We took our granddaughter to lunch today. It was our first time there, my Granddaughter lives in Guilford & is a fan. They did not disappoint. Each of the Submarine Sandwiches tasted delicious! The 2 Gentlemen behind the Counter & the young gal who rang up our order could not have been nicer. Before we left I told one the Employees how pleased we were & that we would be back! Many thanks, Caryl read more

Great quality sandwiches. An easy go-to when you're on the go. Prices are reasonable. Only trouble ever had was an online order which I know has nothing to do with Jersey Mike's restaurant read more

DO NOT GO TO GUILFORD! I placed an online order and prepaid for it. I took my lunch to drive and pick up my order. The guy behind the counter said, "I just gave it to some guy"... So some random person took my lunch, employee didn't check with me, it wasn't noted someone was going to pickup my lunch. I didn't get a new one made, haven't even gotten refunded for my lunch that I didn't get. 2nd time messing up my order within month and failure to make anything better. read more

I ordered and it literally took 30 minutes to make one sandwich..... kept saying it was almost coming out

Food is consistently ready 15-30 later than the pickup time for online orders. Deli-U is a better option. (I have no affiliation) read more

Love the subs but not the prices. $20 for a 12 " sub is ridiculous. Probably will never go back. Not enough people to wait on you. The people that work there do their best. read more

I use the Jersey Mike's app to place my orders. I was a regular at the Guilford location, but noticed a drastic price increase recently. I decided to check around other locations in the app, and was surprised at what I saw. My usual sub is a Giant #9. When looking at the 7 nearest locations in the app, 5 of them price this sub anywhere between $16.75 and $17.20. I understand that prices of everything have been going up recently, but at least these 5 stores were all in the same ballpark. Two other stores (same owner) are Guilford and Branford. Their price for this sub? $21.89! If you look at add extras such as cheese and meat, even the add-ons are substantially more expensive than other area stores. Like I said, I get it that prices on everything are going up, but when one franchisee is more than 20% higher than the surrounding area, I call B.S. If I add extra meat to this sub like I sometimes do, I'm looking at a $27 sub, including taxes. My advice if you're in the mood for a JM sub.... check out the surrounding stores aside from Branford and Guilford and avoid a 20% + shakedown! read more

Such a great spot, location, you name it. When it comes to Jersey Mike's locations, well all of the ones that I have been to thus far, the employees are friendly. I feel like the ones at this Guilford location are super friendly. I've visited this location multiple times during the pandemic thus far and they have handled everything perfectly. Hand sanitizer is available, shields are up, minimal contact, no indoor seating available and following all of the precautionary measures. I typically don't tip at a place like this, but every time I check out here, I can't help myself but to do so. My husband and I always order the roast beef and provolone and add bacon and mayo to it...Mike's Way of course. Try it, you won't be disappointed. I will say, the sandwiches can get a bit pricy. I think to add bacon on a sandwich, there is like a $3 extra charge. But I mean hell, you get what you pay for. It's quality, I'll assure you that. read more

Great subs, made fresh, line moves fast, workers keeping everything clean clean clean! Beautiful new store, parking lot is a bit hard to find a spot on a Friday afternoon at lunchtime. The best sub is #8 Club Sub, ham, turkey, provolone, and bacon. Mikes way means lettuce, tomato, mayo, onions, oil & vinegar generously laid on so your sandwich is bursting. All the meats & cheeses are freshly sliced in front of you and antibiotic hormone free according to the signage, this definitely differentiates them from other sub shop competitors. read more

See all

Somewhat expensive but delicious always fresh subs ! Excellent service also! Many different options to choose from!

The subs are good but the price is outrageous. I won't buy here often. Our local pizza shop makes a good sub for a much better price.

Average chain sub place, expensive for what you get 2 thin pieces of turkey Great service Clean store Fast service read more

I did the most foolish thing and ordered to go from the wrong location (accidentally hit Guilford). I called and without even asking they provided a refund and were just so nice about it. I'll certainly be back. I appreciate their kindness! read more

I got a number 44 sandwich and it was delicious. All the ingredients in the sandwich were fresh and saw it made right in front of me. Very good overall! read more

I visited this Jersey Mike's yesterday and enjoyed my experience so much that I came back again today! The staff is very friendly, funny, engaging, and helpful. My Buffalo Chicken wrap tasted amazing as well. I highly recommend this Jersey Mike's in Guilford. Thank you! Ryan read more

Every time I order from here, I order online and pick it up. They always take FOREVER! Today I ordered and it was supposed to be ready at 3:31. When I got there my hot sandwich was sitting there and I had to wait 20 mins for my cold sandwiches and it wasn't even busy. read more

Today I met my grandson to drive him on an errand. As my reward lunch would be provided. Subs were ordered from Jersey Mike's in Guilford, CT. I changed the time as road construction on the way to his house took me twice as long as normal. Not a problem. When I arrived the order was all set. My grandson orders a chicken cutlet. I ordered the Stick Ball ham sandwich, with pickles. It was the best sub I have had in 50+ years and big enough for lunch and dinner. If I had one suggestion it would to skip the lettuce. Sliced thin it tends to fall out all over the place. Less expensive than area sub shops the value is amazing. Jersey Mike I'll be back. SAC read more

