Always on point, best customer service ever. 6 stars. Glad this little shop is nearby, makes it an easy choice.

Great food and service. Very friendly neighborhood butcher shop. Meat and chicken are fresh and delicious. They even help you out to the car! Very good prepared foods as well. read more

Visiting family in Islip for the week and stopped in to grab some steaks. This place is an awesome old school butcher shop with high quality meat, and knowledgeable butchers who hand cut steaks. We visit a few times a year, and will definitely be back. read more

Everything here is excellent. It can sometimes be a little expensive, but of course meat costs quite a bit. They're really really great and will work with you to try to give you whatever it is that you think you want, and if you're not sure they help you.Highly recommended! The father and son, who own it, and all their staff are fantastic and super nice. read more

What a gem!! I'm so glad I found this spot, it exceeded all expectations. I came in for some Father's Day recommendations, Peter and his dad could not have been nicer or more helpful. They had a fantastic selection of everything, from meat to some pantry items to even home made blue cheese dressing! The store was so clean and lovely, I wish I could have bought everything. I got pork shoulder and short ribs for my dad, and it was a huge hit!!! We still have a few braciole and burgers to try and can't wait! read more

Islip Meat Mkt - Meat Shops Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Pete and his staff are very knowledgeable on the meat industry. They offer a wide variety of items that are locally sourced and free of antibiotics and hormones. All of the staff was very helpful and although the price was steep it's worth the quality hands-down. Thank you again For all of your help read more

I just had the perfect BBQ with the strip steaks from here. Everyone raved about them. I also bought delicious potato wedges that were a perfect side dish. So sick of bad supermarket meat. Worth the trip read more

I stopped in to pick up a nice steak for my girlfriend Trish the other day. I bought (upon the counter persons suggestion ) a beautiful 1" think cut of wonderfully marblized NY Strip. I told him she likes it medium-rare and he said that on a very hot grill, 3 1/2 minutes on each side. It was so perfect, so juicy and a terrific robust flavor. I refuse to buy beef in a grocery store any more. It's usually a just a waste of money. It's always too tough and it taste like garbage. I find that frequently, it taste's like liver. I always get great advice for cooking there and always know I'm in for a treat when I purchase there. read more

Islip Meat Mkt - Thank you Islip Meat Market! - Meat Shops Near Me - Islip, New York

I am kicking myself for passing by so many times! This place is great. They have everything and do an incredible amount of prep in-house. They dry-age beef in-house and smoke their own bacon, and it is delicious. Plus the staff are knowledgeable, friendly, and easy to talk to. I bought rib eyes and bacon and was very satisfied with both. The bacon was cut way too thin for me though, but I'll ask for thicker next time. Definitely going back. read more

See all

Everyone I know who lives in Islip highly recommends this butcher shop! The owners are so charismatic and polite - they remember their customers by name! The service is always outstanding and the food is DELICIOUS! Their prepared foods are divine and the meat is always so fresh. They also have beef marrow bones for your dogs and will even cut them into smaller pieces for you! I highly recommend this place! read more

Friendly knowledgeable staff and fresh delicious food! My "go to" place when I am cooking for special occasions and when company visits . I also pamper myself with their pre made meals when I need a break from cooking! Check it out once... you will not be disappointed!!! read more

Best of the best staff is awesome and the food is fantastic meats are incredible highly recommended

When your heading home from a long vacation and one of the first things that pop into your head is "hey we can stop off at the meat market" you know you found a really special place. What exactly does one look for in a butcher shop.... 1. Experience (Pete and Pete have many years in the field) 2. Honesty...when talking to Pete on the type of meat he will let you know exactly whats what. 3. Value..yes you are going to pay more than at a super market but you will not get anywhere near the quality of food than at this store. Walking into the shop is like the old tv show, Cheers, as everyone seems to know your name. Smiles all around handshakes or a hug from old friends, how could you not like this place. You feel like family and hear other customers talk about their past meals. The star of the show...the tremendpus meats provided by Islip Meat Market. Variety is here..you need a lean cut..no problem..your watching your weight...he we got some home make chicken burgers...you want top shelf..try the peter luger burgers..and we arent even talking about the beautiful steaks hanging. Its a good thing i live over 40 minutes away otherwise id be a very poor man, one qith a smile though lol. read more

