First time here today and got a pepperoni pizza. It's excellent! Best east coast style pizza you can find in the area. I've been pretty disappointed with other local spots and I'm kicking myself for not trying out Hammers sooner. Small little spot with a few chairs. Very friendly owner. Will be back soon! read more

i feel embarrassed that i haven't tried it sooner after having lived here my whole life.... hammer is THE man. 11/10 pizza that tastes just like any OG new york spot, i hope you stay open forever! read more

Great food, great service and great people. It's some of the better tasting pizza that we've had in California. They have a great variety and sides to choose from. read more

Huge 18" pizza! Ordered the Hammers deluxe which is a supreme - all the toppings pizza. $40 which is high coming from AZ but it fed a family of 3 with a huge slice left over. We have several local pizza places in our hometown but my son says this is the best pizza he has ever had! The crust is just right, thin but chewy, lots of toppings and a minimum amount of tomato sauce with a great flavor. The owner was nice enough to take my pickup order right before he closed on Sunday. Excellent pizza after a day at the beach! read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - LARGE slices - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

Stopped by while visiting from LA to SD, amazing pizza and hospitality! Highly recommend read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

The pizza was absolutely amazing. The owner convinced us to share a pizza as they are quite large. I really appreciate his honesty as he could have sold us two pizzas and we would have had leftovers for days. The flavors were amazing and everything was fresh. The crust was crispy and delicious. We definitely will go back. And even tbough we shared we still have enough for lunch tomorrow. A win-win all around! read more

We moved to north county recently and were on the hunt for our new favorite pizza spot. We have been back to Hammer's several times now and every time the pizza is amazing! We get the Hammer's Deluxe and add jalapeños, it is delicious and we always have tons of leftovers for the next day. The parking lot is easy to get into, so you can order ahead and pop right in to grab your pizza to go! The service is quick and the couple people we have talked who work in the place are so friendly. read more

Our experience with Hammer's was pretty good. I liked the crust. As advertised, it's a New York style thin crust, with sauce and a small amount (relative to most) of cheese. The three topping pie I ordered (only size is 18"), came out crispy and ready to go when the guy said it would be done (30 mins.). The place is in a small strip mall. It looked to be a take-out only spot. I don't recall seeing a table. read more

I would consider myself a pizza snob. The pizza is definitely worth it. Flavors were on point and savory. Could tell it was authentic NY style. The cannoli was meh. I'm used to ricotta style filling, but I think this one was made with frosting. A little too sweet for me. Service was quick. Pizza was fresh. Enough pizza for leftovers which is always a win. read more

First time visiting Hammer's Pizza and I'm thoroughly impressed. I've been a loyal Biongiorno's customer for seven years, but recently their quality seemed to decline, so I decided to try something new. Hammer's pizza is absolutely delicious, flavorful and perfectly balanced. I ordered a side of ranch (I'm a big ranch person), but the pizza was so good I didn't even need it. The owner is very friendly, which made the experience even more enjoyable. I'm looking forward to bringing my dad here since he's a fellow pizza lover. This place easily surpasses other local spots like Pizza Port and Corner Pizza. read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

If I want a NY slice, I go here. Mom/pop shop. Nothing fancy inside. It's all about making pizza. The owner is very personable and seems to know the regulars well enough to keep up. These sort of things keep people coming back. Also, because the owner operates it, he gets busy and I'm realizing a little patience and grace can go a long way. Try it out. read more

This was an extremely disappointing experience. You talk a big game about your New York pizza and how fabulous it i, 40 years of pizza making blah blah blah. This area is known for good pizza in this pizza was not.. there's no dining. There's no soda machine and there's no Parmesan cheese.. we asked for cheese to garnish the pizza and we're told that we would be given special cheese that they never give cheese out because the packets are crap and they're always bad which is true. However, the private selection cheese that was given to us in a stamp sized plastic container& was about a teaspoon, and it had mold in it.. We tried the cheesecake, It was mediocre at best. Said it was better than Cheesecake Factory, it was not . It's frozen from a distributor. . It was put in a plastic container frozen. The meatballs tasted manufactured from some frozen food distributor. To say this was a disappointment is an understatement. The phone didn't ring once when we were there at 5 o'clock on Friday, no customers! There are so many fabulous pizza places in Encinitas & Cardiff. This is not one of them! Don't go! read more

Best sauce, best crust, best customer service! I ordered from here 2 times this week because it's just that good.

