We purchased four Herman Miller DCM (Dining Chair, Metal Base) Eames dining chairs about 18 months ago. Of the four, two have since broken.
We are an adult household, no undue abuse, and at almost $900 per chair, we expected they would last forever. In fact, we purchased this chair not only because it is elegant and iconic, but because we wanted commercial grade quality. We could easily have gone to the local furniture stores and purchased a run-of-the-mill chair at a quarter of the price, but we wanted top quality as well as first rate design. What we got was chairs that we are afraid to sit on.
To add to the problem, we received a complete lack of support from Herman Miller. In our case, the bolts holding the plywood back sheared off two of the four chairs. We feel the fact that the same failure was evident in 50% of the chairs within weeks of one another, points to defective bolts with compromised shear strength. Herman Miller's response, when asked to replace the bolts on the remaining two, was to refuse to replace two bolts on each of the remaining two chairs--really, how much could that cost? Their explanation was that they didn't want to invalidate their own warranty, as if they had no control over the situation. Their position is that they will replace the bolts as they fail. So apparently, while they don't want to pay for four bolts, they have no problem putting us and our guests at risk. So much for dealing with a top-notch commercial company.
I would recommend that if you want a chair that is iconic and durable you purchase Emeco's original Navy Chair, that is our replacement for nearly $4,000 worth of Herman Miller furniture. read more