I walked in at 9.10pm. I've ordered and paid at 9.15pm. I've been told it had to be To-Go. I said I would like to eat it here don't you guys close at 10pm? She didn't make a comment. At 9.35pm they served my food in To-Go pizza boxes and they told me to eat outside. I said "I will be eating inside and I'm not here to spend $50 to eat out a Pizza box" they chose to refund me my money at 9.37pm. You tell me if they did not earned this review. Hopefully the owner will read this. The lady up front is very rude read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Review. Bad service - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

I just called to order and the lady on the phone started yelling at me I asked for a small Caesar salad and she said they have one then she told me the total and it was 10 so I asked why a small salad is so much then that's when she started yelling saying i never asked for a small and they don't have small salads and I asked for the manager because she had just yelled at me she said she was the manager! YIKES Angelina's is right down the street. They are always amazing!! read more

We ordered from our hotel for delivery on a Sunday night. It took about and hour. The pizza was not cut very well and being in a hotel there really wasn't anyway to cut it. We did get a couple of plates which was nice. The pizza crust was a little soggy. It did have a variety of veggies which was nice. It was a decent pizza. read more

The pizza and wings are absolutely delish. The service not as friendly, but there is a very gentle cleaning lady who is absolutely great and friendly read more

Wicked good pizza and great service! We both tried a special pizza of the day - Habanero Mango w Chicken. It was available by the slice. Flavor was on point and came out with perfectly crispy crust. Thanks guys! We Will be back! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Mango Habanero for the Win - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

I'm from NEW YORK . There's nothing GOOD about these FELLAS .. save your money Pizza sauce is kinda watery and the crust taste like something you buy in the freezer section. The service was nothing impressive and kinda of rude. Like I said save your money .. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Slice Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

See all

I can't even justify not giving them 5 stars. This is a new build restaurant, so it's ample and clean. The way it works is, you order off the menu at the cash register then you sit wherever and they bring you the food. You pick your drinks off the fridge. I got wine from a small bottle and was totally surprised when they brought me a really nice glass to put it into. The provide complimentary garlic knots that are fluffy, garlicky and oily. What else could you ask for?? We (as in me) ordered the lobster bisque and it was so good, but my son and husband kept taking it from me because it was so good-so I guess we all ordered it. I ordered the eggplant rolatini and it came with soup and pasta ( which was a nice surprise). I asked for an vinaigrette and they provided perfection (a small little bottle with olive oil and balsamic vinegar! Score!! My husband had the vegetarian Stromboli, and he decided to commit sacrilege and added steak. The Stromboli came with a tomato sauce that I wanted to eat like soup! OMG!! That's sauce is LIFE!! My son had the spaghetti and meatballs, which is perfect for him, but I would have opted for a more decadent option like lasagna, and I tried to convince him just so I could try it, but he wouldn't budge. Good thing too, he ate a ton of it and it was huge I didn't think a little guy could put down that much food. read more

See all

I created an account just to write a review of this pizza. My girlfriend and I lifted up the box lid and both started laughing at this thing... it's not pizza. It's garbage. Both the bbq chicken and buffalo chicken. Worst pizza I've ever had. The place was half full of people. Plenty of kitchen staff. Manager was on site and keeping the garbage pies moving quickly... Seriously, look at the pictures of these pizzas! The people of Ft. Pierce need to be liberated from this awful pizza regime. The goodfellas would roll over in their grave. Someone needs to get whacked. Ground chicken on pizza? I wouldn't feed this to my dog. David Portnoy where you at? read more

Goodfella's Pizza - This is a buffalo chicken pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

See all

Good food, good service & delivery service. Been eating here for 15 years! Pizza is awesome.

Stopped in after the beach and it was delicious! The meat lovers stromboli is overflowing with meats and cheese and it's cooked perfectly sometimes i find them a little too crispy on the outside but this one was perfect! It was more than enough for one person read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Homemade Garlic Knots (6) - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

See all

After two hours and $40 I haven't received any food. So I have been robbed. They are too busy to answer the phone

The pizza was mediocre. The pizza dough felt undercooked in some parts and the cheese kept sliding off. The pineapple was very skimpy. It was edible but not something I would get again. read more

I live on the island and there are not too many fast food type places to eat. I de IDES to try this brand new location last night. The inside is new , clean and very nicely done. There menu ranges from wings, all kinds of pizza, and all kinds of pasta and sauces. I tried the traditional large cheese pizza with extra cheese. The pizza was very good. I do wish it did have more (extra cheese) but I guess that's relevant to what they consider normal amount of cheese. It was nicely cooked no big dark air type bubble in pizza. The sauce was lights (which I prefer) and not sweet (which I also prefer). The dough was very thin (such I also prefer). All in all for 20 dollars I got a large extra cheese? Pizza. I would definitely be back to try a few of their other dishes. Nice new addition to the Island. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Large pizza with extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Holy shit. This pizza is as good tasting as it looks. It was the steak pizza and I'm in love. Some serious NY style goodness. Order and forgetta'about-it. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Steak pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

