Their cheesecakes "may be"heavenly, but their service is some of the worst I've ever had anywhere I've ever gone. I ordered a cheesecake to go and it took so long. I told the manager I was going next-door to check out Kyle's Seaford highly recommended when I came back he had put the cheesecake back in the case? He told me he thought I wasn't coming back? So as they were getting ready to box up my cheesecake, I asked the attendant if you would please cut the cheesecake for me. What I thought was a simple request turned into a huge problem as he told me NO then another woman behind the counter said they don't do it because maybe they wouldn't cut the pieces all exactly equally I told her I don't care if they're equal I just simply wanted the cheesecake cut again they refused? At this I was so upset I said keep your cheesecake and left. read more

We came out of Kyle's and saw the Daily sign say "Datil Pepper Burger Buns". Um, what? We had to go over and check it out. This shop is really small. Only maybe 4 people max can be in there looking around. The Key Lime cheesecakes caught my eye but I was trying to be good. He bought the Burger Buns and a 4-pack of Cranberry Cheesecake Muffins. The muffins were incredible! Even my mother who can be a hard sell said they were "very good". That's high praise. The burger buns are not as spicy as one would think but they added just the right amount of kick and flavor to an otherwise plain bread. Will definitely come back on my next Kyle's trip. read more

See all

Small independent business- inside a produce stand Fantastic Cheesecake and cookies, very reasonably priced read more

This is THE best cheesecake I have ever eaten. Better than Juniors, or any other NY cheesecake, baked or otherwise; even better than my grandma's Italian ricotta cheesecake. So having said that -- obviously there are different types! We all have our favorites. I much prefer my own homemade over my bff's - whose cheesecake tastes like a refrigerator cheesecake, but she claims she makes the best. Don't tell her I said hers is so-so. And when it comes to turn-off-the-oven-and-leave-it for two more hours Italian ricotta six eggs grandma Dearie's, well mine is now the best - my Dad agreed. Grated lemon, ricotta, cream cheese and mascarpone, and dash of almond extract- Zwieback for the hint of a crust- a 4 generation recipe from Naples, adapted by my dad, perfected by moi. But for a creamy, dreamy taste of - well, heaven on earth, nobody does cheesecake like Heavenly!!! I will never bake another! My friend Flossy and I could easily sit down with 2 forks and polish one off in a single sitting. The cakes are pricey, but those who bake using prime ingredients will understand. We tried the raspberry but both of us prefer plain- nothing but cheesecake. They do sell other flavors if you prefer. So good, so dreamy, so creamy, so Heavenly!!! PS they also sell cookies, scones, breads, frozen cheesecakes on a stick coated in chocolate & now individual sizes! It's a tiny shop tucked into a corner of the produce shop on US1 near Fort Mose in the same lot as Kyle's Seafood, so a great shopping stop! Great guys with a great sense of humor. read more

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery - Not huge but so heavenly you don't need a lot! - Bakeries Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The truth is in their name-these cheesecakes ARE heavenly!!! This is our first visit to St. Augustine and I had Heavenly Cheesecakes on my "must try" list for our vacation, and I'm so glad we made it by there. The cheesecakes are so smooth and flavorful, the graham cracker crust is buttery and adds just enough texture to complement the cheesecake filling. We got had the plain, chocolate, and strawberry individual cheesecakes, as well as a few cookies. The chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin cookies tasted homemade and were perfectly baked and very tasty. There were plenty of other goodies to try, like cinnamon rolls that looked to die for, and some turnover type items as well. The owner was helpful and friendly, and he's working some magic with these cheesecakes. 5 stars! read more

I live in Jacksonville and drive to St Augustine once a month just to purchase 4 loaves of their delicious flax bread. I keep one loaf to eat right away and pop the other sliced loaves in the freezer. Once thawed they taste just as good as fresh and I can avoid the bad tasting grocery store breads. read more

Awesome cookies and pastries but the cheesecakes top the charts! Try the Key Lime - you won't be disappointed.

Great cheesecake! Not hard to get to in st augistine, plus other yummy options thanks again ;) Chad

Everything I've purchased has been superb. Highly recommend. Friendly staff . Bonus having fresh vegetable business as well as seafood business next to the bakery. One stop shop. read more

I'm afraid to praise too highly in fear that Walter will run out before I can get there. The cheesecake is the best but the breads are also amazing. read more

We stumbled upon this place 1 day driving home from st augustine. Stopped in and bought a strawberry 6 in. It was delish. Went back before Xmas eve and he was sold out. Seems everyone was smart and pre ordered . So I pre ordered for new years eve . I must say I did have huge sticker shock when it cost me 70 for a 9 inch key lime and a 6 inch white chocolate. They were ready when I arrived on Saturday 12/30. Saved for NYE. They were fantastic. The white chocolate was a little thick but im not sure what I was expecting when I ordered it . Shared with my neighbors they all loved the key lime. He also makes amazing turnovers . read more

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery - Pictured is the white choc raspberry 6 inch cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I found the bakery and was told the canoli were no longer being made. Such a disappointment!

