This is one of my favorite lunch places! Their street tacos are amazingly delicious and the hot…read moresalsa is a great addition

From the owner: Tacos, Gringas, Mulitas, Quesadillas, Tortas, Burritosread more

Looks sketchy from the outside. But inside is great! Food was amazing and came out super fast!…read moreWould definitely come back when I'm in town again

This place is great! Casual, authentic, little taqueria. Very nice staff and excellent prices…read more Still $2.50 tacos. Food is made to order. If you're hungry, easily order 4+. Cannot recommend enough for a quick bite headed up to fish the HF or check out YNP.

It was very authentic food especially when considering that the menu is only in Spanish and just…read moreone person working there spoke English. The food was a bit hit or miss. The Quessabirria looked amazing but only tasted of grease which dripped freely all over everything. The carne asada burrito was ok. The meat didn't really stand out and it only tasted of beans, lettuce and sour cream. The two things that were good were the two pork taco options. The pork carnitas had the most amazing texture I've ever been lucky to try. It was moist and crunchy from the flat top. It is definitely worth giving this meat choice a try in anything they have. The true star though was the Adobada tacos. They were amazing. There was tons of meat with so much flavor. These were the best Adobada I've ever had anywhere. I think the highs were very high but the lows were just as low. They have decent salsas but if you can't take a good bit of heat you won't be able to handle even the weakest one. Definitely worth checking out.

This Mexican place is 100% authentic! The tacos were so simple yet so flavorful. My favorite was…read morethe chorizo which has a nice char to the meat. They also have three salsa to enjoy. The habanero was nice but my favorite was the red salsa that was Smokey and hot. The menu was very simple and it was quick to order. If you do come around lunch time expect to wait a bit as it gets very busy around then.

First time in and they just opened up. Staff was new...obviously…read more Overall the staff is super friendly, but didn't know the food or menu items. Placed our order and then a long line formed behind us. It's close to the HS so lots of customer potential. For my Texican taco, I was not impressed. The beef was dry and no seasoning. The Rusty was decent and spicy. My wife's Baja bowl was small compared to the website. Flavor was fine but the portion was small compared to the price. I don't like leaving a review on my first visit unless it's really bad. They didn't have this new location posted yet so I added it.

I've been here a few times now and tried something different each time so I think I can give a fair…read moreassessment of what I've seen so far: The good: flavor. I've only come across one item that I was kind of so-so on but since I personally don't have a ton of experience with chorizo, I'm chalking that up to possibly just not liking chorizo that much. The neutral: size/price ratio. The prices aren't bad but aren't great either when compared to "the big boys," and that's OK. You're definitely getting the most bang for your buck if you order the dinner combo but generally speaking Rusty's seems less about trying to appeal to your sense of "more is better" that most fast-food places do and more about pricing at a rate that's affordable for their bottom line and still appealing for customers. The bad: advertisement vs reality. So, I understand, as we all do, "pre cook weight vs serve weight," "presentation photos," stuff like that. We've all been exposed to it our entire lives, but it's still a real kick in the teeth when you go to a place and the ingredient list for the taco you purchased says "avocado" and the taco picture shows avocado slices, and the pictures shared by the business of the taco shows slices, and then you get the taco and instead it's a small ball of green mush on one side of the taco and you now have to spread it across the taco, but they've given you no utensils because you bought a taco and you're now in a place with no utensils where you intend to eat said taco. Now you're either running your finger through your avocado paste or eating a glob of avocado paste in one bite at the beginning or end. This last bit was the only thing keeping this review from a 4 star. If Rusty Taco were just honest about the use of avocado mash and spread it instead of dropping on one side with no warning, I wouldn't be bothered by it because it's not about a taste or texture difference, it's about an expectation that was set then changed which forces a change of plans on the customer. A side note: Rusty Taco is really inconsistent on their app about calorie counts for items. As much as I hate to be one of those people, I've recently had to become much more aware of my calorie intake so the lack of calorie count one some items turns me away from trying some of the things on their menu I would like to so if anyone from Rusty reads these, I would love to see more complete information on your ordering app.

Slow for what they present. Counter ordering would imply food that would arrive quickly but that…read moreisn't the case. It is more like food that is good that you have to order at the counter and then wait around for quite a while and still have to go pick it up at the counter like McDonalds. I would probably think twice about what I tip if I ever went back. The actual place is clean and the staff is friendly. They have a tiny market to buy items like spices or other product.

Amazing and fresh food. We always have great service and our kids love it too. Our go-to meals are…read morethe street tacos and they never disappoint.

We went to Rusty's one day for lunch. It was great. There was so much to choose from we couldn't…read morepick just one so we both tried some different options. News flash they were all good. A great place for lunch and pretty much any time.

Updated review 4/9/24 they no longer have BOGO taco Tuesdays. We would normally get 8 tacos and a…read moredrink for $12 and change. Today on taco Tuesday we got 7 sale tacos and a drink and it was $24. No longer a cheap date night. We probably won't be going back. Bummer. As always the service is super friendly.

Best tacos in IF! Too bad they are closed Sunday and Mondays!…read moreBest salsa rojo I've had in a long while. Tons of Asada on the tacos Huge burritos

Tacos...on a bus! From what I understand, this place has gone over some changes/ownership over the…read moreyears. As of this writing, I can confidently say that this is a great choice if you are going through Rexburg. I ordered the Quesotaco (pork and beef), they were both really good and you can tell that they were super fresh and made to order. I wish I could take this place home with me!

Honestly the best quesotacos and tacos I've had in a while! The meat is flavorful…read more(adobada/chicharron/carne asad) and their tortillas are handmade! Everything about this taqueria is superb in taste, quality, and service! I wish I could've taken a picture but the tacos were so tasty so I completely forgot

Staff got my order wrong, I just had got off my 16 hour shift. All I want was a cheese burger,…read morewitch by the way 2 burgers was 14+change. I told them about it the manager simply replied "that's not my problem" and refused to fix the issue

"Our computers are down come back in 20-30 minutes."…read more The fries were beyond salty. Overall bad. Won't return. I have done formal reviews through a YouTube channel with one of my buddies. Pocatello Jack and the box... don't go !