My friend and I decided to have lunch here and it was the first time we'd dined there. The front of the house is modern looking and extremely clean. We had to go to the counter to order and even their showcase was so appealing. Cheira took our order and while I was ordering I had a chance to look at the kitchen and work area which were both immaculate. I ordered the sausage and peppers entree and my friend order eggplant parmigiana. With salad and garlic knots included plus a soft drink the cost was 19.80 in total! Suffice to say the meal turned out to be really good and the wonderful Aurelia serving our meal was caring, professional and a pleasure to have met. Muchas gracias Aurelia. I will definitely return. Try it, you'll like it! read more

Great new location near the fort pierce inlet. Enjoy the pizza and the service. New and clean read more

From NJ where pizza is king! I only get my pizza from here ! Amazingly clean. New location. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Burnt pizza + begging for a tip on wrong order = I d rather just call Papa Johns next time This place has lousy customer service and even worse pizza. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Blah - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

See all

There was a baby roach inside the box pizza was decent till i found it super disappointing

I am not from this area and I travel here every year just to have a pizza from good fellas. I have never been to a place that offers the service the cleanliness and the professionalism that goodfella does! keep up the good work and god bless you guys! nick padron read more

Good selection.. I'm spoiled from my hometown pizza but this was definitely good and easy to find something tasty on their menu

If I could give this place negative stars, I would. When we called to tell them, they said they didn't work when we got it so, it's not their problem. The lady actually hung up on me. Their pizza is sloppy and wet at the bottom. Really gross. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Plastic in pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Don't order the pasta or meat balls took only a couple of bites, horrible. No flavor and I don't know what filler that put in the meatballs. Salad was good. Staff friendly read more

Mediocre food and a late delivery based on what the Slice app quotes. We ordered a large meat lovers and a dozen garlic knots. The food wasn't even warm when it arrived. You know how a pizza looks after cooling down with dull looking cheese... this is what our pie looked like. The garlic knots were cold too. There was a time when Goodfellas was the dominant pizza king on Hutchinson Island... seems those days are long gone. When we shared that we ordered pizza from Goodfellas, the year round locals we were with simply said "Good luck!" and told us the 2 places they prefer... my source has been here in Ft Pierce since 1984, who was also a long time fan of the old Goodfellas. Even with it being cold, it's still one of the best tasting sauces and crusts around. I've been spending my entire summer on this island for 20 years. For 20 years I always look forward to having Goodfellas whether it's delivered or pickup. I talk about it before our trip, as it's usually soooo good! The sad truth is their 20 year streak is over. It was a good run Goodfellas. I always enjoyed everything about your pizza. You really only have 2 choices... keep being mediocre and watch the other pizza places take your business or stop settling for second place. Goodfellas has/had one of the best pizzas I've ever had, including pizza I've eaten in NYC, all over Italy and all over the US. This was seriously one of the best pizzas I've ever had back in the day and I've had more than most. For selfish reasons, I sincerely hope that you Goodfellas get your gremlins worked out. I love your pizza pie. read more

Stop in for a slice now and then. Ordered two slices to go and got home to this mess. Check your box before you leave. Nice people but need to set higher expectations. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Who stacks pizza like this? - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

I ordered a meat lovers pizza, I paid for a meat lovers but on my side I didn't want sausage, olives , bacon on my side . They delivered the pizza and didn't put any sausage or bacon on other side . Called them up and they said the guys said he did . They'll remake one but I had waited over an hour for this one . She was very rude and told me oh well nothing I can do . This place has good be down hill!!! Use to love their customer service. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - You can see on the other half no sausage no bacon . No parmesan or hot peppers - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Call consistent and delicious when ordering direct! Grub Hub will mess your order up and not send any special instructions. Call and pick it up or done in for the best quality! Great pizza and subs- have not tried pasta dishes yet. Slice specials too! read more

Ordered Saturday night was so awesome decided to order Sunday night got hung up because we didn't know the specials and we weren't quick enough for the girl who answered the phone she hung up on us and told us to call back when we were ready then the pizza got here an hour and 40 minutes later was not hot the wings were burnt the pizza was nothing like what it was the night before ! On the ticket I had I was a new customer which we are not a little bit more courtesy when you answer the phone and you're representing a company and not so rude ! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Zero stars! I was told 20 minutes on an order, showed up 25 minutes later and only the wings were ready. I ordered a 12 piece wing and a Stromboli. I got 10 wings. I waited in the parking lot for 25 minutes. My Stromboli was delivered and it was undercooked. When I called, the manager's remedy was that I bring the food back and they would redo my order. Really dude? He did offer to deliver it, but at this point I was an hour and a half out from when I ordered. I was starving, and did not agree to a new order being delivered. His rebuttal was ma'am I'm trying to fix this what do you want? I simply replied better service. .... And may have said mean things as I was hanging up. read more

The best Ny style pizza I have ever had in Florida. And their specialty pizzas are out of this world! Chicken Florentine pizza is the best!!

