New clean location has a drive thru, indoor seating, and a small parking lot. Our food was ready for our pick-up order, and everything was exactly as we ordered it. Tonight the bread on one of the sandwiches was a little overcooked. Otherwise, everything was great! read more

Over the past 3 months we have been using this location for group sub orders. They have been awesome fulfilling orders and answering any questions. Huge improvement from last year when we did the same during the basketball season. Staff has been kind and orders have been correct Thank You!!! read more

Hard to complain, as I only needed a couple skinny/slim subs. It wasn't busy, so my sandwiches were done promptly. No complaints here, but nothing made this store stand out over others. read more

What happened to this place?! I've been to this location twice in the past year and both times were shockingly bad. Several months ago I placed a pick up order for lunch on a weekday. The place was SLAMMED and there were 3 employees working which seemed very understaffed for the level of busy. I showed up maybe a minute or two before the promised time and waited no less than 30 minutes for my order. I should have checked to make sure my order was right, but I didn't. I got back to work to find that they forgot my potato salad. I came back to this location today. It wasn't busy (except maybe online orders which I totally understand). I was really excited to try the Mediterranean wrap. The cashier was super nice. I placed my order (wrap no tomato,) and my boyfriend also placed his order. The cashier read the order back and didn't say "no tomatoes" for mine so I reminded him. We waited for close to 10 minutes but that's fine. When I got my "wrap" home, it was so poorly constructed that everything just kept falling out. Oh, and what's that there? Tomatoes. I definitely won't be coming back here. It's too expensive for something I can make better myself at home. read more

Jimmy John's - My falling apart MEDITERRANEAN VEGGIE WRAP with no tomatoes. - Sandwiches Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

Their hours say they're open until 10pm, but they most definitely are not open that late. I drove out of my way to get there before 10pm on Thursday night and they were very much closed. read more

Terrible. Showed up for Freaky Fast service after a 15min detour. I walked in to find the place completely dark with no power. All the other shops had power. I was told sorry they're closed due to power issues. Ridiculous! read more

Close this location. Stale 2 day old bread, untrained staff. Sandwiches missing ingredients, slow r7de service. Never again Jimmy Johns.

I ordered lunch and accidentally transposed my suite number and I never received my food, was told I couldn't get a refund or a new order. So I'm out $32 and got nothing read more

Ordered lunch online. Took 75 minutes for our order to be ready for pickup because they had run out of French bread within three hours of opening. Then we get home with our sandwiches and discover the bread was uderbaked - super chewy and without the exterior crunch one expects from Jimmy John's. The two primary draws of Jimmy John's are that they're freaky fast and the consistency of the product. This location failed at each. read more

