This off-the-beaten path bar and restaurant is tucked away next to Lake Delton with a covered patio…read more(it was February, so we didn't get to enjoy the patio, which looks to have a new outdoor bar this summer). The Green Owl makes their own pizza dough and offered several interesting pizzas. We tried the Mr. Potatoehead (mashed potatoes, rosemary, bacon) and it was really good! Our son RAVED about the lobster mac 'n cheese from the upstairs restaurant and went promptly into a food coma. If you order off the upstairs menu, it will likely come later than anything ordered downstairs, so be patient. :) We were there at a bit after 5 on Valentine's Day and pretty much had our pick of places to sit. About 30 minutes later, a huge group of at least 20 came in and took up several tables. The server had a lot on his hands, but was still really nice about answering questions and bringing us beverages.

Good pizza, glad they are able to have their menu and the menu to the restaurant above. It's nice…read morethat it's also on the water, gives a nice scenery. Good pizza and attentive service. got the white owl added sausage. Nice under crust, would come back again.

Excellent Friday Foods. Really loved the Fish Best Ever. Ham…read moreso tender. Thank You We will be back.

Surprise of a gem and welcome edition to Elroy. Sadly there aren't many options for restaurants in…read moretown. We stopped on the way out of town on a Sunday morning without any real expectations as so so restaurants seem to come and go in Elroy. But... but... this was great experience... coffee was serviceable... Biscuits and Gravy were on point and the star of the show. The single pancake was quite literally much bigger than my head. The Eggs Benedict... Tasty. The serve was also great. When we got there the place was full... only one waitress in sight... but orders were taken quickly and the food came out of the kitchen in a matter of minutes. This is a locals joint... nothing fancy from the outside, but the food is good, prices decent, and service was great!

Great brewery! Lots of activities(shuffleboard, foosball, golf simulator, table games) and seating!…read more Staff was great, our server was very attentive! Pizza was delicious. We ordered 3 large pizzas and they were big and filling, ended up taking one home. Cheese curds were average. Boneless wings were good and the stinging honey garlic sauce was really good! Not too spicy at all.

So lets start with..they were not busy. No one was overwhelmed here. Pizza order took forever…read more pies arrived..not even a little warm. the order was 2.5 pizza and they got one of them wrong. We had waited so long we were NOT going to wait for them to fix it, not on that time line. Margarita thin crust was hands down the worst pizza Ive ever had. flavorless blah etc. Terrible crust. Just. Plain.Bad. The thicker crust did not resemble pizza in any form. It was like a big thick slice of nasty bread. Im not sure if they forgot the sauce, or if it vanished into the bread abyss. Topings were fine. The most average pie you can imagine. We also ordered brisket nachos. Also not hot on arrival. They sat somewhere for a long time because not one chip was crisp. Mushy plate of goo. No accommodation on the bill for late wrong food. The fun part...party of eight or more? Must be one check and 20 percent tip added in automatically.

Blue Gill fish supper was crispy on the outside and flakey inside. Pizza crust was crunchy with…read moredelicious toppings. Beer was cold and tastey! Server was friendly and attentive. Owner brought out the pizza and the cook brought out the fish. Never had a bad experience here.

This place is a hidden gem! Fantastic food and beer! We have been looking for places that aren't…read morejust bar food or frozen pizza components thrown together and disguised as "home made." This is the real deal. Friendly service too! My only suggestion would be to add a kid-friendly pizza. Something much smaller in cheese so 3/4 of it won't end up in a to-go box would be nice. However, I understand if a restaurant has no intention of catering to kids and don't expect everyone to do so. I just know we would be more frequent visitors if options were available.

