For one...girl behind counter is rude and off putting when trying to be polite. Two, prices are an extreme over reach for a medium "specialty" item. Upon receiving pizza I said, "Thank you very much" to said girl. She said nothing and walks away. I get home within two minutes of location. Pizza is drastically soggy!!! Like slime. Thought to myself, "well maybe it'll taste good. Ugh!!! All I could taste was soggy dough, and sauce that may have as well benn ketchup. Couldn't taste cheese, pepperoni, sausage, or anything. I barely was able to taster black olive. Let alone there was to be mushrooms, and green peppers!!! I can only say that a Tatino's frozen at the grocery is 10 times better than the overpriced NOTHING this place puts out. I picked up a slice and everything slid off right back into the box. You're better off with a cheap Caesars pizza! I threw it all out after the first piece. I'd rather settle for cereal!!! By the way...24.60 for what should be critter feed!!! read more

This place is great and the little fella behind the counter knows how to whip up a pizza. Who needs pizza slut or papa slops or doma-blows. This place is the real deal. That's until they fuck up my order though. Hahaha! read more

Ive passed by this place a few times, today I decided to place an order online for pickup... Arrived to pickup my pizza and bottle water.... Paid then was informed my pizza was coming out, was also informed that they didn't have any bottled water....The cashier showed me my pizza, I noticed the extra toppings (mushrooms and spinach) that I didn't order but didn't say anything because I assumed everything else was correct, which it almost was. I went outside to eat my pizza and noticed there were no fresh tomatoes on my pizza, at this point I didn't feel like going back in and waiting for them to prepare another pizza, so I decided to go ahead and eat it..... The pizza was very good, however it wasn't what I ordered. I will return and hopefully next time they get it right read more

See all

Real pizza real ingredients. (F papa Jons) I met the owner owner he opened his first store. Hes really a dedicated guy to his quality. He uses a real oven. The taste of his food is fantastic. Those other places are for the children. This here is for the adults who know and appreciate good tasting pizza. read more

My other half and I had a great Uber Eats experience from this place. We ordered the meat lovers pizza and a strawberry cheesecake slice. Great portion of meat on the pizza, sauce was just right (not overpowering), and the crust was nice and soft. My only complaint was that we didn't order a bigger pizza. We only got the 10 inch personal pie to share, just to try the place. Next time we'll get a bigger one. Not sure if they still do the $13.99 large special advertised two years ago, but if they do I'll be going with that next time, along with some sides and another yummy dessert. read more

Italian Pie - Strawberry cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

See all

Nice nice not bad Good service plus is close to my house lol Nice food Nice place ... read more

So sad... This is how you lose business.... Came here for dinner on Sunday, July 9th... Not sure if this guy is the owner/manager or what of this location, but Louis J the guy at the cash register was just rude, unprofessional and not something I'd expect from Italian Pie. My job spends hundreds caterings pizza from this place every few months and we have been doing this for years. When we order pizzas, we usually order about 6-7 large pies (almost $20 per specialty pizza). My boss, who is part Italian loves their pizza and has got me hooked on it now for the past two years and I have been bragging to a lot of people about how great their pizza is. However, the manager, the guy who wears black athletic shirts and shorts while the rest of the staff dresses professional was just rude. First off, why is the guy dressed in street clothes? When we walked in, no greeting. When I walked to the counter with my family, he said "wait", (he was not evening doing anything) then I kindly asked him if they sold slices, he pointed to the "sign" and said LOOK at the sign... I then placed an order for a few slices of pizza for my young kids and myself and when my wife said what she wanted, he said "I am not finished", then after a few seconds, asked her "what do you want?"... His demeanor was terrible, he definitely did not want to be there. After we started to eat our pizza, he came out and started watching television, while one of the kitchen guys was talking to a friend outside the back door with his t-shirt off. I asked for some water, something they offer at their other locations, but here the guy gestured towards the coolers and said to buy a bottle. I did not get the impression that any patrons were wanted here. As I walked past the manager who was watching television to put my pizza box in the trash (even though we were eating here it was put in a box) and above the trash was a sign to put the boxes above and not to put them in the trash can, which I did read... but before I put it up there this manager guy said "put the box up there"... This is a total 180 degrees difference from the Italian Pie in Dacula. There they are friendly, the employee came to my table and asked if he could cut the pizza slices into smaller bites to make it easier for my son to eat. They put the pizza on a pizza tray, instead of wasting boxes and they provide cups of water. That location they treat you so well, something I love about family owned places... like those in NYC or Chicago... (you can see my review on their page praising them) On a positive note... the lady in the kitchen who brought my family the food was wonderful. She was very polite and friendly. Nevertheless, based on this awful experience, I will never... ever... eat at this location again. My first and last. I'd fire Louis in a second....... [Review #466] (51st Review of 2017) read more