Soooo where do I begin with this? There's SO much address. Let's start with the single positive thing I have to say about this garbage heap. The food is good imo. That's the one single compliment I can choke out. Now let's begin with all the negatives! !!! DISCLAIMER !!! I understand the pandemic has affected places in different ways and I do not know the situation of how this store is ran or lack there of, but I will give you a piece of the turd sandwich that is this Jimmy John's location. 1. Customer service. It's awful. Absolutely the worst. The three times I've went inside, all three times it was awful. Not only do you physically feel unwanted but the staff, it is apparent that you are viewed as a burden. No exaggeration. Me ordering my food, all three times, was met with extreme pushback. As if you asked them the world. One of the three times, will not mention names, the guy that manned the register, wouldn't even let me adjust what I wanted on the sandwich. Before I could finish was just met with a cold monotone "is that all?" followed by a disinterested blank stare off into la land. And the speed. THE SPEED. Freaky slow is the motto here. One of the times I did manage to get a delivery, almost two hours... no joke. 1 hour and 45 minutes later I actually full on forgot I had even ordered... 2. Accuracy. This isn't a huge deal seeing how the child labor that Jimmy John's heavily relies on doesn't care much about what you want rather than what time they can clock out, but come on! I've had so many incorrect orders than I actually stopped customizing my order all together and picked it off myself. I have zero problems with hiring high school students trying their hardest to earn a wage, but when you start having your job applications handed out at the local middle school and have zero experienced people to help, you these kids up for failure. 3. No delivery?? This location hasn't had or offered delivery for over a year now. We'll just go into the store right? Out of the blue, has happened a couple times now, the store is just closed for the day. Lack of staff? Lack of product? Wouldn't know because absolutely zero explanation is given. But as of writing this, I haven't been able to get a delivery for a good year and a half. So why even offer it? So the food is wrong, the hours are wonky, and the service sucks. That's all right? NOPE. 4. Lack of product. One of the three times I've been in there, they were completely out of bread and acted annoyed that I asked when they would get more. Instead, the girl that I talked to said that they are just going to use wheat sandwich bread instead and have no bread to make. Ok. Not completely the end of the world. One of the ten thousand times I've tried to call for a delivery, they weren't delivering because they were going to close early "due to lack of people and product". The Covid response is very understandable if you're talking a couple of issues, but we're looking at a mountain. This location is so bad that myself and others have completely given up going there. I'll go to another location if I want this. Three years after Covid began, it has been only down hill. While small businesses have adapted with the pandemic and some even have even grown, this CHAIN location can't even manage how to deliver, order product, keep production, make product, or sell product. What a shame. If you want a sandwich, grab two pieces of bread and some Oscar Meyer bologna. You'll thank yourself later. read more

Minus stars if I could. I'm in no hurry to leave a negative review for any food service business after what they have been through with th pandemic. Furthermore, I fully understand that help is hard to find right now and good help is much harder to find. On Saturday, 08/06/22 a little after 6 pm I encountered the most extremely rude obnoxious and unprofessional "customer service" person I have ever witnessed by far. If curbside is offered for online orders it probably should be honored or it might be polite to contact the customer if for some reason it can't be honored that day. In short, after waiting outside for 15 minutes after alerting the store I called and was very abruptly told "I'm the only one here. I can't bring the order out. You will have to come in and get it." I told him I can't really do that right now as I'm disabled. The response was a hang-up, seconds later the young man came storming out, threw my order on the passenger seat, stormed back in without even a hello, sorry for the wait, a thank you, absolutely nothing except attitude. We've ordered a few times, the food is OK and we understand the little things and won't bang on about those but this was way over the top. I'm done with JJ's. read more

One could easily argue that the single most important thing in a place like this is order accuracy. They failed miserably in that regard. Sub #1 - did not remove mayo, did not add cucumbers, did not add onions. Sub #2 - duplicate of erroneous sub #1, not something that was ordered at all. Sub #3 - what sub #2 was supposed to be but wrongly labeled. And they never updated the online order to say it was ready. I sat in the parking lot until finally just walking in, and there it was, ready in all its blatant incorrectness. Absolute fail. Never again. read more

Total incompetence going on in this store. Ordered at 11:15 AM. At 12:05 we checked online, and it still said "order received." Called to find out status of order. Spoke to two people (including the "manager") over the course of four minutes before anyone could even find our order. At that point, the manager said "well, it still says "order received," which is not good." She offered to void the order or just resubmit it. Never offered to rush the order, never apologized, never offered any sort of a discount. Utter. And. Complete. Incompetence. Now we're out of time and won't get lunch today. New slogan for Jimmy John's: "subs so slow you'll starve!" read more

Jimmy John's usually has great service but the workers here were so h!gh that they barely noticed us come in. it took them a while to make 2 subs (again, usually JJ is great!) and one was incorrect. one worker was just staring at the sandwich for minutes while the other worker took another order. his eyes were so red that it was obvious what the issue was. dissatisfied :-( read more

