Approximately three months into our summer 2012 Genesis Growers CSA membership, I can report that the quality of the fruits and vegetables we have received from GG has been very high. The sweet corn, in particular, was excellent, and the watermelon we received was perhaps the best I have ever tasted. Additionally, our pick-up location is an easy 10-minute drive from home, and it has been rewarding for us to consume locally raised organic food while supporting the efforts of a farmer who has chosen to earn her living by providing healthy produce to Chicago-area residents.
With that said, however, we have decided not to renew our membership with GG for 2013.
Having worked previously with an outstanding CSA in Wisconsin (Two Onion Farm), we expected 1). that our substantial GG CSA investment would essentially comprise our vegetable budget for this summer and fall, and that, 2). given the vagaries of farming, we would sometimes encounter less appetizing produce items which we could choose to embrace as envelop-pushing meal-planning opportunities.
While GG has met our expectations on point 2 - we have twice enjoyed a delicious new recipe for baked kohlrabi gratin with dill, for example - we have been repeatedly disappointed on point 1. Despite the wide array of vegetables listed in the GG Crop Chart, which we consulted before joining the CSA, our boxes have been consistently short on basic summer dinner vegetables. We have received little or none, for example, of nourishing staples such as green beans, salad greens, Swiss chard, or broccoli, and have relied almost entirely this summer on grocery store purchases of essentials like tomatoes, lettuce, and carrots.
At the other extreme, our GG boxes have provided us with an over-abundance of vegetables we would have enjoyed in smaller quantities. The appearance of our fourth cabbage in eight deliveries, for example, prompted me to write this review. With the burden of this less appealing produce, we are, I suspect, actually eating fewer, and less nutritious, fresh vegetables this summer than we did last year, while having spent considerably more money.
Though it's been an especially difficult growing season for IL farmers, comments in earlier Yelp reviews (see John K., 10/19/2011) suggest that the disappointing weekly produce assortment is not simply a consequence of this year's drought.
In our eagerness to participate in a mutually beneficial relationship with a local, organic farm, we failed to appreciate the important distinction between a true CSA - like Two Onion Farm, in which the entirety of the farm's harvest is distributed to its pre-paid members - and a farm business such as GG, which seeks to maximize profit from its two income streams, the CSA and its farmers market sales. With its delivery boxes dominated by bulky (e.g., peppers, cabbage) and nutrient-poor (e.g., cucumbers, eggplant) fruits and vegetables, our 2012 GG CSA membership was, we have now realized, an expensive mistake, a poor value for our money. read more