Consistently exceptional products. You've got to try their cheesecake! To some extent they will fulfill special requests with due notice. Don't miss this. read more

Delicious cheesecakes. So many individual flavors to try. I got Key Lime, Strawberry and Heath Bar, all Delicious. The oatmeal raisin cookies were also amazing. The service is quick and personal. The ambiance is that of a small family owned business. read more

My mother in law showed up with half a dozen of these marvelous cinnamon rolls and as someone who has always been obsessed with cinnamon rolls I have to say these are magical fluffy pillows. Now, I have no idea what goes into making a cinnamon roll but this is by far the softest, fluffiest and most delicious one I have ever had the privilege of trying. The icing is very good, perhaps it could be a bit less sweet and it would put this over the top. We are having a family gathering at the end of the month and I already know we will need to place a special order for them. My mother in law has told tales about these perfect cinnamon rolls for a while now but she could never get to the store on time before they all got sold out! We got very lucky this past weekend. I look forward to personally visiting their shop and tasting other items that I am certain will be as glorious as this cinnamon roll. read more

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery - Logo on top of box - Bakeries Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Best cheesecakes ever! Every flavor we have tried has been outstanding. The turnovers, cookies and bread are delicious as well. Highly recommend! read more

The cheesecake is truly Heavenly! The store is extremely small but worth the trouble! Staff was efficient.

Yummy! It was a little hard to find but so worth it! The cheesecake and chocolate chip cookies were fresh and delicious.

The name is no lie! Every bite is a little slice of heaven! You've never tried cheesecake like this. I struggled to decide between cherry, raspberry and heath bar - what a challenge! Then was informed I just missed the fresh peach cheesecake that was heading to Georgia for a competition! Sorry to miss out on that but please let us know if it wins! (As it should). Finally settled on the cherry and it was spectacular- with little pieces of sweet cherries mixed into the cake. Best of all, it's so delightful and satisfying you won't tempted to eat the whole thing at once! So go ahead and splurge with a piece of heaven. read more

Excellent! The cheesecake is better than NY. The key line is awesome but order S they run ours breads are great; hopefully will add crusty breads soon. read more

Stopped in for few items the other day and they were so delicious, that we drove over a hour to come back the next day to get even more goodies. Whether you want muffins, pie filling, cookies, bread, cheesecake or turnovers, this is the place to go! The bakery might be small in size, but the flavors are large. We will be back every time we come to Florida! read more

Best cheesecake around! Cannot say enough great things about our truly locals dessert and cookie spot!

Unassuming little place by the side of the road. Wonderful fresh baked bread and a beautiful selection of cheesecakes including plain, Nutella, Tiramisu, Strawberry, Pineapple, Resses etc. Located next door to two equally amazing "stands" including produce and a fresh fish store. You won't be disappointed. read more

This is a HIDDEN gem in St Augustine. I stumbled upon them since they are next to Kyle's Seafood (another great smell business). I decided to pick up a Blueberry and a Reese's Peanut Butter cup Cheesecake for a last minute dessert and everyone RAVED about the cheesecakes. Not too light, not too heavy, just perfect. The home made Blueberry topping was amazing. I'm definitely going back. Help out this small business because I don't want to lose them!! read more

EXCELLENT. Don't let the hole-in-the-wall appearance fool you; behind the door of this tiny, modest establishment is a MASTER baker. I purchased a 12 inch plain cheesecake for a party and wow, was it a hit. When the hostess finally got around to trying the cake she announced that it was the best cheesecake she had ever tasted in her 68 years. She promptly got up and cut a slice that was almost a quarter of the cake and took it to the kitchen to save for her mother who wasn't able to attend. For the rest of the party, people talked about how I had brought the cheesecake. Needless to say, Heavenly Cheesecakes lives up to it's name! read more

Wonderful assortment of cheesecakes and baked goods in this quaint bakery. The best cheesecakes and you can buy in individual cups for a sampling of different flavors. Never bought anything that wasn't short of superb. Highly recommend! read more

Wonderful cheesecakes, easily best in town. Great prices, the owner is lovely. I've bought around 7 cheesecakes from here since they opened. They sell out quick but that's okay because every flavor is delicious. Call ahead for special order/flavor requests. read more

As always this hidden gem does not disappoint large chocolate chip cookies to die for and everything else he makes love this place

We love this one place! Everything is always fresh. He always has a wonderful selection and new things to try! We love all his pastries, mini cheesecakes, and sour dough! 11/10 every single time, must try! read more

Two years in a row, the key lime cheesecake has been the highlight of our vacation! We tried the blueberry this year and it is wonderful as well. read more

So happy to find that a new bakery opened up next to Kyle's Seafood. We tried the rye bread and banana bread which were great! Definitely worth the stop. Haven't tried the cheesecakes but happy to see he has much more to choose from than the name would suggest. Don't miss this. read more

The bread here has spoiled me completely - it is amazing, I've only tried the flaxseed wheat so far, but he has a variety of options - sourdough, rye, steakhouse white. I seriously can't eat my old favorite breads anymore. And don't forget to pick up a cookie for the road!! He has peanut butter, chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and my personal favorite oatmeal raisin that has an amazing depth of flavor. read more

What a great place...nice owner and uh-mazing baked goods...cheesecakes, danishes, cinnamon rolls are ALL delicious!

Amazing! Best fresh baked goods and service. Cinnamon rolls and key lime cheesecake were fantastic. Must stop here for a treat.

What a delicious place to visit!! We loved the cheesecake - it really is heavenly! We tried the strawberry chocolate - fabulous!! We also loved the perfectly flaky texture of the elephant ears and the sour dough bread was amazing. We enjoyed visiting with the baker too. Great customer service! It is a really tiny place in the middle of a fish market and fresh vegetable market and we almost missed it! So fun! read more

I came here in the middle of January and had an incredible experience. Was in town for my moms 50th birthday and got the turtle cheesecake. He didn't have one in the size I desired so he put the toppings on one for me. Cheesecake was amazing, and so was the experience all together. 10/10 recommend read more