Ordered my food on the app like I usually do and asked to have it delivered to my work. I always pay 25% in tips when I do this because I put on the instruction section to bring inside the building and deliver to the desk. When I got notified that my food was delivered I went to the desk to claim it. No food was there. I checked my phone and it said the driver LEFT it outside on the ground by an Emergency Exit Door that is LOCKED AT ALL TIMES unless of a fire. It made me mad because they not only left my food outside, but it was in the slush and out in the open where ANYONE walking by could of grabbed it or tampered with it. At this point I was pissed. I opened the bag to make sure my order was correct, wrong.... They forgot the napkins, mayo and smashed my bag of chips. Very unhappy with how this location handled my food and will no longer order from this location again. Sandwich was dry even though I asked for EXTRA mayo.... read more

worst tuna sub I have ever eaten- if you even want to call it that- mostly mayo with a few pieces of tuna and very "fishy"tasting. will definitely not be returning there!! read more

Several times the delivered to wrong place and now they charged me 25 dollars for a sandwich and didn't even get the order right I suggest not going to this establishment read more

I live in Middleton 1.8 miles from the Jimmy John's in Middleton, but they won't deliver to me because I'm north of Allen Blvd. Found a Milio's 5 miles away in Madison that's happy to take my business any time. read more

So much for freaky fast. We ordered 43 minutes ago and are still waiting... I just called and was told "the driver should be on his way". Finally showed up 46 minutes later, as we are about to walk out the door to leave. read more

Ordered a Cubano with extra bacon and no extra bacon, no Mayo, and no Dijon mustard! I called and manager gave me attitude!

Lousy. Ordered sub with pickles, cucumbers and peppers. Received NONE. Very disappointed.

I normally love jimmy johns. But this has to be their worst location in the country. The staff is simply unable to properly run the facility. Probably my fault for continuing to give them a chance. Today I waited In The restaurant for 25 minutes with 8 other people for a "speedy" sub. The staff could have cared less and the cashier was full of smugness. Eventually I just left with 3 others people who couldn't take the wait either. Abandoned my $11 and subs. Milos a block down had us in and out in 3 minutes. AVOID this location, go to other jimmy johns. read more

Jimmy John's is probably my favorite place for quick subs in Madison/Middleton. They are unbelievably quick, and their sandwiches are good as well. The prices are decent, too. Of course you're not going to be given a gourmet sandwich, but from what you expect, the product is great. read more

Super slow! Never got my sandwich delivered. Waited for almost 2hrs. When I finally called to check on my order they point blank lied to me about having attempted delivery and no one was there. It was to be delivered at another place of business which has employees working all day. Unbelievable!! I guess it's Milios sandwiches from now on! read more

I'll just start by saying I love Jimmy Johns. I always get the Pepe with onions and oregano... Today I didn't want the lettuce or onions because I have onions and leaf lettuce at home I wanted to use, so I ordered the Slim 1. The cashier informed me I wasn't allowed to have oregano on my sub because it was a slim and didn't include vegetables. I find this strange.. They were allowed to give me mayo packets but not a few dashes of oregano? Boooooooooo dissapointed read more

Was so disappointed in my delivery service. So when do companies feel it is an ok thing to deliver to the wrong location, then go back to that location,pick up your order and deliver the same food to you. I should have just flushed my $12 down a toilet. read more

Called at 10:45 AM for a roast beef sandwich-first checked to make sure they deliver to that address-ordered. 45 minutes later, I called to see if my sandwich was going to arrive .The person said they had just one driver. I said ok and continued to wait. 10 minutes later, another person called me and asked my delivery address. I told him and he said my sandwich had gone to the wrong address, but it will be there in 3 minutes. Sooo....3 minutes later Jimmy John person arrives with melted ice in my soda and...the wrong sandwich. Still had to pay full price. Never again read more