We wanted to try out the new sandwich place in Guilford. When I came in the counter person snapped at me for going to the Called In First counter since we had not called in our order ahead of time. Then the counter person had heard of several sandwiches on their own menu and had to call the manager out for help. They acted like we were stupid for not knowing all the toppings that were available and were irritated at having to tell us. This is in mid afternoon with no one else in the store. But the worst was to come. One sandwich was ready in 5 minutes but not the other. After 10 more minutes waiting we went up to see why the delay. Turns out the sandwich was there the whole time but they never called us. A sarcastic "Oh sorry" from the counter person who had been looking right at us the whole 10 minutes. Rude and incompetent, always a great combination read more

We just had delivery via DoorDash & the Italian sub & Kahuna Philly Cheesesteak (as a wrap) are PERFECT! Will definitely be ordering from the Guilford Jersey Mike's again. read more

BIG WARNING: the owner refuses to enforce customers to wear a mask. A customer was wearing his mask under his chin, full mouth and nose exposed(continuously laughing loudly and spitting into the trash can). I asked the employee if he could please ask the customer to put his mask up and he said that the owner will not allow employees to enforce wearing a mask. read more

Great fresh subs with an easy touch free pick up process, and they deliver as well. Excellent addition to that busy plaza. They also donate to local charities frequently. read more

THESE GUYS DO NOT ENFORCE MASK RULES!! Would give a higher review for the food but people must be warned that they do not take masks seriously in there...at all. Would be willing to remove this review with an assurance from the management or owner that they will begin enforcing and taking their customer's safety seriously. They clearly do not. Also, have had SEVERAL bad experiences with rude workers there but I'm less worried about that than I am about their refusal to take public safety and mask wearing and hand sanitizer seriously. read more

Delicious!!!! My food was ready on time and it was well made. Great job! My third time here and yet again superb service.

Not a lot of reviews on this place but there are a couple about masks . People are more concerned with masks that don't do shit then they are about the service. Ordered a sandwich said it would be done at 6:35. Got there at 6:50 and they didn't even start it . That's a problem . Masks aren't. Get your sandwich and leave . Masks are wack and so is your service. read more

This place was great when they first opened in Guilford now the subs barley have any meat in them! They don't get back to you when you fill out the customer satisfaction thing I spend a lot of money there but at $8.95 a sub plus tax and tip I'm done I will be going somewhere else. read more

overpriced sandwiches with unresponsive management. i will never give them business again

You need more than just flavor to keep me as a customer. I have been going to Jersey Mike's since it opened. The sandwich was always good and the service acceptable. Today was the end of that. I ordered a delivery through Door Dash. I received a little while later. Left on my door in a sealed bag with Jersey Mike tape. Great idea. I brought the bag in. Received my soda, my chips and cookies. No sandwich!! I contacted the driver who said he picked up a sealed bag and delivered it as it was handed to him. I then called JM and was told that they put the sandwich in the bag and basically called me a liar. That was followed by the repetition of "sir" in that condescending manner that actually means something profane. Point is no sandwich and a staff member basically calling me a liar just made them lose my business. Its typical of an establishment where the employees make the same regardless of what they say or if they lose customers. Since they have opened, I have spent over $2000 on sandwiches and platters for my office and clients. There are too many good choices (with caring owners) in town to have to put up with that behavior. I am a local business man with a big mouth. This is not over! Coolhaus Issues Voluntary Recall on read more

Despite just opening up, this location had fast and friendly service with a well-crafted sub! Very clean and inviting location - I'll be back for sure. read more

I called the other day for information on pricing and various other questions, was speaking to one of the managers named Whitney. She was professional and helpful with every question. I ended up bringing samples to a large community I was calling on the behalf of and they were well received. Everything was delicious fresh and I know they I've not seen the last of us. read more

I was just going to let my experience ride but after reading a review where a #8 was mentioned I changed my mind. That customer describes it with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, oil & vinegar , wow. I got none of that. 2 other customers in the store, our first time there, 5 people behind the counter not counting the grill area. I asked for a # 17 I believe it was _ philly steak & cheese and a #8 and they wrote out a charge slip for the #17 and told me to take it to cashier, I asked about the #8 and was told that didn't need a slip so I paid. A few slices of meat and cheese and 3 pieces of bacon went on a small *regular* roll, next guy in line took it apart and looked it, moved the bacon and meat around, didn't see him do that to any other and then wrapped it and bagged it. They brought the philly steak out from the grill area and gave it to me along with the one the guy had taken apart...it was a #9 NOT 8 and no offer was made for lettuce or anything else. Woman offered to remake it but at that point I was ready to leave. I said #8 at least 3 times...perhaps if the music wasn't playing so loud they might have heard better and I have no idea why I was not offered the chance to add lettuce or anything else.. For $8.95 it was an over priced mistake I made and we won't be back read more

stopped in to get a grinder after shopping and the staff was very nice and like I said in a previous review whitney the manager is awesome this is my new grinder place....this is like 6 times I have been there never any issues... read more