I visit every time I'm in Rochester. I believe they are the best wings in the city. In the DMV wings are not really what one would call good. Buffalo wing factory was good some years ago but I don't stop in anymore. Jimmy's in Herndon are ok, passable. We went for lunch to Jeremiah's, Jefferson road location. Bar seats were available so we sat there. I ordered a tall Yuengling and she ordered an iced tea. The location has a stack of history for me. In the cooler months outside there are heating units and a bar so if you want to sit outside they accommodate you. On to the wings, I order 10 medium heat done crispy. Not may people at lunch time and my wings are up in a flash. Yuengling was gone...so I order another one. Wings are crispy and tasty. Worth the ride and the wait. Wings gone, beer gone, I pay up and we're gone. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Medium heat wings, done crispy. - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Pulled up to Jeremiah's for happy hour.. $3 well drinks is a steal Wings were decent, I tried the tavern BBQ, bee sting, and nawlin' blues (sauce on the side of course). The vibe felt very local crowd, not really my scene but I can see how people who love neighborhood bars would enjoy it. read more

See all

As a party of two, we were seated fairly quickly because there were very few customers. We waited for something to drink for almost 15 minutes. Once we received a basic beverage we waited another 30 minutes for them too take our order. The place was empty. When we received the food it was overcooked and missing requested items. We returned the overcooked item...and was still charged the cost of the overcooked item. The chili was terrible, as was the Buffalo chicken wrap I ordered. We will never go back. read more

Ah, the holy trinity of a great time! Whether you're watching a game, hanging out with friends, or just enjoying a weekend, chicken wings, sports, and beer make for a classic combination. Do you have a favorite wing flavor or a go-to beer? read more

See all

Four of us had lunch there before the MercyMe concert. We all were very happy with our meals! Our waitress was wonderful!

So disappointed they do not have much for a gluten free person. Offing a salad to someone with gluten intolerance is not acceptable!

Four of us visited on a Friday-boy were they busy. Only took about five minutes to be seated. Waitress took our drink orders quickly, and came back in no time with our drinks. Restaurant was very loud, but it is a bar, after all. Multitude of choices on the menu, everyone was able to find something they liked. As busy as the place was, I believe there were only two people waiting tables-our waitress was really good, and she had a good staff of servers assisting. I'm surprised this place gets such low ratings, i thought they dis a fine job and would definitely consider returning. read more

See all

Jeremiah's is the place to go after a long lacrosse tryout and it's late and not wanting to make dinner. It satisfied the hunger after not eating since lunch. At 9pm on a Monday the best of the best is not expected. The service was good. Food coming out was a bit slow with a hungry teenager in tow. However was good when it arrived. Great for groups as well. Plenty of read more

worst meal ever! could not remember the last time we went there, years for sure so we decided to try Jeremias. I ordered a burger 1104 plate with all macaroni salad. The salad had no salt, and only 2 tiny pieces of a soft carrot in it. Burgers were cooked ok but no flavor and hot sauce was lousy.Ketchup on our table was almost an empty bottle, checked 2 other tables for ketchup and the were the same. If this is a form of portion control, did not appreciate the empty bottle splatted on my shirt. other person ordered a brisket sandwich with curly fries. Sandwich was bad, brisket was overcooked and pulled not sliced. Fries are what you would expect to find in the very bottom of a frozen bag of fries, just small pieces of fries and they were over fried and hard. They may have gotten $45. from us today but will never go back and will never recommend them. read more

Usually a go-to but today was terrible. 1st beer requested was completely flat. Then a different beer ordered to replace that one was stale. My clam "chowdah" was thinner than chicken soup, definitely not a chowder, and the clams were like pencil erasers. My "extra crispy" wings weren't crispy at all and the meat was like rubber. I now know why they are advertising for kitchen help. Will not go back for at least 2 or 3 months if ever. Worst I've been served at any of the Jerimiah's in decades read more

