1. Garco Jewelry

0

Syosset, NY

Cancel

Open app

Search

Garco Jewelry

4.9 (8 reviews)
PriceyJewelry

Garco Jewelry Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Garco Jewelry

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

I have always had great experiences at Garçon! Gary spent extra time and energy on making sure watch battery was done perfectly!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Great jeweler. You won't find anyone more honest and Gary's deigns are beautiful! Been using them for over 30 years.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Gary and Sophie are lovely and very helpful. I bring any jewelry there to be fixed or steam cleaned. Very accomodating

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Best quality jewelery. Family owned and operated. Unique shopping experience. I would not hesitate sending anyone here. Enjoy!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Garco Jewelry

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Jewelry 5,406 times last month within 20 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Maddy Fine Jewelers

Maddy Fine Jewelers

4.8(26 reviews)
1.5 mi
•$$

Maddy Jewelers is a SUPERB Jewelry Store. They are located in Syosset, NY and they treat each…read morecustomer like they are a beloved family member. They know their customers by name and they take real pride in presenting themselves as a small town, non commercial run business.I have personally had both my engagement ring and diamond stud earrings reset in beautiful halo settings and my daughter just had a beautiful non-engagement halo set diamond cluster ring made. The workmanship that goes into all their pieces is second to none !!! They also sell beautiful vintage jewelry pieces at very good prices. I have several friends who have come on board after seeing the quality and artistry of my special pieces. I would greatly recommend making Maddy Jewelers your new stop for the highest quality of diamond and gemstone jewelry pieces !!!! It is very worth making a drive in from Manhattan and the other boroughs to experience the high quality of the jewelry created at Maddy Jewelers .You will feel proud to wear their creations !!!!! Holly Sigman from Syosset, NY

Updating that it wasn't after 3 years I brought back my ring in, it was 6 months after I had the…read morering and it wasn't worn daily. The material is cheap, and you refused to repair it.

Photos
Maddy Fine Jewelers - Stunning diamond necklace in 18k gold with diamonds with gorgeous diamond cocktail rings.

Stunning diamond necklace in 18k gold with diamonds with gorgeous diamond cocktail rings.

Maddy Fine Jewelers - Model Demetria wearing our Elite Diamond Jewelry Collection

Model Demetria wearing our Elite Diamond Jewelry Collection

Maddy Fine Jewelers - Fine diamond right-hand rings, available in many different styles.

See all

Fine diamond right-hand rings, available in many different styles.

Smith Jewelers

Smith Jewelers

5.0(9 reviews)
4.5 mi
•$$
Family-owned & operated
Luxury

This is such a wonderful place run by the nicest people!…read more My husband and I got our wedding bands made here. I'm from the area but live in the city and they were so accommodating to my schedule in picking the rings. When I went in to finalize the purchase and take the rings home I brought my great grandmothers wedding ring in to get cleaned and sized for my other hand. While I was waiting did they not only clean the ring but they replaced the missing side diamond and then told me it was free of charge as a wedding gift! It was so thoughtful that it had me in tears! To top it off our wedding bands are perfect and we always get compliments on them. I will be a lifelong customer of Smiths! I can't say enough about how great they are!

Jewelry is more than gold , silver or bling . It is family…read more. I have been a customer of smith's since 1988. There are pieces in my family that have been handed down generations and worth more to me than an appraisal number . I have always and continue to trust them when they needed repair or cleaning . Worth can sometimes only be measured in how you feel, and walking into the store feels like home . They are a true family business , rare these days ! Their inventory is hand picked with care and simply beautiful . Ii moved away from the area but both my daughter and I will always travel to smiths for all my jewelry needs , So I recommend them and thank them for staying true to their family business .

