Good Fellos is a great spot for a nice evening dinner. The food is delicious and worth the price. The service was impeccable. I appreciate the servers that checked in with myself and my date at the time. Good Fellos has a calm low lit ambiance that makes it easy for people to relax and enjoy their meals. Family friendly as well. I would highly recommend this Resturant for special occasion meals! read more

Good Fellos - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

Cozy local spot. Not too big and not too busy on a Saturday night. Went with a large group and service was really good and fast. Very attentive to refilling drinks and checking on us. Food came out fast. Cocktails all very good. Pizzas are personal sized but still took some home! Truffle fries are to die for!! We got some desserts to go and they were all yummy: coconut cake, chocolate cake, lemon pie. read more

ORDER THE CHEESY GARLIC BREAD ============================ I have been to Goodfellos a few times as it's my son and daughter-in-law's favorite place near Watertown. We rented an Airbnb in Sackets Harbor for a week which was really nice. It's right on Main Street. The War of 1812 is a huge historical event that took place in Sackets Harbor and the battlefield nearby. My in-laws drove in from Rhose Island to dine with us, so I made a reservation a few weeks in advance. We had a nice table in the back room that is surrounded by glass garage doors. I really loved that room. Everything was great from beginning to end. I could live off the cheesy garlic bread, but we ordered that as an appetizer for our table. I tried to get my son to go one more time, but his new roommates cooked us an amazing home cooked meal that night. My husband and I split the Margherita pizza and a Caesar salad. We loved that. I liked their house cabernet. My son wasn't thrilled with the ravioli, so I am sure he won't order that again. Everyone else loved their meals and the service was great. read more

See all

Ample portions whether you get pasta or pizza for food- delicious!!! Good table wines for $9/ bottle on Wednesday. Service was attentive, fast and friendly. Outdoor seating was great for a party of 6. Although the place was crowded, it did not deter from the service or ambiance. Fun an friendly. Fettuccine bolognese- wow! read more

Pretty decent. There is a little room for improvement when looking at quality, service, price, and taste, but overall, a very good experience. Dinner here has been our new years tradition for the last 16 years. read more

Enjoyed our dinner after a long day in the sun at a lacrosse tournament. Not the prime option with Italian after a long hot day, but my son jumped on the opportunity as they had a gluten free pizza option. I had the calzone which was absolutely delicious. My son said the pizza was fantastic. And my husband got the ziti which he said was 'meh'. The restaurant was very busy on a Saturday evening which meant some slow service, however with some good beverages the wait was ok. The service was very friendly. If we are ever back in the area, I'd definitely visit again - the calzone was that good!! read more

See all

What a great find, for us. Taking a trip from Lake George through the Adirondack Mountains to Watertown, NY, we were left with nothing but chain restaurants to choose from. We decided we had enough time until 9/10pm, when everything closes, so we looked for our closest option by the water and that was Sackets Harbor. After looking at all of the choices, we chose Goodfellos, and took the risk to eat Italian food away from where we live (Long Island/NYC... home of Italian food). Well, Goodfellos was GREAT! THE chicken parm was just about the best I've ever had. It was a big thick juicy cutlet good perfectly inside and out. The sauce was great and they cheese was just enough... they didn't drown it, like most places do. Their side pasta w/vodka sauce was nice and light and delicious. My wife has their artichoke, shrimp, scallop, pasta dish, which was over good, but there was too much herb taste in the white sauce and they also served it where this dish was like a puddle. Still, the taste overall was good. Just need to layoff the "thyme" which we believe was the overpowering taste. Their Tiramisu was huge and fantastic. They also had a great and inexpensive bottle of red wine C&B Cab. Great experience, with wonderful service and great atmosphere. Dining in and out available and a full bar. Great Sinatra music playing in the background as well. If we are back in the area again, my go to place for sure. read more

Good Fellos - Chicken Parm and Shrimp, Scallop, Artichoke pasta dish. - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

Went here for our anniversary dinner on a Friday night. Very tiny waiting area but wait was only 10min without a reservation. Food was absolutely DELICIOUS and ambiance was great. We will definitely be back again to work our way through the menu! read more

See all

Nice place. Cozy. Service was very good. Lasagna not so good, almost no sauce, so salty almost not edible.

