Heather made an amazing cake! I had a small intimate ceremony but still wanted a cake. I had called a few bakers and the prices were still really high. I told Heather what I was looking for and she quoted me lower than all the other bakers. I told her I was having a small ceremony but still wanted a cake. She suggested a small two layer cake. I had a few ideas from Pinterest I showed her at the tasting. I ended up selecting vanilla cake with strawberry filling for the bottom layer and the top was marble with alternating layers of white chocolate and ganache. The cake was amazing. We made sure all the guests were sent home with some extra. I ended up taking most of the top layer to our hotel and had it over the next several mornings with coffee (it was my wedding week and I'll eat cake for breakfast if I want!). My only regret is that we didn't save the top layer for our anniversary. M read more

It's Tasty Too! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The first time I visited I drove around since I did not think a custom cake decorating company was inside a delicatessen in a light industrial Warehouse. The deli is Apple Spice junction and was closed the day we were meeting the baker. I was here with my wife and daughter to chose her wedding cake. If it was not that our wedding coordinator recommended this baker I would never had picked it. After meeting the baker and trying the cake options I am very optimistic. The baker listened to my daughter for what she wanted and offered options that we did not even know where options. Then she drew a rough draft of the cake for my daughter and wife to approve and it looked great. Very artistic. I will let you know how it all turns out this summer. read more

See all

Received a cupcake as a holiday gift... and of course promptly scarfed that bad boy down.. (Should have taken a picture, oh well) It was a large red velvet cupcake with a piped sugar icing on top. Once the cupcake was cut into, a small dollop of cream cheese filling was revealed. The cupcake itself was moist, but had no discernable "red velvet" cake taste. In fact it tasted a little too flour-y too me. The icing on top was your standard icing, sugary without being gritty. The cream cheese filling was too small of a dollap to adequately fill up the inside of the cupcake and left me wanting more. The filling was tasty, but a little sweet, however it balanced out the not too sweet cake. Overall, a nicely presented and tasty cupcake, however It's Tasty Too! needs to step up the flavor profile... Note: the storefront is by appointment only. website: http://www.tastytoo.com/Welcome.html read more

It's Tasty Too! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Loved the cake and it was delicious as it was beautiful. It was the perfect centerpiece for my mother's 75th birthday party. Heather captured all of my mother's favorite desserts all on one cake. That's so cool! Last night I finished the last piece, 6 days after the party, and it was as moist as the first bite. That was the most common comment amount the cake at the party. Thank you Heather and Misty for your care! read more

It's Tasty Too! - Light green, light rose, cream and gold palette. Magnolias with floating petals. Love this cake! Thanks to Heather & Misty - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

For many years I've been ordering an average of 30 wedding cakes a year for my clients from Its Tasty Too .The owner Heather has never once disappointed any of my clients in anyway. Her quality, style and taste are down to perfection. Delivery is always on time and they arrive without a dent or a crack. As an event planner, it's such a piece of mind knowing it's one detail I never have to worry about.Her cakes are simply amazing in every way. Hope to continue to do business with Its Tasty Too for many more years to come! Thank you Heather Henriette K. Simply the Best Creations Orlando, Florida, usa read more

I used Its Tasty Too for our wedding cake via Weddings Inc in 2016. Overall, my experience was fine. I would have given 3 stars, but the cake turned out really great. Customer service was my biggest negative. My husband and I were planning our wedding from Pennsylvania and came down for a long weekend for wedding planning. We booked an appointment with Heather well in advance for a cake tasting and to discuss what we wanted. We arrived and the bakery was completely dark. We called the phone number for the business with no answer. Heather forgot our appointment. It was pretty stressful as we weren't coming back to Florida until close to our wedding date. We ended up getting another consultation/cake tasting appointment and Heather's assistant helped us - she was amazing. We described what we wanted and got exactly that. Make sure you confirm your appointment a few days before ESPECIALLY if you're traveling from out of town! read more

It's Tasty Too! - UP inspired wedding cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I contacted this bakery to make a top cake along with 50 cupcakes for my wedding and I can NOT express how happy I was with everything!!!! I planned a destination wedding in Orlando (I live in Ohio) and needless to say I was EXTREMELY nervous ordering a wedding cake remotely without even tasting or seeing anything, but It's Tasty Too made my experience so seamless, easy and efficient. I worked with Heather here who was extremely helpful, professional and pleasant and responded to all of my texts and emails in a timely and helpful manner. Also, when our nerves got the best of us and we decided to visit vendors in Orlando weeks before the wedding, Heather was kind enough to coordinate a tasting for us free of charge last minute. Most importantly, the cake was DELICIOUS, absolutely stunning, and was EXTREMELY affordable!!! It exceeded our expectations and was so much more than what we hoped for. I highly recommend this bakery to anyone looking for cake that looks and tastes good but doesn't break the bank!!! read more

