I've been dying to come here ever since ads for this restaurant have been popping up all over my Facebook. All the food pictures kept tempting me until I decided to crawl out of my study cave and try it out.
Not my brightest idea considering today is Father's Day.
Anyways, my boyfriend and I got to Hazel Bar at about 11:15a and there was one large party ordering. I don't know if it was the fact that the party couldn't decide on their food or that the cashier was new but it took forever for that transaction to finish and for us to finally order. This is a "order at the front and then sit down" kinda place (does that have a formal name? I don't know). The cashier appeared to not know the ingredients of the items on the menu which was slightly off putting but I shrugged it off as having to do with her being new.
In the end, we ended up ordering one espresso; a bacon, turkey and Monterey cheese sandwich on baguette, a hazel trio sandwich (that consisted of salami, turkey and ham) with Munster cheese on baguette and to finish a cookie shot with hazelnut ice cream (to go with the theme of the place). All the sandwiches came with chips and water.
The food was great and really what earned the place 4 stars instead of 3. The baguette on both sandwiches was soft without being soggy. The sandwich was flavorful with just a tiny hint of mustard which I like cause it gives it a tiny kick. The chips were meh, just the average kettle cooked bagged chips, nothing to write home about. My boyfriend says the espresso was nice, not too bitter. They don't bring sugar, syrup, napkins or anything to the table so you have to get up to get everything which is a bummer. The cookie shot was exactly that, a cookie shaped into a shot glass lined on the inside with chocolate and filled with ice cream (it can be filled with milk if that's your thing). The cookie was a bit hard to split with a spoon and that had me worried about biting into it but it turned out to be just the perfect hardness to serve as a glass but not so hard that it was impossible to eat. The hazelnut ice cream paired perfectly, not too overpowering but also not so bland that it faded away.
I almost took 2 stars off for the service but I forgave them a star because the barista was so nice. I believe she is the owner cause she went around the restaurant and made sure to speak to all the customers. That being said, the place is small and we (cause some times the smartness takes a holiday) went on Father's Day so the wait was pretty long for our food (over 30 minutes) and I already mentioned that we had to wait forever to order. The place seats about maybe 16 people and that's pushing it. The kitchen from what I can see is tiny as well so don't expect to be in and out quick, especially on weekends. I will give the place kudos for opening on Sundays and for opening on Father's Day. Most small restaurants on the island tend to close on Sunday's so it's always nice to find a new place to eat that opens Sundays.
Decor wise I will say the place is cute with modern chic lighting, menus, tables and chairs but the seats are not comfortable, I am a 5'7" girl and I felt like a sardine trying to fit my average sized legs under the tiny tables.
All in all, I recommend the place, it's got a cozy atmosphere but it's got some improvements to do. I'll probably order to go next time.
P.S. They do accept phone orders for carry out from what I read on the menu! read more