On 8/21/25 at approximately 6pm went in to dine. Servers were friendly enough and handled requests…read morewell. Ordered a large Stromboli but it was cold garbage. The dough looked like it barely touched the oven and the filling was barely warm on the edges and the center still felt like it was refrigerated. Cheese had not melted, pepperoni and mushrooms hadn't started to sweat, onions still raw. It was the saddest attempt at a Stromboli I have ever had. I would say the portion is generous enough if they actually cooked their food.

Hidden gem in Albion. Food was tasty; good service. I ordered the shrimp Alfredo and my husband…read moreordered the angel hair spaghetti. Both were tasty.

The pizzas are beyond delicious with true cupping pepperoni that takes every single pie to the next…read morelevel. The calzones the Hawaiian the all the meats or the true pepperoni and cheese can't be beat on any of the three. This is hands down the best pizza in the area no question no other contender hard stop. Sauces delicious not sweet not too earthy not like they're putting patchouli in their you know sauce it's delicious The cheese freshly grated none of that cakey yucky came from Sam's club type thing true mozzarella. The calzones we've had there have been amazing meatball and pepper ring, pepperoni and cheese, All the meats, Hawaiian, literally just order all of them You will not be disappointed. We've ordered from the one in King Kone in Perry as well as the original in Madison and the true OG in Duffy's in Madison and they are all absolutely amazing. Thank you Kay Jack for giving us good pizza in the 44081 ZIP code.

It's a good pie place. I was a fan of the dough. The sauce with breadsticks is a bit heavy on the…read morespices. I would order again. My picky eater kids loved it and that's good enough for me!

I looooove diana's! I've eaten there since i was a kid and played softball. Definitely a gem.read more

Was traveling through the area and we were getting hungry. Called and ordered a pizza. Wow, we…read morewere glad we did. Pizza was great and staff was very friendly. If I am in the area again, I know where we we'll be going. Thank you!

Best hand tossed pizza, Calzones and Stromboli are absolutely delicious, Subs are hot and toasted…read moreto perfection, really love the Sicilian style pizza( not available all the time) . When I spend 3 months in Florida, I have yet to find a place that compares, first place I go to eat when I get back to Meadville! Owner and Staff are very friendly every time I go there! Highly recommended you check it out for yourself!

Both food & service was rewarding. If you like Italian give them a try. Pizza is very good.read more

Fantastic Pizza!!! You will love and enjoy this delicious treat. Highly recommend you visit this…read moreplace.

I have loved this pizza since 1979. I live in Girard and drive there at least once a month for…read morepizza. I have shown many friends, and they don't disagree, best pizza in 100 miles.

Castaways pizza and grill in Conneaut Ohio ..... I got this disgusting sandwich with more…read moremayonnaise than is in the actual bottle I wanted all to see so I'm not making it up when I asked for new sandwich they said I had recently complained because it took 2 hrs and change to get my hot food now cold so if you want horrible service disgusting food this is the place for you and to the girl I spoke to Terese I believe FU you are not a assed for that company I never complained in my life as you all know I don't post but everyone should know and see what this place is truly about

What a great local find!! We used google and yelp to find this place, and we weren't disappointed…read more It is nice to find a clean, local place. Service was good considering they just got slammed and was down a person. The swiss burger was great! Made just right and tasted amazing!

I wish I had 10 friends with me to sample this menu of just TASTY food! I'm not local and this…read moreplace makes me wish I was. Another family came in during my visit and from their conversation, they are repeat customers! I was greeted warmly, recommendations were asked for and given, they take pride in their service from the appearance and cleanliness to the warm friendly staff. The menu says "family owned since 1981" which is a great sign, 34 years in business - I'm wondering if they'll consider expanding. If you are passing through town, live near by our simply want to try an amazing place to visit stop here! Their yummy salads will have you licking the plate clean!

We drove an hour back and forth from Erie just to get their food.It was 10 out of 10 for sure!!!I…read moremiss not living so close anymore.Keep up the great work!!!

Beautiful atmosphere, friendly staff and of course, amazing…read morefood! We welcome Pizzis back to Conneaut!

Although I never tried this place during its earlier years, I received so many recommendation from…read morefriends and family that I finally had to try it. Went on a Friday night at dinner time and was delighted to find more than enough off street parking, although on street would have been fine to me. Inside I appreciated the cozy yet updated interior, wonderful lighting, and the ease at which we were able to find a table. The small selection of beers on tap had just what we wanted - a mix of some classic standards and some of the best local craft beer around. The wine and liquor menu was impressive too and all extremely reasonably priced, as was the beer. It was hard to pick just a few things from the menu but tried the salad with the garlic dressing and oh my goodness! One of the best salads ever! I shared it with my husband and the server kindly accommodated us and brought us extra plates and tongs and everything we needed to feel settled. We each ordered a pizza and both were fantastic. We prefer hand tossed Neapolitan style pizza, of which this is not (it's more old world, thin and crispy deep dish) but it was still delicious. We appreciated the amazing pepperoni - unlike anything ever and much better than anything I've ever had, as well as the locally raised and processed sausage . On top of the food and drinks being delicious we received very kind and efficient service that really made our night! The chef checked on us and thanked us for coming in. We couldn't have asked for anything more and we'll look forward to returning soon! We're glad that there is a locally-focused and historic place like this in our region. Highly recommend!

First time visitor. Very comfortable decor. Nice waiter and the owner was cooking. Pizza was very…read moregood. Will definitely return to try the rest of the menu. Pictures next visit. Kudos Mamma T

When we want pizza in Linesville, this is our "go to" pizza shop. Diana does things he he right…read moreway, and we appreciate that.