The food is extremely expensive. Our bill was over 100.00 for pizza, bruschetta, salad, and drinks. The service is great. Ambiance is beyond awful. The restaurant is very crowded, noisy, and difficult to talk with the person you are with and the waiter. We left with our pizzas because we couldn't take it anymore. I think they need a section for adults only so couples can eat is peace with less loud noise. It would also help if the seats were further apart from each other instead of packed so tightly. We go there about once every two years and get reminded there's is no place like home!!!!!! read more

Their menu offers a large variety of dishes that you rarely find in other local Italian restaurants. I typically try something I haven't had before and I have never been disappointed. We frequently have guests from out of state and out of country and this is always on our list of places to take them. Highly recommended. read more

Had reservations for 7. They were already out of the special. The food came out at 830 and was Not Tasty. Very disappointed their food has gone down hill. At least the wait personnel are pleasant and doing their best. read more

It is pricey but the food is great. The food is really fresh and the service is great. Always an upbeat atmostphere but can get crowded on the weekends so make a reservation. Also, I typically get my meals customized because I have diabetes and high cholesterol, so I will get the Chicken Saltimboca without butter or pasta and its still delicious! I will substitute the pasta for broccoli and spinach. They are very accomodating. It is also nice to be near the water for a walk after dinner! Thank you! read more

Super excited to try this place but kind of disappointed with the service! Our server Alice walked past maybe 5-6 time with out checking in, then we had to wait another 10-15 min just for the check while she continued helping the tables around us. Food was good tho read more

It's a good pizza--small and crispy. I like the chicken BBQ. The Price range is $20-40 per person.

We ordered fried calamari and bruschetta for appetizers. Calzone and the spicy pasta with calabrian chili peppers. the bruschetta was good, the pasta was good. The calzone was also good but the very small of oil and basil it came with wasn't pleasant and didn't have the consistency or taste of pesto. The Calamari was an insult to the table. a handful of barely breaded calamari rings on top of a bed of maybe fried zucchini and pepperoncini? It was hard to tell what it was. But the take away is that the plate mostly consisted of anything but calamari. Which is a different from the last time we visited and were actually served fried calamari and the plate only had calamari on it. tentacles and all. The 6$ Merlot (per glass) they have on their house menu was surprisingly good. It was Copper ridge Wineries. If you like Merlot, I do suggest it. My wife ordered an espresso martini that was really good Then we tried to order an aperol spritz. No.. not the aperol sour they have on the menu. Last time we came they made a spritz first us no problem. so we asked if we could order an aperol spritz. I said "an aperol spritz" while emphasizing the spritz part so there was no confusion on what drink we were asking for. She brings the wrong drink anyways. We don't correct it, we drink it anyways but we were not happy with it. I wanted a beer with my calzone so I asked what beers they have on tap and she said "well you can see them over there" while pointing across the room at an awkward angle. You couldn't read anything. So I asked if instead of me walking across the room if she could maybe just tell me what they had and she begrudgingly did. The beer was fine but was first served to the table next to us... which will come up again later in this review We also had their tiramisu which was actually, surprisingly, really good and authentic. Which leads to my next issue. Our bill was totally butchered wrong. Of all stuff I just mentioned that we ordered in this review, they basically started mixing orders from our table and the table next to us. . which.. odd thing to complain about right? was actually 5-10$ cheaper than what our bill should have been. What made me feel bad was we were trying to pay the correct amount and the lady told us that someone messed it up and it's cheaper for us so we should just be ok with it so the young girl who did it doesn't get in trouble. Fine. But the young couple on their first date sitting next to us that (maybe didn't look at the bill that much?) paid for some of our food and drinks. It doesn't sit right with me. Which is why days later, even overlooking the food inconsistencies, and the lack of attention to get our order correct (the drink issue) I am writing this review. With that said, I would still suggest trying this restaurant. I feel like a lot of what I experienced was a one off on a busy night. Well except that calamari, that's just read more

The food was superb and I asked for a recommendation and the server was honest and made a recommendation. Great drink menu . Parking maybe tricky depending time of day you'll find it but may need to walk a bit but it's a lovely area to do so. I'm excited to go back try more read more

Good Fellos - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

It was a Monday night end of April. We were seated in front by the open front door & it was a little chilly so I asked for a different table, it wasn't busy so there were other open tables. I think we started our dinner off on the wrong foot asking for that. Our server was just eh whatever, what do you want, no list of the specials. She didn't want to be there. We have been there many times & will go back but it was probably the most disappointing experiences we have had there. Food was good, but server was not. read more

Great food and great service!! Everything was fresh and hot! The building was beautiful and loved the area read more

Good Fellos - Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

We drive an hour each way just to eat here. I've never had a bad meal, the staff and food is incredible.

