Jimmy John&#x27;s

Some of the best sammiches in the city!! Love both locations, they're accommodating & the food is…read morefresh

Passed by this spot several times but never gone in. About to become regulars. I got the Philly…read morecheesesteak and it was the comfort food I needed. We'll be back.

Order at the counter

The chopped cheese

See all

Outside signage

Shapiro's Delicatessen

4.0(1.1k reviews)

6.2 mi•Pogue's Run

A perfect pastrami sandwich. A perfect rye. This was a fantastic dinning experience. I would…read morerecommend Shapiro's Deli to anyone .

Another fabulous visit to Shapiro's! A friend from out of town wanted a local fav so we came here -…read moreand she was blown away by the flavors and offerings! I ended up getting several pastries and some bagels (as why would you not), as well as their broccoli salad, cheese sandwich and some cherry pie. Yum! We sat for a few hours to chat and I love how it feels like you are in the middle of a community endeavor. Like everyone here is a friend and you can chat and meet up and feel at home. She wanted to take a Rueben home to her husband but it was a flight away, so the staff let her buy all the fixings and then make it at home. Amazing! It traveled well that way and got to be enjoyed by others. Will always go back to this spot as it has a special place in my heart as my Dad loved it, and it is an I su classic!

The Pastrami on Rye with swiss cheese, onion and spicy mustard

See all

McAlister's Deli

3.5(59 reviews)

0.1 mi

I had a really nice experience at this location with my friends. I wasn't wanting an entire meal,…read moreso I opted for a kids meal. The kids meal was huge! It came with a loaded potato, a side, and a cookie! The service was so fast! My friend had gotten a tea, and the employee filled up her tea at the table- wonderful service!

While I've never actually been to the store front, I do want to rave about their catering/delivery…read moreservices! We frequently order from here for work events and they food is always on-time, set-up for us, and gets great reviews from the guests. The cookies and brownies especially are a favorite (and the vegetarian options too!). It is a little more pricey, but the sandwiches are a higher quality than the ones from Panera (or at least, that's our opinion).

See all

Hoagies & Hops

4.4(379 reviews)

5.8 mi

If you want an authentic cheesesteak go no further. Their meat is tender, juicy and flavorful…read more The bread had that authentic chew you get from a real Philly and stands up to the meat and cheese The customer service was spot on. The only thing I would change is to add mushrooms to the menu to put on my sandwich We will definitely be back

I love this place. The atmosphere is unpretentious but clean…read moreThey have managed to bring the best of the Philly sandwich scene to Indy. Down to the Wiz. Check it out!

Dining room

Cheesesteak n fries

See all

Adjoining bar

NYC Food Mart

4.6(32 reviews)

2.9 mi

Tried their chicken and lamb combo over rice and it was really good, specially the sauce.read more

I tried the chicken over rice and it was 10/10. Super flavorful, well seasoned, and plenty of food…read more The wait is usually about 10-15 minutes, but it's absolutely worth it.

Exterior

Chicken over rice meal.

See all

Yamallama Delicatessen

4.8(25 reviews)

4.3 mi

I was at a conference at the AMP and ordered lunch from Yamallama on the first day. The setup here…read moreis really cool. It's mostly grab and go sandwiches and salad, but they also have soup and a great selection of paninis that the staff will press while you wait. I opted for the grilled cheese panini and tomato soup and both were delicious and ready quickly, despite it being a busy day. The price point is reasonable and the woman who took my order and prepared my food was super nice. Yamallama for the win!