We had reservation's for 14 people. We had to ask for napkins, flatware, 1 alcohol menu had to be shared around the table, empty ketchup bottles (not just our table but all 3 surrounding the table we were siting at, I ordered a tall beer and a short was delivered, it took a long time to get our orders placed and took a long time to get the food. Of course being a large group gratuity was added. I wouldn't have given a dime for a tip. Do yourself a favor go across the street. read more

Had high hopes for this place. Was recommended by the in laws that this place had great wings. So I ordered the wings, and my wife ordered the cheesesteak. Our kids got burgers which were both nice and big and they really liked and. I wanted to try two different flavors or wings, so I had to order 5 and 5, for $20?!? But I was confident they'd be good based on what our in laws said. We sat outside on a Thursday for dinner. Wasn't really busy, happy hour had been over for a bit. But unfortunately we had to wait just over 30 minutes for our food to arrive. Tried asking the server/bartender that was taking care of us but he was either behind the bar or over on the other side of the restaurant/patio, nowhere near our table. Food finally arrived, 5 of my wings were barely room temperature(Korean bbq), which just tasted like soy sauce and sesame oil. My wife's cheesesteak was super dry, just meat and a little bit of cheese. Overall the wings were just average, definitely not worth $20 and a 30min wait. Don't plan on going back. Plenty of better options in the area. Our in laws were a little embarrassed because they too were disappointed and regretted recommending Jeremiah's. read more

So, I love the flavor of the wings . However, they do not cook them enough. I specifically check all the boxes for well done or crispy when I order online. I don't think they ever read that. The wings are soggy and doughy. When I say crispy I mean CRUNCH. I know a few other places local who do it well. Disappointed read more

Great food! Great service! I would highly recommend checking this place out if you're in town. We had a group of 20 people, and they gave us a private room in the back and made sure everything we needed was taken care of. The food came out hot and fast And I couldn't ask for anything more! Make sure you come check this place out. read more

This place is so wildly inconsistent. One time you'll get get perfectly cooked beautiful wings, and the next you'll get shrunken overcooked well-done wings. At nearly $2 a wing after taxes, it's simply not worth the roll of the dice. I'm giving up here and trying Tully's next. If that doesn't work, I'll drive the distance to Bar Bill. read more

Our hockey team ate here for a team meal (Saturday lunch) and had a good experience. They allowed us to make a reservation for 20 people, and they assigned two wait staff to our group. Most people really enjoyed their food, and the service was excellent. Large beer selection, wide variety of menu items, and plenty of seating made for a great experience. We had one waitress who was amazing, and she made up for the other who was pretty grumpy. I had the steak tips and my wife had the meatballs. The steak tips were awesome, but the meatballs were just so-so. A lot of the other meals like salads, nachos and burgers looked good as well We would eat here again, but it's probably geared more towards large groups or informal situations. I'm not sure that it would be the best place for a date or business meal. read more

I took a group of 32 people there for lunch. We had one super waitress Desire. The food came out fast, correct and was real good. They even let us split all our checks . we had our own room. It was good but echoed so was kind of hard to hear the conversation..that's building issue ..Staff was fantastic read more

Our waiter started out fabulously! We were anticipating a great experience! But then... - two of us asked for a glass of ice on three separate occasions; it finally arrived AFTER we were done - no silverware - we ended up eating with our fingers (not graceful for mandarin oranges) - waiter never checked on us- we would've ordered additional drinks with/after dinner maybe even dessert. Moral of the story for wait staff: if you have a great personality and connect with your customers at the start, you need to follow through. Your tips are reflective of your overall service. read more

Amazing wings! Best in Rochester...cooked exactly as requested. We'll be back. Take out through yelp was easy and on time. read more

We have been going to Jeremiah's original restaurant since the early 90's. This was our first Jeremiah's other than the original. I am glad to say this location has the best wings around!! I have eaten wings all over the country and never found better wings than Jeremiah's Catatonic wings. We visit Rochester about once a year and the ONLY place we visit every time is Jeremiah's for wings. We had Sam as our waitress this evening and she was great. Ask for Sam and tip her well. Great wings and great service. What else can you ask for? Enjoy read more