Definitely the best pizza around. The owner is great. He is a New Yorker for sure and is proud of his product as he should be. Support your locally owned businesses. You'll be glad you did. read more

Went in for the first time about 7:30 on a Tuesday night. The gentleman was gracious and offered to make us a pie even though closing time was soon. It took a few minutes to decide and we chose the Hammer Deluxe. Quite simply, it was one of the best pizzas I've had in a very long time. It's definitely a take-out type establishment, so don't expect comfy tables and chairs, but we improvised and took our Deluxe to Brewer's Tap Room a block or two away and enjoyed sitting outside under a heater while sipping some delicious red blend wine by Los Cuernos, a San Diego winery. Will happily return! read more

Amazing thin crust pizza! What a great find tucked away in our neighborhood ! Loved both the cheese pizza and Hammers deluxe

Nice fella, who had good customer service. The Stromboli was really good and tasty. I got it pepperoni and Italian meatballs. Plus the garlic knots are too heavy on the garlic. Just the right amount of garlic on the knots. Thank You read more

In any beach city, it is almost a given that you will find a number of choices when it comes to pizza - everything from the traditional Neapolitan to those with a unique twist. The city of Encinitas certainly has a myriad of choices. Most of the popular spots have received very good reviews on Yelp. I like Hammer's NY Pizza for its authenticity. There is just something about the beach vibe and enjoying a big slice of a east coast thin crust that always seem to go well together well. Hammer's is a small, take-out only pizza joint that specializes in the famous New York style thin crust pizza with red sauce and Mozzarella cheese. I ordered the Hammer's Deluxe, which is their 18" combination that comes topped with sausage, pepperoni, bell peppers, onions, garlic, mushrooms and olives. The slices are huge! Two of them will make for a hearty meal. A little salty, but not too bad. I would order from here again but maybe just with cheese alone or with pepperoni as the only topping. Sometimes less is more. read more

See all

Pizza is soooo good. First time trying this pizza place and it will be the go to place from now on

The pizza was really good, I can't tell you about customer service cause I always get it delivered but other than that it's amazing Thank you for blessing my tastebuds read more

Harassed and discriminated against by the owner. He kept going on about me needing to speak up when I came in even though the door rang. It was only a second that I put my keys away. He told me four times even though I verbally acknowledging understanding. He would talk over me and didnt care what I had to say. Going on a rant the entire time I was there to pick up and pay for my pizza. I've have never been treated this way before. Only giving one star so I can post this. read more

Wow great pizza and quick. Came in at 7 and they took care of us and the pizza came out great. Well worth getting a NY pizza here! Thank you! read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - Sausage mushroom and half with ricotta and pepperoni as well! - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

See all

We live in Encinitas and decided to try Hammer's after a recent trip to NYC. I will say this pizza hit the mark on everything that's essential in a NY style slice. The dough is crispy yet retains that perfect chew. It's thin crust with little flop, a perfect undercarriage, and fresh delicious toppings. Some of the best we've had in San Diego. Not to mention the owner seems like a great guy and you can tell he cares about his product and customers. Will definitely be returning soon! read more

Had a large 'roni. Nice staff, nice pizza. As desired, crust is thin, and tasty, has some crunch and chew. Very easy parking! Easy to find. I think will ask for a little "extra sauce" next time, or at least some in the side. will also probably try just a fresh slice in the store next time.. the 15 minute drive home probably didn't do our pie any favors. We took it home and added our own freshly grated parmesan and Romano and my own hot chili peppers. read more

Service was fast and friendly. They even called to make sure I knew where to find the place after I was 20 min past my expected pickup time. Crust, sauce, cheese all in great balance. My kids, who have terrible taste and like dominos, and I, who grew up in NY and have high standards, both like this and will prioritize coming back. read more

Quick service friendly staff and delicious pizza. I will definitely order again from Hammer's NY pizza

Still awesome but whole pies only - no more slice only (Thanks Covid-19). Pro-tip - call and pre-order to avoid a wait. Also - no gluten-free pizzas.... read more

