Legit, gourmet pizza. Vastly superior to everything else in the area. The thing that makes this place truly special is the value. You can tell they use high cost ingredients without absurdly up-charging the customer. If you enjoy wine or spirits, you will be hard-pressed to find a better restaurant. Adam, who I think was the manager, was excellent. His knowledge of food and wine was exceptional -- especially his knowledge of bourbon! I cannot recommend this to place enough! I will most certainly return. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff, great atmosphere...will be back soon to try some other pizza options!

Came in on Tuesday and was greeted by a nice high school boy and was astonished by the pizza and service. 5 stars for sure-will he coming back. read more

- On a trip to Milwaukee from Chicago, I stopped by for a late dinner, and I'm so glad I did. The photos I saw online immediately made me crave pizza (which doesn't happen often)--and there were no regrets! - We went with the Margarita pizza our way, with an Italian sausage add-on. It was delicious--crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and perfectly balanced flavors. - The restaurant is in a quaint little town, quiet yet lively for the time of the night. The space is cozy and well-kept, and the walls are lined with an impressive collection of wine (wish I could've sampled a few!). The staff was super friendly and attentive to me and other patrons. Overall, it's a great spot for a relaxed and satisfying meal. read more

Half And Half Pizza - Margarita pizza our way, with an Italian sausage add-on - Pizza Near Me - Lake Bluff, Illinois

My new favorite pizza place in the north shore! Pizza is incredible! Not your American (neither NY nor Chicago) type of pizza. Not greasy, the 30-days fermented dough hold up, light airy and crispy texture. Fresh ingredients toppings they don't skim on kids pizza either! Great wine by the glass menu and love the wine shop concept for some wine shopping afterward. Wine and pizza, what's not to like! read more

See all

After a long Sunday afternoon and evening in Chicago, my family and I wanted dinner on our way back to Wisconsin. None of my bookmarks that were open sounded appealing, and my wife said she was in the mood for pizza, so I did a search for open pizza places close to our route home. Half And Half Pizza looked good and wasn't too far out of the way, so we stopped there. Our order consisted of garlic bread, a half cheese/half pepperoni pizza, and the White As Snow pizza. Garlic bread isn't on their recently revamped menu, but they were willing to make it for us after the breadsticks we saw on their online menu weren't available. I didn't partake cause I wanted to make the sure the kids had enough, but it looked good. The cheese and pepperoni pizza was good. I thought the pepperoni had a light amount of heat in the small bite I tried, but my wife didn't mention it so I may be mistaken. The crust wasn't as charred as a pizza we saw served at another table, so the kids ate it without complains. I enjoyed the White As Snow pizza. There was a good balance between garlic and cheese and I appreciate that there was enough ricotta dolloped on top to spread evenly over the pizza. I went with thin crust and wasn't disappointed in its crispiness. The prices are higher than I'd prefer, but the cute area it's located in looks bougie, so not out of place given the local competition. I don't think I'd stop back with my family because the kids won't eat char on pizza crust and I think we got lucky with the pizza they ate, but I would possibly stop back to get the White As Snow pizza again. read more

See all

This pizza grocery store concept just opened up in Lake Bluff this week. They have a large variety of wine to choose from and a cooler full of beer that you can walk up and choose. My mom and I ordered wine that was very reasonably priced for the area. They forgot that we ordered our drinks and when we reminded them, they apologized and comped all of our drinks. We ordered the Winner and In a tent pizzas. The pizza was great and was made with quality ingredients. The made one of the pizzas wrong so they comped that as well and gave it to us at the end to take home as well which we thought was very nice. We also ordered the beets and meatballs for an appetizer. The place itself gives grab and go wine and beer store that also serves food vibes. They have indoor and outdoor seating which was awesome. The manager said it was the 1st weekend that they were open so they were working out all the kinks and took care of us for all of their missteps. I think this place has a lot of potential because the prices were great, food was good, and the staff was accommodating and helpful. We will be back and we hope that they figure everything out so that they thrive because the location to the downtown is great! read more

See all

we tried half and half pizza this week and had take out of two types: dad's and marguerita my way. 14" size left us plenty of slices for the next day. also checked out their wines, and even though i mourned foxtrot closing...and now selective locations reopening...yay! i have a new wine shop that is close by. a really great wine selection--i drove home with two: a sauvignon blanc and a cab sav. the pizzas were ready for me when i arrived and the layout is clean and bright. cold wines/beer are also available to go. both of our pizzas were thin crust and cooked perfectly; the sauvignon blanc was terrific and the service was great! v good addition to the yummy pizza places we've tried and we will be back. read more

See all

Another great evening sitting outside with great service have a great wine, and great pizza in Lake Bluff. There is nothing like this place anywhere. All high-end ingredients crispy crust great quality sausage and pepperoni Etc. All in a nice quiet relaxed neighborhood setting. Perfect! read more

Best pizza in town - fresh ingredients, amazing crust. And you can't beat the wine list!