See all

When a friend suggested we meet at Jeremiah's Tavern when we visited Rochester, I looked them up on Yelp and was not impressed with the ratings. Then I thought, we're here to see friends and if that's where they want to eat, so be it. We arrived on a busy Friday night and was told it was a 30-45 minute wait for a table. 18 minutes later, our pager went off and we were seated at a booth away from the noise and traffic area. This allowed us a great opportunity to catch up with friends we see only once or twice a year. My hesitation turned out to be unfounded. Food was very good as was the service. In our group we ordered a Cobb salad, bee sting chicken salad and two apple pecan chicken salad wraps. All were excellent. Portions and quality (especially the variety of greens in the salads) were also good. In short, good food with good friends made for a great evening. read more

During coronavirus period, the food was excellent! I have to praise how well cooked mahi they did and mango was very good! I never thought mango and mahi being drizzled with cilantro dressing. Absolutely delicious! I'd recommend anyone to order this dish because it's perfect time and a great way to bring some summer breeze to here despite of pandemic right now. Thank you for amazing food!! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Island Mahi and Mango Tacos - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Came here for a work lunch because of the location. We made reservations but really didn't need to since there was hardly anyone here. Hostess wouldn't seat us until the entire party was present, I normally agree with this but again the place was almost empty.I did like the interior of the place, all the hardwood floors and benches. We had one server for our group of nine but it seemed like she could of used an extra person to help out. It took a bit for us to all get our drinks and place our orders. We shared some appetizers, the onion rings (crispy with a good taste) Also the pretzel with dipping sauce, the honey mustard sauce was disappointing. For lunch I ordered the Reuben (corned beef) you can get it with turkey...no thanks. I love Reuben's, but this one was nothing great. A bit soggy and just blah. My side dish was the tater tots, these were by far the best thing I had here. I also tired the chicken strips, normal bar food. Many of my coworkers ordered the salads, they seemed happy with those. The bar area looked good, I would come back to try that. read more

