I love this location of Jersey Mike's! The sandwiches are always fantastic, with #8 being my favorite. The Club Sub has Applewood smoked bacon, turkey, ham, and provolone, topped with mayo. I recommend getting it Mike's Way! On top of great subs, the staff is very efficient and friendly. Just a hint: You can put an order in on the app and receive points and save time. Either way, my subs are always ready on time and taste great! read more

Order placed online at 6:17 PM. Pick up time 6:32 PM. Walked in right at 6:32 PM. Food was not ready until 6:53 PM. Three sandwiches only. Also, just because you're wearing gloves doesn't mean you should touch all the receipts, a pen, the monitor, and then make sandwiches and touch the food. Pathetic. I will not be returning. read more

Placed order ahead of time. Three workers visible, not one moving out of first gear, obviously not trained to handle a rush, or any sort of volume. Idon't know who the manager was, but the receipt said Karla. It didn't look like there was a manager working that shift, but three very poorly trained workers. Spent 25 minutes retrieving a sub that was called in ahead of time. read more

We all know that Jersey Mikes sandwich is top 3 sandwiches in the US. This review is to highlight the incredibly helpful, polite, attentive and kind staff that helped us tonight. We came in from a long day at about 850 when they closed at 9. We apologized and the staff couldn't have been cooler about it. Sandwiches were made quickly, the girls at the counter were talkative and friendly. I ordered a giant and asked for juice on only half my sandwich so I could take the other half to work. Without asking, she cut my sandwich in half, put each half in their own bag, and even labeled the one without juice. With restaurant experiences being so hit or miss these days it's great to go to somewhere and see a staff like this. read more

Never a disappointment when going to JM. Food is always good. The service is always friendly. They can get a little busy during lunchtime but have enough seating room to accommodate if you plan to dine in. Alway my first choice sandwich shop because I can depend on everything being fresh the bread is always nice and soft. My goto sandwich #17 famous Philly or Chipotle steak and cheese. For the hot subs. And the deli subs, I love the fact that they slice the meat as it's being ordered my goto cold sub #13 the original Italian. read more

I've lived in New Jersey and many other states. Finally I found a sub like the subs in New Jersey! Delicious!!! The Italian Mikes way, is our favorite. Everything is sliced fresh, right in front of you. The BEST sub place around! You won't be disappointed!!! read more

My Wife and I dashed some subs, we wanted to try the butterscotch tasty cake. They didn't have any, so we were surprised with 3 extra cookies. I called the store to thank them for doing that and even leaving a note apologizing in the bag. Huge thank you to Abigail for not only taking the initiative to make it right, also communicating that they didn't have any. I could have easily thought my order was wrong, but she went over and beyond with leaving a note. read more

I went here on Thursday and had a very good experience. The food was great. I tried the new salsa verde chicken sandwich after the manager Matt recommended it. As I was waiting in line to pay, I watched as the manager seemed to be training a new employee. He was calm and encouraging, and seemed genuinely happy to be there. The young lady Kaitlin I think her name was, was running back and forth helping make sandwiches, ringing customers out, and cleaning the dining area when there were no more customers in line. I will definitely be back. read more

Food was good. Mathew on the other hand was horrible. He was very rude the second I walked before I even placed my order. After I told him my order he wrong it up as the wrong sandwich and I did not notice until I had my receipt. Tried to get his attention and he ignored me until the sandwich was made. Al thought I ended up with the wrong sandwich. It was a good sandwich. read more

Stopped in on the way home never having a Jersey Mike's sub before. I loved that they sliced the meat right there in the shop as you order your sandwich. They give you choices on the size of subs. They were practicing social distancing. I will definitely be back. I just wish they had one in my town. read more

I recently stopped in to buy lunch for myself and a friend. I purchased two giant subs. Both being around 16 dollars. So I was surprised that when looking at my bill it was a total of $64.39. I was charger 26 dollars for extra meat. When asking the manager about the extra charge. She said, "that was just how it is." But let me know I should have not been charged 6 times for extra meat. I guess then charging me extra was my fault. Buyer beware!!!! Wish i could give negative stars. read more

