Great people to work with, communication is easy, been on more dates with them in a month than several years on my own

Apparently they have resorted to spam calling people for business? Yes, I'm single but I gave up on women long ago. How did these schmucks get my number anyway? I don't need some failed matchmaking service calling me and leaving messages at 6:30 PM when I'm driving back home from a stressful Monday. Please refrain and keep your Milwaukee sadness and diseases in Milwaukee where they belong. Thanks! Update: 8/6/25: they have continued to harass me via text and calls read more

I've had an amazing experience working with Camille, Ashley and Taylor of it's Just lunch!! - 10/10; I would recommend it to anyone who is considering membership, and is ready to try their hand at dating in a different way-- Especially those with busy lives who are feeling burnt out or tired of trying their luck on the dating apps/websites. I feel understood, heard & seen, cherished, and cared for by my 3 matchmakers. They take their time and give their best efforts to find me the best possible matches. I believe that your time is a valuable resource...the fact that I no longer have to have to waste my limited free time "vetting" men or endlessly swiping through the online dating apps (because the IJL matchmakers take care of it all...Down to a tee!), is incredibly liberating. They are professional, thorough, trustworthy, competent, & empathic. The service that IJL provides is invaluable. It feels like a trusted group of friends, with my best interest in mind, are setting me up on blind dates! It's also just a lot of fun! These three women have gone above and beyond with how well they communicate, how much they genuinely care, and how lovely they are to work with. Based on my experience, it's Just lunch is an extremely worthwhile investment. I finally feel hopeful about finding "my person". -- Thank you Ashley, Camille and Taylor! read more

This is my second time around with IJL and I have nothing bad to say! All the ladies are fantastic, friendly, professional and want to see you succeed in the dating world. They do all the hard work so you just have to show up and enjoy your time for that first meet up and see where things go. Although I haven't found the one yet, the experience I've had from each date I've had has helped me feel more comfortable when meeting someone the 1st time. I believe the ladies at IJL will continue to root for me and send me the best matches! read more

Ashley, Danielle and Taylor at It's Just Lunch ("IJL") Milwaukee are THE BEST. This service is WORTH EVERY PENNY! I've tried ALL the dating apps for years. They are BS compared to this service. Not all IJL cities are the same. Milwaukee is "par excellence." With dating apps it can take 10 hours of swiping, chatting, talking on the phone to finally meet someone you think is legit only to wonder if their profile pic was 15 years old, airbrushed, modified or altered by their daughters' photo apps to the point where the real woman is now unrecognizable! IJL Milwaukee has set 5 dates for me and every one was a winner. No BS. The ladies I've met are high quality intelligent women with great careers, assets and interests. These women don't want to be victims of dating men without values, jobs, money or intelligence any more than me. You get what you pay for...pay for this service. You won't regret it! read more

I like working with IJL. They take the time to really get to know me as a client and match me with other potential clients. This process is significantly better than any other of the online dating websites I've tried. read more

It's Just Lunch provides excellent customer service and support for its customers. Danielle, Taylor, and Ashley are friendly, professional, and accommodating. They always consider your personal interests and preferences when selecting potential dates for their customers. They do all the work, including selecting potential matches, scheduling dates, and making reservations. They seek feedback after dates the assist them in fine tuning characteristics of potential future dates that might better meet your preferences. I couldn't be more satisfied with the services they offer! I believe there is someone out there for everyone, and I trust them to help me find my someone! read more

Thoughtful professionals working to help you meet great people and keep fine tuning the process to best suit what you're looking for. Responsive team ready to guide you through the process and put your best foot forward. I've had a great experience and having these professionals working to help find matches from a pool of invested, decisive potential partners helps keeps my focus on getting to know new people rather than spending lots of time, money, and energy on finding them. read more

The IJL Connection Team has really done a good job of communicating, understanding any of my concerns and having excellent matches for my dating experiences. All of my dates have been FUN and talented individuals. It's Just Lunch has made dating a lot easier and my optimism level is at a high point without lots of wasted effort to locate a like-minded lady. Thanks for the great effort. read more

Communication really needs to improve. I will reach out and not hear back for days unless I contact a manager. I also had to cancel a date, texted beforehand, and clearly no one looked at my message. I will not recommend It's Just Lunch to friends or family until things change. Really disappointed. read more