Been wanting to try this place for a while. Maybe I got my hopes up too much. They are open 4-8pm and so the hours have not aligned but tonight I finally ordered. So the pizza crust: thin, crisp and seems like sourdough. Might be perfect for many. I was wanting it thicker and softer. The toppings seems average and light on that cheese. Decent value for food. We also got a Caesar salad and cheese sticks. I would go back but it is not a favorite spot. read more

See all

One of the best in Encinitas. Fresh cheese, dough, sauce - tasted like a true New York pizza. Came out quick and was delicious. Highly recommend! read more

This is fantastic pizza! Definitely add this to your list of best New York style pizza in north county. Will definitely be back for more!

Really good NY style pizza! Hit the spot and you can tell they use quality ingredients. Highly recommend this local business. read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - Half cheese half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

I like pizza and this pace has good pizza. They offer a lot of different choices and I am never disappointed.

Pizza was good and authentic NY style pizza... I appreciate that out on the left coast. Owners/ workers were great. I did feel like I needed to take out an early withdrawal on my 401k to pay the bill. Not sure it's worth the prices charged. read more

This is a review I should have written a long time ago, when Hammer's first opened up back in 2015. Long story short, if you want first rate New York style pizza, this is the place. The better known Bronx Pizza in Hillcrest often gets the kudos as being the best pie joint in San Diego, but I would stack Hammer's against that establishment any day. I might add in addition to making a lot of traditional pizzas, Hammer makes the best stromboli you can find in North County. His cheesecake, too (although he doesn't make it), is the real McCoy. One other thing. Hammer does almost exclusively take away (there are a couple of rickety stools), but I beg you not to rob yourself of the pleasure of coming in a little before your order is ready and have a chat with him. The food ain't the only genuine New York experience here. Never at a loss to discuss almost anything, Hammer has got all the outgoing, in-your-face realness of the Big Apple. In this land of the lotus eaters, he is a refreshing change and really makes my day. Highly recommended! read more

I'm one of those, "I'm not from NY but my husband is people". I'm forever being dragged from pizza shop to shop while we seem to search for this "authentic NY style pizza". So now, I get it. Hammers is what the real deal NY pizza is all about. Right down to the shop with no inside tables (one outside) and the owner has even managed to bring his NY attitude with him -- that never hurts the legitimacy of a place like this. Bottom line? The guy knows how to make a NY pie. Thin, no too thin, perfect amount of crust, perfect amount of cheese to topping ratio and wow, it's actually cooked from the center to the crust. You can fold it, hold it, smell the goodness and if you close your eyes while taking a bite -- I almost could hear the cars driving by on the Long Island Expressway, or maybe that was El Camino Real. Don't waste your time at the other shops advertising "Brooklyn or NY Pizza". Want to know what the hype is really about? Stop here first! read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

This store is take out only. The pizza was excellent; I walked in to order and chatted with the owner while he prepared it. Great small local business, you won't be disappointed with his pizzas! read more

Good pizza. For people who like a New York style, thin crust with a dough that's got a good bite to it. It's crisp and holds its own allowing you to eat a pizza the way it's supposed to be. You don't have to babysit it and worry about it giving out and going limp. If you have a good dough, a decent sauce, use good cheese and fresh ingredients . You're golden in my book. These guys nailed it. Keep it simple read more

5 stars for take out. Thin crust deluxe pizza was good. Next time I'd try one of their white or pesto pizzas. This is not a place to dine in. read more

Update #2: Another private nasty-gram from the owner of this business. Told me I was a crybaby and that I'm a self absorbed attention seeker who should "get over it that someone treated me badly." Owner didn't treat me badly until that 2nd message he sent.....well over A MONTH later. In the store, he merely expressed that he was to busy for my business and we left. Angry pizza guy alert! read more

100% New Yawk pizza. Hammer, the owner and cook, is a character. If you don't spend some time talking with him, that's on you. Delicious, fresh, thin crust pizza. Nothing fancy. No goat cheese. No kale. Just straight ahead, thin crust pizza. Small space so best for take out. read more

Hammer's NY Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni. Thin crust. Great flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Encinitas, California

See all