Well what a let down. From the 'Fresh from the cardboard box' tiramisu to the food service grade sauce and toppings made in the 'ultra exclusive' blodgett oven, this pizza is on par with any random bowling alley, and that might be a stretch. Now, in fairness, considering there is literally no other good pizza for miles, I guess this gets an extra star. I guess. So disappointed. I've never had a saltier pizza in my life. Utterly inedible. read more

Very good local pizza. Thin crust. Very nice. We will definitely be back next time we're in town. read more

Everything was excellent! Kind service and tasty, affordable sandwiches for a beach sunset dinner! read more

You never disappoint when we order your pizzas. Everyone enjoyed them! Ordered 5 large, delicious!!!

We ordered a small cheese pizza and a meatball sub. The food was awesome. It's not a place for fine dining, but they do have excellent food. Prices were decent and it's a small place so I support local businesses read more

Great football pizza. Very greasy and needed some more sauce. The crust was great just too floppy for my liking. read more

Geraldi's - Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Englewood, Florida

See all

Great pizza!! Stopped in after our day at the beach and got 2 personal pizzas to go.. they were delicious! Best pizza I've had in a while. Definitely recommend!! read more

Geraldi's - Pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Englewood, Florida

Great pizza and nice little place to visit. Owner who was hard at work was a gentleman and his wife was also hard at work.

Geraldi's pizza is delicious! We had the Pesto Veggie (added ricotta to it) and built our own, both were amazing. The large pizzas are huge, great amount of food for the price. The Geraldi's were both so nice when we picked up our food. It's clear they are hard working people who care about their business. Definitely come here for some amazing pizza. We will be back next time we're in Manasota! read more

Geraldi's - Pesto Veggie - Pizza Near Me - Englewood, Florida

See all

Pizza is amazing!! Service is good. Just pizza, no frills, but Sao good. Carry out only.

The food was very authentic delicious and big proportions. The people were nice and friendly. The restaurant was carry out only.

Good take out food quick friendly service will order food again to take out no dine in available

Pizza was okay just not very impressed. It worked for the moment and that's where they have you. Close to the beach easy in and out. Worker and owner were very very nice. Yes I'd go back just wouldn't run out of my way for it. I rank it a 6.6 one bite everyone knows the rules. read more

Pizza is fine, but I love the owners and it's always fun chatting with them and the other customers.

The Pizzas are Great and the subs have delicious white bread that are wider than other sub shops. Price at Manasota Key very reasonable a much better value than the expensive nearby restaurants. Husband and wife very friendly. PS there is no outside seating as listed probably due to the last hurricane. The public beach across the street has benches and shading from Gazebos on the wooden walkway. read more

Excellent sauce and service - perfect for lunch or dinner pizza. Ft myers location Bell tower

We're from PA and we're pizza snobs. I REALLY did not want to eat pizza down here... I was positive we wouldn't get anything good. I was wrong. The sauce is a tiny bit heavy on the oregano, but the heartburn will be worth it. Cheese was awesome and it was cooked perfectly. read more

Best pizza around! It doesn't have a sit down eating area, it's a takeout place. Always friendly and fast.

Excellent customer service and amazing pizza! Their white pizza is really awesome with mushrooms on it. We also had one of their specialty pizzas. Both were very hot with a superb crust and ingredients. read more

Excellent pizza. Piping hot. Thin crust with light sauce. The husband and wife were both super nice and welcoming. Don't let the outside fool you the service and pizza were great. We will be back again. read more

Made to order Pizzas and Italian food. Small family run business. Love the pizza and garlic bread. Large salads.

This pizza is amazing...the best crust and crumbly sausage! The white pizza is also a must! I like mine with spinach, mushrooms & garlic! And my husband red sauce with pepperoni, sausage & onion! Not to be missed! read more

Geraldi's - two pizzas on a table - Pizza Near Me - Englewood, Florida

Pizza is delicious! Traditional thin crust Italian pizza. Perfect amount of sauce and toppings.

Pizza are large and great quality. We have always encountered a very friendly staff. We love coming here.

