Coldcutt sandwiches are FIRE here. Me and my girl stopped here for some sandwiches, and they were…read moreoff the hook . Love the taste and huge portions. Nice store clerks here and friendly people. Can't wait to shop here again.

Nice little shop, tucked away on a corner in Montclair. Owner and his assistant are very friendly…read more They do a Wednesday night dinner that I've had twice now. Both meals were terrific. I think this will be my regular Wednesday meals. They have many other things to choose from as well. Their chicken sausage is out of sight. I urge anyone to check them out.

Wow what a cute shop! I came here to get Christmas gifts and the owners/employees were so friendly…read moreand encourage us to try as many olive oils/balsamic vinegars as we wanted. Everything was really good but our favorite was the citrus habanero olive oil and the raspberry balsamic vinegar. The chili pepper olive oil and the lemon cucumber balsamic were also really good. They were also very kind and wrapped the gifts and made baskets for us. Definitely the place to go if you're looking for a nice hostess gift or a unique gift.

Food and service were great! Will definitely be back. Especially nice for outdoor dining.read more

I've been a customer of Rosario's Deli for a long time and used to love their sandwiches, which…read moremakes this especially disappointing. Over the past five months, the quality and portion sizes have steadily declined. The last eight sandwiches I've ordered have consistently had very little meat and barely any toppings. For example, the Patriot sandwich had only about four slices of roast beef. The chicken cutlet sandwiches came with just two small strips of chicken cutlet and very few peppers or other toppings. Each visit seems to have fewer ingredients than the last. I understand that food costs have gone up, but charging the same prices while significantly reducing the portions isn't acceptable. Rosario's used to be one of my favorite delis, but after eight disappointing orders in a row, I can't justify coming back. I hope they return to the quality and generosity that made them so popular in the first place. JenV

Normally a reliable deli for sandwiches, but super disappointed with my recent sandwich purchases…read morethere. Ordered a chicken cutlet sub, and basically got a half piece of chicken cutlet cut up for the entire sandwich (see picture). With the amount of solid deli options in the area, I'll probably start getting my sandwiches elsewhere.

What is going on here?…read more I ordered the First Avenue sandwich -- a cheesesteak with bacon and sautéed onions -- and it was an absolute salt bomb. Not "well-seasoned." Not "bold." Just aggressively, overwhelmingly salty. Every bite felt like a dare. Between the bacon and the cheesesteak, it was sodium stacked on sodium with zero balance. I genuinely couldn't finish it after two bites. At that point, it felt like I had just thrown money straight into the trash. The sausage stuffed peppers were decent...thankfully. Not mind-blowing, but at least edible and competently made, which is more than I can say for the sandwich. They saved me from a starving morning. Extremely disappointed. I'm all for flavor, but when the dominant note is "are they trying to preserve this for winter?" something has gone very wrong in the kitchen.

Yum! So delish! I loved everything I had here! From the sandwiches to the salads, everything is…read morefresh and tasty! The customer service is great too! You can stop by and pick something up to go or order it for pick up!

Local staple. My go-to Italian deli for a nice chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella w…read more Balsamic sandwich. Owner is nice, ambiance is deli vibes

This is the best Italian store in an area with plenty of excellent Italian stores. Meats are…read morebeautiful--whether you're getting a sandwich or entrees. An amazing selection of other Italian foods and other items. They have amazing Mozzarella, for example. The owners and staff are so accommodating. I feel like I have been transported to Italy when I visit (and afterwards).

Better or at least equal to Katz without the ridiculous lines. My wife and I shared a fat pastrami…read moresandwich ($18). They also sell pastrami by the pound ($30). I don't think I'll ever go back to Katz unless it's with friends who are tourists.

Because it's "kosher style" and not kosher, the pastrami just wasn't up to par from what you can…read moreget in an old school NYC deli. I was hoping to recreate that experience in the suburbs. Pastrami is a pretty expensive meat, but it was also drier and tougher than I was expecting for the price. I think it was more like corned beef than traditional pastrami. I usually don't do any sauce, but I laid on the mustard just to make a moister sandwich. It was overall pretty disappointing. The employees were nice, but there isn't really any dine in option. We customized it to put on club bread (for an upcharge). Mustard was on side to add at leisure. It was hot out of the bag. It came with pickles and cole slaw. It was overall just a pretty disappointing version of pastrami. In these cases, actual kosher is worth sticking to.

The best place for a cold cuts, very delicious and made with care. I highly recommend it.read more

Stepping into this deli is like stepping into the 80s/90s…read more. they have a little bit of everything and everything is priced great. I wanted a sandwich on rye but they didn't have any so the lady opened a bag of rye they were selling just to make my sandwich. My only issue is they don't have sandwich topping like lettuce tomato and mayo. Not a problem because I live close and just went home to add it. I tried their homemade goose liver liverworst. It was amazing and she loaded the bread up with it. Almost too much. We also tried their donuts and the soup. All were very good. Can't wait to go back.