Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Hometown Cafe

    4.0 (1 review)

    Hometown Cafe Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Hometown Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Secret Sandwich Society

    Secret Sandwich Society

    4.2(191 reviews)
    51.6 mi
    $$

    I'm camping with a group of friends, and we came here for lunch. We didn't really have any…read moreexpectations, but any we had were blown away! Food arrived very quickly, a little less than 10 minutes for 5 plates of food. Server was nice and helpful. (Witny C.) If you are in Fayetteville or surrounding areas, this is a must go!! Would give this a 20/5 if we could!!

    This sandwich shop which is located by itself on Keller Ave in Fayetteville. It offers street…read moreparking and if the business is busy parking can be a little daunting. The business offers both inside and outside seating, along with bar seating. Upon entering, we met the hostess who seated us at a table comprised of a bench and chairs near the window. The business is adorned with signs that say Rome was not built in a day but it was worth it warning that getting your food may take a few. They are not kidding. It took us over 10 minutes to meet our server and when we did, we ordered and then wait for food to come. In that time drinks ran dry and we rarely saw our server. We started with the feta and honey fried brussel sprouts app for the table. I opted for the Truman (turkey, blue cheese and peach jam), my wife got Korean barbecue wings and fries, my daughter got a kids meal cheeseburger with fries, while my oldest son got a steak sandwich and my youngest son got a chicken sandwich. My wife and a really enjoyed the brussel sprout app which my kids refused to touch. My sandwich was good but a little small and their house made chips are really good but my server never delivered the French onion dip I ordered. My wife was not impressed with her wings but my kids enjoyed their sandwiches. Their house made pickles are really good but we asked for some on the side and never got those either. The only thing that was fast about my experience was the server cashing out my check. It's a good meal but maybe sit at the bar. They seemed to get better service.

    Photos
    Secret Sandwich Society
    Secret Sandwich Society
    Secret Sandwich Society - The rear of the restaurant - not the front!

    See all

    The rear of the restaurant - not the front!

    Tamarack Marketplace - West Virginia-made candy

    Tamarack Marketplace

    3.9(321 reviews)
    37.7 mi
    $$

    We were blown away by how delicious the food was here! Not…read moreonly do you get to walk around and enjoy various local artists work, some artists who are actively working (we got to watch glass blowing), but the food was some of the best we had on our trip! My fiance got the Reuben sandwich and the peanut butter pie. Both were absolutely five star! The Reuben had plenty on it and was nicely balanced. The onion rings felt fresh and were dipped in a really delicious batter. As you can see, the peanut butter pie was huge, creamy, and really delicious with a good balance of cream cheese flavor. The chicken pot pie did not disappoint either! It was a bowl of the creamy chicken mixture with a ridiculous amount of actual chicken in it (both light and dark meat). It was topped by a layer of some flaky and delicious pastry. There was just enough of everything, though. It was a lot to eat, and I was unable to finish it all. The tomato cucumber salad was okay, I tend to not like my vegetables as marinated as they were, but it still had good taste. The biggest disappointment was the creme brulee. Don't get me wrong, it tasted amazing and came out perfectly bruleed! But it was the same price as the peanut butter pie, and was extremely misleading and how much was actually there. When looking at the dish it was served in, the entire bottom. Half of the dish was ceramic with a very narrow full to actually place anything in. In the end, I think I got about half the amount of creme that I expected. It did not feel like it was worth the money, so I would not recommend ordering it. That being said, we will definitely make a point of stopping here to eat on every trip in the future, though we might just both end up with peanut butter pie!!

    Always interesting to see what you can find. Crafts from all over West Virginia. I'm personally…read moreamazed at the prices. Being a woodworker, if I could get these prices for my work I'd be retired. People are all friendly. Restaurant is ok. Overpriced. Definitely somewhere to stop as you go by.

    Photos
    Tamarack Marketplace - Art gallery

    Art gallery

    Tamarack Marketplace - Trout with sweet potato fries and fried green tomatoes

    Trout with sweet potato fries and fried green tomatoes

    Tamarack Marketplace - It's so fancy now - lifewithhanny

    See all

    It's so fancy now - lifewithhanny

    Hometown Cafe - food_court - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...