It's Tasty Too! - a wedding cake with red roses - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

We were lucky enough to have It's Tasty Too! provide our wedding cake as part of a package booked through Weddings, Inc. We were initially referred to It's Tasty Too! by a coworker, and after we did our tasting, we were beyond ecstatic. They were our first choice, before we even booked a package deal with Weddings, Inc. When it turned out that this was our assigned vendor for cake, we were pleased as punch. Heather was very sweet (pun fully intended) and gave us a lot of great recommendations. We wanted a simple buttercream design with sugar flowers. The cake was a huge hit, and just absolutely gorgeous. Our favorite flavor was orange with cream cheese filling. We also had chocolate with amaretto and vanilla with cookies 'n cream, which were both amazing as well! But, looking back, we might have just gone for a 100% orange cake. It was the perfect amount of orange flavor. The cake was delicious, and beautifully decorated. I'm not a fan of fondant, neither the taste of it nor the look. Heather did an amazing job with the buttercream frosting and the sugar flowers. Another great note, we are a lesbian couple and happy to say that It's Tasty Too! is most definitely LGBT-friendly! :) read more

It's Tasty Too! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

requested blue hydrange cupcakes- green sloppy cupcakes delivered. so disappointing--baker is not very personable either.

I worked with It's Tasty Too! through Weddings Inc. We absolutely loved our cake! We had an amaretto flavored cake with fondant icing. I'd never tried fondant icing before, but I really loved the marshmallow flavor. Heather was great to work with and delivered exactly what I asked for. We received many compliments on the design and flavor of our cake. Great experience all around. http://statigr.am/p/474522785493187956_191592462 read more

I was from Alaska planning to vacation in Orlando - wanted a special birthday cake made. Had to discuss long distance and yes it was a different type - picture of an Eskimo Whaling scene along with mementos of trips past and future i.e. cowboy hat, guitar (Nashville) Hawaiian Shirt (Hawaii ) passports (Europe). Believe or not some Bakery actually refused (ethical animal treatment LOL) LUCKY ME Boy was this cake awesome huge - stick with 8x8 which is what she recommended but I thought that small (she was right) and went with 9x9. The cake and fillings were the best I ever had - we opted for several flavors my absolutely favorite was the ALMOND cake with HAZLENUT filling. The planning went smoothly and they delivered perfectly timed - good good good quality and value for the money :) read more

See all

Great service. Fair price and absolutely wonderful cake. I couldn't be happier of my dr who anniversary cake. The process from beginning to end was more than I expected. read more

It's Tasty Too! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Can't say enough about Heather and her work. She is awesome. She did both my wedding and baby shower cake & cupcakes Absolutely love her and her work ethics. I am forever a customer and would highly recommend her. Do not pass her, you will not regret it. Wait did I mention that her cake taste as GREAT as it looks. My God! She has tons of flavors and fillings to choose from. I can't wait to work with her again. read more

It's Tasty Too! - a wedding cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I was the maid of honor at my best friend's wedding 2 weeks ago. When we met the delivery man, he said he didn't know which cupcakes were which and that we should just look at them and guess. The color of the wedding cake was incorrect. Customer service resolving the issue was poor. read more

I don't normally leave reviews, but in this case I think it's justified. We used It's Tasty Too for our wedding cake and cupcakes, and were extremely disappointed with the service we received. We ordered red iced cupcakes in four flavors, and a white cake for our wedding. We were promised that upon delivery, the cupcake flavors would be sorted so that we could label them appropriately. Upon delivery, we were told by the man delivering them that he "didn't know which flavors were which, but would try to guess". Additionally, the cupcakes were frosted with a shade of red very different from that of the decorations on the cake, such that they looked orange. After our wedding, we brought up our complaints and were told that we would receive some money back due to the issues we had, which we were completely willing to accept. A week later, we had still not received the money, and tried to find out why. Rather than having a reasonable discussion about the disagreement, the owner resorted to personal attacks on myself and my new wife, when all we wanted was to simply resolve the situation. I recommend that you do not use It's Tasty Too for your event, because you're likely to encounter the same kind of struggles and personal attacks that we've experienced, over what should have been a minor issue. read more