Pretentious, narcissistic and overly obnoxious this is where the new rich boating crowd meets the senior NCOs & Junior officer corps of Ft. Drum. Service is awful. Food can be decent but over priced. Wine list probably the best north of Syracuse NY. Good luck getting served. Ownership has changed hands several times and it's living on prior reputation. read more

My husband and I visited Goodfellos for the first time in about 15 years. It seems that they know what they do well and keep adding more good things! The wood fired pizza is still a sure thing but the menu now features many classic Italian dishes. We weren't super hungry so we opted to share a salad (Pear & Rocket) and a pizza (Old School) and, of course, a bottle of chianti. The salad could have easily fed 3 people. Our waitress brought us fresh bread and dipping oil even though we ordered pizza rather than dinner entrées. She said, "bread goes so good with salad." She won us over right then and there. The pizza was perfection. The crust light and crispy and the toppings perfectly portioned. The only thing I'd change is the bench seating. It's a bit high off the floor. And the salad dressing needs something a little brighter added in or maybe just a lighter portion. Otherwise, it was relaxing, enjoyable and delicious. We will definitely return...sooner than 15 years! read more

See all

My friends and I decided to go to Goodfellos, after it was recommended to us by a coworker. Right when we walked into the restaurant, we were greeted by numerous friendly waitresses who wanted to know if we were being helped. Because we were a party of 8, it took a few minutes for the staff to ready the table. Upon being seated, our drink and food order were taken down and placed. Even though the restaurant is a bit pricey, I decided to try a few different items. I ordered the Smoked Duck Wonton, Pork Milanese, and the Tiramisu. All three plates were very tasty. My friends also enjoyed their meals as well. I think that this place is good if you are going on a date, or having a nice friendly or family gathering. read more

See all

i called to make a reservation and the girl was a BITCCCCH i'll never go there she hung up on me and i wasn't done talking ... Horrible.

The food is always good, but you better come dressed to the nines. If you're not dressed to THEIR standards they seat you in a corner or away from places where you can be seen. I've worn nice dress shorts and a polo, I've been with people in nice sweaters and outfits. and no matter what we get seated out of the way and forgotten about. They are very discriminatory to you based on what you wear. As I stated before the food is good but the service is very bad unless you are dressed to their standards. Never had good service there especially for the price. read more

What a great gem of a restaurant! We stopped in for lunch on a Saturday afternoon and enjoyed the AMAZING truffle fries with garlic aioli (truly delicious --we had to get extra sides of the garlic-rich aioli) as well as the Bianco, Bianco, Bianco pizza and a classic Margarita pizza. All were excellent . The crust was a bit different than what I'm used to from a wood-fired grill, but not in a bad way, The drinks were excellent: nice, strong Cosmos and a very tasty twist on an espresso martini (The Full Throttle). The ambience is warm and cozy and the service was excellent. Highly recommend! read more

Parking: adequate although confusing Ambience: typical bar/italian trattoria, albeit more rustic. Confusing with the white tablecloths because the rest of the experience wasn't indicative of white-tablecloth dining Drinks: only had a local wine which was great, can't comment on any cocktails Service: mediocre. Although my server was initially friendly, she failed to catch errors in our orders and also failed to convey messages from the kitchen in a timely manner so we couldn't make educated decisions about the meal. Also when we called out the errors, she became terse and less friendly. Food: Locals really hyped this place up but I'm glad I went in with low expectations. Honestly, this is probably the best you're going to get within a two-hr drive. I had the Crostacei allá Good Fellos as the server indicated this would be one of, if not the lightest pasta and it was described as a lemon in white wine Demi-glacé. The artichokes hearts were unacceptably hard, I literally couldn't bite through anything but the heart itself and had to forgo most of them. It was missing the sundried tomatoes entirely. It was definitely not a light lemon and wine sauce, it was more of a light Tuscan cream sauce with no hint of lemon. Although admittedly, the flavor was good and I probably would've enjoyed it if I was expecting a cream sauce. read more