I already wrote a review about how obsessed I am with their chicken pesto panini, but I need to…read morewrite again now that I've tried more. I looooove their tangerine tomato soup, falafel bowl, and taco bowl. Last week, I asked an employee which item on the menu is her favorite and she said the curry cauliflower bowl, so I ordered it. I CANNOT EXPLAIN how delicious it was. I got the tahini dressing and opted to add on pulled chicken for $5 and have not gone a day without thinking about it. The curry cauliflower bowl has: curry roasted cauliflower, golden raisins, cashews, pickled red onions, crispy chickpeas, and artisan lettuce blend. I know it sounds healthy and I don't care if you don't even like curry... you will LOVE THIS. I want it for every lunch for the rest of my life and I'm already planning my next visit to The AMP so I can get my hands on it. Order it. The only turmoil I now feel is the stress of wanting to try everything on the menu but not wanting to *not* order this bowl. Take one look at their menu and you'll be so impressed. I mean... they have an "everything bagel caesar" dressing. How delicious and creative is that? They have sandwiches, salads, warm bowls, soups, desserts, and more. Everything is colorful, fresh, and delicious. Thank you so much @Yamallama for being incredible. I saw that you now sell your bowls at Dream Palace Cafe too and I hope to see Yamallama meal options at many more coffee shops, stores, and cafes around town. I'll buy one every time I see one!!! PS: I just saw that they closed their second location in The Garage Food Hall and opened one across the street from The Children's Museum instead, so visit there or this AMP location.

6.3 mi•Mass Ave, Renaissance Place, Mile Square

Curry Cauliflower Salad

See all

Walking taco bowl

Fat Dan's Deli

4.1(318 reviews)

This is the kind of place that you only know about if you're truly familiar with Indy and not…read moreafraid to venture off the main drag of Mass Ave. As a cool little sports bar patio, Fat Dan's seems like the kind of place you might miss if you're not looking too closely. However, you'd be remiss if you didn't make a stop in at some point. They primarily have table service but also a small bar "inside" - when the weather is nice, they open up the garage doors to make the entire establishment be outdoors. The staff that we encountered were all very friendly. Food is fantastic here, we ordered from the Devour menu back in August and got the burger and pulled pork sandwich with fries. They bring your food out on a giant sheet of butcher paper, so you're more than welcome to make a mess at the table! Everything was scrumptious, and the fries home as leftovers are as delicious as when you get them fresh. Perhaps that's why they're called the Best Fries in the World! I'm sure if a good sports game is on TV, you'll find me here soon enough!

Stopped in with my family and had a good experience. Our server was friendly. I thought about…read moregetting a beer so our server gave me a sample of the Upland Brewing's Petal to the kettle sour, it was good but I decided to go with a cocktail instead. I went with a Malibu and ginger ale, and it was served in this cute glass, I loved it! We were all so hungry, so we started out with a large order of fries, and they are a standout. They disappeared fast, came served on paper, and were crispy, hot, and delicious. We ordered the 2 10-piece wings (the biggest order available), including one batch cooked extra crispy. The wings were good, and I especially enjoyed the Fat Dan's hot BBQ sauce over the regular BBQ. I really liked the extra crispy wings. My boys also wanted burgers. One ordered the Wake N Bake Burger and the other got the Fat Dan's Burger. Both looked tasty, and neither of them complained. The ambiance strikes a nice balance between sports bar and family friendly restaurant. There is seating both inside and outside, and when the weather is nice, they open the large doors to create an open-air feel. That's where we sat, and I enjoyed it. Service was quick and efficient, which was much appreciated since my family arrived hungry. This is a solid spot for burgers, wings, and fries.

Bar area

Candy by the host area

See all

Find it near Mass Ave, outside seating available

Goose The Market

4.6(810 reviews)

5.9 mi

There's a reason why this place is consistently voted as Best Sandwich winner in Indy!…read more Goose the Market is a deli/market, selling cured meats and cheeses and fresh produce and much more! They also have a cellar with wine and beer. There's even gelato! But I came for the sandwich! I tried the Batalli sandwich, which was spicy and so flavorful with the perfect balance of textures! I also tried the special Tayaki, which was a good sweet counterpoint! Absolutely delicious! I'm still thinking about these sandwiches a week later! There is a gravel lot across the road and street parking. There's minimal seating indoors and some tables outside. Service was quick, and everyone was so kind and welcoming!