It's Just Lunch has been wonderful to work with, Ashley and Camille really get to know you as a person and try to match you with someone with similar interests. Aligning schedules is a breeze for dates. Venues selected have been very nice. Being recently widowed and not been in the dating scene for 20+ years IJL has made the experience exciting and fun. I tried a few dating apps and most people lie or make false profiles, bait n switch, or are bots. I've been on 4 dates so far and meet some really nice women. I would have given them 5 stars but the service is expensive. read more

Save your money and date the old fashioned way. Trust me when I say, they do not care about you and your relationship goals but solely on the bottom line. The first date was cancelled by the the other party, the day prior.I wasn't notified until I was already halfway to the date, what a joke. It's been a month since I heard from IJL. It's always me reaching out to them asking about dates. Definitely unacceptable for the amount of money you shell out. I have been on 4 dates so far and the matches have not been impressive. read more

I recently joined IJL and I'm really in the baby steps of the process. But I can tell you right now that I am really enjoying it because of Ashley, Taylor, and Camille. They really care about you as an individual and have treated me with such care and respect. They work hard and want to find the perfect person and relationship for their clients. I've meet one match already and I have a couple more matches lined up. It really does help to have these great ladies working for you on your behalf. They really take care of the "grunt work" and all you have is go out and have fun! I'm excited to continue this process with Ashley, Taylor, and Camille and see where everything goes. If you are considering joining IYL...I would highly recommend working with these ladies. read more

I am open minded. I see the monthly date as another opportunity to try to find a long term relationship. It is a much better than online dating honestly. It helps me in addition to the dates I am able to get on my on. I have suggested to two college friends it is worth trying versus doing nothing. read more

I have enjoyed working with the staff, in trying to find my match. They are all friendly, and take an interest in helping you find someone that you have a connection with. They will ask for your feed back after each date trying to see what you liked about the person, and what you disliked about them. read more

New to IJL so far as been a good experience with the staff. They listen to your needs to set you up with the right person. Looking forward to meeting dates going forward. read more

Ashley at it's just lunch is my favorite person to hear from! I go on the most fantastic dates with people at fabulous locations!

I previously provided a 1 star rating and was disappointed in both the matches and staff. I agreed to give it one more shot, and have met 2 well matched wonderful men and the staff has been much more attentive and responsive. The "misses " were big misses, but I'm very pleased with the two hits. Both are a much higher quality than the traditional dating websites ever provided. So I would say I'm cautiously optimistic! read more

I joined approximately 6 weeks ago .( i did take 2 weeks off.) i have had 2 dates. I'm not sure if they really have a lot of quality men in their database. The girls have been absolutely amazing, very friendly. read more

Camille and Ashley have been very helpful. They make it easier and friendlier. I am having a wonderful time in this new journey!

IJL is the right fit for me. As a recent widow who has not dated in 30 years, I needed a safe and fun environment to move on with my life. Camille and I hit it off right away discussing how their matchmaking works so it was an easy decision for me. Taylor, Ashley and Jolene all have been great supporting me in my dating journey. I look forward to my next matches! read more

I started IJL earlier this year. I have been on 5 or 6 dates and not even close to any kind of match. I paid 4500.00 definitely not worth the time and money. The offered me the ELITE package of 20,000 to 30,000 dollars- I said, "no thank you". I asked the dates if they too were offered the ELITE package- and they were. I would hope people read my message and think again before starting with IJL. I had about three weeks on my contract and left early- I could not continue - such a waste. read more

I did have several conversations with the IJL team about my experience, expectations and level of service. From my experience, it felt as though I was being passed from person to person, I had to tell my preferences to four different people. I was a little surprised they were not included on my profile. Again, my perspective it just seemed like there was very little interest in helping me. When I spoke with the dates I was matched with, their interactions with the team seemed more fun and personal. I did appreciate not having to swipe through endless profiles. The matches were all nice but after match 2,3 &4, I couldn't understand why they selected them. Match 1, 2, &3 basically looked exactly the same, and match 4 was a miss on my preferences. Maybe this service will work for some women and men but it didn't work for me. I cancelled my subscription after a few short months and it's very disappointing. I really hoped this would be a positive experience but it fell short of what Camille told me to execution is services. read more