Oh my god was our wedding cake from It's tasty too beautiful! It tasted amazing as well! We order the carrot cake with white chocolate filling for the top tier of our cake and the rum cake with key lime filling for the first tier. We had an ivory octagon cake with cascading ivory flowers. It was exceptionally beautiful and we couldn't have asked for a better experience. Our cake was reasonably priced, especially for the quality and delivered on time to our resort room. Another great point was that It's Tasty Too offers to give you your first layer for free on your anniversary, if you come back to the Orlando area to celebrate! They are the perfect company to choose if your celebrating your wedding on Disney property but don't want to pay an exorbitant price for a Disney wedding that includes a cake. We had a Disney Memories Wedding and ordered a cake from It's Tasty Too and everything went off without a hitch. What a magical memory that will last for years and years to come. Thank you so much It's Tasty Too! You are truly a quality company! read more

It's Tasty Too made the cake for my wedding. I was amazed at how good the cake looked when I got to my reception, and even more pleased when I tasted it! Heather and her staff did an incredible job. What's more, the price was half of what any other company quoted us. I couldn't have been happier!! read more

We did our wedding cake here and it was delicious!!!! Every layer different and exactly what we wanted. We had it made for 110 people but it was still just as moist and amazing as if it were a small cake which I am sure it not easy to do. Thank you!!!!! read more

It's Tasty Too! - This is our wedding cake, and on top of it being exactly how I asked, it was absolutely delicious!!! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Orlando, Florida

It's Tasty Too! baked a wedding cake that was both yummy and affordable. The design was beautiful, just as we asked for, and we got to choose four different flavors! Would highly recommend this company for weddings! read more

I wish I could give Heather and It's Tasty Too a gazillion stars. Heather is a cake GENIUS. She's talented beyond my comprehension. She is very dedicated to her business and she truly is the best. She pours her heart and soul into her cakes and it shows. read more

Here is one of the bad stories of our wedding week. We worked with a company called It's Tasty Too for our wedding cake. I went up to the delivery man when he was dropping off the cupcakes at the wedding and asked him if he knew which flavors were which. He said no. I said, well thats not right because I spoke to the lady and she said that as long as i provided you with signs then my cupcakes will be labeled correctly. He said that he could just look at the cupcakes and guess. (How can you make a guess when the cake part is covered in icing?) I was disappointed to say the least but had a wedding plan to stick to and was not about to let it ruin our special day. At the time of the cake cutting Kyle and I quickly realized how orange the cupcakes were. It was made more noticeable by the bright red flower on the top of the cake. We began asking our guests what color is this. Orange was the repeated answer. Following along we had guests saying that they would grab a raspberry but it would be vanilla. Or marble and it would be Oreo. We expressed our disappointment with the lady in charge and she said that she will refund us half the money. That's more than we wanted. We simple wanted her to know of the issue and give an apology for such a blunder on such a big day. A week has gone by. No money returned. Only two texts were sent simple saying "This is Breanne. The money has not been returned." What happened next truly took my breath away and the only word to be said over and over again is "WOW." "There was a reasonable doubt in my mind to side in your favor." "I feel that you grossly stretched and manipulated the truth." "So, as you can see, there is a serious trust issue." "All of this says a lot to me about your character." She went on to say that her delivery man denies those claims and that one of my guests must have switched the labels. Now she refuses to stick to her promise. Which is fine. Don't refund us. But you are not going to speak to me, my husband, or my mother like that. I am not one to post like this, but I hate being wrongly accused, spoken down to, and people that won't own there part. She was also unresponsive during the wedding process. Don't let them ruin your wedding day. read more

I used this company for my wedding cake last year. They were very professional and the cake was amazing! They helped me custom design a cake which had 3 tiers with a different combinations of flavors on each tier. It came out exactly as I envisioned and I got loads of compliments on how good it was! I would definitely recommend them! read more

I had an excellent experience with Its Tasty Too! From my first e-mail, they were very responsive and more than willing to deliver a cake on Christmas Day (which we were very grateful for). We had a very specific idea in mind for our cake to look like Christmas presents and it was perfect!!!! It looked exactly like we wanted and tasted out of this world! We had the spice cake on the bottom layer and almond on the top layer and everyone was raving that it was the best cake they've ever had at a wedding. The cake was very affordable and the service was great. I can't wait to get our one year anniversary cake made by Its Tasty Too!! read more

It's Tasty Too made our wedding cake and groom's cake. Heather is extremely talented and very friendly and easy to deal with. Their prices are extremely reasonable and I recommend that anyone in the Central Florida area getting married to give them a try. Everything came out perfect and tasted delicious. read more

My wedding cake was beautiful. I love that this company will make you a new cake for your first anniversary. I would highly recommend this to anyone looking for a delicious cake from a reliable company! read more