Italian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

See all

Seriously Gross. Do these people know how to make italian food? Ordered a Large Calzone and a Chicken Parm Sub. Calzone was filled with ground beef that looked and felt like boiled meat. Gross, rubbery and tasteless. Pepperoni was sparse. The calzone was Huge, but 80% of it was overcooked chewy tasteless dough. Dough did not rise because it had been stretched too thin causing it to be overcooked, and tough. I could not cut it with a steak knife! Calzones are crescent shaped, this one could have been used to paddle a canoe. It was gross, my dog wouldn't even eat it. Sadly just a year ago this place rocked. The Chicken Parm Sub was Sub-Par as in inedible and tasted nasty and old. NEVER AGAIN! read more

I've been going to the Italian pie franchise for a long time probably over 15 years now. the one in Lawrenceville is terrific the one on Beaver ruin road I will never go again. I ordered three calzones with certain ingredients they made up three strombolis with different ingredients then what I ordered, for 50 bucks I'll take the ride out to Lawrenceville. They also argue with me for what I ordered and my son had been sitting right next to me when I placed the order and they confirmed calzone and they confirmed the ingredients none of the three strombolis had what they were supposed to have and it was supposed to be calzones. The one in Lawrenceville is five star, and worth the drive, never again to Beaver ruin road. read more

The pizzas are delicious and great portions. No matter the size of the pizza pie you feel like you get more for your buck. This is one of my favorite places to order pizza. read more

I ordered a margarita pizza and the first flag was the price difference compared to other Italian pie. Then the dough had no salt. It was so bland and beyond edible. I ordered extra sauce but this was soles and not cooked. It was like a uncooked dough with some attempt at trying something. I paid $20 for something that just was not edible. Very disappointed. I know the owner Raphael but at this location they claimed he was not the owner and they had no idea who he was. Well if that's the case I will never buy there again and recommend you too don't wast your money there. Very bad business to be honest. They should know better. read more

Pizza is absolutely amazing although you need to repeat your order repeatedly to insure they get your order correct !

The chicken vodka pasta is so good here!!! We order it very often. Good portion, with salad, and garlic knots. The wings are also very good!!! This is the best italian pie the food has flavor! Few Gripes: they never give utensils even asked or parmesan cheese. Today they left out my garlic knots read more

I ordered today from door dash Italian pie did not fix my order right at all and the driver gave my food to someone else , it states it comes with tomatoes and lettuce on a cheese steak with mushrooms, onions and peppers, not the case . I will never order from here on a third party app I will face this store head on . Because your not getting what you paid for. Upsetting. read more

I went to Restaurant Depot to pick up 50lbs of onions. I I went to the front of the building where the handicapped spaces were and the they were full of regular cars without stickers. The BMW from Italian Pizza Pie - Lilburn was one of them. I could see there was a woman and child waiting in the car as I approchaed it. By the time I got to the car the man you see carrying the cases saw me taking photos of his car. I told him I was going to call this manager. I was told he was the F-ing manage among many other vulgar things. I tried to call the other four locations they have listed but it seems the Italian Pizza Pie has no management available on weekends. So, that means I will just post the photos here and every other available sites I can. As you can see there is no handicapped sticker or tag on his car and he is carrying those cases just fine on his shoulder. I don't understand why people think that it is okay to park in a handicapped space if you leave people in the car while you go in. Then you have the right to be so vulgar in front of your child when you are caught. read more

See all

This place was amazing. Me and my mom both love this place, and the food here is delicious! The garlic knots are to die for, and the pizza is truly amazing! read more

Recent transplant from NYC to ATL and always on the lookout for some good pizza, I tried this place after someone recommended it to me. Staff was friendly and the pizza is really good, not quite epic Bronx pizza but properly good pizza, I will be back for sure. One request for management, put more garlic and oregano shakers out. read more