Good Fellos - Crostacei allá Good Fellos, with the sundried tomatoes mysteriously missing. - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

My favorite place to eat in sackets! Awesome, thin crust pizza and great salads. They usually have great specials too. It's also a great spot to visit in the winter because they put out the best Christmas decorations, not too much or too tacky either. Service is good. read more

While on vacation we ordered 2 Supreme pizzas, they were delicious! Just know this is not a "regular" pizzeria style pizza if that's what you're looking for. read more

We were staying in Sacketts Harbor for a weekend getaway for the July 4th weekend and decided to try Goodfellos on a Friday night for dinner after seeing all the rave reviews. The restaurant had a weird smell when we entered, and there were fruit flies flying around everywhere inside. There's a fine bar area and cute little half booths running along the wall. The service was ok. While it was efficient, I didn't appreciate the waitress taking our app plate away while having a conversation with the next table. For apps we got the crab cakes. It was ok. It was not bad by any means, but really nothing mind blowing. The sauce was really good, it had a tangy flavor profile and really lifted the whole dish. The thing that brought the dish down was the size of the cakes relative to what we paid. We paid $16 for 2 crab cakes that are barely an inch thick and a little bigger than a quarter. For entree I got the featured duck dish which was 2 duck legs with an orange glaze and veggies. My bf got the Crostacei alla Good Fellos which consisted of sauteed jump shrimp, sea scallops and white win demi-glace service over cappellini pasta. The duck was ok. It was tender, but in a mushy way. There was no texture in the meat, was it old?? And where is the orange glaze? I didn't taste any of it?? Instead it was smothered in sort of gravy which was ultimately flat in flavor. The veggies were so boring I don't remember what they were until I looked at the pictures. The one thing was there was a lot of duck but for the price of $35+ I expected more flavor. My bf's pasta was even worse. He literally got 2 shrimps and 2 scallops! The scallops were the size of a quarter! There wasn't even that much pasta either. For $26, give the guy some more seafood please! To top off the price, the pasta tasted like nothing. The shrimp was cooked ok but by no means were they "jumbo" and the scallops were so overcooked they were not charred anymore, they just turned brown and had a stringy texture. The one redeeming thing was that the pasta was cooked correctly. We are more than willing to pay for quality food but the bill was way too much for what we got. I think we made wrong choices by not going for the pizzas but please don't call yourself an "Italian" bistro if your pasta dish tasted like nothing. read more

See all

Was visiting Watertown after recently moving away. Goodfellos is ALWAYS a must as it never disappoints. We called in to be placed on the waitlist as the wait was about 45 minutes. The phone line was busy so I imagine they had multiple to go orders and people calling in at once. This is a pizza and wine bar! Once we arrived, I checked in to let them know we were here and gave my number where they would contact me to let me know the table was ready. Inside was packed from wall to wall. The bar was full, barely any standing room for those waiting, and so the tables were full. They have outside dining when the weather is nice but it's January in the North Country so you know what that means. Once seated, our waiter was nice, accommodating, and very energetic. He brought waters for the table (party of 3). For starters we ordered, Classic Salad for 2 and Garlic Cheese Bread. Ordered my son kids cheese pizza, waiter gave him crackers for the wait which he demolished. The salad is always fresh and the dressing is light but just enough. The cheese bread is crispy crunchy but ooo sooooo gooey cheesey. They specialize in brick ovens so super plus. For dinner, I had the shrimp and garlic pizza with a white base sauce! I am bot a traditional pizza sauce pizza eater! Also got the Buffalo chicken supreme pizza! Listen these pizzas are to die for. The ingredients are fresh and the pizza crust is cooked to perfection. This is always a must visit when in town and I'll be back! Like I mentioned, up top, WINE BAR so of course wine was had ! CHEERS!! read more