See all

So boom, I check out Jeremiah's Website to see their selection of sauces so I can figure out which wings I'm about to devour. These guys have SAUCES ON DECK. Sauce Selection: Buffalo (Mild, Medium, Hot) Catatonic (Jalapeno based hot) Wise Guy (A Spicier version of Catatonic) Holy Habanero (With habanero chunks in it!) Pow Pow (Creamy peppery garlic sauce with a little kick to it) Nawlin's Blues (Buffalo cajun garlic parm with blue cheese crumbles) Teriyaki Pineapple (A sweet and sour wing) Tavern BBQ (Thick and tangy) Garlic Parm (Buttery goodness) Cajun (A dry rub) Bee-Sting (Sweet and Spicy) Jamaican Jerk (You already know what it is) Korean BBQ (Sweet, peppery and spicy) I'm honestly impressed by the variety of sauces they have. Each sounds delicious and their chef's must really be in the lab whipping these up! Below the sauce selection on their website you can find the wing prices. They're in the following order 5 Wings - 7.99 10 Wings - 14.50 20 Wings - 28.75 30 Wings - 42.75 50 Wings - 59.49 My thoughts on reading these prices. THESE ARE SOME EXPENSIVE ASS WINGS. I'm shocked they cost this much but so many people say they're the best in town so I'm sure it's justified. IMPORTANT NOTE: Jeremiah's doesn't allow you to split sauces unless you order 50 wings. If you want a variety of sauces, you have to order by quantity for each flavor you want. Ordering over the phone, I was greeted by a nice young lady who took my order. She was very attentive, quick and to the point. I like that. I settled on the following sauces: Bee-Sting Catatonic Nawlin's Blues Pow-Pow I ordered 5 of each flavor and my total was $36 dollars and some change. That's STEEP for some wings, so they better be FIRE. When picking up my wings, it was a very in and out process that didn't have any unnecessary talking or conversation. Driving back home, I immediately noticed that these wings smell AMAZING. The big body caddy was filled with an aroma of spices and flavors that had my mouth watering. Could these be the best wings I've had yet? Let's get to it. Opening my big brown bag of deliciousness, I noticed that each flavor was packaged individually in a cardboard box with foil and paper. I really do appreciate the great packaging and presentation. Everyone in Rochester should learn from this because Jeremiah's packs their food better than anyone else (It's also recyclable!). Nawlin's Blues: These wings have a bit of a kick to it! The sauce is full of flavor and the blue cheese crumbles really do make a huge difference in how they taste. The parmesan flavor didn't stand out to me, but the rest of the flavors made their presence known. If you love buffalo wings and blue cheese, these are a MUST TRY. My first wing wasn't the most crispy but BOYYYYY was it JUICY. These wings had me drooling. Bee-Sting: This sauce is INCREDIBLE. Sweet, tangy, spicy and oh so delicious. I can't say enough good things about this sauce! The heat is JUST right, and I feel like I could taste a hint of honey in it. If you love country sweet sauce, you'll like this one even more! They're mouth watering delicious and a must have if you're in Rochester! This was definitely my favorite sauce out of the bunch. Pow Pow: This sauce SLATHERED these wings. The flavor was reminiscent of garlic parm but with a bit of a kick as you eat them. Initially I was unimpressed by this flavor. It felt bland on the first bite and I didn't enjoy them as much as the other flavors. Regardless, I ended up dogging these wings because they cost so much. I'll be damned if I let food go to waste! Catatonic: Bruce Lee must've made these wings because they got some KICK to it. It looked like these wings were slathered in a buffalo sauce and covered in chunks of jalapenos! As a spice lover, these weren't as hot as I wanted them to be, but they were still alright. Not my favorite flavor, but still pretty good. Final Thoughts: These wings are pretty good and I was pleasantly surprised at how much flavor they packed. Packaging was second to none and I really appreciate the detail and time they put into presenting these wings. Most wings had a little bit of crisp to them but it wasn't consistent for each wing. Personally, I think they should bring the price down a tad. I understand the effort and money that goes into the packaging and presentation of these wings but I just don't think that 20 wings for 36 dollars is worth it in my book. Are they the best in town? Nah, but you won't be disappointed if you order from them! A solid 8/10 read more

See all

Was told that this is one of the best spots in Rochester to get buffalo wings, and that recoomendation was not wrong. The wings were great. Perfectly coated in sauce that had a very nice spice that wasn't overwhelming. And the tater tot poutine was excellent. It is one of my favorite dishes, and they did a very good job with their preparation. Will definitely go back the next time I'm in the Rochester area. read more

Comfort food! Not the classic kind of comfort food, but trust me, I am very comfortable with wings and sides like onion rings and loaded fries. And Jeremiah's does all those really well and consistently so. There is always a table available, no waits or reservations. Service is friendly and good. I admit that their wings is not the best I have ever had but they are reliably good. Prices are okay. Ambiance varies between locations but Jefferson Rd may be newer and better. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Wings, onion rings and loaded fries ... what else do you want? - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Later on a Friday night we stopped in for wings, beer and sandwiches. We called ahead and were told it wasn't too busy so we were seated quickly. There was a little confusion about what beer could be ordered in pitcher form, we were hoping for not just the standard (labatts, bud etc) but no dice. The reuben was tender, well sized and didn't sog out. Wings were ordered hot and well done which they delivered on. The Manny melt was cooked as requested and reportedly delicious. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Manny melt w tots - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Unclear why this location's kitchen closes at 8:46 pm. The Monroe Ave location let me know that the kitchen was open until 10 pm at the Henrietta location so it's nice to know the staff lied. When I tried to call, no one picked up. Terrible customer service. read more

