In short, Gary Smith Ford did approximately $1000 damage to my car's paint ( per several body shops), thoroughly disrespected me when I tried to negotiate for compensation, and gave me $600.00 to get me to leave the dealership. Maybe you will have better luck, should you decide to use them. Details below.
I took my car in for an oil change. The technician swung my door into another car in the parking lot, chipping and scratching my paint. I watched this happen. Not sure if the other persons car was damaged or if they were even notified. He admitted he damaged the car and took it over to determine repairs. They eventually offered to fix it, but they would have to paint the entire door and blend to the adjoining panels; and it still might not be perfect. I decided not to risk further damage or a botched paint job. So I asked for compensation for the damage instead. Here is where things went bad.
The tech called and initially told me it would cost them $600 to paint the car. I knew this was low because I had already called another local Ford dealer and other body shops to get an idea of the repair cost, but I didn't really care. However, the tech called me back after talking to Frank, their service manager, saying they would only pay $250 for the damage. At that point, I decided to go to the dealer to discuss in person. I went to Franks office and tried to explain the situation and why I didn't want to paint the car. I could not explain because he repeatedly cut me of and made rude comments. It got so bad, I told him I would wait until he was finished talking so he could calm down. He even said quote " I had a car better than yours" when I tried to explain the sentimental value of my car. After arguing with him for 20 minutes, I eventually asked him what a fair cost for the damages was. He said $600.00. I told him that was unacceptable after they tried to cheat me, and were so disrespectful. He then told me to get out of his office. I told them I would take them to court and report their behavior, then I left the office.
After that ridiculous situation, I asked to speak to the manager of the dealership. At this point, I did not care about the money but I wanted to report Frank. The technician explained the paint issue and the manager seemed accommodating at first. But he kept pressuring me to paint the car. I explained to him why I did not want to, and that my issue was primarily with the poor service from Frank. Instead of apologizing, he made excuses saying Frank was old and he dealt with upset customers constantly, as if that justified being absurdly rude. He did say he would talk to Frank, but he also said he "could see why Frank was like that", implying I was the reason Frank insulted my car and kicked me out of his office. He then went on to say I was being "combative" because I called him and Frank out for being unprofessional. Keep in mind, I did not yell or insult them at any point. I just tried to explain why I didn't want to paint, that I just wanted fair compensation for my cars damage and to be respected. He then ordered the technician to "cut him a check for $600.00" then dismissed me from the office. I apologized for the situation, even though I maintained dignity and professionalism and they didn't. The manager tried to be polite at that point, for whatever reason.
Never before have I been in a customer service situation where I was the only one maintaining composure and professionalism. If they act like this when caught clearly in the wrong, how can you trust them with your car behind closed doors?
If you made it this far, congratulations. I hope this helps you make an informed decision. read more