I was at the Madison location, but they chose to use the Milwaukee location to try to find dates and didn't respect or honor my dealbreaker requests on even the most basic search criteria, like religion. When they were unable to honor what they offered, they refused to provide a refund. read more

Location: Milwaukee Area. The people who work for IJL are sweet and the initial process is throughout. However, paying a lot of money for a dating service up front for 6 months and NOT getting the quality service you paid for is frustrating. I call my matchmaker more times than she calls me, and the last time I've gone on a date was 45 days ago and counting. Save your money elsewhere. read more

Buyer Beware! I paid a $2,300 membership fee in June, plus an additional $95: month and was introduced to four women from The end of June through the end of October. Only one out of the four were within an hour drive of me in Green Bay. I was told verbally by Jade that there were plenty of candidates in my area. There were not! They did offer not to charge me t to GE monthly fee for a while, but I declined in order to cut my losses, save my time, and try the old-fashioned way. At least that way is less frustrating and much less expensive! Waste of money!!! read more

The staff is very friendly. Easy to work with.Taylor has been extremely helpful. One of the best people to work with.

I'm extremely disappointed in the quality and quantity of members, and the responsiveness of the staff. I've been a member for 9 weeks and have only been presented with 4 members. The first was horrendous, one was a nice guy and we met twice before determining we weren't a match, and the other two were painfully introverted and the zoom calls were short and awkward. I have always had to call to provide feedback vs them checking in as stated. I was heavily recruited, and now feel ghosted. It seems that the staff spends all their time recruiting vs matchmaking. I feel like I was subjected to a bait and switch scam. So, so disappointed. Please do not fall for this scam like I did! read more

I regret paying as much as I did. I was not impressed by the six dates I went on in a month and a half. Yes, I could have given it more time but I put my account on hold (a $30/mo. charge to do so) and after much better meet ups with online dating I decided to cancel my IJL membership three months later. I suspect there isn't a good inventory of men for them to work with in the MKE area, and I do not believe they reach out to members on hold status should a suitable match arise. When my membership was on hold I would have gladly changed my status and paid the extra rate/mo if they called me and said "we found a great match for you". It seems like once you join you become a statistic; I didn't find there was any bit of a personalized experience as one would expect with this kind of service. Therefore I found the "matchmaking" advantages as a gimmick. read more

I am very disappointed. After paying a lot of money and an lengthy interview I got like 8 dates, all extremely far from what I told them. They kept saying that they were testing and after few minths I received a call letting me know that the subscription was over and if I wanted to renew it. Lol I highly not recommend this website. They match you with whoever they have, careless of what you ask. read more

Agree with all comments from past reviews. Was a client for 6 months in Madison and met guys in Madison and Milwaukee. What was promised didn't come close to what was delivered. Avoid feeling like you got scammed and save your money. read more

I was very disappointed with my experience with IJL. I paid a lot of money, talked to them every week after a date to say what was good/bad. 90% of the time it was bad. The guys I was set up with weren't anything like I was interested in even though they said there were "lots" of options. I will never suggested this to anyone! read more

As a professional in my 30s, like many, I don't have the luxury of meeting people outside my typical networks. I have relied on IJL to provide high-quality introductions, which have been screened to ensure professionalism, personal success, financial stability, and optimism towards love and life. Emily, Anna and Ari have been lovely to work with. They have connected me with the most compatible clients using their intuition and an in-depth understanding of my relationship goals. Even if they haven't introduced me to "The One" yet, they have still created memorable dating experiences throughout this adventure. If you don't have patience or optimism, IJL is not for you. I went into this journey knowing I needed to be open. I say "open" but by no means does this translate to conceding (Emily and Anna can attest). My list of qualifications--emotionally experienced and financially stable with the same depth and fulfillment needs in a relationship--are not easy qualifications to find from one person in the Milwaukee area. However, the IJL MKE team has bent over backwards to curate successful introductions with partners for whom I'm searching. The rest is up to fate. read more

I totally agree with all the bad reviews that are listed. I had ONE date and called them to let them know I wanted out as I went back to my girlfriend. They refused any type of refund even though I only had ONE DATE! Yes, this group,is a joke. It took three times for their people to get it right once I did get it right. They don't listen and they think they know whatnot want before you even talk it through. So, as one person said earlier.....RUN...RUN FAST AND FAR, FAR AWAY read more