Gates (Buffalo Road) location. The food is good, if slightly expensive. More attention needs to be paid to the deep fryer time, it looks like. Curly fries were overcooked to oblivion. The service was polite enough, I guess. The problem is the atmosphere/mood of the place. Grim, mundane, and quasi-elitist. read more

Flew in and my hotel room wasn't ready up the street. Spent a few hours chilling, watching sports, having a few beers. Hot day, so I brought in candy that I bought for my mom, to keep it from melting. One hour, two hours, three hours, almost 4. My phone showed that my room was ready, one last cold beer on the bar, I picked up my candy to take it to the car and crack the windows.......cold beer still at the bar.... STOP! Says the manager (?). You are NOT permitted to exit this building! You have an open tab! I said, just a quick trip to the car, then I'll finish my last beer and tally up. NO! My rules. You can NOT exit this building! All of this in front of customers and some were kids. I've never been treated so dis-respectful from an establishment. Well, you lost a regular customer. Your Nazi, manager can cost his servers all of the tips they deserve. You deserve zero stars *Yelp Elite customer. See below response: Remember, fresh beer just poured, no one took it away. The response of "Concern" is diversion from the issue. So what I get from this is your staff will serve, then disrespect customers. I'm tired of this diversion from what happened. I'm going to Tully's read more

great fall off the bone smoked wings. A bit overpriced in my opinion but at least tasty. I usually go for buffalo for sauce but if you like lots of options they have them for sure read more

Food and drink isn't a huge deal. Lots of bars nearby. But if you've ever been in customer service, you know that it's easy to tell who cares about their job and who are simply here to punch in and punch out. Meghan at the bar definitely takes an interest in her job and how she's treated me the last few times. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Singlecut Half-stack always on tap. - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Great food spot from what I've tried so far, Burger and soup And I like how many beers they have on tap, think it's like minimum 18 I was just passing through town traveling but seems like a great spot Pretty affordable too I will say though I ate here and ordered a "1104" plate and I did not realize from the wording on the description that I was ordering a fry plate intended to be ate as a mix I thought it was a deal or something with 2 cheeseburgers, it's 2 beef patties on top of fries with Macoroni salad on the bottom and slightly spicy ground beef, like sloppy joe on top Food was still good but def not what I was expecting. Great experience, would recommend to others read more

See all

Food is good, but on the expensive side. $2.75 for a single slice of bacon on my burger is ridiculous. This burger with only grilled onions and a single slice of bacon cost $18.25...before tax! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I was at the extended-stay behind the restaurant and ordered a turkey Reuben with fries and a side salad to go. Everything was very fresh and it was super fast. read more

This was. My 1st time her, and my 1st time eating the food as well. The wings were awesome. Honestly some of the best I've had in Rochester. I was craving them for about a week after! The pretzels were also very good. Now for those shrimp tacos. They were massive, but they weren't that great. The shrimp had absolutely no taste. It was so disappointing to me, because those tacos had so much potential. The service..... my waitress was very nice but she was soooooo slow. We went and there wasnt that many people. I couldnt get a refill on my water to save my life, to the point that I needed to go look for her. This is my reason for taking a star off. read more

See all

We've gotten both takeout here and dined in their outside space. I will say that the outside space is greet and they have an impressive draft beer offering. But food is over cooked and fries are underdone. read more

Fantastic food and frriendly attentive service paired with amazing wings for the win. Definitely recommend read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Never been to this location before and I'll definitly be back. The bar area was super noisy so we sat in the dining room. Our server was great, super attentive. I got chicken fingers and steak fries. Baxter was plentiful and delicious. Fries were nice and hot. Hubby got fish fry and he said it was absolutely delicious. They also have a cute outdoor area too. read more

Why on earth would you serve someone's food on a dirty pan that was covered up with paper. That was tonight. When I went in last week, the general manager was visibly drunk while working the front counter. Thankfully, he walked out before he got more ugly than he already was to his customers. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - The corners of the tray had baked on food. - New American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all