosphere, and value. The food was delicious!! The fish and shrimp tacos were on point! The crab cakes were some of the best I've ever had! The wings were delicious. The meal was fantastic! Service was amazing! Everyone was so friendly! The place was clean, inside and out! The atmosphere was great! Nice and relaxing, and such a beautiful day! The value was good. I left very full, and didn't have to take out a loan. Very reasonable. Sometimes, the stars align, and the dining experience is just perfect. I will dream of this place for a long time. read more

We love Kitchen 251. The food is always consistent and delicious. Great service, nice staff and atmosphere. I've noticed the kitchen gets orders out pretty quick. It's definitely a well-run, well organized restaurant. read more

This is a locals favorite and a travelers dream spot to find. Whether it's the catch of the day or a menu favorite, the food, drinks and VIEW are a perfect combo. Every time I eat her I can't believe how good the people and food are. I almost don't want to tell you about it!! Our little secret! read more

Kitchen 251 - Grilled Mahi. - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

we ordered one bison burger and fried green tomato sandwich. The French fries came out of a bag as well the fried green tomato. we each had one martini which was just average. Had to ask for olives.The bill came to$90. don't plan on returning. read more

Finally, true, home-cooked, quality food, including desserts! But of course, Chef Michael does it again! This time, Chef chooses one of the best locations and historic buildings in Downtown Fernandina Beach, with parking! Yes, the entrance offers a lovely courtyard with seating! Walking into the historic home...a large, indoor saloon-type bar area on the right side greets you upon arrival. A wonderful array of dining rooms and seating invites your attendance to the left. The food is exactly what you would expect on all levels, served with an experienced server with a smile, doing everything to make your visit memorable! Shimp and Grits, collard greens, sold! This classic, old-world Florida estate also has a beautiful "special event" room which can hold up to 40 guests plus! Did we mention there is also a smaller, intimate, bright sunroom and a private dining area? This intimate, large, windowed, elegant room comfortably holds 14 guests. Yes, we could go on, but all we can see is...finally! Fernandina Beach, old town, is now better than ever, now that we have Kitchen 251. Thank you, Chef Michael, you continue to give us exactly what we expect! Bill and Greg F. read more

Based on Yelp reviews we very excited to eat here but unfortunately the food was such a disappointment, both flavor and cost wise. The crab cakes were mushy and seemed undercooked and lacked flavor, the crab soup was so bland that we kept adding salt, the beans and rice was also flavorless, and the shrimp tacos were $26 for something that seemed pretty basic. The saving grace of this trip was the friendly service and the location at the marina to view the boats and water. Unfortunately this one was a big miss. read more

Kitchen 251 - Crab corn chowder- very bland - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Nice ambience and saw beautiful sunset. Look at specials. Try seafood dip and crab Closes at 8...great hamburger, and key lime pie read more

Kitchen 251 - Menu - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Waterside Restauranton Amelia Island, just over the bridge from mainland. Dine on patio Deck or indoors. Everything except fries homemade. Gumbo spicy and filling. Shrimp Salad Tacos satisfying. Local beer on tap Good and friendly service. read more

Kitchen 251 - Chicken and Sausage Gumbo. - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Great location. Friendly people However, One fish sandwich and two cokes was $34.00!!!! I also don't like the aromatic tip starting at 25% when you pay. I added $4.00 on a take out order which put me at $38.00 for ONE SANDWICH AND TWO COKES!!!!! Are you kidding me???? read more

Food was fantastic - we brought in our own catch and the created some blacken red fish and some fried sea trout - both were delicious

If you didn't know it was there you'd would never find it. At the marina just before going over the bridge to Yule. We haven't been here for a few years, what with , COVID, work and such. Fresh fish basket and a cider two sides, and the spouse went for crab cakes, corn and crab soup, 1/2 lb of peal and eat shrimp. I should have asked what the cost for the catch of the day was , even though it was pretty good. As was the rest of the meal. ( I don't understand why the south thinks Mac and cheese is so good I've tried several places and am not impressed. Any how we were happy with the meal until the bill $ 70 for a quick lunch. Second most expensive this trip. Yikes. We will probably return but will ask more questions and be a bit picky on what we order. read more

Kitchen 251 - The view from the table - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

A friend recommended Kitchen 251 , he said he came here for lunch twice in a row . Salmon salad was excellent, 3 big pieces of salmon on top of a giant bed of mixed greens , lemon citrus vinaigrette.plus a red velvet cup cake . The salmon was blackened, not too salty and super moist . Best lunch of my life . read more

See all

I've enjoyed every meal or time I've been to 251 since it opened. It's like my neighborhood restaurant, go to place. Food is always great and I love the people that work there there. read more

Love the closeness to where we live. Dining looking at the river and the marina is enjoyable. They have indoor and outdoor dining. This was our first time dining at this establishment. It was very clean and busy. My husband and I both had the fried shrimp dinners. They were fresh. As an appetizer my husband had the crab corn soup. Refills were slow and service was fast once the order is taken. We are looking forward to going back to try something different. Price for 2 shrimp dinners, bowl of soup, 2 Cokes and tip $93. read more

Kitchen 251 - Crab corn soup - Food Trucks Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Good food. Great location. On marina with nice water views. Food was fresh and service was fast.