No, just no, an absolute no. Almost zero protein sandwiches, soaked and drenched in some kind of…read more sauce. The "other" location builds pretty decent sandwiches with plenty of protein, chips included for the same or lower price. I'm was a big fan of Goose Island, but this was my first and last visit to this miserable location. Honestly, read the reviews. These people are idiots. They have never been out of the country and maybe the state of Indiana. "Scrumptious, delicious, delectable,tasty, and something about textures are ignorant responses for incredibly cheap, beyond cheap, almost non existent portions of protein.

Cashier area

Gander sandwich - vegetarian no mayo

See all

Yelp sandwich week!

Potbelly

3.6(240 reviews)

6.2 mi•Mile Square

So on weekends it's half off milkshakes and ice cream. I come in with my client and when we ask…read moreabout ordering a banana milkshake, the worker tells us "So we're not doing milkshakes or ice cream here because it's a lot of work to take out and clean up." I then joke and say, "Just not feeling up to it today, huh?" And he goes "every day, pretty much." What the heck? Why have a huge sign that says "half off milkshakes on Saturdays and Sundays" and decor center around sandwiches and milkshakes ("order your shake now!" Signs) if you can't be bothered to even serve them? Very lazy.

This place is slept on but so good. They have the best veggie soup in the game. Sometimes it has a…read morelittle too many white beans for my liking but I think that's a function of getting a random scoop. Also, I love spicy food but I strongly discourage getting the "hot peppers" on the sandwich when it's made. They come in an oil or something and because capsaicin (the molecule that you taste as "hot") is water soluble, it hits you so hard and makes the sandwich WAY too spicy. Instead you should get them on the side and put one on each of the bites you want, as you eat the sandwich. You'll thank me later. Also, don't go to this location between noon and 1. They are just way too busy

See all

Jaggers

4.4(60 reviews)

3.8 mi

Food was great and the employees were friendly. I never had a bad experience here before. I will be…read moreback here shortly.

Stopped by for a sweet treat and decided to try the strawberry shake. It reminded me of a…read morestrawberry shake from Dairy Queen, with a good, strawberry flavor. Overall, it was a tasty treat and satisfied my sweet tooth!

Clean dining room

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Denise B.

12 years ago

try the tuna sandwich, it's so healthy and delicious!

Brian C.

13 years ago

Best sandwich in town!!

Jimmy John's - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Jimmy John's also viewed

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.5

(67 reviews)

Jersey Mike's delivers every time…read more We always get The Original Italian. Unless there's a special limited time sub we want to give a try. The last special we had was Mike's Hot Italian, and it was delicious. We added chips and drinks to complete our meals. The staff greeted us with smiles and handled our order quickly. I redeemed a free sub through the app without any trouble. The ordering process stayed quick and simple. I keep going back to Jersey Mike's. The food is tasty, the service is friendly and the dining area is clean. My fave sub shop by far.

Oh no, oh no, oh no, no, no, no, no. This was a terrible…read moreidea. I was getting my eyes checked near Jersey Mikes and was starving after. I had passed this location on the way and thought I'd check them out since I had never had it. I got the Italian sandwich, brownie, and a side of the pepper relish. Big mistake. This has got to be the most broke tasting sandwich I've maybe ever eaten. It's giving armor meat sandwich for Panera prices. The ham gave Bar S and the salami gave budding. Just gross. I couldn't stand more than three bites and that was because I was starving. I threw almost this whole sandwich away. The brownie was pretty good and kind of reminded me of Chick-fil-A. That pepper relish was really delicious and all of the veggies were super fresh, but limited. You can miss me with that meat though. The bread wasn't that great either. I don't understand why people would come here when Penn Station is right across the street. The customer service was fine and the inside of the restaurant was clean enough. But I will never ever be back.

Arby's

3.3

(10 reviews)

Love how they got my order right! And everything was so good!! Loved the special I got & their…read morepotato cakes!

what a shit show at this location. placed online order, get to the store and am told that the shake…read moremachine is not working, so I ask for a Lemonade and they say they don't have any, Ask for a refund of the shake price and was told I need to contact corporate to get a refund. WTF?? Fish sandwich was lousy, breading was almost twice as thick as the fish. WE WILL NOT BE RETURNING!