I've lived in New jersey and New York for most of my life and coming down to the south where all my friends eat lil ceasars and papa johns exclusively, finding a place like Italian Pie was nothing short of a revelation. The short and sweet of it is this is the best pizza I've hand in Atlanta, hands down, with reasonable prices, and good sandwiches and fries if you're not feeling down for a pie. However this isn't the location that offers tacos and those are pretty good as well if incongruous with the rest of what the menu has to offer. My favorite pizza to get is meatballs, mushrooms, basil, and ricotta, just the right combination of whats good. read more

I've heard the food is good but the service is terrible went there today 08/13/20. Went to pay my friends order but the manager supervisor ate a slice from it..so I asked whats the precentage off of that..and they said 15%..That told me they didn't care....they should have made a fresh one and apologized...my friend showed up when I left no Idea what happened after that. read more

Italian Pie - a sign on the outside of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

See all

First of all. Very late delivery, horrible customer service, offers specials. But won't deliver over 30$ for a pizza. Ordered extra pepperoni, extra cheese, I call back the pizza place and he proceeds to keep lying and telling me theirs double pepperoni on the pizza, and that it's under the cheese. Just looks like a regular pizza. Nothing double about it. And theirs no pepperoni under the cheese, every location but this one is great. And their ranch is alright. Guy likes to get loud on the phone if you say your gonna leave a yelp review, told me to write one so I did, only reason I downloaded yelp read more

First and last time i will ever order here . The pizza was bland and it was an oily mess. The crust was almost burnt and I had barely any sauce on it. I will never order from here again. read more

Great pizza! Nice people working there, wearing masks. I don't live near here but I'll find reasons to come back.

Italian pie is my definitive place to get a GIGANTIC calzone for cheap (15 bucks on uber before fees) that serves 3 (or at least me 3 times) and i have only ever received fantastic customer service from them despite the fact that i oftentimes order it immediately when they open (i work 3rd shift). They always follow my special instructions to the letter and then some and my absolute only complaint is that i cant tip through the ubereats app. OH! I almost forgot, their marinara sauce is PHENOMENAL, its the perfect base for parmesean cheese or red pepper or (in my case) hot sauce. 6 stars. read more

Awesome. Food was so good. You don't get this kind of quality from any other pizza delivery in my area. It beats Pizza Hut, Papa John's, Little Caesars and Domino's by far. More options, better food and they deliver on Saturdays. Restaurant quality delivery without an extra party deliverer. Driver was awesome also. read more

This place is terrible I got a xl pizza and the crust was chewy and burnt my jaw hurt after trying to eat it. I called to speak with a manager to get a new pizza but he refused to do anything about it not even a discount on a future order. I will never go here again. read more

The wings are the bomb I love the wings Pizza great. Customer service outstanding. I will be back check this place out I ordered a Greek salad wings soda and pizza and I am very satisfied read more

I order pizza here often - the pizza's are often larger than the boxes can hold. They are always hot and use fresh ingredients. I must say though, Thursday night I ordered a large with mushrooms and sausage and some wings for pick up. It was raining, so the guy behind the counter brought it out to my car for me (very nice guy). I got home and saw that there was no sausage on the pizza. I called to tell them, and even though the manager was reluctant to do so, the kid that brought the pizza out to me convinced him to replace our pizza and let him deliver it to us. This not only made things right, but proved that they are willing to go the extra bit to make sure the customer is happy. Good job, guys! read more

I ordered cheese bread expecting hot thick gooey garlic cheese bread. I raced back to work ready to eat it while it was hot. I opened the box disappointed to find a cheese pizza with the sauce on the side. Yuck read more

Online and on their coupons said they were closed at 11PM. We tried to call at 10PM to order but they didn't pick up the phone. So we drove there after and they were already closed... We lived about 3mins from the store. read more

BEST PIZZA EVER! Everything they offer is delicious. Especially there Jamaican wings.. great customer service!

I went in to order two slices of Hawaiian w/ Spinach pizza. I thought i would try this place out because it is close to my home. When i received the pizza, it looked like a slice of cheese pizza with toppings just thrown on it. The spinach looked like it just came out of a bag wasn't cooked at all. I asked them to cook the toppings, he told me the reason why it's like that is because i didn't order a whole pizza just the slice. I love pizza and out of all of the years of eating pizza and ordering slices i have never seen it where the toppings are not cooked. I will never eat here again, a total waste of my money! read more

I have eaten at Italian Pizza pie & wings twice after roller skating across the street. Delicios wings and Pizza every time. Small place great taste! read more