Returned to the Gem to try another menu item. The place is famous for pizza and it is an out of…read morethis world experience. Today we were surrounded by pizza eaters, everyone happy and smiling. Place has open seating and plenty of TVs. We went for burgers. We had heard good things about burgers, so we dipped our toes into the change pool and gave it a shot. Unfortunately, it was a disappointment. Either we had the wrong day or an inattentive cook. Wifey had the regular burger with a slice of raw and fries. Burger was ordered medium, a little pink showing. I went with the Gem Burger 1/3 pound with all the trimmings - tomato, lettuce, onion, bacon and a slice of pepper jack - and an order of fries. Wifeys burger was well done, even singed black on one side and her fries looked like they were from the end of the bag. All of them were pretty much less than an inch long. My burger was similar, not medium and more on the well side, but my bun was burned. Not just toasted a little extra, I could taste the burned bread. My fries were similar. The Gem has a problem with quality control. All the pizzas that came out looked fantastic, our burgers, not so much. The kicker was the cook came out to get a look at us before the end of the meal. Just a quick look and back to the kitchen. Bottom line .... stick to pizza. I'll never go back for another burger. There are better places in town for a good burger. Recommend that non pizza orders be double checked with good quality standards before leaving the kitchen.

Overall happy with our experience here. Pretty sure the spinach artichoke dip was microwaved to…read moreheat up. But still tasted good. The BBQ chicken pizza was amazing. Definitely more than enough food for 2 people. Prices are reasonable as well. Service was quick. The menu isn't extensive but the things we tried were good. Would definitely consider stopping again.

You get to pick make your own 11 inch pizza for 15$ or make your own salad or Mac n cheese for…read more11-13$. This is one place that does it right from the hard working employees helping their customers to making sure they don't skimp on toppings you want and you can ask for extra toppings at any time. They have all sorts of veggie and meat options to choose from and have an unlimited Amt of options. For 15$ it's a great lunch or dinner option in the area with fresh ingredients and great service! I would def go back. Only drawback is it takes a bit of time for cooking the pizza but that's all part of the process of how you will enjoy it

The concept is good. Pick what you want and they make it. Not too many seats but what was there was…read moreclean. The pizza was decent but the dough was a bit tough to bite through.

You know, there are times that you come back to the familiar, the tried and true. This morning is…read moreone of those mornings. This place has always been consistent with its food and fair. From all the home made dishes to the made from scratch pies. Best place for miles around. Today, Prime with with eggs! Come in and say hi to Shannon and Jim, great people who will steal your heart!

Great spot for breakfast. Friendly people, charming ambience, and just great food. We'll be…read moreregulars from here on out. I had the chicken fired steak and my wife enjoyed raspberry crepes. We will be back! Like a step back in time, in a very good way.

Nice local Italian restaurant with tasty food. Will definitely be going there again soon.read more

Great little place for a cozy pizza dinner. Friendly, attentive staff. Pizza was perfect…read more In from Alabama and was really wanting a good pizza. This place did not disappoint. Really fills you up. Looking for a great local pizza place, this is it.

Just passing by this small town while really hungry when we saw this pizza place and wanted to give…read moreit a try. Most orders are takeout but they had a small seating area. The pizzas are between 15-20$ for a good sized pizza and was pretty average overall. The service was okay and the bad part was loaded breadsticks came with this fake artificial nacho cheese with bacon bits which I would have never expected and was not even able to take one bite of it to enjoy it. Probably wouldn't go back but was very hungry at the time

Pizza was good. Owner was server, and likely chef cook and bottle washer, as they say! He was…read moregreat. Went there for the GF pizza and it was very good. Will return. I little bit . . . okay, more than a little bit . . . of a hole in the wall, as I think there a only three small tables. I'm guessing, it does quite a take-out/delivery business. Not a place for a date night, but worth giving it a try for a bite!

Was having a bad day but was hungry for a good bar burger. Fishy's was the perfect place for me. I…read morehad an awesome CHEDDER BURGER complete with lettuce, tomato & a nice slice of sweet onion. My favorite skinny french fries completed my perfect lunch at a quiet corner table. Oh, Stella on tap was a lovely bonus!

What a great staff. Always a good time great food and a friendly atmosphere priced accordingly and…read moreover all a great stop for lunch or dinner. Trust me you won't be disappointed