If it was possible to give 0.5 stars, I would I tried this service out because I wanted to settle down at point and it seemed better than trying to browse through thousands of profiles on other dating sites. But I don't know if I have anything good to say about the service. It almost felt like after the first meeting, they pressure you into signing up with them. After that, They did stay in contact with me and set me up with several men who kind of fit the bill of what I wanted not totally. They even had me driving out to Johnson Creek from Milwaukee to meet with someone for like an hour..... I called to cancel after several months because I met someone figuring that they would stop calling me but they don't. They keep on calling every once in a while even when I told them I've met someone and wasn't interested in using the service. They didn't even stop when I told them I was engaged and was going to get married (they even called like 1.5 months before my wedding). Seriously? Me telling you that I am getting married so means I'm not interested in going on any dates with other guys!! I wouldn't recommend this place at all. read more

I cannot warn people enough to stay away from this dating service. First, they will work very hard to get you to sign a contract. I got calls numerous times daily for about 2 weeks, urging me to come in and sign up. I finally went in to meet the gal who'd been inundating me with calls (I incorrectly assumed she'd work that hard for me once I signed up). The meeting was short and consisted of me circling things like "I like to go camping." Once we were done with the meeting, she basically regurgitated the exact qualities I said I wanted and said she had that man as a potential date right now. I took the bait....... ...then came the switch. I got set up on 2 dates initially, neither of which was my type. Worse, they actually possessed qualities I specifically said I did *not* want. But the fact remains, neither was the guy she said she had in mind for me when she was selling me the service. It's been 8 months since then and I've had only 2 other dates. (They don't call me as much as they did *before* I signed the contract.) The third was 5 years older than the max age I gave them. The fourth was actually ok, but we spent the whole date complaining about how terrible IJL is so we didn't really get to know one another all that well ;) I'm sure they just match me with whatever guy they have in their inventory. My biggest concern, which I stated to them in very clear terms, was that they didn't have an inventory of men big enough to ensure I'd find my match. They alleviated those concerns ten-fold. Went so far as to say they have "1000s" of men to choose from. Don't believe it! DO NOT fall for their sales tactics. Do yourself a favor and read the comments on the Chicago Yelp site for IJL. I wish I had. I'd still have that $1,400 in my pocket... or a much better experience to share instead. This was the WORST money I've ever spent. At best, "It's Just Terrible Service," and at worst, "It's Just a Scam." read more

Excellent dating service. Very highly and educated staff that understand how to match people together. Highly recommended and nice experience read more

Well it's been over 4 months since I paid for the service and a monthly fee. 4 dates of which only one came close to fitting the criteria of what I asked for before I signed up. I asked if they had a lot of women available and looking for dates. I was assured that there were a lot of female members who fit my criteria. Not. It was a big lie. I've also had 3 ghost dates. Two canceled while I was driving to meet them and one 3 days before. I'm 55 years old. It shouldn't be this hard to find a date. Save your money. It's a big scam. I've called and texted many times now. It falls on deaf ears. If anyone wants to contact me I'd be glad to tell you about the service I was verbally promised and about the really bad service I got. Kevin Gilmore Boscobel Wisconsin 608 732 3557 Review for the month of August. Month of September to follow. read more

I wish I had done more research before I wasted my $$$$! This has been the worst experience ever! The staff is so unqualified starting with Julie. There is constant turnover and no communication! The men they have set me up are nothing short of desperate. This isn't a match making service it's a SCAM! PLEASE do NOT make the same mistake that I made! read more

I will keep this very short. SAVE YOUR MONEY, DO NOT SIGN UP!!! I used this service for 5 months before I started realizing this company is nothing but a scam. Whoever they "matched" me up ended up cancelling on me hours if not a couple days before. I signed up because I am a busy working professional that doesn't have the time for online dating. Company advertised with a more established and elite dating service with high-class clients. I don't know how other professionals are, but once I have you in my calendar, you are in my calendar. Dates would take on average 7-10 days to set up and cancelled less than 48 hours due to "last minute" scheduling conflicts. read more