Photos
Smith Jewelers
Smith Jewelers
Smith Jewelers

See all

Anthony Jewelers

Anthony Jewelers

5.0(13 reviews)
1.1 mi
•$$

WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE! It's no wonder why Anthony Jewelers has the reputation it does! From the…read moremoment I walked in the door, my experience was excellent. Martin is a true professional and has 50 years of experience in the business. He had multiple customers waiting (which is a good sign!) and he acknowledged my presence right away and told me he would be right with me. This little act goes a long way because I've been to other jewelers that don't acknowledge you at all when you walk through the door let alone when they are tending to other customers. He was nice and kind to every customer in the shop and everyone left happy and smiling. The woman before me was overjoyed with the work he did on her watches. When it quickly came time for me to shop, I told him what I was looking for (a bracelet for a friend) and he took time to understand what sort of style and price range. He was not pushy at all. He really listened to me and brought out item options that fit my description. Ultimately, we ended up with a beautiful and unique necklace and my friend nearly cried when I gave it to her. I wasn't opting for a necklace, but I trusted him and his experience and I am so glad I did. Rosemary packaged it beautifully too. Of course I left with a few beautiful goodies for myself - two sets of earrings. They are gorgeous and special and not something you'd find online or in another shop. Martin generously cleaned my current jewelry and offered me my own complimentary cleaning solution to take care of some of the pieces I had at home - I was so appreciative. For a 30-something woman, this is the type of jeweler I want to grow my collection with. I look forward to picking up pieces over the years and will be bringing back some cherished items I have now (both my own and from relatives) to be fixed and cleaned. Highly recommend!!!!!

Going to Anthony's is always a true boutique experience. My family and I have been loyal customers…read morefor nearly 30 years, and we wouldn't trust anyone else with our jewelry. Whether it's cleaning, resetting, or creating breathtaking custom designs, Anthony and his team consistently deliver exceptional craftsmanship and service. This is the only jeweler we'll ever go to.

Photos
Anthony Jewelers
Anthony Jewelers
Anthony Jewelers

See all

Jewels By David Lloyd

Jewels By David Lloyd

4.8(24 reviews)
2.0 mi
•$$

When I stopped into Jewels by David Lloyd I got so much more than I expected. I found a jeweler…read morethat was not only honest trustworthy and knowledgeable but David is also passionate about his craft and his clients. I found a jeweler for life. It has been over a year since I walked through his door and I still wake up every morning and love the beautiful creation on my finger and to this day still get compliments on what a beautiful wedding ring set I have. I had been searching all over the island for the "perfect" wedding ring set. I had the perfect diamond in a setting that I liked for all of 2 weeks although it had sat on my finger for more than 8 years. This perfect 2.5 carat, 8 sided diamond, with 88 facets sat in a weak tulip setting that I allowed a jeweler to talk me into and I was determined to not let that happen again. I had an idea of what I wanted and I set out on my search. My fiancé and I hit every major jewelry chain on Long Island and they all had the same type selection and ALL tried to get me to settle for what they had in their display case. Some had even refused to set my diamond in one of their settings and suggested I just buy what they had to replace my near flawless diamond. With 20 days left before I had to leave on my wedding cruise, I decided to stop into that little jewelers next to the Whole Foods in Jericho. I had always wanted to check it out and I figured I was going to have settle again so it wouldn't hurt. I was greeted with warm genuine smiles from David and his staff. I told them what I was looking for and although they had beautiful things that could be modified to be close to what I wanted, nothing was exactly what I was looking for. Then he said the most amazing thing to me. "I can see you are not happy. Why don't we just make it?" And he did. I drew what I wanted on a piece of paper. He took measurements of my diamond, redrew what I had with measurements to give it scale and proper dimension and within an hour my vision was on paper and becoming a reality. He had less than 3 weeks and worked with his team around the clock to create a mold, cast the ring, find 12 perfect diamonds to go with my solitaire, make sure it fit my finger and set my diamond into it, and rhodium plate it. There were many nights (way after the store was closed) that we texted back and forth the work out the details to make sure he was creating what I wanted. David did not want me to settle. It was clear that client satisfaction is his priority and he is truly passionate about his craft. He never charged me a dime extra for his late nights and completed this set for less than a ready-made set at the big chain retailers. When the day came and my ring was complete, it was the most beautiful set I had ever seen. It was better than what I envisioned. We named the rings, The Geslani set, after my new married name. I am stopped by random people who comment on my rings all the time. It has a "peek-a-boo" feature built in where the diamond placed on the side of the wedding band can been seen through the engagement ring. Each of the diamond tips in the channel setting, can also be seen through a side opening of the wedding band. This thing sparkles for miles! Thank you David for your commitment to excellence.

I called David Lloyd in New York and asked if they could send me a photo of their recommendation…read morefor a gold chain. Instead of sending a photo, as I requested, the only response I received was, "What is your price range?" I was disappointed that they didn't seem interested in helping me or showing me what they had to offer. I decided to purchase my gold chain from a local jeweler instead.

Photos
Jewels By David Lloyd
Jewels By David Lloyd
Jewels By David Lloyd

See all

Garco Jewelry - jewelry - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...