Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Godfathers Pizza - Cayuga

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Godfathers Pizza - Cayuga Photos

    More like Godfathers Pizza - Cayuga

    Recommended Reviews - Godfathers Pizza - Cayuga

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 101 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Pizza Guru's

    Pizza Guru's

    4.0(4 reviews)
    71.1 km

    Ownership recently changed. Re-opened on May 1, 2026. Will re-eview as soon as we have enough…read moreinfo on current offerings. We ordered take out tonight, and there were some differences. First, the look of the pizzeria has improved greatly. From a fresh paint job inside and out, to new windows in the front, to a re-do of the layout, the place looks refreshed and inviting. There are two tables for eating in. There are some difference with the new owners. We wanted a small pizza, but they were sold out (because the demand from the first two days of being open again was so great). We were thinking small and large pizzas would be the same size as before, but the large pizza we got was a 16" diam., as opposed to the old 12". We also ordered an order of wings (10, the same as before), and asked for medium sauce on the side. The pizza sauce was sweeter than the former owners', so those who like the sweeter sauce that most Western New York pizzerias offer will enjoy that. We prefer a less sweet sauce, but this sauce was fine. We asked for light sauce, and there was still plenty of sauce. The pepperoni is now smaller, more "cup" pepperoni, but not as small as most that is offered in the region. The sweet peppers were pre-cooked before being cooked on the pizza, which is okay, but we prefer ours to be uncooked before being put on pizza. The dough was slightly thicker than before, and seemed tough when cutting slices, but it didn't chew tough. The pepperoni and peppers were generous. The cost was higher than before, but considering it is a larger pizza and probably chicken prices have increased dramatically in the period they've been closed, $46.10 probably wasn't out of line. We will certainly be back for more, and intend on trying much of their menu. It is good to have a local pizzeria once again.

    New owners are killing it! The prices are great, everything is fresh and put together well, and the…read moreemployees are knowledgeable and friendly. Definitely 5 all around.

    Photos
    Pizza Guru's
    Pizza Guru's
    Pizza Guru's

    See all

    Fattie G's Pizzeria

    Fattie G's Pizzeria

    4.5(12 reviews)
    74.5 km

    Fast delivery, reasonable prices, steak sub with mushrooms and sweet peppers with provolone cheese…read more Slightly oily. Nice size and will have half for lunch tomorrow. Also ordered ham and turkey sub with provolone cheese another Nice size sub. Wish a menu was available.

    So, we came in today, 7/18, while traveling to take a break and ordered a 12" pizza, a small sub…read moreand bang bang shrimp. No one was in the shop. To go orders were moved in and out quickly. We got there at 6p and received our order at 6:56. Unacceptable and never again. Cost us over an hour and a half of our trip time. Food was ok but definitely not worth getting off the interstate for. UPDATE: This is the owner's response. "Tony Griffin I apologize for that. I wish you would've spoke to me before you posted a yelp review just saying and if you would've talked to me beforehand, and if I knew what was going on for I was in and out I probably would've gave all the food to you for nothing" And my reply was: Gordon Sheffer Thanks for replying. I understand things can get busy, but nearly an hour wait with no explanation, especially when no one else was dining in, just isn't acceptable -- and it's not on me to chase down the owner to make that right. You were the one that brought our food out. I asked the young man at the register if there was an issue with our food and he acted lost. I shared my honest experience so others can decide if it's worth their time. Hopefully the feedback helps.

    Photos
    Fattie G's Pizzeria
    Fattie G's Pizzeria
    Fattie G's Pizzeria - Steak sub with mushrooms and sweet peppers and provolone cheese.  Very good dinner

    See all

    Steak sub with mushrooms and sweet peppers and provolone cheese. Very good dinner

    Godfathers Pizza - Cayuga - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...