Jimmy John's just opened in Middleton. I can't say that Middleton was lacking in sub places, but they're a welcome addition regardless. As you would expect from a chain, this location does not differ at all from the other locations. They have a reasonably-sized menu and you don't get many options in terms of customizing your sandwich. So, if you're lucky enough to arrive when there are no other customers, your sandwich will be ready in about a minute. Their subs are tasty but not out-of-this-world. They never have any kind of special, limited-time subs, and the menu is very unadventurous (no "Buffalo Chicken Bacon Chipotle Club Supreme!!!!"), so if you went there every day you would be bored after two weeks. If you're hungry, I recommend the Italian Night Club (probably the best chain Italian sub anywhere) or the Hunter's Club (not great-quality roast beef, but a lot of it). If you're not very hungry (or, as my Mom says, you have a bird-like appetite), go for the JJBLT. JJ's uses only Hellman's mayo, which, as far as I'm concerned, is the only mayo which is fit for human ingestion. They also only use provolone cheese, which is actually saltier and less cheeselike than Subway's provolone. So those two cancel each other out. Normally I would give only three stars, but as this location seems friendlier and faster than other Jimmy Johnses, I awarded them an extra star. I am normally do not appropriate stars in such a generous manner, but the situation warrants it. Now I have to deal with the fact that when I went to Middleton High School, the only restaurants within walking distance were China Wok and Taco Johns (RIP in peace), while the spoiled brats these days get a JJ's and an entire organic grocery store. Grrr. read more

The only reason they get two stars is that my in-store experiences have been pleasant. My experience with their delivery service is atrocious. Example 1: Apparently the driver couldn't find the address for my work, despite the big building being like 2 miles straight down the road. Over an hour after I ordered, I called JJ's to ask about my sandwich. They claimed the driver called to clarify and the number they called wasn't a valid phone #. Really? The phone I was talking to them from wasn't a valid phone? News to me. They made a fuss and brought the food out to me, the only thing they did for me was remake my drink. Example 2: Tried ordering again, listed my phone number and asked them to call when they arrived so I could come out to pick up. Realized my cell was dead, so I called the shop to give them my office phone. Delivery guy shows up after about 50 min, never called, and told the receptionist that he didn't know who the food was for. Right on the receipt here I see my name, my phone number, and my note about calling. Seriously? Don't bother ordering. You will probably be ok if you go to the store yourself. read more

I really love the staff! When I come in they already know my order. They are as fast as you'd think in the store. For delivery they are always nice but take longer than you'd expect. read more

I go to this location often, since it's so convenient to work. Regardless of crowds, the staff is always friendly, quick, and my order is always fantastic. And I customize my subs. I'd recommend this location to friends. read more

Super good subs for super good prices. My order got here in 6 mins after placing it. Couldnt ask for much more. 5 stars

Waited 45 minutes for my sandwich. Called the store and the worker was polite, but there's no excuse for taking 45 minutes to deliver a sandwich. If you're running that far behind on orders, hire more people. read more

Don't believe the commercials when it comes to this place. Waited over 90 minutes for my sandwich today. I called after an hour and the guy on the phone was a real punk a$$. If you can't get a sandwich delivered two miles in an hour and a half, at least don't be a jerk when I call to find out what's up. read more

Sandwiches were delicious but service was lacking. I bought 5 subs with chips and cookies. The cashier handed me a bag and I was expected to bag all my stuff on my own. I realize that this sounds extremely petty but it just portrayed rude and lazy service in my opinion. I would expect a little more friendly assistance at a sub shop. read more

I work at a business in Greenway Station, in Middleton. We give this jimmy johns a lot of business, and i mean ALOT. we called today for a delivery and the person who answered the phone was extremely rude. Then we had someone call later in the evening for a delivery and they told us we were out of area, and then when I told him that we get delivery's here all the time, and he laughed like it was such a problem. so they wouldn't deliver to us. I hung up because i felt very offended. As we are a customer based business we are always very respectful when situation become tense, but this was very poor customer service And for the guy who answered the phones tonight, this is your job, you get paid to make sandwiches and tend to your customers, if its such a problem, maybe work somewhere else. I can personally say say we probably won't be giving this JJs as much business as we used to. how disappointing. read more