This place has not been the same since the pandemic. They have continued to use this as an excuse to be as much as an hour late blaming not enough help as to everything else not acceptable. Called after they were an hour late last week and got were short of drivers for an excuse. Called again this week because they do have good food but made sure they were not gonna be an hour late and they were only 15 minutes late food arrived cold and they raise their prices so much it's ridiculous. I am going to try Angelina's and pie hole and see if they do any better read more

I really love Goodfellas pizza. But I just ordered 13 pizzas and no one even offered to help me carry them out. I would think after spending nearly $300 on just pizza summer would've offered me assistance to get them to my car. read more

We wanted pizza and pie hole was closed so we decided to God fathers. We have been there before but the last time we went. I found a fly in the pizza. Besides the fly the pizza was alright. read more

On 08/31/24 my wife and I went into the goodfellas off of seaway drive in Fort Pierce, Florida. We ordered a medium pizza with light sauce and mushrooms and garlic knots with extra Garlic. We waited for over 40 minutes for the order to be prepared and when it was finally ready we tried to find a seat in the restaurant. There were no clean tables to sit anywhere. We notified an associate and they refused to come around to clean a table for us. We went down the road to a local beach to try to eat there. We found a picnic table and took our first look at our food. The pizza looked absolutely disgusting and was flooded with sauce making it inedible for the both of us. There was so much sauce that you could not even lift up a slice without the cheese and toppings sliding off. Also to add to our dissatisfaction the garlic knots didn't even have extra garlic like we requested and paid extra for. We decided to head back to the restaurant to simply request a refund for this inedible food but when we got there the associate absolutely refused to give us a refund despite looking at all the food and seeing a clear discrepancy between what we had and what was ordered on the receipt. In the end we left with no food and no refund. This is very poor customer service practices and we will not be eating at this establishment anymore. read more

I ordered a Buffalo chicken pizza. On the online menu it says it has sweet BBQ sauce. I called the location and was told that was an error on the menu and they were sorry. I ordered 2 pizza. The other was mediocre at best. The Buffalo chicken was horrible. No sauce only shredded chicken and cheese. I ordered based on the description on menu, they acknowledged but not their problem I guess. Not even what they could do to make it right. Have been ordering here for 3 years. I will be taking my business elsewhere. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

I'm new to the area and have tried a few pizza places. I had a pizza or two from this Goodfellas and thought it was good. Thin crust, cooked well and the right amount of toppings. Last night, I tried a Margarita, as well as the standard Pepperoni for my son. So, someone didn't care what they made. Management clearly failed as well... I got thIs, blob of undercooked thick crust pizza... dry, pale and just awful. So, Margarita is a classic pie, and there's lots pictures that professionals could look at, right? Well, whoever made this didn't look at any picture nor did they give a shit about their work. It was 19.99 btw. Medium! I'm done with Goodfellas. I called, and they were busy and somewhat disinterested. Hey, Management... ever heard of customer acquisition? I cut off the plate dough and attached the p read more

I eat there all the time and have never had a bad meal or service. I get pizzas delivered all over Fort Pierce and never had problems with late or bad deliveries. I think the people that leave negative reviews might want to look in the mirror to find the problem read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Best meatball sub around - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

A group of women from stuart spent the night in ft pierce Monday night.we ordered pizza.when we got it back to the room it was completely black on the bottom and limp.the toppings were even inedible.we called they said they do not give refunds even though we sent them pictures of the disgusting pizza.they said they could make a new one but we did not want to take a chance.that one should have not left the kitchen .and to top it off they wanted us to come pick the new one up.disgusting food poor business communication with the customer and would not recommend it to anyone read more

Cold pizza Sandy soda can as if it had been rolling around in a floorboard delivery address is only a block away pizza was an hour and a half late no refund was given and was hung up on I order from this place three or four times a week that stops today you've lost a good customer good thing there's another pizza place a block down the road read more

Damn good pizza. Definitely need to try. Very good atmosphere and food. Homemade crust the marina is best I've ever had.​