As expected, the #17 was delicious. Fresh bread, tender meat, covered with cheese! Never disappoints. Their portions are very generous and will fill you up. Pick your size and make it a meal or not. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Menu - Fast Food Near Me - Mt. Pleasant, Wisconsin

Used to love these subs, now they are super tiny and still the same price. They downsized their sub like 25%-35%. It's such a shame when businesses cut back on cost and in turn make a inferior product. No longer the best subs In town. Instead of Jersey Mikes subs they should be called little baby subs. read more

Bread was stale - blew 16 bucks - very disappointing. I hate to say it because Subway is terrible, but it was worse than Subway. Cousins will be my only choice moving forward. Wish Quiznos hadn't folded. read more

I ordered 2 hot sandwiches today and asked to get food mike's way. I asked them if they made it mike's way, they said no because that wasn't the way I ordered it. Blaming a customer for your mistakes is not a good way to run a business. I wouldn't suggest this place to anyone. read more

Okay, having moved to the Midwest from California; and having visited New Jersey and had the best Chicken Philly Cheesesteak I ever tasted in Phillipsburg ... I didn't think I would have a chance to find another cheesesteak as good; Well, Jersey Mike's is now in Racine and although it's not that same Cheesesteak, it was very close, tasty and Fabulous. The sauce the mild peppers, the Chicken, The Cheese, and Yes, The Fresh Bread. The price is standard, the place was nice and clean and the Sandwiches, Total Bonus. I will definitely be ordering or stopping in frequently. If you want a really good Sub, Why Not? It is Delicious ... Jersey Shores, West Coast and Midwest, A really good Cheesesteak is worth it!!! read more

Outstanding service and atmosphere just walking in! Staff was well versed in JM subs and they also were very cordial and attentive. I ordered the Philly Cheesesteak and I wasn't disappointed. Very hot and fresh. The portions are very large for the price you pay. Restaurant was clean and the counters and tables continuously wiped down. Definitely on my favorites list! read more

Terrible the workers are childishly talking like there in the street about there personal lives I was looking at the menus on top and the guy qas rushing me to hurry up and order was like rushing me so I told him its my first time here so I needed time and he said well we are open all day like mocking me I didnt really get it till I started thinking why are they laughing when he said that but so patiently I ignored him so to tell the truth the bread was old it was hard to bite in for the price I paid dor it no way was it worth it at there rate no I will never return there.. read more

First time an won't be the last.. seen commercial and thought looks good but won't look like that... Wrong yes it did.. #56 read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #43... Didn't take pic of #56 ate on wat home well half... - Fast Food Near Me - Mt. Pleasant, Wisconsin

Moved to the area recently, this place is just down the street. We've ordered from them multiple times already. Easy to order on the app & the food is ready when you walk in. Great subs read more

My wife and I purchased a fundraiser card from The Horlick High School football team. The reusable center has a coupon for "free sub with the purchase of sub of equal or greater value and 2 drinks." We ordered two identical giant sized subs, two drinks and presented our card. We were told with plenty of bad attitude that "those are only good on the regular size subs." My wife politely let them know that wasn't how the card read. Other employees "chimed in" that it was for a regular size sub only. It does NOT state that. It wasn't until we were going to walk away from the purchase that we received the "well......we can do it this time." The workers stopped just short of calling my wife a liar. Pretty rude service, especially when there are plenty of other sandwich shops around. If the card is only good on a regular size sub, might want to post a notice before you lose more customers. read more

Great staff and very fast service. The #7 Mike's way was excellent! See you all again soon.

We ordered 2 club subs and they were wonderful. Staff was friendly and the place was clean. Really worth trying. Had a great experience and we will be back. read more

Great subs and fast service. Tried about half the menu items so far and have not found one I do not like. Only issue is the music playing makes it hard to communicate when ordering. read more

Subs are good, but they play the music so loud the people making the subs can't hear what I want on mine. It is even hard to talk to my wife at the table eating. read more

The subs are delicious, especially the cheesesteak subs. I do feel, however, that they are completely understaffed at this location. Food takes a long time to receive especially during peak periods. The workers are clearly putting a lot of effort in to make sandwiches as fast as possible and with care. Between online orders and orders that are being made in person, they are stretched too thin. Please hire more staff. read more