Don't let the other reviews fool you. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this shop or…read moreits staff. I brought my car in on August 10th for an oil change, tire rotation, and to check a service light on the dash. About an hour later I got a call about it, and was given an outrageous quote to repair the root cause of the light, which turned out to be my alternator. On that call I wasn't given any real explanation or even a breakdown of the cost. That's also where I learned about a diagnostic fee I would be charged even if I went ahead with the repair, something I was never told about upfront. I declined the repair. After that call, I got quotes from a dealership and two other local shops for the same alternator repair. DiMaggio was going to charge me roughly 30 percent more than the dealership and nearly 70 percent more than the other local shops. Nobody called to let me know my car was ready, so I showed up assuming it was done. At pickup, I was charged for services I never approved, with no explanation until I pushed for one. My invoice said I had been given a courtesy vehicle inspection, but I didn't actually receive the results until after I had already complained. When I asked for the manager's contact information in person, I was handed a business card with an incorrect email address on it. I had to track down his correct email myself just to reach him. He did call the following day, and I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1 only because of that call, but the conversation mostly defended his team's handling of things rather than offering any real path to fixing it. Because of that, I ended up taking my car to another shop instead. This experience was more than terrible. It didn't make sense on paper or even in person. Avoid this shop if you can.

It's been a while since I had my car serviced there. At that time when I did go to DiMaggio's the…read morefront desk was VERY Nice and was informative! I didn't have to wait long and they did do a good job with my car. I would recommend this business to anyone.

Ömar and group are amazing. Very willing to work with you. Always trying to find the best and…read morecheapest solution. Very calm.

My car battery died today- huge bummer. I called a tow person to jump it and then called Budd's for…read morethe first time ever for a replacement battery. I was met with the absolute best customer service. Not only did they squeeze me into a tight schedule but they also did a quick check over on my car and made sure it was running as smoothly as possible. I knew I needed an oil change and they were able to get that done as well. I spoke with one of the owners in depth about their business philosophy of repair instead of replace parts when possible and always taking care of customers. They were super helpful and nice and took the time to explain everything. I will be going to this spot for all my car issues for the rest of my time in Madison. I felt like they really cared for their customers and I'm so glad I found them!!

I have brought my 1974 Camaro to them. They always treat me right. Honest place to get your car…read moreworked on. That's hard to find today.

Thank You Shawn & Brandon I'm on the older side of life…read moreand have been to many auto shops in my time. The honesty and kindness they showed me, kind of took me by surprise. I thought the days of caring for and showing respect for a paying customer was a thing of the past. Shawn and Brandon not only solved the stalling issues the car was having in a timely manner at a very reasonable rate, but also made me feel welcome while in the waiting room. Even enjoyed reading the sports page. Go Pack Go! Sincerely, Bob

My mom recommended this place and I'm glad she did (and not only because the location is convenient…read morefor me). The staff is always friendly and honest and Capitol offers reasonable prices. A few months ago, we brought our truck in for repairs and they helped us through the process of how to apply our warranty to our amount due to help ease the cost. Just today I dropped my car off right away for an oil change stating I did not need it back until 5 PM and they had it done within an hour. I was so impressed! Their hours say that they open at 8, but I have come 10 minutes prior to that and they have been open and ready to help me with a smile. It also doesn't hurt that there is the sweetest black lab that will greet you when you walk in. Seriously. If you were having a bad day, this has to make you smile (unless you're not a dog person). I just wish they were open on weekends, but hey, they deserve a break, too.

When Shawn owned Capitol Tire it was the most honest car repair place in town…read more Shawn retired and sold Capitol Tire, now expect to be told you need service and parts you don't need.

Yuck‼ I rate Gary Wille's automobile repair shop an "F."…read more When we moved to Oregon, Wisconsin, we went to Wille's. I dropped off the car first thing in the morning, saying, "Inspect the air conditioning, do oil and lube, and inspect all systems." The guy wrote it down. As I picked up the car at the end of the day, I looked at the invoice. They hadn't taken a look at the air conditioning at all. Nothin'. Nada. Duh! Air conditioning had been at the top of the list. How could have possibly have missed AIR CONDITIONING unless they were illiterate⁉ They essentially had done nothin' worth anything that day, and charged me for doin' nothin'. They weren't even apologetic. I was not a happy camper. I was new in town, didn't know anyone so -- fool that I was,-- I gave them another chance. They didn't do any better the second time around. According to my experience, they charged me a pretty penny for doing doodly-squat. Do I recommend them? Not on your life. Not a chance. They s_ck -- is that strong enough wording? I categorize them as "incompetent thieves." Move on. Find another shop. I can say unequivocally that Gary's Wille's was the worst vehicle repair shop I have ever gone to. I would give them "zero stars" if I could (or even a negative rating, like "minus 5"). This shop doesn't deserve one star, but Yelp requires a rating, so fine, one f'in' star.

Questionable service…read more My grandmother went there for her oil change and they forced her to pay $5.00 for filling her tires with air..

Great local shop that we trust to bring our cars to. We know they are honest with estimates and…read morethe work they do. Best to plan ahead on when maintenance is needed so they can fit us in for appts. There is a reason they are so booked up - they are the best!

Went today to figure out best approach to shield on bottom of car coming loose. Initially offered…read moreto take it off for free before realizing there were more problems, ended up only costing $15 for cost of materials. Interacted with Tyler, very nice very helpful - explained everything he was doing and why and didn't overcharge- if I have another problem I'd come back here!

Fixed coolant leak, get it home, still leaking coolant. Shop claims system was pressure tested and…read morepassed. Get it back into the shop; fix second leak with additional parts and labor costs. Claims pressure tested system and passed for the second time. Currently no leak. Took two trips, two bills, and didn't have my car for little under two weeks. You decide if this is the experience you want.

Branden and the team are amazing! Great experience all around. Excellent customer service that made…read moresuch a different and solid work!

Very good customer service who are also friendly and knowledgable. A pleasure to do business with…read more Quality body and paint work. My car looks like it came straight out of the factory!

Zimbrick refused to work on a car purchased brand new from them. But they did charge me to diagnose…read moreit. I've never been treated worse by a car company