I was genuinely disappointed to see so many negative reviews for this amazing collectible shop…read morebecause my experience has been the complete opposite. I've sold several Pokémon cards and other collectibles here, and I felt I was compensated fairly every time. Many of the negative reviews seem to come from personal collectors who naturally place a higher emotional value on their collections. The reality is that collectibles are a market like any other--their value fluctuates based on supply, demand, and current trends. Just because someone paid retail or above retail doesn't mean the market will always support that price. The owner, AJ, is knowledgeable, honest, and transparent about how he evaluates collections. If you're willing to ask questions instead of assuming you're being lowballed, he'll gladly explain the process and how he arrives at his offers. I also took the time to compare buyback offers from other collectible shops, and most either offer significantly lower percentages or aren't interested in purchasing certain items at all. If I had to make a comparison, I'd say many other shops operate like a used car lot, while Collectible N Stuff feels more like CarMax--straightforward, professional, and transparent. AJ is a genuinely friendly, down-to-earth person who clearly knows the hobby and the business. Based on my personal experience, I highly recommend this shop. Five stars!

I've visited this business a couple times. Limited slab selection though they have several binders…read moreworth of vintage to modern and even Japanese singles. They have a few sealed English and Japanese product from Evolving Skies/OF ETBs to the Chinese Gengar 151 boxes. They also have Magic and sports cards. They have a WILD selection of Pop figures too. In terms of selling, I was told they don't buy Pokemon common or uncommon bulk but they might for V's or better. I did see them buy like 2 bigger than flat rate boxes worth of Sports cards. I was told depending on the item, they can buy 70% cash or 80% trade. In terms of buying, they say they price cards based on how much they also got them for so I've seen 10% below to 20% above TCGPlayer market price. Just like all your purchases, do your due diligence and see if you agree with their comps or if you are willing to buy at a slight premium for the convenience of being able to check out the card and not needing to wait for pay for shipping. AJ was great helping me out. Very personable. No issues getting prices when some cards were unmarked. I also sold some slabs to him, a lot I couldnt give a flying fc while some I know had value but I just didnt have the time to sell. I had to comp the valuable ones in person but he gave me all the time I needed, never rushed me or sounded annoyed and the rest I essentially just used to help me get a better percent on what I valued. Note that the highest valued slab was ~$150-$200 depending on how you comp. We ended up with a 60 or 65% coin flip probably less with the random slabs I added on.. Never did I think I'd coin flip in a shop. I did win, but did I really? Haha. I did get cash which I wanted cause I'll be going on a couple trips but overall still a positive experience for both visits in the shop.

Let me tell you the story of a guy who went to Level Up Games and bought some stuff and then traded…read morein some stuff. Normal, right? Then fast forward at least 15 maybe even 20 years and this guy entirely forgot he had credit because his job took him away from Santa Cruz. But one day he returns to get the batteries changed in his old Pokemon games (which they did quickly and for a very reasonable price) and he was informed he had almost 20 bucks sitting there. That's me. I'm the guy. It's been so long that they could never have told me and I would never have been the wiser. Also, even if I remembered they could have kept the money after so much time had passed and I would have fully understood. But nope, they held on to it and even told me about it. Their collection of retro games is amazing and you can buy modern games there too? It's all you could want in a game store.

If in the area, you must come by and check this place out. My son loves comics and collectibles, a…read moregreat find during our last visit was definitely the 'FALLOUT' Jones cola! He was super excited as he had been on the hunt for this drink for a while. He originally bought 2 but then decided to go back and just get the pack. Definitely a new place to keep coming too.

I am so happy every time I see a bookstore. It is nice to see Barnes & Noble where I used to spend…read moreimmeasurable hours before they became a rare sighting. Great helpful staff and I bought a few books here.

Drove all the way down here for my best friends wedding last month, the barista working was a very…read morepale blonde, I think her name was Ruth? She made me the best oat milk flat white I've ever had, with the little dot on the top being a heart. She really made my day and entertained my screaming children, and I've been thinking about her since. If heaven has a starbucks, I just know that she'll be my barista.

Terrible service. 1 sales rep leisurely holding a conversation about cars with a customer as I sat…read morethere for 40 minutes. Instead of placing me in the queue when I arrived, he placed me in the virtual queue when I he was finally finished with his conversation.

Great help. Beautiful woman stunning helped me out. Very nice and offered help to resolve my issue…read more I would recommend.

This place is definitely up there with regards to all of the card shops I've visited!…read more The atmosphere was great (not crowded at all, but I went with a couple of friends close to closing) and the person at the counter was friendly, knew their stuff, and easy to talk to. Good selection of singles, and the prices are reasonable too. Would totally come back again!

Best card shop in Gilroy! They always have a good selection and are always friendly with my 9 year…read moreold who takes forever to decide on what he wants to add to his pokemon collection. Lol great place to take your kiddo who wants to add some singles to their pokemon collection as they have a good selection of unique cards for a good price. They also have an awesome stream on whatnot as well.

Great store in the outlets to find my teen son t shirts . He's 18 and I buy him a large. Closes at…read more8 pm .

Had the best shoe shopping experience here! Shannon was so helpful and friendly. She was able to…read morehelp my son find the shoes he was looking for despite how picky he is. This is where we will be shoe shopping from now on. Thank you Shannon for the outstanding customer service!

This group shouldn't own a store. The two team remember have zero interest in helping. They just…read moresit behind the counter talking about food and football. The one person I asked for help looked at me like I was a bother. He had no idea where the item was and did kit offer to help. I showed him the part from the website that said they had 2 in store, he was more interested in eating his hoagie. This is why no one is in your store, people can't get help to find something and the place was absolutely empty, not surprised.

The worst ACE I've ever been to. When one calls they don't know common tools and aren't helpful…read more Most of the time they are busy gabbing with other employees.

This shop is a hidden gem for finding unique gifts anytime of the year. It's a great place to…read moresupport small businesses and discover a wide variety of options. Plus, the shop has a really cool and inviting atmosphere.

If you are a vendor, I would be careful with this store. I left my book to be sold by this store…read moreunder the agreement that they would give me 60%, but I never received the email with this agreement, and eventually this store told me they didn't want it and wanted me to come and get it, but this store is 45 minutes away from me. I repeatedly asked them to mail it to me, given the fact, that they haphazardly changed their mind, and refused to reply to my emails or phone calls. In essence, they stole my book and will not respond to me.