See all

A group of friends and I were getting together for our yearly birthday dinner...it was Friday June 9th...there were 5 of us and we sat on the patio. Prior, we wanted to have a couple drinks so we were early....the bar was busy as all the seats were taken as to be expected. I offered to grab the first round....as i tried to find an opening between 2 people which is awkward enough, i tried desparately to get the attention of either bartender...I understand it was busy but at the time the bartenders didnt seem to be actively serving anyone, so after standing there for about a minute with no acknowkedgement I raised my hand with my card to maybe get her attention and said " excuse me" now here is the kicker ....she was standing right in front of me.....she didn't even look up to see if anyone needed anything...but then turned around, fiddled with some wine glasses as she proceeded to chit chat with the other bartender who wasn't paying any attention either. At this point, I'm trying like hell to make eye contact with either of them, still kinda waving my hand up a little, watching them talk to eachother. I am certain I was annoying the hell out of the couple in front of me....I have been in the industry for 30 plus years so i know how not to be overly abnoxscious when trying to get the bartenders attention. Ten minutes went by and not 1 time did I recieve any acknowledgement....at that time, other than the people sitting at the bar I was litteraly the only person standing up needing a drink. I was very annoyed, finally I walked to the other end of the bar where the server station was ( which I know all staff hates) and asked the bartender for some drinks. 5 minutes later my other friend arrives and the sane thing happened when she tried. I would really advise the bartenders to pay attention to the surroundings and maybe do a little less talking to eachother. just moved back to the area and I had not been to sackets in years.....the food was great and our server was fantastic and I wish I could Remember her name but we were the group that had the custom cake that said " fabulous and 50". She was awesome so ty for giving us a great dining experience....bartenders.....you need some work read more

Good Fellos - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

Service was good and the atmosphere is nice with a pleasant view of downtown. But honestly the food was nothing spectacular, and was very expensive. The pizza was cracker like , small , & just didn't wow me. This was my first time in New York so I guess I was expecting to be wowed by my first New York pizza. The best thing was the tiramisu. Don't skip that! Overall after hearing such great things about this place I was kind of disappointed. The pasta dish portions were extremely generous so definitely could share. read more

I got the "Pollo alla Francese" based on the waitresses opinion and it was terrible. I've been to places where this price reflects fresh pasta and this place was NOT fresh pasta at all. The dish lacked salt in all Components. Maybe I'm just use to California where Italian restaurants are taken seriously. The noodles were obviously store bought. The sauce was extremely watery to the point that you couldn't even taste the bitterness of the capers. I should have just ordered pizza. I'm assuming all the pasta dishes are just as bad. If you're not going to use fresh pasta, atleast make sure your sauces are on point. It's safe to say I won't be back here nor recommend too others. UPDATE: Just threw up. I imagine it's from from the chicken since it's the only thing that I'd assume would cause me to throw up. Terrible night. -$100+$50 tip. What a waste. read more

Always excellent food and service here. We usually on Wine Wednesday's ($2 house glasses and $8 house bottles of wine) and while that means usually a wait for a table, the service and food is always very good for how busy they are. Pizzas always cooked to perfection with lots of good ingredients, and pasta dishes are great too. Various specials every day of the week that are worth considering as well. A must stop if you're spending time in Sackets Harbor ! read more

2 nd time here and still really good Italian food , very good service(Alica), reasonable price

Excellent service, food and vibe. $8 bottle for their house wine Wednesday night! The salads, appetizers and pizza were all excellent.

Way overpriced! I had dinner with a group of friends on a week night. My dinner alone was just over $60! I had a salad, entree, and glass of wine. Nothing fancy or special about my meal. There is no justification for these prices in Jefferson County, NY. I've had better meals at Pete's, right in the city, and have paid much less. read more

Yummy wood fired pizza. Bolognese pizza had perfect amount of meat. Even better flavor the next day for breakfast. read more

Good Fellos - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

I have been dining here for 13 years and something has changed. The food was "ok" and similar but not the same. The pizza dough was under proved and flat. Desserts were as cold as hell and disappointing ,after we had to ask for them. Entires meal was poorly timed overall and the server distant and terse. Not a great vibe. I miss the former management and Chad. read more