Firehouse Subs

3.2

(61 reviews)

When I'm in the mood for a sub sandwich while out shopping in this area, I hit up Firehouse Subs…read more I've found their offerings to be notches above some other sub shops. The staff at this location is consistently friendly. It is always clean as well. On this visit I noticed the ad for the new Steak & Cheese Melt. Boasting a whopping 42g of protein, it sounded like a winner. Sandwich was ready in about 5 minutes. The bread was soft and the melt was just right. You could taste the peppers and seasoning. They also offer chips and cookies and other treats.

In November, they have a challenge of 3 purchases to accumulate increasing points. I order on…read moreMondays online for pickup and use their deals. When I order online, I see more customizing options like extra free pickles. I inquired if they were selling gift cards with bonus card but unfortunately, no savings.

McAlister's Deli

3.2

(61 reviews)

Food here is great! Right next to my work so I come here a lot. The service gets a little rude tho…read morewhen they are in a rush. I've worked in fast food b4 so I know how it is. But one girl, who I think was the manager, was rude when I told her I had an online order. She said "what do you need" in a rude and rushed way. When I told her the name was either under one name or the shortened version of the name, she brought it to me and said I need to know what my name is b4 I come get it. Like girl I was picking it up for a friend idk what name she put it under. I get you're stressed but be more professional.

Ordered my food on the app to grab and go. I always enjoy their choose 2 options and decided on the…read morehalf Horseradish Roast Beef and Cheddar sandwich and the cup of Country Potato Soup. It was ready and waiting for me on time and it was still hot when I arrived home. If you haven't tried this sandwich I suggest you do, I just love the slight kick from the horseradish and with the roast beef and cheddar cheese, it's just a great combination of flavors. Along with the hot, creamy soup, it all just hit the spot.

Potbelly

3.6

(57 reviews)

I'd never eaten at Potbelly before and needed to grab a quick bite, so I decided to give them a…read moretry. I went through the drive-thru, and the cashier was super helpful and patient while helping me navigate the menu. I ended up ordering the Chicken Bacon sub, and it was probably the BEST sub I've ever had! It was absolutely delicious, and the bread was easily some of the best I've had. Everything tasted fresh and flavorful. Such a great first experience! I can't wait to go back and try more of their menu.

I've been to this location a couple of times and I always get a good sandwich. The space is clean…read moreand well managed and service is always friendly. The ingradients seem fresh and I appreciate the size options.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

3.8

(12 reviews)

I have ordered delivery from the Downtown location before but this was my first time visiting any…read morelocation in person. It's very cool on the inside with vintage and Indiana-themed decor, tin ceilings, and, of course, a potbelly stove. The staff were friendly. But brother and I were very confused about the ordering process. There wasn't a lot of directional signage showing where to start and each step of the process. I watched a few other customers go through and they didn't seem like they had a problem so maybe it was just us. Next time I would probably just order online and pick it up so I could avoid the in-person ordering process altogether. I had the turkey sandwich and it was pretty good. I would say definitely a step up from your typical sub sandwich chain in terms of flavor and toppings options. I tried the chili mac as well. The chili is definitely à la Wendy's but I enjoyed it. The mac and cheese was good as well. I'd probably get either on its own but not together again. I also tried the Potbelly/Zapp's collab chips, the Hot Pepper flavor. They were good but are definitely not for everyone. When I visited, most of their fountain soda options were out of order so I settled on a no sugar added Pineapple Passionfruit juice/soda which was actually pretty good. We'll definitely be back - especially to try out their milkshakes!

Food is incredible ! Regular size sandwiches are great..get the Italian with hot peppers added…read more Staff is very caring and kind. We Buddy , and the manager Jackson goes above and beyond ! He is constantly cleaning his restaurant..

Chick-fil-A

3.7

(86 reviews)