Went in for the first time and was promptly greater by Pat. He was so friendly and knowledgeable, providing us with background on the business as well as many helpful cooking tips. We immediately eyed the short rib in the case, which Pat cut up for us to cook in the crockpot for dinner later that evening. We also tried the sweet and spicy sausages, which come from a 106 year old family recipe. Everything was delicious and was high quality! My whole family loved it and are looking forward to trying other items such as steak or burgers in the near future. I love a local business that makes you feel like your part of their family! read more

See all

Called in an order yesterday for a pickup today could to have been any better and the meat that I bought looks great. Everything was great they are very friendly and helpful. I found a new butcher for the future. read more

Best NY strip steak, I ever had from a butcher. Usually I eat half of my steak and save other half for next day. I ate the entire steak , it was that delicious. Tender and flavorful. read more

A great local meat market! Always have great fresh meats. Always willing to talk to you about how to prepare anything. Peter was very helpful when I went in for duck breast. Highly recommended read more

Outstanding products, a cut above all the rest. The owners Pete & Pete are true gentlemen. Their products are great you get what you pay for. So if you can't cook, buy your items at your local food store. But if you can cook it's worth every penny! read more

I have been passing by this establishment for years and not realizing it was there. Then I was shopping for a nice local Butcher and I came across IMM. Who's j had Great Yelp reviews. I wanted either a rib roast or steak to enjoy with my wife. I met Pete who by the way is the Most Professional,Cordial Gentleman I've come across in retail in a Long Time! Pete took his time to show and explain the different cuts and prices of the Meats I was interested in and MORE!! I finally made a decision on 2 T Bone stakes approx 1-1/2" thick that looked incredible. I explained I couldn't BBQ where I live now and Pete gave me probably the simplest instructions on cooking the steaks on a cast Ironman and then into a super Hot oven for no more than 10mins total and he was on the Freakin $. Thanks Again Pete!! You have a New Customer. They also have Freshly prepared side dishes,homemade salads,Dry Aged Meats and plenty of BBQ sauces,mustards,ketchups and condiments for sale also. But the Best part of the visit was the saw dust On the floor for that Old School Butcher Shop Feel. It brought me back to the the days of going to the butcher with my Grand Parents and Parents. I Highly Recommend trying this Family Owned and Run Business at-least once. I'll Bet like myself you'll Appreciate their Welcomes when Entering and Professional No Attitude Service !!! read more

Good local place for your meat. Been there forever. Smell of the place a little weird, which takes a star away, but it is a good spot. read more

Islip Meat Mkt - The meat from the Islip Meat Market - Meat Shops Near Me - Islip, New York

Loved the curbside pickup. Thank you for your service during this difficult time. Can't wait to order again this week! Loved the gorgonzola, walnut, cranberry salad, the meats and the italian bread. Was craving a sirloin burger and it was delicious! You are a nice addition to Main St.! read more

Stopped in for the first time last week- definitely first of many future visits! Pete was extremely helpful and friendly. I purchased a dry aged T-Bone. I was a little nervous, fearing that I would over cook it, but sticking with Pete's advice it came out perfect! read more

I was looking for a new butcher because my old butcher must have changed owners and went downhill quality wise on their meats. So, I looked online at reviews and decided to go to Islip Meat Market! My gosh, I'm so glad I came here! Pete is just the nicest, most helpful person, and they are all just wonderful to deal with! The meats were exceptional and you can even call in your order and pick it up curb-side if you wanted! I'll definitely be coming back here! I highly recommend this place! Beautiful meats and exceptional customer service! read more

THE BEST! Pete and Pete are great! The quality, service, & prices are just as awesome! The ONLY cold cuts my boys will eat! I love trying their speciality items too. And if you want to get creative and bring your own reusable containers they will do what they can to make sure you are happy!!! Great job guys. Thanks so much for being part of our community! read more

If I could give Pete and Pete more than 5 stars I would. Everything I have purchased has been of excellent quality and butchered to order. The store is beautifully redone and the customer service is EXCELLENT!!! Pete and Pete are incredibly knowledgable about their products and are keeping the old fashioned tradition of the neighbor butcher alive. read more

Just bought some Cowboy Steaks for a bbq at the house. Just moved to the area and this is my 3rd time here. As soon as you walk in the guys are so welcoming and extremely helpful in getting the right cut of meat for you. The pricing is in line with other butchers. Quality exceeds other places. This is the place for fresh cut meats. I'll try other stuff on my return. read more

doesnt get any better than this. peter carries the same quality as your big name steak houses. his other meats are all great and his prepared veggies and salads as well. you get what you pay for! money well spent each week read more