Great food and great service! Ordered the margarita pizza with the salt and pepper wings.

Really amazing pizza. Super great service as well. Definitely will be back soon! Cute and clean restaurant, our new favorite spot in the suburbs! read more

The concept and atmosphere is perfect for a casual catchup with friends. You can pick a bottle of wine and enjoy with your pizza. The pizza is light and fun options to choose from. read more

Great pizza, similar to the ones I've had in Naples, Italy. Excellent outdoor dining experience. Ordering from the toast site was very easy.

Delicious pizza. Such great flavor and amazing crust. Our server was awesome. Definitely recommend. read more

Solid pizza & salad, and a beautiful small business Loved the fresh ingredients, and the crispy crust that HELD UP to all those fresh ingredients. We brought our kids in on Valentine's Day. What a pleasant experience!!! Beautiful space too. We will be back! read more

We come here often- great pizza and drink selection! Such a great place to spend an evening, wonderful outdoor and indoor seating. Would definitely recommend to others! read more

This cute little restaurant offers delicious pizza, nice selection of wines and great service.

I was craving some good Italian pizza post race but this place was definitely no where near Italian. Tasted like a frozen pizza and the service wasn't great. The drinks are good which is why it's low mid IMO. read more

First time trying Half & Half - it did not disappoint! The pizza crust is light and buttery. Toppings are creative and delicious. The staff's recommendations were spot on. read more

Half And Half Pizza - No Faith Pizza & Silverado Sauvignon Blanc - Pizza Near Me - Lake Bluff, Illinois

Food is unique and delicious, service is great. Ambience is more modern, still has the classic pizza place Feel to it.

The food was spectacular. We ordered pizzas and artichoke appetizer. The service was first class and we can't wait to come back.

Take away pizza. When it's good it's great but when it's not good it really isn't good. Cheesy pizza bread with zero garlic and way too much red sauce Pizzas were awesome last week but this week just way too much red sauce and it was bitter and too sweet all at the same time. I will try again but I won't be spending $100 next time incase it's wasted. read more

First time trying and we found it to be delicious. 14" was definitely large enough for two hungry people. Ordered an Italian sausage with sweet onions and basil. Everything about this pizza delivered - exceptional sausage, great sauce, the crust has a slight rise to it and makes for enjoyable eating. We loved it. It's well worth the price and can't wait to try more combos. The only tiniest critique would be it wasn't as hot as it could be, although it was ready at appointed time. Maybe a way to keep the pizza warm prior to pick up? We so enjoyed the deliciousness of this great pizza, that we shrugged off that one detail. Can't wait for the next one! read more

I was extremely excited to try this new pizza place when I got a letter in the mail, and I was not disappointed. The pizza was phenomenal, and the crust was one of the best pizza crusts I have ever had. However, the reason that I give it 3 stars is because of the service. It was TERRIBLE! We arrived at 5:54 for our 6pm order pickup, and the lady behind the counter went to go find it. She came back a full 3 mins later with the news that it was not ready. She then read us back the order wrong, and looked it up on the computer. She then went to the warmer after having us tell her the name on the order for the third time and handed us the wrong order saying "here you go, this is your order". One look at the label and receipt showed that it WASNT EVEN CLOSE TO MY ORDER. She then consulted the computer and said the order would be ready in 20 MINUTES. I have no idea what she was looking at but our order appeared moments later. To top it off, she was wearing AirPods while working. Maybe if she stopped her music she could have heard us better or even gotten the correct order instead of being wrong. Good pizza but bad service. read more

Half And Half Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Lake Bluff, Illinois

See all

We ordered a margarita pizza. The worst. It's not like it looks in the picture. It looks ghetto when they bring it to you. Never again. Will I order the worst? read more

Great pizza and apps! We've been here twice with our kids and Matt's always been awesome. Definitely recommend for eat in or carry out.

What a great first experience. And you can pick your wine next door. Matt made the experience fun with outstanding service too.

First visit to Half and Half. Matt our server was outstanding. The friendliest service with great menu suggestions. Food was delicious and a great value. Highly recommend. read more

Amazing pizza! Probably the best I've had since we left NJ. Fresh ingredients and amazing crust. We'll be back with friends!

The apps are awesome and the pizza is the best! We ate in. Nice music, great atmosphere! Matt was the waiter and he was so great!

Had a wonderful meal here tonight. Matt was amazing, food stupendous. we'll be back!!

World class pizza and service ! Highly recommend to anyone - bring family and friends! Excellent atmosphere!

Great pizza! What can I say? It has very good quality ingredient. Good char. Good execution!

waited an hour for raw dough. poor quality cheese. one bite and dumped rest in the garbage. read more

Half And Half Pizza - WIted an hour for raw dough. Directly in garbage. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Bluff, Illinois