Be prepared to wait. This is a small primarily To go place.we ordered a large sausage and pepperoni and a medium pepperoni pizza. They were both good albeit they were very greasy. Be prepared to wipe it off when you get it. We ordered at 7:05 and went to pick it up at 7:30. When we arrived we were told it wouldn't Be ready till 8:15. Once we got it it was hot but a tad bit soggy. All in all it was ok and I would most likely try it again. read more

Geraldi's - Sausage and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Englewood, Florida

City girl, visiting the beach. To be fair, I haven't found a restaurant in the area I will eat at again (my mom lives here). But I don't know how one makes bad pizza. Same for mozzarella sticks... You just throw some frozen ones in the fryer. I feel bad being less than complimentary, but this is meant to be a warning for more foodie types (though my really not picky husband concurs). I'll keep trying to find a place to get meals when we visit. read more

Overall average pizza taste, it's very pricey . Costed me almost $50 for just two large boxes if you want a better pizza get Pizza Hut or dominoes to be honest read more

Great pizza delivered poolside to where I was staying. I loved it hot or cold (the next morning)

Great pizza! Very convenient if you are staying on Manasota Key. They were friendly and informative about things to do in the area.

It doesn't look like much from the street (the sign is half broken) and inside is very much a small mom and pop, but the pizza is quite good! We grabbed takeout to enjoy a sunset pizza picnic on the beach and between the pizza and the gorgeous view, it was probably the best meal of the trip! In addition to the pepperoni pizza we tried the garlic bread, spaghetti with meatballs and the mozzarella sticks. I would skip the mozz sticks next time (they are just frozen ones). The spaghetti was very simple but pretty good - the meatballs were a tad too done. The pizza was the star and we ended up having it one more time before our trip was over. read more

Very solid pizza. We only have a few choices given the current environment. The folks were very busy given it is all carry out.

My friends and I were in town for spring break and wanted to grab a quick bite to eat after a long day at the beach. We had seen Geraldi's on the way in and decided to stop in. The inside is very small and you can see the pizza being made right there. We ordered a large cheese pizza, an order of spaghetti, and an order of garlic bread to share among the 5 of us. Unfortunately, they do not provide cups of water so we had to purchase bottled beverages there. We took a seat on their outdoor patio after ordering. The staff was very friendly. The food came out fresh and hot. Everything was amazing. The pizza was authentic Italian style with great sauce and incredible crust. It reminded me of some of my favorite Italian pizza parlors in the NJ/NY area. We devoured all of it within minutes and had a great time. Plus, since we split the food, it ended up being really cheap for all of us! Would definitely recommend. read more

This is excellent pizza. Enjoyed the chewy thinner crust. Glad we stopped here. Very friendly service.

Chicago gal. Ordered the thin crust. Requested extra crispy and it came soggy, not enough sauce and just bland. The mozzarella sticks were like frozen mozzarella sticks that you just pop in the microwave. Very disappointed. :( read more

Crispy and hot ! Really good pizza great to order to pick up or delivery. If you want to eat outside that's pretty much the only seating but that is more then enough. Definitely recommend this place! read more

Great place to get take out they only have outdoor seating. We ordered the Mama Mia pizza , anti pasta salad & garden salad. We went back again just to get the take out anti pasta salad . read more

Fantastic pizza! Very fresh ingredients and really good house salad and dressings. We are from new jersey and own an Italian restaurant so we know food-- try this place! read more

This is our go to pizza joint on every visit to Englewood. We usually get it delivered to our hotel, it's always on time if not earlier than she quotes, hot, and yummy! The meatballs are heaven, the lasagna is super good as well! It's a mom and pop place that will not kiss your .... But they will make your belly super happy!!!!!! read more

Sadly, pizza was one of the worst I have had. Dry crust, non existent sauce, and bland cheese. $2.50 for a small slice, not worth it if you ask me. Asked for a cup of water to take a pill and the server tried to upsell me to a bottled water. I asked if there was a problem with their tap water and she said no, they just don't have any cups. After begging for anything to put a little water in for me to take a pill one of the other workers gave me a 4oz condiment container full of water. That left a bad taste in my mouth, so to speak, and the pizza didn't help. I won't be going back again. read more

I had someone tell me the pizza was not very good here, and boy were they wrong. We got a half pepperoni half meatball and it was amazing. Great pizza! read more